Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Understanding Current Cheap Oil: Two Hypotheses

  • Low oil prices are one of the main issues to be addressed in 2015. Some say that it will facilitate the exit to the economic crisis. That, being a trap for some producers, the others will soon end. Why do you pay the barrel that was 90 or 100 dollars 12 months ago below 50 dollars in these weeks? Here are two different, perhaps complementary, explanations.
Errusiako lehendakari Vladimir Putin eta Saudi Arabiako printze Abdulaziz Al Saud  iaz Brisbanen (Australia) G20 herrialdek azaroaren 15ean burututako biltzarrean. 27an, berriro elkartu ziren Lurralde Petrolio Esportatzaileen Erakundeak (OPEC) Vienan egin
Errusiako lehendakari Vladimir Putin eta Saudi Arabiako printze Abdulaziz Al Saud iaz Brisbanen (Australia) G20 herrialdek azaroaren 15ean burututako biltzarrean. 27an, berriro elkartu ziren Lurralde Petrolio Esportatzaileen Erakundeak (OPEC) Vienan egindako biltzarrean. Bertan proposatu zion, antza, Saudi Arabiak Errusiari petrolio produkzioa murriztea, munduko ekonomiaren geldialdiagatik erregaien eskaria ere asko jaitsia zelako. Asko aipatu da Errusia, Iran eta Venezuela direla kaltetuenak gaurko prezio apalengatik, honek baldintzatu dizkielarik beren barne ekonomien orekak bezala kanpoko hautu geopolitikoak. Gutxiago aipatu da Saudi Arabia, Kuwait eta Arabiar Emirerri Batuak estuki daudela loturik AEBetako energia korporazio erraldoiekin eta baita gobernuarekin ere, prezioak finkatzean bezala Ekialde Hurbila eta Magreb hankaz gora jarri duten gatazketan.

It's not going to last so long cheap, Alexander Reid Ross wrote in an interview given to the magazine 'The Ecologist'. “The fall in oil prices reflects the multi-layered conflict in the ideological, political and military realm in the Middle East, and it will not last long. After a cruel message to Russia, Iran and Venezuela, oil companies in the North Atlantic will return to their usual profits and unconventional dangerous projects.”

Reid Ross runs Earth First! The Grabbing Back has been posted on the web and recently: Essays Against the Global Land Grab The article published by The Ecologists summarizes the arguments of those who analyze the reduction of oil from the point of view of geopolitics.

For starters, almost everyone agrees that lower prices respond to oversupply. The decline in fuel demand in the drowned economies in the global crisis since 2008 has made supply too high. Starting to lower prices, it has been the first to notice the shocks among the producers that have created the most expensive fuel, those that work with fracking technology.

Reid Ross has highlighted three of the geopolitical reasons mentioned, which lie behind these low prices. Some understand this curious decline in oil within geopolitical tensions within the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC).

Others have clearly underlined the influence of Russia’s foreign policy. The phenomenon of the Army Signal Network cited by The Economist: In recent decades, oil has gone down so immeasurably every time Russia has intervened militarily abroad.

And then there are those who think that the United States is behind everything, that Saudi Arabia makes it a servant; that's what Indian Vijay Prashad calls "dispossession by manipulation," expropriation by manipulation.

Reid Ross, without taking his predecessors right, believes that the real problem lies in the war in Iraq and Syria. “The collapse of the oil price in Iraq is affecting Iraq: It prevents Iraq from fighting the Islamic State (IS), while IS is comfortable in Mosul, the third Iraqi city, with minimal services. The United States has achieved the greatest success in the battle against IS by supporting the Kurds in northern Syria and Iraq, but Turkey is furious because the Iraqi Kurds are collaborating with the Civil Protection Units (YPG) fighting in the part of Syria.” The battle of Kobane is the main example.

Turkey would want more to see an autonomous Kurdish government on its land. That's why he works so generously with IS. According to Reid Ross, if the Kurds fail to cut their way to the IS, the price of oil will rise again, because that is what the big producers are interested in.

Reid Ross, who writes from environmentalism, has a clear message for those who hope that cheap oil will stop technologies as expensive as fracking, without the struggle of the people: prices will rise soon and the multinationals will stay in it.

Benefits in $100

Arthur E, advisor to big oil companies. The geologist Berman sees nothing but a short-term economic calculus, marginalized from geopolitics and from what he calls “conspiracy theories.” Berman's interview can be read in the Energyskeptic space: “The Real Cause Of Low Oil Prices”.

Berman represented the fund with a brief dialogue between two Heads of State: “Saudi Arabia met with Russia before the November OPEC meeting and proposed that if Russia reduced production, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Emirates would do the same. Russia said ‘no’ and Saudi Arabia said: ‘O.K., you may not respond the same in six months’.

For Bermam this is only the result of short-term calculations. “The Saudis are good at money and arithmetic. It was a painful option, that is, to lose money by keeping production and selling the barrel at 60 dollars, or to take two million barrels out of the market and lose more money. If they are lost in both cases, they have deviated along the road that has caused the least damage to us. If then there are secondary reasons, harming fracking oil producers in the United States, or hurting Iran and Russia, that was also going well, but it was essentially a matter of money.”

In Berman's view, oil will again become more expensive this year, probably when the OPEC countries meet in June and decide to cut production.

If anyone has thought that with this price reduction, fracking centred companies are going to quit their jobs, Berman thinks they're wrong. Fracking fever begins again with the rise in oil, which is no longer enough.

It is a critical guarantee with many who boast about the profitability of fracking. The deposits excavated with these techniques require oil to be at $90 to attract capital, although its propaganda has spread the idea that they are also profitable for $60. “Those who mention these prices do not count on costs other than drilling and oil transformation, forgetting the rest of the burdens.” And in the hidden costs, Berman does not take into account damage to the environment or to human health, or many more, relate directly to the activities of the companies.

Some have seen in recent months the opportunity to refute the famous Peak Oil. Berman, however, has no doubt: “Many think that the rise in oil production in the United States shows that Peak Oila was wrong. But the pinnacle of oil doesn't mean running out of oil. It means that when you start producing the well-known conventional oil, the supplies of the future will come from more difficult or more expensive sources.”

This expert believes that conventional oil production has reached its peak in 2005-2008. In the United States, fracking gas will rise above its peak within five to seven years. And over the next few decades, natural gas will be fundamental, and much more, what Russia, Iran, Qatar and Turkmenistan have. Meanwhile, reader, be careful that oil will return for $100.


You are interested in the channel: Energia krisia
2024-12-23 | Estitxu Eizagirre
EH Bizirik has mobilized against the plan approved by the Basque Government:
"Overcoming the current capitalist model is fundamental to finding a way out to the ecological and energy emergency"
On 20 December the Basque Government approved the "provisional version" of the Sectoral Territorial Plan for Renewable Energy (PTS), following the tradition that projects that generate social conflict will be approved on the eve of the holiday. EH Activa has concentrated before... [+]

“We are not your monkeys anymore”

The Centre Tricontinental has described the historical resistance of the Congolese in the dossier The Congolese Fight for Their Own Wealth (the Congolese people struggle for their wealth) (July 2024, No. 77). During the colonialism, the panic among the peasants by the Force... [+]


Congo and cobalt
What are we willing to stay connected for?
It serves us to take this last portrait with twilight. Or the little puppet that we just asked the waiter of the pay bar in a moment. And, wow, in the back pocket of the pants that want to mimic the Levi’s come perfectly. The cell phone also serves that. So who cares that in... [+]

The UN begins the final phase of negotiations to limit plastic pollution
The summit, which runs through the city of Busan in South Korea, will last from 25 November to 1 December. The oil-producing countries and their lobbies are putting obstacles, as they do not want to limit production.

Luis González Reyes
"It is essential to overcome the capitalism of growth"
At the end of October, the Subai Erakuntza Foundation held a conference on growth in Pamplona. There, Luis González Reyes (Madrid, 1974) delivered his speech. It was based on the book published in 2023 with Adrián Almazán: “Growth: from what to how. Proposals for the... [+]

We have argued against the Navarre Energy Plan that does not plan

The update of the Navarra Energy Plan goes unnoticed. The Government of Navarre made this public and, at the end of the period for the submission of claims, no government official has explained to us what their proposals are to the citizens.

The reading of the documentation... [+]


Urumea Mountains Bizirik
"Wind companies are more proud of small towns"
They are Erramun Galparsoro and Joxe Manuel Muñoz, neighbours of Aranoa, who have died. They have been living in a small town in Navarre, which is about 440 meters high and looks at the sea and has 114 inhabitants, for 22 and 30 years, respectively. The two are part of the... [+]

2024-10-29 | Jon Torner Zabala
Hundreds of ecologists block the oil tanker factory in Belgium Total
Activists from the Code Rouge movement have repeatedly denounced that Total Energies is polluting the environment and harming local communities for greater profits. They have therefore blocked the factory in the Belgian city of Feluy, and have made protests at the entrance of... [+]

Compulsory macro-projects

Recently we have had other arguments to convince us of the need for macro-projects in the surroundings of Euskal Herria. An example of this was the article published on the website of the EHNE of Bizkaia to one of the participants of the Ecosocial Jump initiative: "For... [+]


NEE/TEN Conference, a real Energy Plan for Navarra

On 3 September the Official Bulletin of Navarre published the announcement by the Government of Navarre announcing the update of the Navarre Energy Plan. This should be an important step for the future of our community, taking into account the importance of energy and its use... [+]


2024-10-11 | ARGIA
Conference on growth in Pamplona from 21 to 24 October
The Coordinator against the Large Renewable Polygons in Energy Transformation of Navarra convenes three days to rethink the energy transition. These meetings will reflect on the problem of energy and the need for a defrost in the social fabric.

Old news

I don't know if we're hit by heat waves anymore, if it's a normal hypocrisy or a systemic logic, but the gap between what we know, what we say and what we do, beyond concern, surprises me, especially in a summer environment. News, research, social media interactions… constitute a... [+]


Electricity consumption in the Spanish State stagnates at 2004 levels
The Electricity Network of Spain has reported that electricity consumption in the Spanish State in June was as follows: 19,422 gigawatts per hour. That is, very similar to the 2004 data: then there were 19,384 Gigawatios.

The Basque Government presents thousands of resources against Gorbeialdea's energy macro-projects
Solaria intends to build a 100-hectare photovoltaic park in Zigoitia and cross the region with a very high voltage line. Urkabustaiz, Zigoitia and Zuia residents have presented 5,540 citizen resources "with the intention of paralyzing projects that threaten the area". The... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude