Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"Our conception of work can change, really, is changing."

  • The ecological transition of the economy of Florent Marcellesi (Angers, France, 1979) refers to the influence of the division of labour and green employment in the Basque Country. Why? What for? How? in the study, edited by the Manu Robles-Arangiz Institute. The theorist of political ecology is also coordinator of the Ecopolitics center, where a dossier has been promoted with a proposal of a working day of 21 hours. His latest book is Farewell to Growth. Florentmarcellesi.eu posts reflections on your blog.
"Kontzientziazio lana egin behar dugu lehenik, eta sindikatuei gogorarazi behar diegu lana banatzea eta lanaldia murriztea euren aldarrikapen historikoa dela. Maiatzaren Lehena horregatik ospatzen dugu".

“Ecology and work come hand in hand,” he says in his study for the Manu Robles-Arangiz Institute. What do you mean by that?

Politicians and institutions often say that ecology is against employment, which is for the rich. But it's the other way around, because ecology does more work. If this crisis has emerged from an economy that harms nature, it has to look for jobs related to ecology and use more hands than before. For example, with organic farming you need 30% more labor than with “conventional” agriculture. Ecology is a work of the future, more ecology, less energy and more work.

Unemployment is becoming more and more serious and there is increasing talk of the possibility of distributing work. At the Ecopolitics Centre you have claimed a working week of 21 hours, why?

The New Economic Foundation conducted a study in England and is the model we have taken as a reference. We have calculated the paid working time and the number of salaries without pay, the average between the two is 21 hours. But it's a symbolic number, we're in the 21st century, and people have to start thinking that maybe we have to work less to live better. We want to provoke him.

A friend told me when I talked to him about the distribution of work. “If you cut my electricity and gas bill in half…”.

If you propose a 21-hour working week without changing anything else between people, that is called minijob. All you're going to do is make poor workers, like in Germany. But this is one more measure among many others. You have to redistribute wealth, consume less and have a different lifestyle. Without that you will not be able to reduce the working week.

Serge Latouche: “You have to work less to earn more. More and more work is being done, less is being done. It is the law of the market.”

In France, at 35 hours, it was claimed that less work was needed to live better. Then Sarkozy said we had to work harder to win more; that can still have some logic. What are we hearing in Spain with the People’s Party? Recently, Rajoy said we had to work harder, but winning less to get out of the crisis.

Faced with the crisis, many people think that wages should be lowered and more work should be done to produce more. That classic thinking can lead to competition with the Chinese, but it will only make society even more impoverished.

He says that with a day of 21 hours you also have to change your life. You talked about leisure, but it also affects other areas, such as equality between women and men.

Distributing the work serves to protect the planet, that is very important and we cannot forget it. If you work less on pay, you will have more time for a greener life: Instead of going to Rome in a single day by plane, you’ll do it in more days; instead of buying prepared dishes in Carrefour, you’ll spend more time cooking…

But it also serves to deepen social justice. Nowadays, unpaid work is performed by women, who is in charge of domestic tasks or care? Men have to go home, work on a day-to-day basis, educate children… It’s a way to rebalance jobs.

The concept of work has been changing according to the time.

The Greeks believed that work was for slaves, while in the Middle Ages work was linked to the sun and religion. When the industrial revolution came, we radically changed our minds and started to work looking at the clock. In the 19th century, people’s rights suffered a great setback; in the Middle Ages some 1,500 hours were worked per person a year, that is, awkwardly, and at the time of industrialization some 3,000 hours came to work. The working-class struggle of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries meant, to a large extent, a return to the medieval situation.

The myth that industrialization was a breakthrough must therefore be called into question. We have inherited the industrialization model. But what does all this teach us? That you can change the concept that we have of work, it's actually already changing, and that's where the journey that feminists have made goes. In twenty years' time, our idea of work is going to be very different.

Even when entrepreneurs talk about privilege or flexicurity, are they changing the perspective of work?

Yes, of course. Flexibility is a new factor to take into account. We didn't imagine working all our lives in the same place, but our parents already had that idea, that they would keep working in the factory where they started working until their retirement. Some of us accept flexibility in a positive way, because we “liberate” from paid work, but others use it to exploit it: the burden of keeping the worker and hiring him when they want, without having to pay social security, can be removed from the burden.

The Danish model says: I will give you more flexibility, but you will give me more security. What do we do here? The worker provides flexibility, but receives less social protection in return. The distribution of work has to do with solidarity, with the maintenance of close links to protect the most vulnerable.

The study reveals that with the subsidies for the implementation of the 35-hour working day at the CAPV, 15,000 jobs can be created. LAB in Navarre expects 28,000 jobs with different measures. This type of project requires the involvement of many actors, how can we achieve it?

We have given the idea, but we have to think about how to convince the institutions, the employers and also the workers. The worker can say that, like his partner, he cannot pay the mortgage or gas by reducing his working hours. First of all, we have to do a job of raising awareness and remind the trade unions that the division of labour and the reduction of working time is one of their historic demands. That is why we celebrated 1 May.

The institutions, on the other hand, do well, because it makes it possible to reduce unemployment. And among some aspects, the idea of distributing the work has also been welcomed. If I am not mistaken, Bildu, Equo and Ezker Batua picked it up in their election show.

What about the entrepreneur?

I would say that there are entrepreneurs and entrepreneurs. We have a tough fight with multinationals, but small businesses are closer, and innovative ideas, such as the Economy of the Common Good, are emerging there. We don't have a social majority yet, but it's slowly building up.

There are citizens who, out of solidarity, have reduced their working hours, and in some companies there has also been a proposal to reduce employment.

If you want to be consistent with yourself and believe in it, what less than practicing. In addition, it will help us improve our daily lives. But that does have its limits, in many places it is impossible to reduce working hours. We must make a qualitative leap towards collective bargaining, so that the reduction in working time is regulated for all workers.

There the unions have an important role to play, and I think they have started to take it up again. If until recently that idea has been among us! Popular legislative initiatives around basic income in the 1990s also raised the division of labor.

You have made a classification of employment by ethics and ecology, because not everything is worth having “full employment”…

We have to see what kind of employment we can accept in society. There are jobs that destroy value, like the arms industry. How many companies do we have in Euskal Herria in this area? A hundred? They only lead to death, poverty and hunger. There are jobs that are not worth it and others that are worth it.

Are you talking about green employment?

Green and decent jobs. Green employment is not valid if the worker is exploited. The green jobs are the ones that restore nature, the ones that cause the least damage to the environment, the ones that allow the development of the South… We have made a list according to that.

The number of jobs that can be created in Euskal Herria has also been analyzed.

The European Union and the International Labour Organisation have carried out numerous studies to promote the ecological transition of the economy, but in the Basque Country we have found hardly any of them. What we have done is extrapolate the hypotheses of these organizations to Euskal Herria and contrast the results. For example, a building rehabilitation plan can generate up to 18,000 jobs here.

How many jobs are we talking about in total?

In Hego Euskal Herria they could be close to 100,000.

What is “New Deal Berdea”?

It is a way of naming everything we are talking about. The New Deal Berdea calls for a major ecological transition, proposes a major public investment to get out of a brown and unsustainable economy, with the support of private capital, to carry out sustainable activities. It's a political project to change what we have.

Job creation and investment in the millions, how are they reconciled with the decline?

Investing does not mean creating wealth, but acquiring what you have already created, has nothing to do with growth.

For many of us, we are already in starvation, but what we need is “organised disgrowth”.

I agree. We now have a growth rate, the wealth of the poorest has been transferred to the richest. The word “organized” is very important, as the transition has to be democratic. If we are to set limits on ourselves, we need rules decided collectively and democratically.

The year 1968 was a stimulus to the environmental struggle. Is political ecology today at a turning point like that?

The 1968 one is easy to say, because we have 40 years of view. It was a turning point for the good and the bad. We lack that vision to explain the current, but I think yes, we have indications to think that important things are happening. It is now impossible for a politician to go through all this, the ecological transition is no longer a political option, but a political necessity. In addition, there is no other solution, as growth is not going to return, it is over.

In Euskal Herria, the vanguard of environmentalism has been citizen initiatives and platforms. Is a strong political movement necessary for the “ecological transition”?

Both are necessary. We have to change things from the bottom, and a lot of experiences are emerging, like ethical cooperatives, that are going to shape the world of tomorrow. But if you want that to extend to the whole of society and be systemic, you need a political project behind it. We can't forget that, because only small experiences don't work. That is why I am in a political party, because I have made that commitment. In any case, I am not referring to usual political parties, but to parties that are very close to social movements.

Utah estatua eta Loos-en-Gohelle meatzari-herria: bi adibide trantsizio ekologikorantz

Utah (AEB): “Lau eguneko lan astea”, 2008-2009

2008an AEBetako Utah estatua izan zen lehena sektore publikoko langileei lau lan eguneko lan astea derrigorrez ezartzen. Helburua zen energia aurreztu eta karbono isuriak murriztea. Working4Utah ekimenak 8 orduko bost lan eguneko aste konbentzionala ordezkatu zuen 10 orduko lau lan egunekoarekin, astelehenetik ostegunera. Lanean jardundako ordu kopurua bera zen, baina langileek hiru jai egun zituzten jarraian.

Estatuak bere gain zituen 25.000 langiletik 18.000k hartu zuen parte esperientzia horretan. Asebetetze indizeak handitu egin ziren esperientziak aurrera egin ahala. 2009ko maiatzean langileen erdiak baino gehiagok zioen produktiboagoak zirela lau lan eguneko astearekin eta hiru laurdenek nahiago zuten plan berria. Absentismoaren jaitsieraren ondorioz 4,1 milioi dolar aurreztu zituen estatuak.

Lau eguneko lan astearekin 4.546 tona metriko karbono gutxiago isuri zen. Estatuko automobiletan 3 milioi milla gutxiago egin ziren eta 744.000 galoi petrolio gutxiago kontsumitu. 1,4 milioi dolar aurreztu ziren.

(New Economic Foundation-en
21 hours dosierrean argitaratua)

Loos-en-Gohelle (Frantzia): Herri bat, trantsizio ekologikoko laborategi

Frantzia iparraldeko meatzari herria da Loos-en-Gohelle (7.000 biztanle). 1980an azkeneko meatzeak itxi zituztenean, langabezia, prekarietatea eta ingurumen-kalte larriak zituen eskualde osoak.

Herriko sektoreen birmoldaketa ekologikoa egin zen: bioeraikuntza (%90 murriztu dute berokuntza-gastua zenbait etxebizitza sozialetan, urtean 1.500 euro etxebizitzako); mugikortasun jasangarria; energia berriztagarriak (elektrizitate ekoizpenean buruaskitasunera iritsi dira) eta ekonomia solidarioa.

Eskualdeko beste herri batzuek automobilgintza sustatu zuten, egun krisiak jota dagoen sektorea, gorabidean dauden herrialdetara eramaten ari baitira lana. Loss-en-Gohellen aldiz, langabezia eskualdeko bataz bestekoa baino %15 txikiagoa da, jarduerak ez direlako deslokalizagarriak eta eskulan ugari behar dutelako. Garapen Jasangarrirako Baliabide Zentroa, ekoenpresen haztegia, I+G+Brako eguzki-plataforma eta materialak birziklatzeko lehiakortasun gunea (12 milioi euro ikerketa eta garapenerako)... Trantsizio ekologikoaren laborategi bihurtu da herria. Nortasuna eta ondarea ere zaindu dute eta meatzaritza guneak irizpide ekologikoen arabera birgaitu. UNESCOk Gizateriaren Ondare izendatu zituen eskualdeko meatze hondarrak.

Bestalde, partaidetzaren arloan “%50-%50 konpromisoa” ekimena abiarazi dute: Udalak dirua eta teknikariak jartzen ditu herritarren proiektuentzako eta hauek hitzematen dute mantendu eta zainduko dutela.

(Ekonomiaren trantsizio ekologikoa ikerlanean argitaratua,
Manu Robles-Arangiz Institutua)


You are interested in the channel: Ekonomia soziala
Red winter

Budgets and the closure of annual accounts are nothing more at this time, from the domestic economy to most of the socio-economic spaces that we share. Large companies have begun to extract calculators and implement major plans for 2025. Small and medium-sized institutions and... [+]


2024-12-13 | ARGIA
The KoopFabrika School of Entrepreneurship will start without subsidy from the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa
KoopFabrika is a free school for people and groups wanting to launch cooperative and community economic projects. The registration period is now open. The first meeting will be held on 28 January. Olatukoop, Gezki and Lanki have been in charge of organizing the ninth edition of... [+]

International Congress to Discuss Transformative Syndicalism and Work in Leioa
More than 40 rapporteurs will participate this Thursday and Friday in the Leioa Campus of the UPV/EHU at the First International Labour and Trade Union Congress of the 21st Century. The guest will talk about the challenges and strategies of the world of work and the... [+]

Oiartzun will be a three-day meeting point for transformative projects focusing on sovereignty and the eco-social transition
From 17 to 19 October, Oiartzun Burujab and Udalbiltza organised a conference under the name of Soberanias. In addition to learning about the local transformative experiences, the Mayor of Girona, Lluc Salellas, and the former Cup parliamentarian, Mireia Vehí, will participate... [+]

Arrigorri
In order to draw up these lines, we have stopped making cheese and are in the process of sterilisation. This means that ordeons are increasingly dispersed over time, until sheep's milk disappears. In some cases, the process will end in a few days, and a few will cost more.

Pello Rodríguez assumes the leadership of MONDRAGON with competitiveness as the axis
The annual congress held at the Euskalduna Palace in Bilbao has staged the handover of Mondragón's president, Iñigo Ucín, so far head of the group, and from now on, Pello Rodríguez. In addition, cooperatives within the group have established a roadmap for the coming years,... [+]

About the need for smooth utopias

I write these lines the day after the elections to the European Parliament, the dark times, the triumph of the Reactionary International in the elections to the European Parliament. It was already in advance and it is the confirmation of the conservative phase we live in, but it... [+]


Katakrak and Koop57 buy a 1,500 square meter building in the Gran Vía de Pamplona
They have acquired the 18th century building located on the 54th Major Street, next to the current bookstore of Katakrak. “In this building there will be no hostels, no luxury hotels, no housing that the area’s neighbors could not afford, here we are going to build urban... [+]

2024-06-14 | ARGIA
It has opened a programme of support for projects in line with its social action
The cooperative Orkli de Ordizia will provide a fund of 50,000 euros to support "initiatives arising from the community". The program has been named Orklidea and projects from all over the Basque Country can be presented.

Four, three, two, one -- Long live Olatukoop! Festival of the transformative economy in Donostia
The Transforming Social Economy Network, Olatukoop, is ten years old and on Saturday has held a party in San Sebastian among its members and participants. They have claimed (and demonstrated) that economy and cooperativism can be approached from a different perspective: from the... [+]

Olatukoop 10th Anniversary
Olatukoop reaffirms its commitment to economic and territorial transformation
About 80 people have met in the Katakraken Hall in Pamplona to celebrate the ten years of the Olatukoop network, a reference to the transformative social economy. It has been an initiative to present detailed proposals for economic and territorial transformation.

Eroski earns EUR 109 million in 2023, 70% more than the previous year
The distribution of the Mondragon group has shown optimism with the benefits gained in 2023; it has responded "firmly" against the background of inflation and cost increases. This has allowed it to continue expanding in the Spanish state and last year opened 74 new supermarkets... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude