Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"The false dichotomy between public health and political freedoms must be broken"

  • Isabel Benitez (Badajoz, 1981) merges sociology, economics and journalism. As soon as it arrived in Barcelona, it began its journey in social movements: the student movement, the COS union and the struggle for housing. He is a member of Karl Marx's Taifa Thought Seminar and collaborates in La Directa. It has analysed the economic and social consequences of the pandemic.
"Askatasun politikoen murrizketen testuinguruan kokatu behar ditugu lan arloan ematen ari diren atzerapausoak" (Argazkia: Jordi Borràs)

Is the economic crisis we are experiencing a consequence of the pandemic or should it be placed in an earlier context?

The economic crisis is not the direct consequence of the pandemic, that is the first reading that needs to be done. We must go back to the 2008 crisis and remember that the policies of cuts and indebtedness driven by the neoliberal programme have had an impact on inequality in society. The pandemic has highlighted and accentuated these inequalities. We are now faced with a paradox: the need to use public funds to try to maintain economic activity.

It may seem that temporary employment regulation dossiers are a mechanism for trying to prevent job losses, but it is a short-term solution. What comes next?

This indebtedness mechanism will increase social polarisation in all areas: difficulties in access to decent housing, job destruction, wage devaluation... entails greater precariousness and social exclusion. We must be clear that we will never return to the job offer we had a few years ago, nor to the quality of public services.

Can they be part of the solution proposed as a universal basic income or a reduction in working hours?

Both are proposals that need to be put in a concrete context so that they do not lose their meaning. For example, there is perverse rhetoric on basic income, which could make it possible to reduce public services. I think it would be more reasonable to guarantee universal basic services to people. On the other hand, talking about a reduction in working hours without guaranteeing the level of pay would amount to greater poverty and insecurity.

The pandemic has deepened the changes in the labour market: teleworking has come to stay, platform capitalism is becoming more common... Do you think there is a setback in labour rights?

As far as workers’ rights are concerned, we must put the setbacks that are being made in relation to security and pay within a framework: cuts to political freedoms.

 

Photo: Jordi Borràs
Photo: Jordi Borràs

Can you develop it?

Measures limiting social contacts have been systematically introduced, while productive activity is continuing, as if there were no occupational infections. It is surprising how easily they have removed the right to mobility and assembly and the right to express concern about a crisis of a marked political nature.

The measures have not gone hand in hand with the discourse of putting life at the centre, which was strengthened at the beginning of the pandemic.

The question is: What lifestyle do we want to put in the center? Life is important to capitalism, but it's a life at the service of production. It seems that, from the point of view that is being used to design decrees, we are atoms, as if we were not part of society. In their speeches, politicians use the familiar nuclei, the closest ones and other concepts. But what about relationships and communities outside the traditional family?

Cuts are causing difficulties for the organisation. Have we adapted or become critical bystanders?

Beyond idealism, in these months there have been organized demonstrations of collective solidarity: networks of mutual assistance, housing unions, reports of police abuse... but to overcome the crisis we need more than volunteering. We should consider whether there is an organised force capable of achieving more than what the European Union, the CEOE (Confederation of Employers’ Associations of Spain) or the financial oligarchy give us.

One of the consequences of the pandemic has been the weakening of political participation and the collective action force. Why has it happened and how can it be recovered?

There is always a balance of risks and benefits, and now the potential prejudices to carry out collective actions are greater than the benefits. The false dichotomy between public health and political freedoms must be broken. Ensure the defence of political freedoms as a means of acquiring and maintaining rights.

On the other hand, some manifestations of pain have been systematically related to negationism or to the far-right.

Yes, that's why I was talking about prejudice. When the fascists of the wealthy neighborhoods of Madrid appear, they oppose the political freedoms of others, against collective public health. When a eviction is stopped, the social distance may break, someone may not wear the mask well dressed, but a collective defense exercise is being carried out. In the context of the pandemic, we should not fall into the subversion of the discourse of criminalization of protest, as these are totally antagonistic readings.

The working class as the axis

He arrived in Barcelona almost twenty years ago, thanks to a scholarship. Still a student, he participated in mobilizations against the Bologna plan. One thing led Benitez to the other, and Taifa got into the seminar on political economics, working on the relationships between capital and patriarchy. Working-class struggle is one of the pillars of their lives. He has published a book:Panrico, la vaga més llarga (Panrico, the longest strike).

 


You are interested in the channel: Ekonomia krisia
2024-12-19 | Leire Ibar
Mobilising in Bilbao against increased public transport
Dozens of people called for by the Ecosocial Jump and the Charter of Social Rights of Euskal Herria have criticised the increase in the price of public transport and the elimination of discounts as "unacceptable". They also stressed that this would be an "additional burden" for... [+]

The Basque Government is once again linking the poorest with fraud, putting an anonymous mailbox to denounce aid.
The Basque Government has once again launched a mailbox for citizens to communicate anonymously “any suspicion of irregular actions” and has strengthened the Lanbide Control Unit, even though no fraud is committed around Income Guarantee.

Report the "collapse" of the sexually transmitted infections center of the Bilbao Fire Station Etxaniz
Alfonso Setiey, president of Anitzak, said that there is a lack of staff and information, that the waiting list is "long" and that there is a "great stigmatization".

They denounce the Valencian President and call for his resignation
The CGT trade union has denounced the president of the Valencian Generalitat for not having taken the necessary measures to prevent the death of a member of the eta. Twenty social and trade union agents, for their part, have called in the capital a demonstration for next... [+]

2024-11-05 | ARGIA
They're back without doctors in the Amurrio emergency room.
The Amurrio Outpatient Continuing Care Centre has not attended any doctors last Sunday, Aiaraldea reported. A number of neighbours in the area have initiated a collection of signatures so that the area ' s neighbours can join it. “The practice without a doctor has been... [+]

Banquet
Iberdrola has earned a profit of EUR 5,472 million until September of this year, which is a new revenue record in 2024, 14% more than last year. Repsol had in his pocket EUR 1.626 million for the month of July, and the EUR 3.168 million he won in 2023 seem to outnumber this... [+]

Tax allowances for young people: The impact of the movie 'On falling'?
The Portuguese Government has proposed reducing or eliminating IRPF for young people in some cases, but for the moment it has only put the question, because it is not clear whether it will be able to approve the budgets, because the parties that make up the government do not add... [+]

VAT on basic food in Hego Euskal Herria
Since January 2023, the measure to prevent the application of VAT to basic foods, where olive oil has been present for three months, has been in force.

Europe imposes a fine of EUR 15 billion on multinationals Apple and Google
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has sentenced the Apple and Ireland case and has ratified the conviction of Google for abuse of a dominant position.

Two out of three doctors are missing at Elizondo Health Center
Services without medical personnel are being carried out in Elizondo through overtime and voluntary hours. Dr. Xabi Zarandona has denounced that "the continuity of patients cannot be guaranteed".

2024-06-19 | ARGIA
Doctors and pediatricians missing in Bortziri and Baztan
They have gone to the streets to denounce the lack of doctors and pediatricians from Bortziri and Baztan, the endless waiting lists and the delay in appointments, among others. “Those of us who live in rural areas also deserve proper attention.”

Europe opens the door to the far-right converted into merchandise
The prices of housing and rents continue to rise without limits, which has left millions of people in a very precarious situation: young people cannot afford to emancipate themselves, they have kicked many citizens of their neighbourhood, and for many the only solution is to... [+]

The drop in interest rates, how will it affect the housing crisis?
The European Central Bank will cut interest rates this Thursday, after two years of continuous growth. The increase or decrease in money has a direct impact on Euribor and the mortgages that citizens have to pay. But how will this change be noticed?

Return of austerity
They take on the new tax rules in Brussels and open the door to social cuts
The European Union is on track to return to the strict pre-pandemic tax rules, following the adoption by the European Parliament of new fiscal measures to limit the deficit and indebtedness of Member States. According to the Ecofin decision at the end of 2023, this will mean... [+]

European Central Bank announces "structural reforms" to meet defence spending
Luis de Guindos, Vice-President of the European Central Bank, spoke in Barcelona of the European "threats": "We have to talk again about structural reforms".

Eguneraketa berriak daude