The commodification of housing is an undeniable reality. And behind there is a series of tragic evidences: evictions, inability to access decent housing, speculation, living drowned by renting… In short, the brutal imposition of the logic of private property. Faced with this, we often claim the “right to housing”. But don't homeowners have the right to do business with housing?
It is a subject with political and not terminological consequences. The right versus business dichotomy in housing is a mere mystification. Because housing is in turn a right (use value) and a business (exchange value). This means that we cannot claim a right as a natural characteristic, as an abstract ethics or morality. Because law is a social relationship, a relationship of strength and antagonism.
"There is a collision of conflicting rights: proprietary class (capital accumulation right) and expropriated class (housing right)"
David Harvey investigated the ambivalence of the concept of law, saying that its use and claim is contradictory: “The right of access to the city can be requested by the financiers and promoters, and it has full right to do so, but it can also be claimed by the homeless and papers. The definition of the right is therefore the object of the struggle, which must accompany the struggle for its exercise”.
Something similar happens with the right to housing. In capitalist society there is a collision between two contradictory and antagonistic rights: that of the proprietary class (right to capital accumulation) and that of the expropriated class (right to housing). And, as Marx said, "among the same rights, force decides."
In other words, we cannot raise the issue of rights only at the moral level. We must bring it to the plane of class organization and accumulation of forces. The ruling class is organized to exercise the right to housing as a business, reproducing the regime of goods and establishing the dictatorship of private property. The right to housing for the expropriated, therefore, will not come from institutions or bourgeois reforms. The right to housing will only be achieved by our ability to develop the organisation and the instruments of struggle.
There is no compatibility between conflicting rights. Therefore, class struggle will be the battlefield that will decide which of the two conceptions of the right to housing will prevail.
Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora
ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.
Predicting the end of anything has become fashionable. The end of the human being, ideologies, community, authority, philosophy, or democracy. Are they labels full of sensationalism?
Maybe it was Francis Fukuyama who started that final fashion. After the collapse of the Berlin... [+]
Bagira prozesuaren emaitza, Herri bidea bide-orria izan zen. Bide-orri honetan, abertzaleen helburua herriari boterea itzultzea dela aipatzen da, eta boterea itzultzeko, herriari burujabetza maila maximoa emanen dioten instituzioak herriari eskaintzea adierazten da. Zehazten da... [+]
The Municipal Police of Donostia-San Sebastián has not yet solved the lack of staff in its staff. During the summer the workforce has been strengthened by the hiring of dozens of local police officers to meet the different needs and services that emerge during the summer in a... [+]
The demands of Basque Country in Osakidetza are abusive. No doubt. We are putting and mobilizing health professionals in this line. Without being against the Basque Country, with little intention to learn and much less to use.
The new reference platform is “United by a Real... [+]
Pello Salaburu placed on social networks that within fifteen years the burden of the immigrant population in Bizkaia would multiply to 22% of the total population, which “actually constitutes the threat of the Basque Country”. Of course, thrown in this way, without further... [+]
The sun has risen for the fourth time in the besieged area of the Baiona festivities and I believe that in this northern Basque Country we breathe better, especially because our three Members are from the New People’s Front and we have relegated the third place to the black... [+]
The new spokesperson of the PNV in the Basque Parliament, Joseba Díez Antxustegi, has considered that lehendakari, Imanol Pradales, "has formed a government of women and men with great experience, respected in the professional sectors and committed to the Basque Country". The... [+]
Dear Mrs. Pedrosa:
Congratulations on your appointment as an Education Advisor. It is not a new responsibility that from now on you will have over you. You have to know the Department of Education well after four years as Vice-Advisor. At the end of the course, I would like to... [+]
The debate about Joe Biden's cognitive impairment lasts about two years. Sometimes he behaved strangely, sometimes didn't get it right or said things that weren't true, like his son had died in Iraq. However, the liberal establishment considered any doubt about its cognitive state... [+]
I read two or three days ago an article about the ranks of Guillem Martínez and I do not know if I understood it well. He said that under his house he has a ice cream store that had nothing to do with him and that, in recent times, he usually has people as soon as he opens, one... [+]
I'm not very clear if, individually, we have enough power to guide our lives, but we do have to keep trying. Although a lot can be done in groups, every day we have a lonely struggle with ourselves to move forward. Most human beings spend their time standing on the one-way stream... [+]
Despite the fact that two centuries have passed, the problem of La Plutónica cannot be allowed to fade in the well of oblivion. In addition to 200 years ago to learn about the history of La Plutónica, we must go back to the other side of the ocean, Montevideo.
The brothers... [+]
The crew is one of the hallmarks of the Basques. Every Basque has a crew or, at least, that is what is expected of a Basque born. It is no less, because we could say that the Group is the social unit of the Basque Country, the atom or basic component of our society. In this... [+]