Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

What if Mesopotamia wasn't the cradle of capitalism?

  • It has been considered that civilizations of Antiquity were the germ of the present financial universe; places where merchants and agora were born from the instinct of man. Karl Polanyi dismantles all of this with his research, discovering a world based on reciprocity and redistribution. The primitivism of returning to an ideal past that was not theirs, with the empirical analysis, wanted to find the keys to overcome the disaster caused by capitalism. From the book The Limits of the Market (Captain Swing, 2014) you will find below a free summary of several articles written by the anthropologist.

21 March 2016
'Agora. Demokraziatik merkatura' dokumentalaren fotograma. Greziarrek azken urteetan jasandako hondoratzea kontatzen du filmak, eta antzinako agora demokratikoa gaurko deudokraziarekin kontrajartzen, Polanyik egin bezala. (www.agorathedoc.com)
'Agora. Demokraziatik merkatura' dokumentalaren fotograma. Greziarrek azken urteetan jasandako hondoratzea kontatzen du filmak, eta antzinako agora demokratikoa gaurko deudokraziarekin kontrajartzen, Polanyik egin bezala. (www.agorathedoc.com)

In 1901, French archaeologists discovered in the city of Susa, near Tigris, in Southeast Iran today, a basalt column with very valuable information: it makes 81 grandmothers elaborated with the laws in force in Mesopotamia. The Code of Hammurabi, which at the time was given its name since he was king of Babylon, allowed the writing to be re-read in the clay tablets that had been found until then. It is said that in Babylon we found the cradle of our world, of business.

Before the eyes appeared the true origin of a trade with a capitalist mentality: a civilization that venerated the king, the god and the benefits to the same extent. The law on demand and supply underpinned monetary customs, prices, transactions or accounts of debts and profits. A stone London city in an oasis. What happens is that this whole structure falls from the top down if there's no market. And that was what Polanyi was going, that in Babylon there was no market, at least as we understand it today.

When Herodotus visited Babylon 2,500 years ago, he realized that the Persians didn't go to the markets. Numerous later archaeological studies and excavations have shown that in Babylon and the Middle East there was no free space to be used as a market, and that words translated supposedly as a “market” of cuneiform writing did not mean any of that.

The business of Assyrians without risk

In the disappearing city of Kanish in present-day Turkey, the Assyrians set up a shopping centre to supply copper to the city. That was where the negotiators of the karum rank acted. The profits they obtained from the sale, left the money on loan or invested, and as in the most modern companies, there were shares and profits were distributed. From Kanish fabrics and other products were exported, the most important under a quota, and prices and interest rates fluctuated as stock indices.

This is in line with the market system. However, the experts who have investigated this case knew that something was wrong: in the old written tablets, the benefits were rarely mentioned and the losses never. Little attention was also paid to prices and traders should not leave the bond for treatment.

In fact, karums weren't merchants doing selling business, but rather a kind of savage officials. The difference is clear: unlike free trade, “concerted” trade does not pose a risk, either in the face of falling prices, or in the face of the difficulty of paying debts. Transactions were not private, they were mere provisions of the public authorities, and prices were not imposed by the markets, so profits did not come from their ups and downs, but from the use of products. This trade without market or speculation was a shocking activity, but it was only a risk-free business.

“Silent trade” in commercial ports

Commercial ports have existed at all times and in all geographies. When we see metal containers next to each other in the ports of Rotterdam or Bilbao, we might think that it is free traffic rooted in competition. But before modern times, security guarantees were needed to trade abroad. Commercial ports were a neutral instrument, from one country to another, where we could act without threats. Usually, they had low walls, open to the sea, to the river or to the plain, and more than price rivalry, they overlapped the rules of administration.

In these commercial ports, “silent trade” was often practised. When the Carthaginians began the conquest of the North African coast in the 5th century BC. C., they did it in the silent exchange of their tribes. As a precaution, both of them headed to the same site near the beach. There they left furniture and gold, and the operation was repeated several times until everyone agreed. Then, everyone took their way without physical or physical contact with the other. This system, which appeared to be a gift exchange, did not cause disturbances in its peoples, since it was not considered a commercial exchange.

The Basque whalers and the Amerindians around Ternua were not mute when they saw it, the Pigdin franca language emerged from their relationship. We know that in the sixteenth century the Basques and their peoples created a commercial network in North America – axes have also been found extracted from our ferries hundreds of kilometres from the sea – but to what extent was it not a system of exchange like the one we have just mentioned? If not, how do we understand the friendship of those Basques with the devils while the European colonizers slaughtered all the peoples of America?

Mesoamerica before the conquest was full of commercial ports. In Yucatan Terms Lake, for example, the Mayans and the Aztecs had a strong trade, and a tacit or tacit law said that that place could not be dominated by anyone. There were the warehouses and the premises for handling goods, a port without market, a multiple storage complex organized before a long trip. The Spanish conquerors destroyed all these ports and disappeared.

Ancient Babylon could be a commercial port of this kind, since, according to the latest investigations, there was no market in the capital of the Mesopotamian empire. So the question is clear: How, where and when did markets emerge? That competitive system that puts profits and losses at the whims of prices? Perhaps the history of the market could take a millennium and reach various degrees in the west, from Babylon to Greece.

Greek agora: Democracy Fair

In early 2015, filmmaker Yorgos Avgeropoulos produced, with the help of the Arab chain Al Jazeera, a successful documentary that crude the shipwreck of recent years in Greece: Agora. From democracy to the market. The film shows the impact of the crisis in the Hellenic country on the population and democratic institutions: “In the film there is a surreal scene, a parody within Parliament,” says the author in response to the French newspaper Liberation. They pass a law when the Assembly is practically empty and the speaker tries to convince the fantasies of parliamentarians.” According to Avgeropoulos, public democracy was extinguished when Greek public television took a black color.

In the territory that brought democracy to our civilization that we call the West, the agora was a public square of citizens for the assemblies. In the memory of modern Greece, however, it has been mixed with the market of purchase and sale. This anachronism is very noticeable in the case of classical Athens, where trade in products in large groups was banned, business with the land was publicly advertised and cash businesses closed. In Agora they dominated the decisions of the political sphere, and their creation had a great influence on social changes: if the farmer did not pay, he no longer feared that the creditors would sell it abroad, as the German banks do today with the Greek public companies.

From the memory we have been erased the social and political function of Agora, which historiography has broken Aristotle's vision of the economy. It is curious how the great classical philosopher has been exalted in the field of metaphysics or aesthetics, but how few cases have been made to those who said about the market. For him, the desire to make money was not natural, man was self-sufficient as an animal. Modern economists viewed this idea as a non-scientific prejudice, but they didn't realize that genius had been ahead of events: in Greece from the 4th century BC. C. in which he lived, the market trading system was still in its infancy and yet almost 2,500 years later it was as radical as the citizens who gather in the Sintagma Square in Athens.


Newest
Lau maki, 1947 eta 1948 urteetan Donostian erailak

Maki gerrillari antifrankistek Euskal Herrian ez zuten presentzia bereziki nabarmena izan, baina batzuk pasatu ziren, baita erregimenaren errepresio bortitza pairatu ere. Guardia Zibilak hiru hil zituen Ibaetan 1947an eta bat Zubietan 1948an, ahaztuta badaude ere.


2025-04-14 | Uriola.eus
Gerra finantzatzeari uko egiteko zerga desobedientziaren ekimena abian da

Ekimenak bakea eta justizia soziala sustatzeko proiektuak finantzatzea du helburu. Sustatzaile diren gizarte mugimenduek mezu argi bat bidali diete gobernuei eta armagintza industriari: "Ez dugu gerraren konplize izan nahi".


A garden for you, Hypatia
When it is said that several achievements can only be made collectively, it is often between the lines that once thought, thought, and discussed collectively, they usually come after, if they mature. But to achieve something, it is essential to think. Because you don't just... [+]

The analysis
Microphones in theaters

"Ask for your turn and we'll join you," the willing and cheerful announcer who speaks from the studios tells the young correspondent who walks through the streets of Bilbao. The presenter immediately addressed the audience. "In the meantime, we are going to Pamplona..." They opened... [+]


Basque Arms Industry Debate (I)
Opening the debate on the military industry raised by the Government and Cedarras Business Forum

At the beginning of the year, the Zedarria group publicly supported the "opening of the debate" on the "defense" industry (as well as the nuclear industry), to which the Basque Government has immediately joined. First, through Mikel Torres, Vice President and Economic Counselor, who... [+]


We also lugorri
They write to me asking where to collect the medicinal plants and I usually tell them to look at the roadsides. Romanticism has harmed us in many areas of life and even here, because the medicinal plants are not (only) on the paths near the top of the mountain, nor in that... [+]

red traffic light, deceitful of enemies
The scientific name of the insect that we present today explains, among other things, that it is red (not completely) and has no wings. They are not both wrong, but red is not their only coloration, and it has also had wings, but their size is very variable between some grains... [+]

2025-04-14 | Jakoba Errekondo
Live the Garden’s thriving terrestrial ecosystem
April takes us back to the old troubles. April will be the key of the whole year. Organising the land, completing the fertilisation, planting the seeds, arranging the pardas, sticks, nets, cords... If it’s a little bit of work, the biggest step for the new season, which will... [+]

2025-04-14 | Garazi Zabaleta
Location of Dai Konbutxa
Conbutx and fermented for life
Around 2021, the Gernika Itziar Presa Blasco began to immerse itself in the world of the convoy. “I studied teaching and worked in education for years, but when my children were born I had the opportunity to stay at home and I perceived that everything up until then had... [+]

On May 10, the Sorionekuak initiative will cross bridges and gates to proclaim that the Basque language belongs to all Navarrans
In the morning the most significant bridges in Navarre will be populated by the dynamic Sorionekuak. In the afternoon a citizen mobilization has been called from the Parque Costarapea in Pamplona to the Parque Takonera in the Old Town.

The Supreme annuls the express action of the Municipalities in the Basque language
The High Court of Justice ruled in 2023 against certain articles of the Basque language municipal law, which has now been ratified by the Supreme Court. The Basque Government has not submitted a timely appeal against the ruling.

2025-04-11 | ARGIA
The director of the music band of Lekeitio receives complaints of harassment
The City Council of Lekeitio reports that the directors of the band have been mistreated through various testimonies. The City Council explains that, following the advice of the Basque Government, they have taken several steps, including talking to the Director and receiving... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude