Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"Giving too much light to citizens does not go for the privileged"

  • The Quebetan philosopher Normand Baillargeon considers education and the free media essential to achieve citizens in a critical spirit. Faced with the difficulty of the road, some of the keys are being offered to the citizens. In 2005 he published the book Petit cours d’autodéfense intellectuelle (Small Course of Intellectual Self-Defense), which has also been successful outside Quebec.
“Berdintasuna eta hobekuntza hitz emana zitzaien klase ertain eta ertain-apalek engainatuak izanaren sentimendua dute. 
Haserre dira eta edonor entzuteko prest dira, Trump esaterako.  Herritar horiek entzuteko ardura du ezkerrak”. (Arg.: zonneoccupee.com
“Berdintasuna eta hobekuntza hitz emana zitzaien klase ertain eta ertain-apalek engainatuak izanaren sentimendua dute. Haserre dira eta edonor entzuteko prest dira, Trump esaterako. Herritar horiek entzuteko ardura du ezkerrak”. (Arg.: zonneoccupee.com)

Your goal is to develop a critical spirit.

It's a long-standing goal. Concerning EE.UU. And Europe, the basis of this idea is found in the Age of Enlightenment. How is democracy going to be? Who will make the decisions? Nicolas de Condorcet and others of the same appreciation gave a clear answer to these questions: if we want to have enlightened citizens, they need a critical spirit, and to do so the development of public education is essential. An adverse reaction soon developed, as giving too much light to the citizens would not support the privileged.

We're always on it.

So the goal is always there. We have to know a propaganda, not let ourselves be fooled by the media or by a type of education. What I'm mentioning is not abstract. Look at the big challenge of climate warming. Oil companies have been working on a message based on lies. Donald Trump, the head of foreign policy, is denying climate change to the region.

The marks that the critical spirit is weakened are winning in Trump, the threat of Le Pen, the victory of Brexit?

We are faced with an extremely complex and difficult phenomenon. Trump’s victory has been made possible by the formation of public opinion that has opted for it. The sharp rise in inequalities, the massive rejection of democratic dialogue, the rise in unemployment... All of this, coupled with the work of the Republican Party over the past 30 years, has led Trump to power logically. We must look at what the citizens say.

What do they say?

The middle and lower classes to which equality and improvement were compromised have the feeling of being deceived. They're angry and they hear anybody. That feeling of discomfort is felt in many countries. The Left has a responsibility to listen to these citizens.

It is often regrettable that the left is quick in the complaint but fragile in the proposals.

Constructive proposals are scarce on the left. We know that the Left is against this or against that. It's easy to say. The fact is that the one who has lost his job or the one who is in poverty knows it perfectly! We must be able to propose positive and alternative proposals.

Is the left in self-criticism?

I regret to say that, but I am not quite self-critical. I am also deplore the moral setback within the left. At the heart of Western Anglophone universities, a moralizing left is banning speech, because what is said does not like it. I am an anarcho-syndicalist and we have always been talking or making proposals. Work museums or work bags were spaces for that. It is a pity that there is no more talk of self-management.

The media are essential.

Media concentration, funding through advertising… Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman say we are a “media propaganda model”. A concept of the world that reflects the interests of the dominators is being proposed. We are in a critical situation and need more free and independent media than ever before. There is only a handful of Maleruski left.

As far as public resources are concerned, what do you say?

Although anarchist, I have to acknowledge that we need them. On Sunday morning, I spent five years talking about philosophy on public radio Radio Canada. Many media outlets would not risk it! Unlike private media, audiences have the opportunity and luxury to make the offer they want.

Two words about the transformation of public education?

From the business world, you feel a lot of pressure, you want education at your service. That is very clear in EE.UU, economic interests are in universities. They also have a rapid trend towards funding research. The results and the choice of the subject remain in the hands of those who have provided them. We are in a confused situation.

In 2005, he wrote a book on intellectual self-defense.

In this book, I collected knowledge about language, sophism, numbers. Always with the idea of providing tools to ensure critical spirit.

A book of great success.

People know that many of the information they receive are questionable and that there are counter-arguments that are not heard. Thus, they seek tools to improve their situation and understand the world. That is how I explain this success. On another level, the success of Chomsky’s ideas can also be explained: it gives us tools, tells us perspectives that we did not know. It certainly takes a whim not to realise the situation in which it finds itself today! We need tools and traces to push and respond to interrogation.

Publikotik dimititurik

“35 urtez aritu naiz hezkuntza publikoan, filosofia eta hezkuntza irakasten. 2009an utzi nuen unibertsitateko postua, desadostasun gehiegi nituelako lankideekin. Mendebaldeari doakionez, bestelakotze sakon bat bizi du hezkuntzak eta jokoan dena ikaragarria da”. 


You are interested in the channel: Ezkerreko pentsamendua
The German left: BSW has come to stay
In the last elections in the state of Brandenburg, the Sahra Wagenknecht (BSW) alliance received 13.5% of the votes. The match was created by Sahra Wagenknecht, former member of left party Die Linke. Die Linke has gone from 10.7% to 3% of the votes and has stayed outside the... [+]

ANALYSIS
With responsibility and common sense

Macron made his press conference on 12 June to read the elections to Parliament. Above all, it has had the time to repeat that the right end and the left end are both landers exactly the same. Although he has criticised one and the other, he has opened up ideas of charm of the... [+]


2024-03-07 | Txema García
Gaza: where is the left?

I will spare you too many explanations and details, the esteemed reader who looked at this text. The issue is very simple. I'll talk about you, about me, about all of us. I am going to refer to the amazing travellers of this boat that is still floating without direction and ever... [+]


Strengthening the right in Latin America

The crisis on the left jumps to Latin America. Until recently, progressive governments could be found on almost the entire map of the region. But things are changing in recent months. The three presidential elections marked a turning point: Daniel Noboa won in Ecuador, Javier... [+]


Thinking about Lenin
Pakistani writer Tariq Ali says that after Lenin's death, the Soviet political bureau opted for mummification, with an absolute family renunciation. Stalin wanted to use Lenin’s figure to point out the historical and political continuity between the two. Once dead, it is... [+]

Vox anti-Basque systems

“And what is the weather she perceives for Thursday?” I asked the feminist militant that she was organizing the A30 strike. “The truth is that lately I’ve had my head in a conflict at school,” he replied with a serious face.

The Vox Solidarity party union called for a... [+]


Click back or forward?

When analyzing the history of social movements and protest, the most abundant studies are those of the Contemporary Age. Sources are more abundant, conflicts are more abundant, and researchers also share the view of the world of research. That is, as we pass through the sieve of... [+]


Left and nation on each side of the Pyrenees

French and Spanish leftist parties and movements have a different relationship with the concept of nation and with nationalism. This completely conditions the relationship with the Basque nationalists. But why? The key to the theme lies in the different processes of creation of... [+]


2023-05-31 | ARGIA
The sociologist Maria Mies dies, precursor of ecofeminism
On May 15, Maria Mies died (1931-2023) German sociologist at the age of 92, one of the main theoretical references of ecofeminism in recent decades. Along with Silvia Federici and others, Mies worked on the theoretical line of anticapitalist feminism, recognizing a productive... [+]

Angel Prado. Communal democracy
"We don't want to be an island."
Venezuelan wrestler Ángel Prado Padua toured different places in Euskal Herria earlier this month, informing of socialist El Maizal, invited by the International Network for Community Democracy. We met in Hernani on the eve of his speech. The Maizal keeps alive the passion of... [+]

2023-01-25 | Aurélien Berlan
Meeting our needs
Aurélien Berlan, philosopher and horticulturist, writes and teaches for half a time and dedicates the other half to ‘survival work’, as in the garden at home. In November 2021 he published in the small editorial La Lenteur Terre et Liberté, the quête d’autonomie contre... [+]

Brazilian elections: a sample of a totally polarized country
The second round of the general elections will be held on 30 October: They must choose between the far-right Jair Bolsonaro and the leftist Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva Lula. It is not just any choice: the current President Bolsonaro applies ultra-conservative and neoliberal... [+]

2022-10-03 | ARGIA
Herriz herriko aurkezpen bira egiten ari da Kimua ekimena

Euskal Herrian "paradigma iraultzaile berria" zabaldu eta garatu nahi duen Kimua ekimen herritarra zenbait herritan aurkezpen bira osatzen ari da. Hala Bedi irratian Kimuako kide batekin hitz egin dute proiektuaren inguruan gehiago jakiteko.


So the story doesn't end

“A ghost travels through Europe: the ghost of communism.” This is how the Communist Manifesto that he wrote 174 years ago begins. Marx and Engels began exploring the path of scientific socialism. In March 1871, the revolt that he sowed with the first program of workers took... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude