Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Weeds of education

Antton Olariaga

Although I'm usually presented as a free education expert -- or perhaps because of that -- I try to start speeches and conversations about it by saying that the concepts of education and freedom are antagonistic. They want to model boys and girls showing that it's not very compatible with freedom, but that's what all educational models do in the essential and fundamental sense, that the educational name and the free adjective form an impossible couple. By itself and in principle.

The will to sculpt the character of children can be more humble or more evident according to the educational model. They also have much to do with the ideology and personality of the educator, for example, when defining the number or set of psychological characteristics to be removed and inserted into the child. However, I do not believe that depending on these parameters it is necessary to try to overcome the contradiction between education and freedom. Because the problem is not wanting to change a child's quality too much, but wanting to change. Or the desire to promote in children the value of obedience, rather than rebellion, for example, but the consent that we give ourselves to impose certain values and the legitimacy that we recognize.
Raising the issue of education as a matter of measures and quality is very dangerous, as it must always be decided on the basis of arbitrary, subjective and cultural criteria, for example, when interventionism is excessive, what are the psychological qualities that must be enhanced in young people, or what conduct and character of children we must consider healthy or pathological. And because it's very debatable, of course.

For educators and educators who are progressive, in any case, this way of understanding education offers us a way to justify and justify ourselves. Because it offers an easy slice, an interventionist inertia or a manipulative trend that we all have within, which can only be attributed to an education that is too directive. Authoritarian adults and facilitators, to believe that they only exist in reactionary realities. Always far from us, of course. Never in our casa.La
the essence of education has changed too much, as it has done now, because the adult imposes on the child its reality, the ways used for it are the ones that have changed the most. Now it is achieved through invitation and motivation, which in its day was done through authoritarianism and coercion. But fundamentally, the main goal remains the same. Let the spirit of the adult prevail and prevail, that it may be achieved in an easier and more effective way by means of sweeter techniques.

The conflict between education and the freedom of children is based on the unethical principle that establishes education as a basis: that the child must cease to be as it is to adapt to the way another has chosen, designed and implanted. To want to educate is the end of the essence of education, which occupies a privileged place in the list of unrecognized objectives of the hidden curriculum. Well, the problem with education is that you want to educate. Think we need to educate. Act as if we had legitimacy to manipulate children at our convenience. To internalize that education is a totally natural and neutral action.

In order to be compatible with the dignity of children, the adult must uproot from his particular education those old and weeds that prevent the flourishing of freedom. Let's see.


Newest
2024-09-18 | ARGIA
Second wave of explosions in Lebanon, looking for walkie-talkies
Reuters has reported that, citing witnesses and security sources, several explosions have been recorded this Wednesday in several cities in Lebanon. One of them took place next to a funeral organized in tribute to those who died the day before.

José Manuel Uriagereka. Franciscan in South Korea
"Those of us who went to Korea have kept the Basque very well"
Born in Bermeo, he became Franciscan most of his life in South Korea, 40 years old. At one time he did what many did in the bumps, went to the convent. Subsequently, Uriagereka jumped into the world, into other foreign languages and cultures.

Massive explosion at search engine distance
Thousands injured and twelve killed in an indiscriminate attack on Israel in Lebanon
Israel placed explosive devices on several of the thousands of search engines imported by Hezbollah, according to sources consulted by the local agency Reuters. This is the "greatest breach of security" suffered since 7 October, according to the armed group. Hezbollah has promised... [+]

2024-09-18 | Jon Alonso
Fifth column

If the Ribera has historically been Euskaldun, it is the Byzantine debate (the Byzantine debate: a pointless debate in which each side cannot demonstrate its assertions to the other side) that has been repeated in Navarre for forty years. Jimeno Jurio, orthodox but reasonable,... [+]


2024-09-18 | Castillo Suárez
Variants

When I change my house or, even more, when someone has left home, I have my head and heart filled with memories. So I start trying to decide what I'm going to keep and what I'm not. Because all objects bind us to something, or bring us to someone's memory, and therefore, to exclude... [+]


Land Uprisings

Outside the police state! They sing through the explosions of tear gas. Committed young people, amateur militants, covered faces, or not, clowns, musicians, trade unionists and politicians, doctors with a helmet, farmers on tractors... Both in the countryside and in the city,... [+]


What Palestine brings to the world

It is well known that some French companies (Thales, Airbus, Dassault) have long been helping Israel complete its military equipment. According to a survey by the Disclose Association, the French Government has supplied electronic components to Israel, in order to use drones to... [+]


Free thoughts

Things are not like that, things are like that. This phrase was recorded when I heard Gorka Urbizu's full and quiet album. I thought I'd made a great discovery with that identification, innocent! Later I realized that, besides being a motto for merchandising, it is an incomparable... [+]


Violence, endogamy and smallpox in Treviño

Treviño, 6th century. A group of hermits began living in the caves of Las Gobas and excavated new caves in the gorge of the Laño River, occupied since prehistory. In the next century, the community began to use one of the caves as a necropolis. In the 9th century they left the... [+]


Technology
WorldAA Vision

Human beings have never been easy to think calmly for long periods of time, we live with the responsibility of taking our lives forward, both ours and our descendants. In this opportunity that we have had to live, we want to do things as best we can. For these responsibilities,... [+]


2024-09-18 | Estitxu Eizagirre
Seeds and future issues
Practical knowledge of seed processing and the political vision of seeds. Miguel Arribas Kelo and Marc Badal joined forces in the book Haziak. There are many issues at stake in each seed: biodiversity vs standardization, autonomy vs economic dependence, transgenic vs... [+]

"I took the migrants in the car and took them off the roads that the police could be on."
Aritz takes many migrants in her car so they don't get run over, so they don't get lost in the darkness of the night and they can safely go back and forth. It is particularly reminiscent of the woman who helped her cross the border between Irun and Hendaia and slept in her house... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude