Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Meritocracy

Meritocracy is a recurring theme in social sciences and especially in sociology. In a simplified or explained way, this concept indicates that the social position of each depends on their merits or effort. That is, positions of social power are a consequence of people's efforts. With this idea, however, we do not limit ourselves to the description, as if social organization were meritocratic, it would also be just at the same time, because what would be in the most powerful positions would be the ones that have made the effort. They are therefore beliefs or ideologies.

Does anyone believe that society is meritocratic? If it is not enough to look at the environment, most of the works on the subject clearly show that people do not believe that society is meritocratic, since their daily experiences demonstrate the opposite: the ways of permanence in the positions of command, and the paths, almost always have little relation to the effort. Evidently, in academic studies they are also marginal views, usually as ideological provocation. However, the concept remains important in the social sciences, if not applied in its entirety to society, in relation to more concrete areas, especially education.

In the sociology of education there is much talk about the meritocracy issue. Paradoxically, contrary to what happens in society as a whole, the educational system is generally related to effort and merit in a relatively natural and uncritical way. What is my academic trajectory, if not the result of my effort or my laziness? Of course, the individual effort in the process a person may have at school is an important variable, but other forces and factors, often covertly, also influence. In other words, as we see more clearly when talking about society, neither everyone in education should make the same effort to achieve similar results.

People do not believe that societies are meritocratic: the ways of being in command positions are almost always unrelated to effort.

Among the hundreds, thousands, of works that have studied the exchange between meritocracy and school in the sociology of education and in other disciplines, I will quote that of the social scientist Paul Willis, who is Learning to Labour: In the ethnographic work How Working Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs (Learning to Work: How Working-Class Kids Get Working Class Jobs), in the 1970s, he looked at the topic that appears in the title itself at a low-class school in the UK. The author highlighted, along with many other aspects, the reproduction of the socioeconomic inequality that occurs at school. Students, rather than participating in a clear game about knowledge according to their merits, were assuming the social position they would occupy in the future, according to the author's long study.

The truth is that in the sociology of education we are in favour of repeating the idea of reproduction of inequality, perhaps because it seems to us that it is not said otherwise. And yet it is also true that the education system is an important instrument for equality. The school shares both characteristics, reproduction and transformation. But, as we are talking about meritocracy today, it should be noted that the educational system has become the last strength of meritocratic ideology, and this perspective is far from fair.

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Iritzia
To the department of education

I received your e-mail in personal mail on the strike portals. At first, like many others, I thought it was to let you know what options we have in the face of the strike. But no, the e-mail received was a political and communicative movement against the strike.

I will confess... [+]


2025-01-29 | Aramaixo Bizirik
Assessment of the environmental report against the “Itsaraz” wind power plant
On January 16, the Ministry of Energy Transition of the Administration of Madrid published the environmental impact statement about the “Itsaraz” project that we were looking forward to and worried about. The resolution expresses a decision that is as firm as it is clear... [+]

The technology
The aesthetic of

This weekend I've been thinking about the word 'aesthetic' in relation to a phrase said by a friend: “This work is aesthetic.” I have studied the etymology of the word aesthetic, it seems that its meaning was originally perceived through the senses, and it was later associated... [+]


Industrial policies: the tool of whom?

In recent years, the concept of industrial policy has reappeared strongly at various levels. The organization that was the hammer of neoliberalism, the International Monetary Fund, today insists that markets have been pressured to allocate resources efficiently and solve these... [+]


The personality

The other day in Bilbao, I met a friend at the Bira bar. We were very happy at the Tar and I said: “Of course, since you’re Guipúzcoa, hahahaha.” And he insisted that he was not Guipuzcoan. Without me understanding it, I kept saying, “Ah! Is it not? You were born in New... [+]


Gurasotasun baimena

Zalantza asko izan ditut, meloia ireki ala ez. Ausartuko naiz, zer demontre! Aspaldian buruan dudan gogoeta jarri nahi dut mahai gainean: ez da justua erditu den emakumearen eta beste gurasoaren baimen-iraupena bera izatea. Hobeto esanda, baimen-denbora bera izanda ere, ez... [+]


2025-01-29 | Andrea Bartolo
War on the imperialist war

We are in the midst of a world imperialist offensive led by the Western bourgeoisie. The form that the imperialist offensive has taken is that of war, with all its variants: economic war, cognitive and cultural war, lawfarr; and, of course, military war. Western imperialism has... [+]


2025-01-29 | Cira Crespo
Don't say colonization

I just saw a series from another sad detective. All the plots take place on a remote island in Scotland. You know how these fictions work: many dead, ordinary people but not so many, and the dark green landscape. This time it reminded me of a trip I made to the Scottish... [+]


2025-01-27 | Aritz Arrieta
The Basque host country?

To be honest, I don't know why I'm writing this. In today’s hostile environment, opinions of this kind are not well received. Perhaps LUZ will not publish this because it does not correspond to the opinions they have published so far (but if they have finally decided to publish... [+]


Don’t let the sound of money silence the buzz of bombs

On January 15, the techno-business lobby called Cedarios presented its 6th report, Euskadi and the European Union, the shared destiny of prosperity and competitiveness. This neoliberal Think Tank, made up of eminent experts drawn from the world of finance, presented a magical... [+]


The Basque Country Welcome Village

We Basques move our feet behind the witness of Korrika to proclaim that we want to survive as a Basque people in favor of our language, with the aim of the Basque Country we desire.

The tipi-tapa is the first step taken by a migrant person who leaves his homeland in Africa,... [+]


Strikes of glutamate

And for another year, the unions have organized prefabricated strikes for us. And we, individually, will decide whether or not to join the strike, without the need for any assembly at the school.

The strike model that I was taught is no longer in vogue, it seems. In my... [+]


The technology
Systems of Life

Life surrounds everything, it is limited and fragile. To live good lives, it seems to me that the body knows what to do, while the mind, although it knows (when it is well informed), often sees the body deliberately silence. In this silence the mind opens itself to relations... [+]


2025-01-22 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Lurraldea eta arkitektura
Erosoa

Eroso gaude ingurunea gure egoera fisiko/emozionalera egokitzen denean. Besteak ni kontuan hartu nauenean, izan gizaki bat, objektu bat, espazio bat. Erosotasunaren klabea produktu eta espazio diseinuan beharrizan handi gisa sartu da, erosotzat jotzen dena erosgarria delako... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude