Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Fear of change, also in Catalonia

The decline of the West has many faces. One of them is the regrettable spectacle that the hegemonic left has given in recent decades, becoming the squire Progrí of imperialism and neoliberalism. However, the emergence of a new left other than the ashes of the crisis caused illusion in some places. Then came the frustrations. This new left has achieved a government in Greece, but instead of changing things, it has continued to delve deeper into the path of economic austerity. That is why, in the short and medium term, it is difficult to imagine the success of the transformative left in the decadent First World.

The concern about the impossibility of the left is not just at the political level, the roots of the problem are deeper. Western societies are very conservative. We have often heard that they are accommodated, but no, we must not confuse economic comfort with the high level of consumption. More and more people are facing financial difficulties or the long hours they give cannot be defined as part of a comfortable life. However, people live in the grip of consumerism, the population is ageing and, in general, most of them experience something similar to Stockholm syndrome, so they fear real change.

The Catalans have everything prepared for the day after the proclamation of independence, but what they have not prepared is the majority psychology of citizenship. Certain sectors (especially among employers) have already appeared saying that they are not prepared to suffer the pain, while many others cannot imagine the damage that such a process can cause in the short term.

Real change means pain. It is punctual pain, although it may be better for the future, but there is no change without pain in one way or another. However, painless change is what the moderate or transformative Western left sells today. It has been convinced that it will vote, win the elections, nullify current economic policies and everything will return to normal. The Greek party Syriza wanted to do the same, prioritizing social policies, putting the general interest before any other interest, but without altering the economic system. But if the people are not prepared to suffer the pain, that was an illusion, for example, to leave the euro or to make a real attempt to abandon it, to really negotiate to defeat the European Union and Germany. In the short term, this would have caused great pain, but in the long term it would be beneficial for the Greek economy and people. Syriza said that this is not what the Greeks want and that it is therefore making cuts and implementing the most brutal neoliberal policies in exchange for staying in the euro.

In the Basque Country we have also seen and see it every day. To smile, colours here and there, confessions and a good atmosphere, with these, but above all with the vote, you want to convince the public that the objectives will be achieved. In Catalonia they experience a similar syndrome, the secesory process has shown great organizational, creative and dexterity skills, but it has two shortcomings and a great problem: on the one hand, the lack of leadership and a clear majority after the last elections; on the other hand, the binomial "mine of change" has not been worked out.

The Catalans have everything prepared for the day after the proclamation of independence, but what they do not have is the majority psychology of citizenship. Some sectors, especially among entrepreneurs, have already appeared saying that they are not prepared to suffer the pain, while others cannot imagine the pain that such a process can cause in the short term.

Any unilateral process of independence has created pain in the short term, as citizenship has suffered discomforts if one wishes to express itself in a more pleasant way. The economy is sick, the financial system is distorted and deteriorating without international recognition, wages behave in the same way, while product prices are growing, etc. Will the independence Catalans be willing to suffer similar situations? The failure to comply with the deadlines announced so far and the delay in the process makes clear the will to avoid pain, will fear overcome?

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Iritzia
Guggenheim Urdaibai: who listens to whom and for what?

In 2021 we began to hear the first echoes of the Guggenheim Urdaibai project. The then General Manager Unai Rementeria told us that it would be done yes or yes. To reinforce his claims, he left 40 million euros “shielded” by the time the museums were built. There it is!... [+]


In defense of Labraza
"(The purpose of the Oion Plenary) is clear, to legitimize by law the energy megaprojects with significant irregularities in the processing"

Last Wednesday we had a hard and unpleasant day, not only for Labraza, but also for all the towns where we are threatened by a wind,... [+]


Just as we experienced the flourishing of the Basque Country with the help of the artists, so that this time, taking advantage of their impulses, we continue to make our way together giving the necessary support to the Basque political prisoners, exiles and deportees

The... [+]


Reflecting on the present of yesterday’s philosophers

Epistemology, or theory of knowledge, is one of the main areas of philosophy, and throughout history there have been important debates about the limits and bases of our knowledge. Within this we find two powerful corridors that propose different ways of accessing knowledge: The... [+]


Institutional responsibility for the protection of children

We learned this week that the Court of Getxo has closed the case of 4-year-old children from the Europa School. This leads us to ask: are the judicial, police, etc. authorities prepared to respond to the children’s requests? Are our children really protected when they are... [+]


Harreman publiko-komunitario-kooperatiboak eraikitzeaz

Gure lurraldeetan eta bizitzetan sortzen diren behar, desio eta ekimenen inguruan gero eta gehiago entzuten dugu harreman eta proiektu publiko-komunitarioak landu beharraz, eta pozgarria da benetan, merkaturik gabeko gizarte antolaketarako ezinbesteko eredua baita. Baina... [+]


2025-02-12 | Edu Zelaieta Anta
Deprotection of overprotection

We have renewed the dialogue in the secretariat of the faculty, for the most auspicious: they are far away, for their enrollment, the times when only the students came. The trend has changed for a long time, and parents – most notably mothers – are taking an increasingly... [+]


2025-02-12 | Iñaki Barcena
The silogism of the carpentry

The argument of a syllogism has three propositions, the last of which is necessarily deduced from the other two. It is with this deductive logic that I can analyze, for me, the long and traumatic socioecological conflict in Carpinteria that is taking place in Navarre.

The... [+]


The legacy of the depressed Despremu

I have recently worked in class on Etxahun Barkox’s beautiful and touching cobla. The bad guy! The afflictions of the house began because of the creation of the “praube with beauty”, but in seventeen years she had entered the sea of misfortune, having to abandon the girl... [+]


2025-02-12 | Jesús Rodríguez
Etxegabetzeen aurrean, irabazteko antolatu

Azken egunak garrantzi handikoak izan dira Bartzelonan, etxebizitzaren aldeko mugimenduarentzat eta espekulatzaileen aurkako borrokarentzat. Urtarrilaren 28an, polizia-armada batek Raval auzoko Massana Zaharrari [zentro sozial okupatua] eraso egin zion goizaldean, aurrez abisatu... [+]


Teknologia
Bilakaera kontzientea

Zer jakin behar dut? Norekin erlazionatu behar dut? Non bizi behar dut? Ardura horiekin gabiltza gizakiok gure gizarteen baitan bizitza on baten ideia bizitzeko bidean. Ondo erantzuten ez badakigu, bazterretan geratuko garen beldurrez.

Joan den astean, kanpoan geratzearen... [+]


Statement of the Basque Committee of the EITB
With this letter, the Basque Committee of the EITB and the EITB bodies that underwrite it wish to express their concern and rejection of the selection processes that have been put in place in recent months for the management positions of the EITB, since the demand for knowledge... [+]

From the Caldereros: A blackface in San Sebastian?

I don't want my daughter disguising herself as a Gypsy in the caldereros. I don’t want Gypsy children at my daughter’s school to dress up as Gypsies in caldereros. Because being a gypsy is not a disguise. Because being a gypsy is not a party that takes place once a year, with... [+]


2025-02-05 | Iñaki Murua
Long way in small steps!

The road goes by steps, and I learned a little while ago that it seems to have already begun. But people also want to learn to fill that sentence with content. Alone we could achieve little, maybe even resignation as soon as we started. Gathering huge crowds can also complicate... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude