Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

500 years of Patagonia: nothing to celebrate

  • The official distinctions and celebrations related to the Fifth Centenary of the Elkano World Tour have also reached Chile and Argentina. The men of the Magellan expedition were the first Europeans to meet the inhabitants of South America. Or, rather, in the words of the authors of the article: "Colliding" with them. After 500 years, what do the natives of Patagonia have to celebrate?
"Europako kronikalariek jatorrizko herriei buruzko irudikapen desitxuratuak biderkatu zituzten –tehueltxe, maputxe, willitxe, kawashkar, yagan, selk'nam, haush…–, aurreiritziz jositakoak.

In 2020, it is five hundred years since the Magallanes-Elkano expedition arrived at the bay where "San Julián" was baptized. They were there five months, until after the winter. This expedition, which took the first round of the world, also identified a sea crossing between the Atlantic Ocean and the Pacific, called the "Magellanic Strait." Until the opening of the Panama Canal in 1914, thousands of boats crossed this road.

The first meeting (or clash) between Europeans and indigenous people took place near this bay, according to Antonio Pigafetta. He described the tehuelches as giants. Inspired by an ancient cavalry novel, Magellan baptized them as "Patagones," a word that would later give the land its name: Patagonia.

Fantasies about monstrous beings and the desire to find hidden riches aroused the imagination of Europeans. Drawn by the mystery of the giants, the following chroniclers multiplied distorted representations about the people of origin - tehuelche, mapuche, willitxe, kawashkar, yagan, selk'nam, haush… - stitched with prejudices. The Europeans, after taking over these territories that "had been discovered", replaced the toponyms with names related to the Christian liturgy and then came persecutions, rapes and murders in the name of "civilisation".

This year, the first Argentine Catholic Mass was held in San Julián on 1 April 1520. On the plateau known as Monte Cristo, there is a giant cross remembering the date. The chronicler of the journey, Antonio Pigafetta, says: "At the top of the highest mountain we planted a cross to prove that those lands belong to the King of Spain and we call it Monte de Cristo."
Photo: District of San Julián

Independence, military arrival and assimilation in the colonial
era (16th century). Between the nineteenth and nineteenth centuries), the Crown of Spain and some groups of indigenous people of the Argentine State signed treaties to establish alliances and negotiate the expansion of the State in the territory of the peoples of origin. After independence, a series of agreements were signed until, at the end of the nineteenth century, the Argentine State ceased to comply with them and opted for direct violence.

The objective of extending militancy in the Patagonian territories - "Conquest of the Desert" (1879-1885) in Argentina; "Pacification of the Araukania" in Chile (1861-1883) - was to increase the production capacity to obtain more fertile land and to allocate it to livestock and agriculture. Through investments from Britain, land and capital were built up. These new Latifundist lords exploited the indigenous workforce.

A group of "Indian hunters" from the Earth of Fire. Photo: Patagonia Institute.

Some were taken as peones on the farms, others were taken north to collect cotton, vine or sugar cane or to build train tracks. They were forced to move, confined to concentration camps and taken away from their children. Thus, they disarticulated their social and political organization. In the south, "reserves" were created under the control of the State and the Church.

On Tierra del Fuego, Salesians and Anglicans gathered indigenous people on missions to free them from their "brutal" life and put them at their service.

Trauma and invisibility The
trauma caused by violence forced many indigenous people to hide its origin, and paralyzed the intergenerational transmission of memory, knowledge, cosmology and language. As they did not speak in the language of their ancestors, the new generations did not see themselves as indigenous, but as their "descendants".

Through eugenic policies, scientific research that multiplied in the 1930s analyzed the so-called "last pure Indians" (according to racist ideologies). The announcement that the "disappearance" of the indigenous peoples of Patagonia would be imminent. Closing the circle, the following assimilationist policies promoted the displacement of rural areas to cities. This made indigenous people become part of the most humble sectors of society, becoming invisible.

The discussions on the centenary’s encumbrances, the
discussions on the fifth centenary of the 1992 “Discovery of America” or, as Edmundo O’Gorman called it, the “Invention of America”, provoked winds of change. Indigenous activists and their allies denounced the cruelty of the conquerors saying that "there was nothing to celebrate."

The results were the pressures of the indigenous people to accept the bloody legacy of conquest and colonialism: the national and local legal frameworks that recognize the existence of indigenous peoples before States were expanded and policies for the recognition, reparation and protection of their rights were adopted.

169 International Labour Organization Argentina and Chile have ratified the Convention (1989) and have invaded the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007), despite the fact that in practice, the application of these laws often fails.

The Chilean authorities pay tribute to the Fifth Centenary of the expedition initiated by Magallanes and carried out by Juan Sebastián Elcano. As in Euskal Herria, there has also been a great noise there. An example of this in the image. In Punta Arenas, one of the main cities of Patagonia in Chile, hundreds of people demonstrated on September 5, 2019 under the motto 500 reasons to protest, some 500 reasons why they met, promoted by some thirty social movements. Photo: The Magallanic.

The recovery and recovery of memory, with
or without the recognition of the State, are gaining strength throughout America in the processes of recovery of indigenous peoples. They defeated the speeches announcing the disappearance of the peoples of Argentina and Chile, Tehuelche and Selk'nam, as well as those who presented the Mapuches as foreigners in their home country. Families, communities and organizations of origin are uniting the past and the present, transferring fragmented, painful, humiliated and silenced memories to the front line, in contact with committed research and, sometimes, technological innovations.

Indigenous peoples are currently fighting neo-extractivism, which directly affects their territories, bodies and spirits. Heritage projects that take ownership of their past and knowledge are questioning, through consultation, the right to decide on matters affecting them.

Recognition of the sovereignty of indigenous people and their territorial rights has put some communities at the forefront of biodiversity protection, although this has also made them a target of attacks.

In response to the hegemonic history and official celebrations around the anniversary of the 1520 expedition, indigenous voices are expressing great sadness. Like the fifth centenary of Christopher Columbus's first trip, it is said that there is nothing to celebrate anymore. The arrival of the Magellan expedition opened the door to looting, bloodshed and the colony that has lasted five hundred years. And those are not reasons to celebrate it.

 

  • Geraldine Lublin is a professor of Hispanic Studies at the Swansea University of Wales.
  • Mariela Eva Rodríguez is an adjunct researcher and professor at the University of Buenos Aires.

The original article was published by The Conversation and we brought it with the Creative Commons license.


You are interested in the channel: Elkanoren mundu bira
In Vitoria the "Basque Country Decolonial" will be proclaimed on the anniversary of the Elcano world tour
Wednesday will be mobilized for the second consecutive year to denounce the "historical dominion of the global and white north".

No Limits or how to repeat conventional narratives about the first world tour
On 6 September, the 5th Centenary of the arrival of the ship Victoria to Sanlucar de Barrameda was celebrated, with the memory that three years after its departure, five centuries before, the first world round was formed. As is usual in this type of commemoration, in these years... [+]

2022-09-06 | ARGIA
"We want to work for a decolonial Basque Country"
On 6 September it was declared a holiday by the Basque Government in the Basque Autonomous Community to celebrate the tour that Juan Sebastián Elcano has given to the world. The Vitorian popular initiative has focused on Plaza General Loma. He pointed out that "with this... [+]

2022-09-05 | Axier Lopez
Landings in Getaria and the Philippines to pay tribute to
On Tuesday, the popular theatre El desembarco de Elcano will be represented in Getaria. Coinciding with the festivity established by the Basque Government and with the 500th anniversary of the arrival of Elcano to Sanlúcar de Barrameda, in Cádiz. However, this is not the only... [+]

2022-09-05 | Sonia González
Elcano and us (and who are we?)

Two friends offered a small rap performance in the plaza and musutruk, after a simple popular meal. With a song, we were reminded that a neighbor, a young man, recently passed away. Money had to be raised to return the body to its hometown. Oh, that mother of mine! Your child's... [+]


2022-08-29 | ARGIA
'Our heroes. First presentation of the book 'A Story of Elkano and the Colonialists of the Basque Country' on Thursday in Getaria
Axier López, a journalist of ARGIA, has analyzed in his book Ot. heroiak, the presence of characters related to colonialism and slavery in the streets of Euskal Herria, moving the international debate on these symbols around the importance of Euskal Herria. The book is... [+]

2022-07-23 | Nekane Txapartegi
Who we are and what we want to be ...

Unconscious day-to-day exercise has become a topic during your stay in the Basque Country. I haven't been there for many days and I've been squeezing my breath several times... I'm an observer trying to find and rediscover my people. If I didn’t want to see things before or if... [+]


The Government grants a direct grant of EUR 15,000 to the Elkano Foundation for the organisation of a congress
The Basque Government, at its Government meeting on 5 July, agreed to grant the Elkano Foundation a grant of EUR 15,000 through the Department of Culture and Linguistic Policy.

2022-07-14 | Peru Iparragirre
Axier Lopez
"Speeches to our navel have prevailed here when the debate on decolonality is boiling"
Our hero has written the book López on the occasion of the fifth centenary of the Elkano World Tour and will be published by ARGIA in September. He has analyzed the presence of characters related to colonialism and slavery in the streets of Euskal Herria, considering the need... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude