Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"Big Brother is no longer a threat, but a reliable friend."

  • Lars Wehring is a colonial, physical and expert in quantum computing. In May he gave a talk at the Zirika space in Bilbao to raise awareness of the risks of the hyper-connected society that corporate capitalism is developing as a member of the Capulcu collective in Germany. He has researched the links between technology and power and has stated that in the face of technologically more oriented relations we must make digital self-defense to recover natural relations.
"Teknologia ez da tresna, sistema oso bat baizik, pentsatzeko era bat. Horregatik diogu teknologia biolentzia dela, gerra soziala" (Argazkia: Iñigo Azkona)
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

What is the Capulcu collective?

We took the name of the 2013 protests against Turkey’s President, Erdogan. Erdogan said they were twins who despised citizens defending a park in Istanbul, vague, useless. The protesters turned the insult half round, taking the floor with pride in identifying themselves.

We knew each other through the street, through social movements and through the hacker scene. Eduard Snowden’s allegations in 2013 were the starting point for our group. We thought we had to do a kind of digital self-defense to maintain the spaces of privacy and anonymity. But then we realized that self-defense, however necessary it was, wouldn't be enough, that we had to form a radical discourse about technology itself.

Is technology neutral?

Within the left, there has been a tendency to believe in the liberating capacity of technological progress and at the same time try to liberate it from capitalism, understanding that technology is neutral. We are of another view, because from an autonomous radical point of view it seems to us that most of the criticisms are made from a Social Democrat point of view. According to Marcus, domination is not only the use of technology, but technology is domination. Some of the objectives and interests of domination are not established from the outside, but as a sign of identity of the technology itself. Power uses technology to transform society into a direction. So technology is not a tool, but an entire system, a way of thinking. That's why we say technology is violence, social war. Taylor invented the assembly chain to fight for worker autonomy, and a similar process is currently taking place.

One of the achievements of capitalism is the disappearance of the self-awareness of the working class. Even the precarious do not feel like a working class.

In addition, they think they have control of their lives, that all of those devices give them the power, and they don't realize the power they're giving to corporations. Only if we take into account that these devices are useful, are we lost. The virtualization processes of the capitalist platform, which refers to platforms like UBER, Airbnb or Deliveroo, cause us to lose consciousness.

Photo: Iñigo Azkona

Is Amazon the current paradigm of corporate capitalism?

Yes, along with Google. Both want to know in depth our situation, customs and aspirations, monitor them to do business. The staff also controls through a device. The device tells the worker what are the topics that make up each order and what is the shortest path within each purchase warehouse. The device also measures this worker's speed for Amazon, but it doesn't tell him what his productivity level is; the worker, worried, is working harder. Every three months, Amazon fires workers below average.

Facebook creates profiles with our private data and sells them to advertisers, as well as parties, lobbies or governments.

They are selling, but we will increasingly see how they will use them directly to dominate the sectors. Amazon itself, for example, is going to soon enter the world of health insurance. They know so much about us, that using data they can calculate our situation and our risks based on the consumption we make. The insurance company Generali offers its customers smart bracelets for free. With the data extracted, it is known whether the person performs the exercise, how his body responds and whether it is convenient to ensure it. It is a paternalistic approach, “the world is too complex for you, give all the information to the experts and we will take care of you”; soon they will start asking for DNA samples “for our good” to make sure and the prices will be set dynamically and adapted to each profile.

There was a time when the autonomous vision very much observed the idea that power spied on us. Currently, the paradigm has changed radically: The Big Brother is harder to identify and we are also the ones informing him.

Yes, and it's getting complicated. The prospect of the 1980s of oppressive power was simple, too simplistic. Orwell’s image does not very well reflect the current situation, as it is not a terrible panoptician who sees us all, it is more a mixture of normalisation processes. If you don't want to participate, you can disconnect, but stay out of everyday social communication. It is, therefore, the confusion between free entry and forced entry. We are invited to give details about our life and the mechanism works very well, we are pleased to make known the most intimate aspects of our life. The current version of power rarely uses the old repressive mechanism. Big Brother is no longer a threat, but a reliable friend.

Is there less and less chance of living disconnected?

In China, for example, a comprehensive social scoring system has been implemented that extends not only to the Internet, but also to all measurable aspects of offline life. For example, if you behave well as a driver, you'll earn points, because the surveillance system knows your car's license plate. You'll get negative points if you break the rules. You get positive or negative points for everything you do: to buy, to evaluate services... Then, depending on those points your capacities in society are defined and what you can do: go abroad, rent a house... In order to do some things, it is necessary to have a minimum of points. Inter-online differentiation is disappearing.

What about people who don't get enough points?

They're not dissidents automatically, but they have very little chance in society. In China, you don't get tickets for the high-speed train or for international flights, you don't get a job, you get a home ... Your profile assessment is becoming a prerequisite for more and more basic services. They intend to bring this comprehensive system to Europe, and now you can proudly say that you would never accept such a system, but they will make it part of the standardisation process, without resorting to violence.

This seems like a description of a dystopian nightmare.

Yes, and it starts to open down. For example, students, parents, friends… There are groups that organize themselves in Whatsapp. If you refuse to do so, you separate yourself in some way, you reproach yourself from social groups. This is not, therefore, just the Chinese issue, but it seems that in Europe too it is going to be implemented very easily. So resistance has to start much earlier, we have to stop these cybernetic processes of measuring and driving social life, we have to deal with that idea that in social life everything is measurable. These measurements will become evaluations that will serve as a starting point for predicting our social life and correcting our dissident behavior. Therefore, to begin with, we must face up to our own measurement process.

Photo: Iñigo Azkona

Is domotics one of the ways that this dystopia uses to access our homes?

Yes, cars, homes and smart cities -- it's a process to get into all aspects of our lives, and we have to give up on it. It's more comfortable to live in an autonomous system where not everything is interconnected, because otherwise, we lose control of our lives. In the Smart Home concept, you cannot close or turn on your home door without connecting to the central computer, if this is damaged you cannot leave your home, it is absurd. The trend towards the interconnection of everything is creating great dependencies, not a liberating trend, but quite the opposite. It turns us into subjects of corporations like Amazon, Google, Facebook or Apple.

What about the real physical plazas and bars, the traditional spaces of socialization?

Corporations are weakening the representative authority of the classic state. Administrations are losing the ability to control citizens for the benefit of these companies, although they have similar strategies. The State, through urbanism, wants to eliminate the real plazas and street meeting points that are uncontrollable, and Facebook and Google try to transfer communication to predefined channels. From our point of view, it is fundamental to maintain true and analogous relationships on the street, because they are out of control.

The more we get into this interconnected world, the harder it is to get out.

Indeed, technological development is taking a lot of speeds, we are no longer standing in front of it to stop the train, but perhaps to run behind it. We have to think about what technologies are that are not yet fully approved, artificial intelligence is going to have great development soon but it's not yet approved. There, for example, we are still in time to act with a strong attitude of resistance.

What can we do, is it possible to disconnect?

Disconnecting is expensive, because in today's society it means cutting all of your possibilities. So everyone has to look at which of these social services they really need, what they can give up on. I would never enter Facebook because it would be a renunciation of many things, but there are, among Mexican activists, people and collectives who agree to use Whatsapp for the fight.

What other tools do we have at our disposal?

Hacker attacks, data filtration, boycotts against Google Bus and robots, campaigns against Google glasses, protests against Google Campus and Amazon distribution centers, attacks on their digital infrastructures, tackling cybernization of social life, etc. Keep the future unwritten.

An error in the Matrix
“There’s a significant anecdote: bike food dealers started organizing, but not because they created a Whatsapp group, but because of a system failure. The point is that these riders met in certain places, pending the next request, and at that time some things began to be discussed, such as their working conditions.”

 


You are interested in the channel: Teknologia berriak
TikTok, X eta Instagrameko algoritmoek eskuin muturreko edukiak nabarmen hedatzen dituztela frogatu dute

Ikerketa bat egin dute Alemanian, hauteskundeen atarian: kontuak sortu dituzte TikToken, X-n eta Instagramen, eta aztertu egin dute algoritmoak zer nolako edukiak erakusten dituen. Guztietan, algoritmoak eskuinera eta eskuin muturrera jotzen du gehien, TikToken nabarmen.


2025-02-24 | Sustatu
Euskorpus proiektuak hautsak harrotu ditu

Euskorpora elkartearen eta Euskorpus proiektuaren abiatzeak hautsak harrotu ditu. Pello Otxandiano EH Bilduko Eusko Legebiltzarreko oposizio buruak Euskorpusena akatsa dela uste du, "ezjakintasuna edo estrategia klientelarra". EH Bilduk galdera sorta egin du... [+]


The use of video games has increased among adults, according to Ipsos
Julen Linazaroso, from Macsonrisas, explains that the reward balls, loot boxes and others aim to play more hours of video games. The use of video games among people between the ages of 35 and 64 has increased from 2023 to 2024, according to data provided by Ipsos.

2025-02-20 | Sustatu
Euscorpora and Euskorpus presented
On Wednesday there was a mass presentation of the Euscorpora association in San Sebastián, where the project called Euskorpus was announced. Euskorpus, the Basque language, will be a digital resource bank in which the Basque Government will invest 5 million.

The technology
The unified voice of the education system

There are many ways to gain power; not all are beautiful. There are those who want to divide the power and the responsibility that it entails with it, who seek authority. Others have a lot of respect for him and the fact that each step is so measured makes them unable to make a... [+]


Reflections on the use of screens

From the Association of Parents of the Instituto Arratia Small Tram we want to encourage reflection on the use of screens in the learning community.

Lately there is a lot of concern about the impact of screens on children and adolescents. This responsibility extends from... [+]


Zer erosi?

Azken boladan gero eta gehiago entzuten dugu gazte askok etxebizitza erosteko ahalmenik ez dugula. Batzuetan, badirudi ez dagoela beste gairik; egia da gai serioa dela. Niri neuri ere, 31 gertu izan arren, oraindik pixka bat falta zait neurea izango den etxebizitza lortzeko... [+]


The Art of Education group presents the manifesto: "They have implemented pedagogical fashions one after the other"
The recent creation of the Educational Art Teachers’ Confluence has required teachers to take into account the knowledge accumulated over years, guarantee autonomy in decision-making by the clausters, stop the plans that promote the “use of ICTs at all times”, and... [+]

"We are concerned about the technological determinism of the Minister of Education: yes or yes must be introduced in an uncritical way"
The use of technologies is being discussed in the Education Committee of the Basque Parliament, for which several experts and agents are making their contribution in the committee. We spoke with the team responsible for Cabecera Levada, who has requested a general regulation to... [+]

Teknologia
Bilakaera kontzientea

Zer jakin behar dut? Norekin erlazionatu behar dut? Non bizi behar dut? Ardura horiekin gabiltza gizakiok gure gizarteen baitan bizitza on baten ideia bizitzeko bidean. Ondo erantzuten ez badakigu, bazterretan geratuko garen beldurrez.

Joan den astean, kanpoan geratzearen... [+]


2025-02-11 | Sustatu
If the Met has hacked into Libgen, why not?
The Met (the owner of Facebook) has reportedly hacked Libgen’s network library using BitTorrent protocols. They got at least 81.7 terabytes in this way to power their artificial intelligence systems. In order to get the essay and science in the main international halves for... [+]

The Generalitat wants to ban mobile phones at all stages of compulsory education
From Early Childhood Education to the end of Compulsory Secondary Education, the Minister of Education of the Generalitat de Catalunya aims to ban mobile phones in schools. It also aims to study the lack of technological materials in the classrooms of children up to 6 years old... [+]

2025-02-03 | Axier Lopez
Why does Facebook leave Twitter and Facebook?
Algorithms that promote hatred, applications designed to generate addiction, platforms that see advertising recipients instead of people, social networks that treat us like merchandise... It seems that lately the population only receives toxicity from the main social networks,... [+]

2025-01-30 | Axier Lopez
Schools without mobile phones in Brazil
The invasion of screens in our lives has accelerated in recent years. In the Basque Country, on the one hand, we want “screens in Basque” to increase the audiovisual offer, and on the other hand, we organize ourselves to reduce the areas that have gained the most diverse... [+]

Things to do in Martintxo Etxauri: “In the face of toxic networks we have the alternative Mastodon”
Mastodon is a social network and microblogging service. It was founded by the German Eugen Rochko in 2016. It is based on free software. Lately, free individuals and organizations have decided to enter into it. It is made up of independent structures that communicate with each... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude