Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"I've thought a lot about the Argentine aristocracy in decay."

  • Martin Benchimol (Buenos Aires, Argentina, 1985) directed the film El Castillo (Castillo), winner of Horizontes Latinos in the last edition of the San Sebastian Film Festival. The films are starred by mother and daughter Justina and Alexia, who interpret themselves, possessing a wonderful castle lost in the Argentine countryside. The situation of the inherited castle imposes on the protagonists a hard life: bills to pay, roof holes... and the mother-daughter relationship flashes. The film reflects on the leap between fiction and reality, the possibility of elevating class and the close connection of both protagonists.
Dani Blanco / ARGIA CC BY SA
Dani Blanco / ARGIA CC BY SA

It seems essential to start with the question: How much does the movie of reality have and how much of fiction?
It's hard to say. I met Justina and Alexia while recording my previous documentary, looking for locations for that work. I saw Justina working around the castle and asked him who was the owner of the building. “You have it in front of your eyes,” he replied. So I usually say I didn't expect to make this film. So the film has a lot of reality. At first it had to be documentary, but once the recording started I found the observation insufficient. Strictly speaking, we went a little further from the documentary and delved into fiction.

However, we have recorded everyday scenes, anecdote reconstructions lived together and imaginable future scenarios. It is therefore difficult to say in which category the film can enter. It is a representation of the lives of the protagonists. They represent themselves.

Immersed in the game of the autofiquia, did the protagonists put any red line?
Justina said: “Show me what you want, but don’t record me smoking the pipe.”

Cigarettes do.
Cigarettes, no pepper. In general, they carried the recording process comfortably, they were happy in front of the cameras, and they liked the way they appeared in the film. In addition to the question of Pipa, I have another scene that they did not want to record, related to the death of a cow. The situation was very harsh for them, as Justina deeply loved the animals, which he did not want to represent in front of the camera.

Dani Blanco / ARGIA CC BY, S.A.

He casually met Justina and Alexia. How was the relationship built and deepened until you were part of your intimacy?
In the early years, there were no cameras. We got to know each other naturally, and it took years until they started recording. The recording was nothing more than a continuation of that built relationship, and it was simple, it was they who represented their lives, always according to their desires, in matters that were comfortable.

There I see the boundary between organic and non-organic. If you look for the definition of the documentary word, for example on Wikipedia, you will read “the film that represents reality.” In this sense, my film does not intend to represent reality, it is impossible for me. I have the will to represent the link between the protagonists.

Was it clear from the beginning that I wanted to turn their lives into fictions?From the beginning I saw it clear that their real stories build a very strong narrative, but these powerful narratives didn't always appear on their own when the cameras turned on, and we had to create a context that
would break it. Then we began to approach fiction, because this exercise required the narrative cadence of fiction: the actors, the sequences, the development of the characters… I liked that melody of fiction, so we encouraged ourselves to add music.

It's that dream music that gives it amor-story meaning.
Every time we presented ourselves for calls, or had to prepare a text about the film, we described El Castillo as a “fable” or “love story.” One day I said: “Come on, let’s do, let’s put the music of love stories and let’s move forward.” It has worked perfectly.

In the tension between the magical and the real possibilities, music feeds the former. In this tension, on the one hand we have the property of the castle, which looks like a rise in class or a miraculous salvation. But we have a reality on the other side, very different. The film does not focus on the mere possibility of economic promotion, which would be magic, but on the adherence of classes that is maintained. Because from the beginning of the film Justina presents us in the position of owner, and more when the house is acquiring symbolically. However, this does not change their situation in reality.

Dani Blanco / ARGIA CC BY, S.A.

The castle and its precarious situation reflect the situation of the Argentine aristocracy in the Decadence. Justina and Alexia must manage their consequences. The legacy castle, isn't it a poisoned gift?
In the process of creating the film, I've thought a lot about it. The film is based on the nonsense and contradiction of the class system and how heritage defines us from birth. It is clear in the case of Justina, who started working as a maid at the age of six and has not received any money for many years. His first salary was the money he received with this film.

"The property of the castle is not purely economic; class consciousness is at stake the nature of the construction"

In this respect, on the one hand, we have a fundamentally economic issue. If you do an account, someone can say: “Sell the house and buy something cheaper with the money for sale.” But the film goes beyond that mathematical aspect. The property of the castle is not purely economic. That is precisely the fundamental question I have to answer, the nature of the construction of class consciousness. It is not enough to inherit a castle that seems to have fallen from the sky, that changes nothing. The important thing is to symbolically fight the property of the house.

The main plot of the film is the mother-daughter relationship. However, from the anecdotes and the multiple possibilities of the autofiche that left the relationship that each year had matured, you could open several directions in the argument. How and at what time is the main plot determined among all the options?
First of all, I wanted the milestone of this film to be present. The film is traversed by an inheritance that actually refers to the past. But I didn't want me to look back at the movie, my intention was to focus on the present of the two leading women. This forced me to erase or summarize a lot of information. I thought you could also understand what wasn't explicitly told. That is why very little is said of the past. That Justina inherited the castle, nothing else.

In dramatic terms, everything was in the relationship between Justina and Alexia. So I put the focus on it, and I tried to do the opposite, instead of adding things to the plot. It only added the link between the two and what their development required, either the family visit, the mention of Justina's partner or the appearance of friends of Alexia.

Photo of the movie 'El Castillo'.

In addition to the jump to fiction, it's the first movie you've directed alone. Was it a big challenge? It was
very interesting. In previous films I have been director of Pablo Aparo. We've been friends since adolescence, we had a rock band, and we learned cinema together. Recording the first job together, that brought the next one, and the next one… Now everyone goes with their jobs, but we go together, we have a producer together.

However, film is a capricious and very personal direction. With this film I have been able to delve into this more personal aspect. In addition, film is also an exercise in empathy, and that's very personal, how you relate to the characters.

On the eve of the interview, people from the Argentine film world met in Kursaal to denounce the promises of the reactionary candidates to the elections in your country, such as the closure of the Ministry of Culture or the INCAA Film Institute. What do you think is the attitude of the film world to such threats and to the normalization of fascist tendencies? As
he said, if you win these kind of neofascist and homophobic candidates, Argentine cinema is threatened... But not only that, but other rights will also be at risk. Beyond the economic punishment film can receive, what is at stake is the legitimacy of a discourse. His speech tells us that we should only care for what can be “a round and big business.” The starting point is extremely dangerous. In fact, the existence of films that move beyond the commercial point of view is of vital importance, leaving creation in the spotlight.

"Beyond the economic punishment film can receive, the legitimacy of the discourse of the [neofaxic candidates] is at stake."

It is therefore not just a question of this candidate winning or not, but of fighting for an idea that argues that trade is the only avenue of wonder. I think that's what we have to denounce, and create movies that override that idea. Our mission is to create movies that show that another way to drink is possible.

Until now, the film El Castillo has been presented at the Berlinale, Lima and Hong Kong Film Festivals, among others. In the latter you won the award for the best director. How is the reception of the public and your experience being?
The truth is, we're circling with quite a few suitcases. We come from Candem in the United States, now we are in San Sebastian, then Biarritz, then Iceland, Zurich… The tour is being great and it is surprising to note the echo left by our history. In fact, history can be a little weird, but people are falling in love with the connection between the two protagonists.


You are interested in the channel: Zinema
2024-12-17 | ARGIA
Once coastal management is in the hands of the Basque Government, projects "can be accelerated"
The Basque Government has two other powers: Coastal Management and Cinematography and Audiovisual Activity. The Joint Transfer Committee met this Monday in Madrid to agree on the transfer of these two competences to the CAV and Navarra.

They accuse ETB of “counter-programming” the film ‘Bizkarsoro’ on Basque Day
ETB1 premiered the film Bizkarsoro on Basque Day. Although ETB2 was proposed to broadcast simultaneously in Spanish, Tasio eventually offered to be in Spanish on this channel, which has provoked some indignation on social networks.

2024-11-27 | Onintza Enbeita
Aran Calleja. Film music composer
"In music, women are doing a great job for them to see us."
The creative women around him are surprised that they have it, but he's had imposter syndrome for many years. But permanence has taught him that he has done a lot of good things. In 2021 he won the Goya of the Spanish State with Maite Arroitajauregi for the music of the film... [+]

Fermín Muguruza
“Change and movement I am passionate about”
Fermín was born in the former hospital of Irun in 1963, within the Muguruza de los Ugarte family. He is an artist who has exerted a gigantic influence on Basque music in recent decades. Not for nothing, he has been the singer and alma mater of Kortatu and Negu Gorriak, the... [+]

'Bizkarsoro' arrives at Donostiarras cinemas thanks to the collaboration of Bagará, the City Hall and SADE
The film Bizkarsoro (Josu Martínez, 2023) will be screened at Donostia-San Sebastian cinemas from this Friday (day 22) and, as explained by Iñaki Elorza of SADE, will be screened in principle for about two weeks and, if successful, longer. This was explained this Monday... [+]

The Homeless Film Festival begins in Bilbao, which works on the inclusion of people in a situation of exclusion
The film and theatre festival organized by the Bizitegi association since 2016 is already underway in Bilbao.

2024-10-23 | Julene Flamarique
Zinebi will show 132 films from 44 countries in Bilbao for a week
The San Sebastian film festival will be held from 8 to 15 November. You will also be able to watch Basque films such as Tasio, a restored version of the film and Mikel's Death, 40 years after the premiere of the film.

2024-10-21 | Zuzeu
47. Basque Centre for Basque Studies celebrates International Basque Film Day
Jone Arriola’s film “Everything Is Invented” has been the winner of the Golden Goose at the awards ceremony held this Saturday. The Gazette of the Basque Cinema has honoured the trajectory of actress Itziar Ituño.

2024-10-18 | Urumeako Kronika
The festival 'Hariak', witness the stories of resistance, from 7 to 17 November in Hernani
This year’s edition will be the third, and the topic of memory will be the axis, the Feminist Intercultural Plaza.

2024-10-14 | Leire Ibar
Euskal Zine bilera de Lekeitio this week reaches its 47th edition
The festival is 47 years old, and between 16 and 21 October, through lectures and workshops, different areas of Basque cinematography will be worked. Under the motto “The Always New Film”, the festival aims to make a wink to the young people who want to tell the new... [+]

2024-10-11 | Uriola.eus
The International Festival of Invisible Film “Social Film” in Bilbao will bring to the screens what is hidden
From 10 to 17 October, ZINEMA Ikusezinak will show in Bilbao 81 films that encourage reflection and critical awareness on important and topical social issues. Organized by the Non-Governmental Development Organization “KDC” (Culture, Communication and Development).

2024-10-11 | Sustatu
More than nostalgia: When Son Goku started in Basque
Last week was 35 years of the first time Son Goku spoke in Basque. On 4 October 1989, the Dragon Ball was released in ETB1 (which started in Japan in 1984) and a commemorative event will be held in San Sebastian on 20 October, Sunday, with the issuance of that first episode and... [+]

2024-10-09 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Basque Country

Edurne Azkarate said from the micro stage that the Basque film has little Basque in the celebration of the San Sebastian Film Festival. The phrase echoes for its truthfulness. In the architecture scene you can repeat the same motto and I am sure that in so many other cultural... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude