Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"When I take out the corruption cases, I see them with complex aspects."

  • After investigating many cases of corruption in the Basque Country, Canadian journalist Igor Meltxor has reported 35 cases of corruption in the Basque Country. He has published them in the book EUStelkeria which he has written with DIBUJANTE Javier Etayo Tasio.
Argazkia: Ibai Arrieta.
Argazkia: Ibai Arrieta.
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

Where did you get the idea of writing a book with Tasio?

On the one hand, I saw it necessary to write a book that would repeat the cases of corruption in the Basque Country. Not only in the Basque Autonomous Community, but in Navarra during the mandate of UPN we have had the CAN case; one of the former lehendakaris of Navarra, Gabriel Urralburu, has been in jail and another, Javier Otano, almost both of the PSN. Looking at what's been, what's there and what's going to be sure, there's enough reason to make a book. On the other hand, I wanted to make a pedagogical book, and taking advantage of my friendship with Tasio, I proposed to do something clear and graphic without too many texts.

The book presents 35 cases, of which at least four are currently open.

Among them, I would highlight the case of De Miguel. A total of 26 members of the PNV are charged by the commission of commissions of 4 per cent assigned to them. Contacts with the prosecutor's office are currently under way. The businessman who brought the case to light denounced that he had been wanted to extort and that he had been arrested. All this was done by Alavés Alfredo De Miguel from the Provincial Council of Álava and through the official email. The cases of school canteens and fraud in Osakidetza are also open, and I would say that many important things are still going to come to light.

Cases related to Bidegi and TAV are also open.

As for the Bidegi case, the judge has a period of five years to carry out the investigation. When we investigated this case, we thought we only started breaking the skin. A EUR 30 million hole. The average cost overruns on the roads that have been built in Gipuzkoa have been between 35% and 40%, a level that is not seen in the Spanish State. If the judge has taken such a hard job, I would say that there is reason to investigate. As for the case of the TAV, the book contains statements by Xabier Arzallus on a meeting in the Spanish Ministry of Development on the works of the TAV, and we believe they will give something to say. We also have the case of the Gipuzkoa incinerator.

Photo: Ibai Arrieta

In the preamble to the book, Larraitz Ugarte says that we talk a lot about corruption in the Spanish State, but here we are all silent. What corruption is there?

I do not know if it can be compared to what we have seen in Spain. But I know it exists and that functioning is the same here and there. For example, compared to the case of 3% in Catalonia, the PNV has a similar way of functioning. In the case of De Miguel, we have seen this clear. Moreover, in the latter case, Catalan entrepreneurs are involved. However, when something comes out here, we are told that a case is nothing more than an anecdote.

Are the models repeated?

Seeing the cases here, I am encouraged to talk about “Oasis Vasca”

The fraud of the Osakidetza test in 1990 was a mass and organized fraud of a similar nature. 28 years later, the operation is the same. At that time it was organized for the friends of PSOE and UGT, and now for the friends of the PNV. Modus operandi is repeated, for example, in the cases of De Miguel and Slot Machines. After 30 years, we go back to the same point. That is why, in order to understand what is happening now, it is important to investigate well what has happened in the past. There are a lot of dynamics that imply the requirement of commissions for the party, both by UPN, PSN and PNV. That’s why I was fascinated to talk about “Oasis Vasca”, because here too we’ve had a lot of things. In such cases, action must be taken without any complexes. When it comes to publishing a number of cases of corruption, I see them with some complex political parties. And not only with cases of corruption, but also with ways of acting.

Can it be said that it is widespread that the parties in the governments ask for commissions?

Care must be taken with generalisation. But in Gipuzkoa, for example, after 35 years ruled by the same party, a concrete form of action has been taken. They create customer networks: the same media, local companies with Basque label, state companies, lawyers, parties and politicians are defending these injustices. They keep the business and the party in government, and in return, they award works, jobs, etc. It's these companies. We have seen that irregular awards have been made in works where there were overruns.

It is stated in the book that many politicians and businessmen have previously agreed on certain overruns, then have disappointed the work of that company and, finally, at the end of the work, distribute these false overruns between the two.

That was what we realized in the Bidegi case. In 2011, when Bildu arrived at the Gipuzkoa Council, he found that corrupt form that worked for years. In the written book on the Bidegi case, the emails that the construction companies sent to the politicians were published. In those messages, without any embarrassment, the extra cost had to be what the businessmen said to Bidegi. Speaking to the workers of the works of Bidegi, we were told that the employers had seen the bottles of champagne on the works. Then, they always separate. Cases come to light when one of the two receives less than the other, or when an honored person enters.

Photo: Ibai Arrieta

So, do you understand corruption in relation to the management model?

I am sometimes much more interested in the form of management than in specific cases of corruption. Customer networks and corruption cases move in this management model and that makes it possible. Agreeing on the cost overruns and distributing the money is linked to the lack of control mechanisms. In order to put an end to this problem of corruption, the control mechanisms must first be put in place. The VAT overruns and the cost overruns we have seen in the cases of Bidegi, which exceed 15% and 20%, have been considered normal here for years. Consideration of these overruns as normal is dangerous. In De Miguel’s case, the businessman was told by email that he knew he “had to go through the box.” In view of the ways of speaking, this entrepreneur came to the conclusion that many people had done the same. These are the ways of working in our “Oasis Vasca”.

Seeing that there have been few convictions in all these years, what do you think is the attitude of the judicial system towards corruption?

On the one hand, I would say that the judicial system has acted with a little bit of disregard in the cases we have described. Many cases have gone too long, and some have even prescribed. All this calls into question the position of the judicial system with regard to these cases. On the other hand, the resources available to judges are also scarce: we have no anti-corruption prosecutor’s office. In the case of Bidegi, Bildu requested the cooperation of the Civil Guard to carry out the investigation, since the Ertzaintza alleged that it had no capacity to investigate such cases. Under this impunity, all this corruption has grown, and I think it is time for things to come to light.

Photo: Ibai Arrieta

 


You are interested in the channel: Ustelkeria
The PNV pressured its mayor of Mundaka to act above the municipal secretary
The mayor of Mundaka was Mikel Bilbao at the time when the facts were described, in the years 2019 and 2020, and the Local Presidential Board of the PNV pressured the citizens to recontract the legal services contracted by the previous city council. The Secretary of the City... [+]

Standardisation of corruption

EUR 904 billion. This is the annual cost of corruption in the European Union, according to a study carried out in 2020. Between 2008 and 2020, 3,743 cases of corruption were published in the media, of which 109 corresponded to Hego Euskal Herria. Of course, we will find more... [+]


Commissions of ten million euros in the operation of the mask that stop Koldo García
According to the Civil Guard, this amount of EUR 10 million would be a sum paid by businessman Victor de Aldama, linked to the transactions made by the Spanish Ministry of Transport during the pandemic. This Thursday leaves García free with the order to appear before the judge.

The Audience of Gipuzkoa reopens the 'Bidegi auzia' and orders an independent report
By way of an appeal by EH Bildu, the Territorial Court of Gipuzkoa reopened one of the two disputes in the Bidegi case, corresponding to the Eskoriatza-Arlaban section of the AP1 motorway. Last September the Azpeitia Court decided to provisionally file the case. The court has... [+]

The Government was unaware of the characterisation of waste shipped from Zubieta to Artajona
The Environment Department of the Basque Government did not have information on the characterisation of waste shipped to Artajona, as indicated in the documentation submitted to the Basque Parliament. Ekondakin, manager of the Gipuzkoa incinerator, continued to send leachers... [+]

Prosecutor asks to reduce the fine against Iberdrola from 85 to 5.4 million euros
The Spanish state prosecutor against corruption has confirmed that Iberdrola manipulated the electricity price in 2013 and has ruled out the removal of water from dams in a trial against the electricity company.

Prosecuted, continues to serve as Minister of Justice of France by Dupond-Moret
The case against the French Minister of Justice opens in Paris on Monday with the accusation of “opposition of interest”. The trial should last for two weeks.

2023-10-18 | ARGIA
Iberdrola is tried accusing him of exaggerating the price of electricity
In the midst of the economic crisis, the Spanish Market and Competition Commission concludes that in 2013 Iberdrola artificially manipulated and increased the electricity price, forcing consumers to pay an additional €96.7 million. In the course of the trial against the... [+]

2023-09-14 | Gedar
Corruption in the UGT trade union: Cheques up to EUR 7,000 to the management of Madrid
High charges stole money from a current account that kept public aid and affiliate fees. It is estimated that between 2019 and 2021, EUR 114.175 was allocated.

The judge provisionally filed a complaint in the Bidegi case
Eight years later, one of the pieces that make up the Bidegi case, the last complaint that the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa made in its day, has been filed by the judge of the Azpeitia court. He says the complaint report "is full of mistakes." EH Bildu believes that it is... [+]

2023-08-30 | Ilargi Manzanares
Disqualification of the party of the elected president of Guatemala
Bernardo Arévalo's party, after winning the election, has been temporarily banned by the Supreme Electoral Tribunal for alleged fake signatures in 2017.

2023-08-21 | Ilargi Manzanares
Progressive Movement Seed Party wins elections in Guatemala
Bernardo Arévalo de León’s party won 58% of the votes and passed the right-wing Sandra Torres. Progressives have managed to win over political harassment.

2023-07-06 | Ilargi Manzanares
The new Environment Deputy in Álava investigates by prevarication
The environmental platform Larramendiko Arnasa denounced the nationalist Amaia Barredo for authorizing a waste incineration project against the criterion of the Bergara City Hall.

2023-07-06 | Ilargi Manzanares
De Miguel and his former colleagues Otxandiano enter Álava prison
Otxandiano enters Wednesday and De Miguel on Thursday morning. The 2nd section of the Provincial Court of Álava granted them a period of 72 hours to enter on their own in prison. They were condemned for their participation in the largest network of political corruption tried in... [+]

2023-06-22
What is behind the multinational Solway?
Solway Investment Group is a private multinational mining company that mainly operates nickel and is based in Switzerland, one of the most important in the world. The website indicates that it has projects in Guatemala, Ukraine, Macedonia and Indonesia, and that in 2021 it had... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude