Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

I'm not a writer

Antton Olariaga
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

If the gods do nothing wrong, then they are no longer gods.

This phrase, explosive for the morality of centuries and centuries, revolutionary in the etymological sense, is written by Stéphane Mallarmé, in the least expected place. As a young man, when he made a living as an English teacher and translator, he translated a mythology manual from English to French.

The original version, as is normal, says just the opposite: “If the gods do aught unseemly, then they are not gods at all.” The phrase literally follows Euripides' known fame. So did the French poet want to qualify himself as a god and, with an unpretentious conduct, disrupt the centenary base of Good? For the translator, it is an unbreakable law to keep the original as it was. The well-known adage, which denounces that the translator is a traitor, does not go beyond the small changes of meaning that can occur in the nuances. Only a criminal (or a god, that is, a being that has the property of all creation) would dare to introduce a "no" into a translation.

But it is not clear that, for the gods to exist, they have to do evil if it is intentionally written by Stéphane Mallarmé or later created by a hyper-direct corrector, seeing “if they are dieux font rien d’inconvenant”, and considering that the particle “rien” lacked a “ne”.

Another hypothesis could lead us to think that this anonymous corrector, not knowing that he belonged to Mallarmé, among other things, because he was not from Mallarmé, who had his job of tracking Mallarmé's text in search of errors, considered himself a god and, introducing a no, he himself committed the attack on morality until then, as in the new History of the Lisbon Site of José. The Basque reader, reading the translation of Jon Alonso, will remember that in it the director of an editorial decides in a book of History to deny an affirmation and with it manages to change the history and its own history, the individuals (readers? ). In claiming his capacity to influence and transform in the Great Story, if not in an iconoclast against the figure of the sacralized writer.

The owner of the work is no longer the author. It is known that the writer, like the god, has died, repeated to tiredness. Because anyone can mistranslate anything written (even the biggest poets), because they can correct it wrong (even the most honest and diligent of the texts of Argia) or because any reader can misunderstand it. How do I know, to put it solemnly, that this column that I have built with these words would stand outside my hand?

That is why, even if it is not for that reason, I refuse to apply the word writer to myself. I admit that it can be seen as a sign of humility, as I acknowledge that anything can be interpreted. Someone who writes would have no more to say that he writes. In the novel Martutene, for example, her translator Julia (and her partner) reflects on the writer Martin: “They talk about books [Lynn and Martin]. She thinks she already knows she's a writer. He would like to know how that was said. I write? In any case, he’s convinced he hasn’t told I’m a writer, that’s never.”

In this warm afternoon of July I do not think anything more unpleasant (to recover for a moment the divinity).


ASTEKARIA
2012ko uztailaren 29a
Azoka
Newest
2025-03-08 | ARGIA
ARGAZKI GALERIA
Mugimendu Feminista: “Faxismoaren kontra, ausardia eta aliantza feministez armaturik gaude”

Mugimendu feministak manifestazioak egin ditu goizean Donostian, Gasteizen eta Iruñean eta arratsaldean Baionan eta Bilbon. Oinarrizko irakurketa partekatu dute, eta horri gehitu diote hiri bakoitzean bertako problematika, eragile eta ekimenen erreferentzia.


2025-03-08 | ARGIA
Bilgune Feminista
“Feminismoa da heldulekurik argiena desio dugun Euskal Herrirako”

Bilgune Feministak Heldulekuak argi, Euskal Herria feminista leloa baliatu du M8an, azpimarratzeko feminismoak ematen dituela “datorrenari aurre egiteko tresnak”, eta gogorarazteko faxismoaren gorakadaren testuinguru hau helduleku horretatik irakurri eta borrokatu... [+]


Iruña-Veleia: epaiketatik bost urtera

Otsailean bost urte bete dira Iruña-Veleiako epaiketatik, baina oraindik hainbat pasarte ezezagunak dira.

11 urteko gurutze-bidea. Arabako Foru Aldundiak (AFA) kereila jarri zuenetik epaiketa burutzera 11 urte luze pasa ziren. Luzatzen den justizia ez dela justizia, dio... [+]


Superwoman

MAITE: (biharko eguna antolatzen bere buruaren baitan) Jaiki, gosaldu, bazkaria prestatu, arropa garbitu, etxea garbitu, gizon hori jaiki, seme-alabak jaiki, hiru horien gosaria prestatu, haiek agurtu, erosketak egin, lanera joan, seme-alabak eskolatik jaso, merienda eman,... [+]


Espainiako Sustapen Ministerioa: “Ez dakigu Ezkioko lotunea oso bideragarria den”

Josu Estarrona EH Bilduko Arabako senatariak egindako galderari erantzun dio Espainiako Sustapen Ministerioak, eta hor berretsi du Ezkioko aukera zailtasunez beteta dagoela.


2025-03-07 | Laia Alduntzin
Hezkuntza gotorleku

Matxismoa normalizatzen ari da, eskuin muturreko alderdien nahiz sare sozialetako pertsonaien eskutik, ideia matxistak zabaltzen eta egonkortzen ari baitira gizarte osoan. Egoera larria da, eta are larriagoa izan daiteke, ideia zein jarrera matxistei eta erreakzionarioei ateak... [+]


Mazónek ez du lortu bere misioa: Valentziako gurasoek katalanaren alde egin dute

“Askatasunaren” izenean, ikastetxean zein oinarrizko hizkuntza nahi duten galdetu diete guraso valentziarrei. Helburua katalana zokoratzea zen. PPren eta Voxen gobernuak ez du lortu. 33 eskualdeetatik 22tan katalana gailendu da. Emaitzarekin oso pozik agertu dira... [+]


800.000 euro gastatuko ditu EBk errusiar inbasioaren mamuari aurre egiteko

Europar Kontseiluak onartu du Ursula Von der Leyenek gastu militarrean proposatu duen 800.000 milioi euroko gastuarekin aurrera egitea. Horretarako bi arrazoi nagusi argudiatu ditu: Errusiari aurrea egitea eta Europar Batasunak aurrerantzean bere burua AEBen babes militarrik... [+]


Gizakunde
Badator, esnatu da

Gizakunde (Inauteriak)
Noiz: otsailaren 15ean.
Non: Arizkun eta Erratzun. plazan.

------------------------------------------------

Amaitu dira inauteriak, sutan erre ditugu gaiztoak, gaizkiak, sardinak eta panpinak. Baina xomorroak esnatu dira eta badator... [+]


Kontzertuak, hitzaldiak, antzerkiak, dantzak, bertso-saioak... M8ko ekitaldi kulturalen bilduma

Festa egiteko musika eta kontzertu eskaintza ez ezik, erakusketak, hitzaldiak, zine eta antzerki ikuskizunak eta zientoka ekintza kultural antolatu dituzte eragile ugarik Martxoaren 8aren bueltarako. Artikulu honetan, bilduma moduan, zokorrak gisa miatuko ditugu Euskal Herriko... [+]


Bizi testamentua: aurretiazko borondateen agiriaren gakoak

Soco Lizarraga mediku eta Nafarroako Duintasunez Hiltzeko Eskubidea elkarteko kidearen ustez bizi testamentuak heriotza duin bat eskaini eta familiari gauzak errazten dizkio.


“Topaketa antiinperialistak” egingo ditu Askapenak martxoaren 15 eta 16an Bilbon

Karmela espazio autogestionastuan egingo ditu, eta Euskal Herriko zein nazioarteko gonbidatuak egongo dira bertan. "Koiuntura analisi orokorretik abiatu eta Euskal Herriko borroka internazionalistaren gakoetarainoko bidea" egingo dutela adierazi du Askapenak... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude