Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Weeds of education

Antton Olariaga
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

Although I'm usually presented as a free education expert -- or perhaps because of that -- I try to start speeches and conversations about it by saying that the concepts of education and freedom are antagonistic. They want to model boys and girls showing that it's not very compatible with freedom, but that's what all educational models do in the essential and fundamental sense, that the educational name and the free adjective form an impossible couple. By itself and in principle.

The will to sculpt the character of children can be more humble or more evident according to the educational model. They also have much to do with the ideology and personality of the educator, for example, when defining the number or set of psychological characteristics to be removed and inserted into the child. However, I do not believe that depending on these parameters it is necessary to try to overcome the contradiction between education and freedom. Because the problem is not wanting to change a child's quality too much, but wanting to change. Or the desire to promote in children the value of obedience, rather than rebellion, for example, but the consent that we give ourselves to impose certain values and the legitimacy that we recognize.
Raising the issue of education as a matter of measures and quality is very dangerous, as it must always be decided on the basis of arbitrary, subjective and cultural criteria, for example, when interventionism is excessive, what are the psychological qualities that must be enhanced in young people, or what conduct and character of children we must consider healthy or pathological. And because it's very debatable, of course.

For educators and educators who are progressive, in any case, this way of understanding education offers us a way to justify and justify ourselves. Because it offers an easy slice, an interventionist inertia or a manipulative trend that we all have within, which can only be attributed to an education that is too directive. Authoritarian adults and facilitators, to believe that they only exist in reactionary realities. Always far from us, of course. Never in our casa.La
the essence of education has changed too much, as it has done now, because the adult imposes on the child its reality, the ways used for it are the ones that have changed the most. Now it is achieved through invitation and motivation, which in its day was done through authoritarianism and coercion. But fundamentally, the main goal remains the same. Let the spirit of the adult prevail and prevail, that it may be achieved in an easier and more effective way by means of sweeter techniques.

The conflict between education and the freedom of children is based on the unethical principle that establishes education as a basis: that the child must cease to be as it is to adapt to the way another has chosen, designed and implanted. To want to educate is the end of the essence of education, which occupies a privileged place in the list of unrecognized objectives of the hidden curriculum. Well, the problem with education is that you want to educate. Think we need to educate. Act as if we had legitimacy to manipulate children at our convenience. To internalize that education is a totally natural and neutral action.

In order to be compatible with the dignity of children, the adult must uproot from his particular education those old and weeds that prevent the flourishing of freedom. Let's see.


Newest
2024-11-27 | Julene Flamarique
Barakaldo City Hall uses "a language other than the Basque language" in a campaign
The Basque association Sasiburu has denounced that the City of Barakaldo has made a "humiliating" use of Euskera. Following the publication of the complaint, the City Council has deleted the Basque version of the campaign. Sasiburu has called for the necessary means and the public... [+]

2024-11-27 | Julene Flamarique
TAV works in the CAV are delayed until at least 2027
The Basque Government expected the High-Speed Train to be ready by 2027 when the Astigarraga-Hernani stretch ends in February 2024. The Basque Government has now launched a tender for the works of the Arkaute link, which has made available to the company Euskal Trenbide Sarea,... [+]

Benito Lertxundi retires
The 82-year-old Oriotarra singer will offer her latest concert...

Luis González Reyes
"It is essential to overcome the capitalism of growth"
At the end of October, the Subai Erakuntza Foundation held a conference on growth in Pamplona. There, Luis González Reyes (Madrid, 1974) delivered his speech. It was based on the book published in 2023 with Adrián Almazán: “Growth: from what to how. Proposals for the... [+]

Hysterical materialism
I want with you

In recent years, I have made little progress. I have said it many times, I know, but just in case. Today I attended a bertsos session. “I wish you a lot.” Yes, that is why I have warned that I leave little, I assume that you are attending many cultural events, and that you... [+]


Technology
Because to receive is to give

The evolution that the Internet has taken over the last 15 years, together with its technological and business model, makes us think that it is a tool to increase the worst aspects of humanity. Around the world, agents have been created that are not satisfied with this idea... [+]


2024-11-27 | Mati Iturralde
I remember them.

In 2006, Baltasar Garzón, then star judge, suffered a kind of revelation and drafted a practice that guaranteed the rights of those detained for terrorism. The same judge saw hundreds of incommunicado detainees pass through his room, many with obvious signs of ill-treatment,... [+]


2024-11-27 | Castillo Suárez
From perseverance

They're one of the most beautiful memories I have in my heart. At the time I was doing Basque Philology and we went to a society in Arbizu to a concert by Ruper Ordorika. There were Rikardo Arrangi Diaz of Heredia and Juanjo Olasgrip. I didn't dare to tell Arrangi that I had in my... [+]


Luna de Valencia

Recently, when asked what the climate emergency consisted of, a scientist gave the excellent answer: “Look, the climate emergency is this, you increasingly see on your mobile more videos related to extreme weather events, and when you realize, it’s you who are recording one... [+]


2024-11-27 | Mikel Zurbano
Trumpkonomy

It is not an easy task to define what the new US mandate will bring in the economic sphere. The axis of the new economic strategy will be the peculiar union between liberalism and protectionism for the external sector. Despite what has happened in the United States on a regular... [+]


Francis Williams Excellence Test

London 1928. At the Victoria and Albert Museum there was a very special painting: in the painting there is a black man, with wig and Levite, surrounded by books and scientific instruments. Thus it was catalogued in the Museum: “Unique satirical portrait representing a failed... [+]


2024-11-27 | Onintza Enbeita
Aran Calleja. Film music composer
"In music, women are doing a great job for them to see us."
The creative women around him are surprised that they have it, but he's had imposter syndrome for many years. But permanence has taught him that he has done a lot of good things. In 2021 he won the Goya of the Spanish State with Maite Arroitajauregi for the music of the film... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude