Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"A new political subject is being built around housing issues"

  • Besides working at the Institute of European Urban Studies of the Bauhaus University of Weimar, sub\urban. zeitschrift für critische stadtforschung (sub-urban) Lisa Vollmer (Radolfzell, Germany, 1987) is also a member of the journal's editorial team. As a member of the Berlin tenants’ movement, he has been in operation for years and is familiar with the movements and protests surrounding rental throughout Germany. This known reality has moved it to the field of research and analyzed the movements of the tenants of Berlin and New York in their doctoral dissertation. The editorial Katakrak has published in the book Strategien gegen gentrifizierung (Strategies against gentrification) some of the findings he has made through this research.
(Argazkia: Iban Aginaga)

It's been analyzing gentrification processes. He says that in order to promote these processes, the middle class is promoted.

Gentrification must be understood within the context of the capitalist city and within the logic of the capitalist production of the city. For their study, real estate companies must be observed, who obtain benefits through gentrification processes. On the other hand, municipalities are also closely related to the lobbys of the real estate industry, whose interests respond through corrupt practices. The interests of municipalities are focused on attracting rich people and displacing the poor, as gentrification falls on the richest people who pay more taxes and get tax benefits. That's gentrification: the displacement of poor people through the richest people.

This promotion of the middle class generates certain lifestyles, which are often considered to be the culprits of gentrification: artists, hipsters, etc. However, you argue that they are merely the expression of gentrification.

Blaming the groups or subjects mentioned presupposes diverting attention from what is really important. Behind this dynamic is a strategy that blames various social groups and limits tension to a moral debate. This debate, instead of focusing on the interests and structures behind gentrification, points to people’s practices, and on that basis seeks the guilty.

We should be clear that collectives are not the main problem, but the victim of gentrification processes. For example, artists who feel guilty are cheap places that allow them to do their jobs, and in some places they engage in movements against gentrification. What's more, they're a valuable asset because mobilizations make them more fun and colorful, and they have tools to create narratives that can be useful for movement.

"The gentrification process has several stages, with many displacement waves"

The expulsion of the inhabitants of a neighborhood is the basis of gentrification, as the middle class that has initiated a gentrification process can be expelled throughout the same process. You call this phenomenon “supergentrification”.

The gentrification process has several stages, with numerous displacement waves. You can start with the artists listed or the students, but they can also be kicked out. The first link of the displacement process can be displaced through a richer middle class, while the secondary sector can be eliminated by the upper class. In Germany, for example, the reality is very different from here, it's a lot of people living on rent, even in the middle class. It therefore affects these processes.

How does this all relate to tourism?

The effects of turistification and gentrification are inseparable and their relationship can be seen in three areas. On the one hand, it helps residents to become tourist dwellings, as can be clearly seen from the activity of companies such as Airbnb. Secondly, economic gentrification is given way: tourists and the richest class that has just arrived in the neighborhood drive other types of shops, displacing those that had been their shops until then. On the other hand, the different uses of public space made by tourists and their inhabitants also generate conflicts.

People with flashlights in an action against gentrification in the Berlin neighborhood of Kreuzberg. You can read "Power for tenants" in a lantern in the form of housing (Photo: Bildarchiv)

He also talks about day-to-day travel: increasingly, he states that individuals act as tourists in their own city. Who is the tourist subject?

The question is difficult to answer. In the Academy, a term has been extended: neotourism. In fact, today tourists not only look for signs of a place, but also want to visit authentic, local or touristic places. Likewise, the inhabitants of the cities that are the starting point of tourism are the individuals who travel with the same dynamics to other tourist destinations. And that makes the distinction between who he is and who he is not difficult.

On the other hand, it is often difficult to determine who the tourist is. For example, with the economic crisis, many Italians and Spaniards moved to Berlin, and in such cases it is difficult to determine what the tourist is and what the native is. The distinction between tourists and locals should not be based on individual differences, but on the different practices of use and consumption of the space they make.

Airbnb non, turistification in situ.

There is a great deal of debate in Germany on the issue of tourist apartments, and in the face of this trend, public administrations are also pushing for a number of policies. The City of Berlin, for example, has banned apartments from becoming a tourist home. The problem is that they have not hired anyone to monitor the measure, so there is no inspection of the measure put in place.

With the entry into force of this law, the Airbnb company put up posters all over the city. In them several people were seen, along with the following citations: “My neighborhood is very plural, but now they don’t let me rent my room.” Most of the people on the posters were people of different colors and ethnicities, with surnames that were not German. Thus, the company diverted the ban on turning housing into tourist grounds and described them as racism.

"There are three pillars to eradicate the neoliberal housing policy paradigm: accessibility, democratization and de-commodification"

Given the housing problem, the need to build the city from below has been evidenced. Would you say that the political subject of the tenant is being created, which politicizes the issue of housing and puts it collectively?

The housing issue echoed a lot in Berlin in the mid-2000s, and tenants created partnerships. Many of the initiatives promoted by them resisted increases in rent prices and were organized by politicizing the housing issue. Until then, for some 20 years, there had been hardly any political debate on the right to housing.

The initiatives of renters are very varied and include very diverse groups: people of different origins and ages, migrants and not, with or without political experience… in practice a new political subject is being built, crossed by different borders and problems.

According to you, there are three pillars to eradicate the paradigm of neoliberal housing policy.

Yes, accessibility, democratisation and de-commodification. Since gentrification is a housing policy, accessibility is very important for housing to be accessible to low-income people. In order to do this, we need resolute regulation of the rental pricing system, so that prices are not very high. But since the essence of the housing market is the benefits, housing has to be de-commercialized. We have to build public buildings; or to make private housing a public purchase, and expand the collective housing sector, such as collective housing projects or cooperatives.

In order for the individuals to be part of the construction processes of the new neighborhood nuclei, the planning processes as well as the public institutions that provide housing must be democratized. Within the neoliberal panorama, the fact that a housing company is public does not necessarily guarantee a reasonable or economic rental, nor does it guarantee that the company will not make a profit. If tenants were within the structure of these companies, this situation could be tackled.

Photo: Iban Aginaga

It seems undeniable that citizens have to exert considerable pressure to make laws that guarantee the right to housing. You argue that the municipal government should serve as an empowerment structure for social movements in favor of the right to housing.

In fact, in Germany, most groups are opposed to this, fighting municipal governments, which for a long time have driven gentrification processes and concrete policies. However, as housing movements have become relatively strong in the last ten years, changes have taken place in some municipalities. Since these movements had high-impact media campaigns, several political parties introduced the issue of housing in their electoral campaigns, compromising the right to housing and the city. It can be said that today, in some places, there is a greater interaction between popular movements and municipal governments.

They affirm that self-managed housing survives the cracks of the capitalist development of the city, but do not manage to destroy that capitalist development. However, if we understand occupation as an instrument rather than an end, would it not be useful in the struggle for the right to housing?

Housing remains occupied in Germany in the 1980s and 1990s, which have been legalized, offering the public affordable housing. But unfortunately, the neighbors are not participating in the tenant movement. In recent years, there have also been attempts at occupation, but the problem is that there are not as many empty homes as before, so now it is more complex. In addition, the occupation movements in Germany are part of the radical autonomous left and the narratives about their occupation can be considered particular or different.


You are interested in the channel: Hirigintza
2024-09-23 | Garazi Zabaleta
The need to renaturalize cities in the face of heat
Although most of Euskal Herria is located in a temperate zone, not only in the south of Álava and Navarra, but also throughout the territory, the strong streaks of summer heat. And apparently, with climate change, the situation is going to get worse, or are you already doing... [+]

Report on the ecological damage of the French Army's works in the Baiona area
The Union of Environmental Associations (CADE), the Bergeret-22 Neighbourhood Collective and the Attaque Association have denounced the works to be carried out in the Citadel of Baiona. It would cut 1.5 hectares of forest and, on the contrary, they are considered as protected... [+]

2024-09-11 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Europe

I have few friends with a European feeling, I do not know whether Europeity becomes an identity. But when we travel to Europe, a friendship may emerge, because the main areas of territoriality that are taking place in Europe and in Europe are shared, where it is decided to... [+]


"Many school areas in Bilbao are areas full of pollution and noise"
The too small patio of cement, on the one hand, the school environment plagued with roads and cars, on the other, the vast majority of the associations of fathers and mothers of the city, along with their forces, have come to the City Hall to denounce and ask for the... [+]

Hundreds of people manifest in San Sebastian by a habitable city model
Organized by the San Sebastian Ombudsman Coordinator, formed by various associations of neighbours and social movements in Donostia, hundreds of people have spoken out this Sunday in favor of a habitable city model. 42 social groups and neighborhood associations have joined the... [+]

Olaia Beroiz: “Emakume errepresaliatuen kemena gogoratzea ezinbestekoa da”

Iruñeko Txantrea auzoko kale-izendegian frankismoan errepresaliatuak izan ziren hamar emakume gogoratuko dituzte. Ekitaldia egin zuten atzo eta auzoaren hegoaldean dagoen plaza bat oroimen gune ere izendatu zuten. "Garrantzitsua da historian gertatutakoa gogoratzea;... [+]


2024-02-29 | Estitxu Eizagirre
How do we feed cities?
Why not cultivate fruit trees and vegetables directly for the population in urban parks?
How do we feed cities? This is Eli Pagola's question to peasant Audrey Hoc in Egonarria. Hoc, together with his friend Aimar Rodríguez, produces fruit trees, has an edible forest of Etxalar and is implementing a food sovereignty strategy with the town hall of Biriatou. He has... [+]

The streets of Chantrea are dressed in the name of women repressive by Franco
The decree signed by the City of Pamplona contains the result of three years of work. The initiative that emerged from the neighborhood will allow the designation of seven streets and three squares.

Chinatown: cooked and squeezed

China, about 1417 years old. Admiral Zheng He, a salaried explorer of Ming Dynasty emperors, said it was possible “for everyone to leave China.” By then, the Chinese colony network began to expand in the Indian Ocean, the Red Sea and Southeast Asia, so the Chinese explorer... [+]


2024-01-04 | ARGIA
6.486 donostiarras voted negatively on its implementation in the parks of the Basque Culinary Center Gros and Ulia
The Ulia neighbourhood association and the SOS Manteo platform have held a popular consultation this weekend. A total of 6,948 people participated and 6,486 supported park protection.

2023-12-13 | Axier Lopez
The Arrasate City Hall changes the name of the street tribute to the king of Castile who conquered Gipuzkoa at the request of the citizens
They will change the name of the street in honor of King Alfonso VIII who brought Gipuzkoa out of the Kingdom of Navarra and conquered for Castile. For its part, this street will be called “17 women” in honor of some of the women of the town who fought against the Francoist... [+]

Basque Culinary Center, also in Laguardia
The Drinks & Wine Campus (EDA) will have a second seat in Rioja Alavesa along with Vitoria. EDA is a project “developed and led” by the Basque Culinary Center, promoted by the Basque Government and the Provincial Council of Álava. “The EDA wants to bring Álava up to the... [+]

Re-demonstrate in Donostia against the new headquarters of the Basque Culinary Center
With the arrival in November of the new headquarters of the Basque Culinary Center in Manteo (GOe), Ulia Auzo Elkartea has again called the demonstration. They will be mobilized on Friday 10 at 19:00 from the Okendo Cultural Center.

2023-10-26 | Jon Torner Zabala
How do you eat the space you ate?
On March 22, 100 days from the start of the Tour de France, Mayor Juan Mari Aburto landed at the San Mamés stadium in Bilbao. He traveled in the middle of a platoon of people, on a red electric bicycle with the logo of the rental service to Bilbaobiz, to show that he will be... [+]

The Labrit gateway in Pamplona has cost over 500%, from €390,000 to almost 2 million
The Labrit walkway was built in 2010 with a budget of 390,000 euros. The final price was EUR 670 billion. But after seven years of error closure, it was rearranged at a cost of 1.6 million.

Eguneraketa berriak daude