Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

War is not in human genes, 10,000 years old.

  • Barack Obama, upon receiving the Nobel in 2009, said: “War is sometimes necessary and partly expresses the feelings of the human being.” John Horgan wants to challenge him with his book The End of War. That is, in terms of biology, that the human being is as peaceful as a warrior, that war can be avoided.
Ron Avi argazkilariaren irudian soldadu serbiarrak ageri dira Bosniako hiriburu Sarajevoko aldirietan, 1992tik 1995era bitartean izandako gerran. Egia da Balkanetako liskar odoltsuetan ere eragin zutela geopolitikak eta interes ekonomikoek, baina zerk era
Ron Avi argazkilariaren irudian soldadu serbiarrak ageri dira Bosniako hiriburu Sarajevoko aldirietan, 1992tik 1995era bitartean izandako gerran. Egia da Balkanetako liskar odoltsuetan ere eragin zutela geopolitikak eta interes ekonomikoek, baina zerk eraman zituen bortizkeria beldurgarri hartara Europaren bihotzean aski bizimodu erosoa zeukaten herritarrak? John Horganen hitzetan, ez du balio sarraskien errua talde barruko "ardi beltzei" edo "sagar ustelduei" egozteak , hobe da hitz egitea mailatutako saskikada osoaz. "Gerra da saskiko sagar guztiak usteltzea bezala. Piztuz gero, pertsona on, gizatiar eta zintzoak ere sarritan hasten dira jokatzen munstroak bailiran, berek bestela nahita ere. Hori ez da berez dakarten zerbait. Ez daukate geneetan idatzirik. Jokabide hori gerrak berak piztuarazi die".

John Horgan is a scientific journalist, writer of the prestigious journal Scientific American for years, collaborator of the BBC network and professor at the Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken, New Yersey (USA). It's written earlier by connections between science and spirituality. This February has published The End of War, which summarizes and analyzes what has been said so far on the subject from anthropology and biology. For the advanced web Alternet, he has been interviewed by Brad Jacobson.

Horgan wants to put an end to the prejudices that have dominated the war: that he is in the human being, that there have always been people in war, that he is in our genes, that we will not know a society without wars. “I have written a book fundamentally to condemn this negative perspective.”

Exploring the anthropology of war, Horgan discovers that scientists predominate those of that opinion. I mean, war is as old as man, or maybe older, than the old grandfather we have with chimpanzees could also use it.

Almost everyone says that the chimpanzees on one team come together and attack the chimpanzees on the other. Researching the scientific literature that has been published to take this for granted, Horgan finds that there are only a dozen confirmed cases. Richard Wrangham, who says that chimpanzees and the forms of guerrilla warfare of human beings are almost the same, further clarifies that this is a conduct he has rarely seen. Jane Goodall, who specializes in gorillas, also suggested that the practice of fighting may have been born recently, after the man was tightly squeezed by the primates' homes.

The other primates that have become fashionable in recent years are the Bonobos, who have popularized much more peaceful behaviors. “Peaceni [pacifist] loves people, especially the peacenics who believe that human beings are peaceful and welcoming in themselves. I am referring to the investigation of the Bonobos to deal with that chimpanzee issue. But I think we should put chimpanzees and bonobos aside because their behaviors can be very changed.”

It gives more importance to what archaeology says. According to archaeologists, war emerged among humans 10,000 years ago, in different parts of the world, and then spread to everything. So, it's not so old, instruments have already been invented, food cooking, religions, art and music. War is a young cultural innovation.

From the point of view of biology, most people say that competition for war, water, hunting, land and women has been caused by an excessively large population. Today, the main theme of the battle would be oil, according to that. But Horgan believes that this idea also has weak points. Sometimes a charismatic sociopath is able to bring all the people to battle.

Chimpanzee or bonobo?

However, more than a spring, Horgan is interested in mechanics. Once it's on, it starts a dynamic that feeds on itself. “We have to see war as a meme [in anthropology and sociology, the meme is a basic unit of cultural ideas and practices that can be transmitted between people], an idea or a practice that perpetuates itself since it has been created in a place, with a depth and lasting.”

This leads to battles for revenge or as a preventive attack on the enemy. Horgan explains the noise of the wars that are taking place between Iran, on the one hand, and the United States and Israel, on the other.

But just as war tends to perpetuate itself, people can also say “enough.” Horgan has featured three models. Switzerland and Sweden decided a long time ago to have an army but no longer to wage war. Horgan loves Costa Rica even more, which in the 1940s suffered a bloody civil war and since then refused to have an army.

Costa Rica is located in Central America, the most violent region in the world in the last half century, along with Nicaragua, Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, and lives in peace. That is why Horgan believes today that militarism and war must first be relinquished, and then democracy, freedom and others come along.

That man is naturally a warrior? Horgan mentions the book On Killing by Colonel Dave Grossman. Grossman has pointed out that most human beings do not want to kill anyone by investigating the practices of American soldiers. II. During the World War it was shown that many infantry soldiers did not shoot the enemy, did not want to kill him.

With the results of the investigation, the US Army hardened its training. In the war in Korea and especially in Vietnam, the soldiers were better targeting the enemy. On the other hand, upon returning home, stress from trauma increased a lot. In the 21st century, it burns farther than before to the enemy, with artillery, mumbai from the plane -- and lately, drones without a pilot. But that's a curiosity. Many of the military in Afghanistan, as if they were playing video games from a base in Nevada, are also stressed by trauma.

There are few people who enjoy washing their neighbour, even in wars, according to the studies mentioned by Horgan, 2%. Many of the others are shot to death. But people put everything in, and blood too. Philip Zimbardo, author of The Lucifer Effect, did an experiment at Stanford University in the 1970s. At Stanford Prison Experiment, some of his disciples were imprisoned and other guardians. By the second day the “guardians” sadly treated the “prisoners”...

Is war a matter for men? On the contrary, Horgan, following anthropologist Sarah Blaffer Hardy, believes that when a group formerly living in peace enters war, wars change the roles of men and women. Gamberradas are a consequence.

He is a disciple of sociologist Horgan Gene Sharp when it comes to war and peace. It has been written a thousand times that Sharp's ideas have greatly influenced the peaceful revolts of recent times. Horgan also believes that war is not a matter for the Social Democrats. “Just as important as man’s own aggressiveness is that people give in to war.”


ASTEKARIA
2012ko apirilaren 01
Most read
Using Matomo
Azoka
Newest
Agreement reached to improve conditions for children’s school workers on the threshold of two strike calls
After 16 years, the Basque Government and the Haurreskolak Consortium reached an agreement to renew the labor agreement on Monday evening. A strike was called for this Wednesday and Thursday, and the LAB and Steilas have left both calls without force. He will speak on Tuesday.

In the second round it will be decided who will be the President of Ecuador
Despite the fact that the current right-wing president, Daniel Noboa, is the favorite of most of the polls, he has taken less space than expected from the Correist candidate, Luisa González. The second round will take place on April 13.

2025-02-10 | ARGIA
Tractors on the streets of Vitoria-Gasteiz, Bayonne and Tafalla at the anniversary of the last protests
The protests in Vitoria-Gasteiz have been called by the associations Treviñu and Álava, the Tafalla by the association Semilla y Herarra and the Bayonne by the 'Peasants of the Pyrenees Mountain Range'. They have all denounced the competition stemming from the Mercosur trade... [+]

Goya Awards and Various Things to Say (No)
A large number of Basque citizens have been recognized by the Spanish film academy at the Goya Awards, which took place last weekend. In the second part of the article, we will highlight some of the issues that have given a lot to talk about.

Trump announces 25% tariffs on steel and aluminum
Donald Trump has announced that he will impose tariffs of 25% on steel and aluminum that imports the United States. It does not specify when the measure will enter into force.

Hamas and Israel hold fifth prisoner exchange
Three weeks after the ceasefire came into effect, Hamas released a total of 21 hostages, while Israel released 730. Israel’s president, Isaac Herzog, denounced the images of Israeli hostages as “an example of a crime against humanity.”

BDS organizes a boycott day against Carrefour for Saturday
The Boycott, Divestments and Sanctions campaign, prolonged in solidarity with Palestinian society, has called for "national reconciliation" on February 15 at five Carrefour shopping centers in the Southern Basque Country.

UPV Professor Investigated for Spreading “Fascist” Messages Denounces Identity Substitution in Networks
"Until the matter is clarified, the teacher will not return to the campus," said the rector, Joxerramón Bengoetxea, adding that a "mediation" has been launched to investigate what has happened and see what to do about it. Iñigo Ugedo, President of the UPV/EHU Student Council, has... [+]

EH Bila reaches out to the PNV and the Confederal Left to form joint lists with a view to Spain and Europe
It is possible to have a "minimum common program of broad consensus" at the base, says EH Bil. It will prioritize the formation of joint lists in the Spanish and European elections, taking the form of the New Citizen Front of the French State.

Hundreds of people in Bilbao demand the halt of the Ibaip motorway project
It has been denounced that the project initiated by the Provincial Council of Bizkaia does not respond to "the real needs of the population", Subfluvial NO! Called the platform. Instead of building highways, it has been said that institutions should promote public transport.

Beltrán and Sololuze commemorate the fifth anniversary of the Zaldibargo disaster
In addition to remembering the two employees, they have demanded responsibilities in the event held by Zaldibar Luz on Sunday in Eitzaga. They denounce the slowness of the justice system, since the summary is still in the stage of investigation.

“The City Council is illegally denying the census to the most disadvantaged people”
The initiative No Being Without a Census published two internal documents of the City Council of Vitoria-Gasteiz on 30 January. It includes restrictive criteria for registration in the municipality, “unfair and illegal”, according to the agent, to the detriment of the most... [+]

2025-02-10 | Behe Banda
Bar Warros |
Bring up the topic

Sometimes I don't know if it's too much. That we're eating a pipe, that we're talking about anything else, that we're bringing it up. We like to speak aloud, to leave almost no pause, to cover the voices, to throw a bigger one. Talk about each one of them, each one of them, what we... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude