Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Will the music school be re-tuned?

  • The resignation of CEO Carmen Rodríguez Suso can put an end to Musikene’s convulsive situation over the past two years. The two management committees of the High School of Music will now take care to bring normalcy to Musikene and, above all, to restore quality to music education.
Donostiako Bulebarrean kontzertuak eskaini zituzten Musikeneko ikasleek, besteak beste, zentroak bizi zuen egoera salatzeko.
Donostiako Bulebarrean kontzertuak eskaini zituzten Musikeneko ikasleek, besteak beste, zentroak bizi zuen egoera salatzeko.Juan Carlos Ruiz / Argazki press

The first week of July will officially finish the course in Musikene, but not in any way. For days students have not gone to class, on strike to denounce the management of the center. The strike that began on 19 May was the last in the mobilizations and protests called in the last two years against the leadership position presided over by Carmen Rodríguez Suso. The goal was clear, that Musikene would return to the normal situation, and inevitably, Rodríguez Suso would leave office. The general coordinator of Podemos announced his resignation on 15 June, following a brief meeting. This was the “first step towards solution”, according to the Rally Beñat, a student of Pedagogy of Language and Musical Education.

Rodríguez Suso was appointed general coordinator of Musikene in October 2009, on the proposal of the president of the school board, the Basque Government Education Minister, Isabel Celaá. In statements to journalists after a month in office, Rodríguez Suso stressed that “having so many teachers and such good managers per square meter was one of the main reasons for Musikene’s pride.”

But these words didn't fit the reality. Immediately after his appointment, Rodriguez Suso suspended Musikene’s organic regulations and dismissed the artistic director and the center’s managing director, without a substitute being foreseen for them. It was then learned that some school officials and counselors had also resigned, angry with the new policy. This policy contemplated profound changes in Musikene, arguing that the leadership team that preceded Suso had brought the music school to an “unsustainable” situation and stressing that the economic cuts were necessary. In this regard, the Vice-Minister of Universities and Research of the Basque Government, Pedro Luis Arias, pointed out that, on the occasion of the recent dismissals, “the situation required a series of measures to be taken seriously”.

The new management measures only increased the critical voices that began to emerge among professors and, above all, among students. In February 2010, the Rules of Rights and Duties of Students of Musikene were signed to the students of the center. In a five-page document, attention was drawn to a point that sparked protests. According to the regulations, the management considered it a very serious error and, therefore, the dismissal of the student could be motivated “by conducts that, facing the outside, impair the prestige and image of Musikene”. With this measure, the team of Rodríguez Suso concealed in practice critical voices against politics, which had already begun to create reticence. Specifically, it was at that time that several students and professors of Musikene published the manifesto Musikene salve, denouncing that the new management jeopardizes the “built model” for years (today the text has the adhesion of 2,700 people linked to music).The appointment of
Juan Carlos Perez as new artistic director also provoked controversy at the National Audience in April 2010. Without questioning the artistic trajectory of the composer and member of the Itoiz group, the students denounced that it was a person without musical qualifications or experience in academic management. They criticized that the selection criteria were not those of an academic director of the higher school. The teachers also showed the direction their "surprise" and told them that the choice seemed "inappropriate". In an interview with ETB, Pérez defended himself in the decision of Musikene's patron, escaping criticism: “I presented my resume and the board considered it appropriate.”

In the interview offered
shortly after the Declaration of the Quality of Education, Juan Carlos Pérez relativized the possible consequences of the cuts proposed for Musikene: “I don’t think the cuts will influence the quality of education; it’s just going to be adapting to new numbers.”

These new measures, which were planned to deal with the economic crisis, resulted in the dismissal of 27 teachers in August 2010. The management also wanted to reduce from 114 to 50 the places of new students for the 2010-2011 course, while reducing the specializations of students from 34 to 20. The mobilizations and pressures that emerged from teachers and students rejected the intention of the management and finally, 75 places were offered, a figure significantly lower than that of the previous course. No special class known as masterclass has been held in the last year and the optional subjects that students can attend have been drastically reduced. The management also proposed the collectivization of the practice classes - so far personalized - for the training in the instrument of each student.

Contrary to the words of Juan Carlos Pérez, students and professors of Musikene repeatedly denounced that the new management measures impacted the quality of education. They emphasized the importance of individuality for the musical training of students, especially in the practical training of musical instruments, as well as the wide variety of specializations. They denounced that many students who would enroll in Musikene to study with those teachers, firing professors of recognized prestige, would not register. In the words of the piano professor at the center Enmanuel Ferrer-Laloe, Musikene had become a “theoretical school of music.” For their part, the students denounced that “in an educational center the terms of cost of companies cannot be used” because “musical training is not
a screw company”. The “excellence” achieved by Musikene over the years, which led him to be a benchmark in Europe, even more so in the state, was at risk by students and teachers, due to the measures taken by the management. They believed it was possible to guarantee a minimum of quality without the “drastic” cuts that had been made. There were voices that felt that the measures did not respond to the economic situation, but pursued other objectives. One of them is that of student Beñat Ralla, who wants to highlight that it is a personal opinion: “I have often had the suspicion that they do not want such a center for Euskal Herria. If it is not in Spain, it is not here either; that Euskal Herria does not stand out in this sense”. The words of the general coordinator, Rodríguez Suso, do not go far from this idea: “Let Musikene not be a parachutist, not an island of excellence in the middle of the ocean of mediocrity.”

As the months progressed, and through other controversial measures and suspicions, especially the denunciation of the meeting with Rodríguez
Suso Pier Cao in Paris, before he was officially appointed director of Orchestral Studies, he increased criticism of the management of the new direction. In the early days of May of this year, three members of the Musikene management team and ten counselors from the school resigned. Those who resigned denounced the lack of transparency in leadership and the lack of confidence of Rodríguez Suso's professors. They also expressed doubts about the criteria used in the process of choosing professors and positions in recent months and demanded resources to end the “precariousness” that reduced the quality of education. Given the inability to cope with the situation, Juan Carlos Pérez himself resigned on 18 May, after almost a year in office.

The students, who also considered the resignation of the general coordinator, Rodríguez Suso, to solve the situation, intensified their protests and called for a strike on May 19, signed by 68.75% of the students. On the Boulevard de Donostia-San Sebastián the claim came to society through concerts.

Finally, on June 15, Rodríguez Suso surrendered his position to the patron of Musikene, who resigned the following day. This opened the way to the measure agreed days before by the heads of the Department of Education and the Musikene Business Committee. Accordingly, two management committees will be set up, one with three members, chaired by Patricio Goyalde, and another joint committee, which will be represented by all sectors of the educational community. They will be in charge of bringing normality to Musikene from now on and those who take on the challenge of returning quality to music education, in order to repair the damaged “excellence”. The students have also been in favor of the measure and live the situation with hope, as according to the Rally “Patri Goyalde is the person who gives us confidence”.


Newest
For education in Basque, no more English sessions

We have had to endure another attack on our language by the Department of Education of the Government of Navarre; we have been forced to make an anti-Basque change in the PAI program. In recent years, by law, new Model D schools have had to introduce the PAI program and have had... [+]


2025-04-15 | Irutxuloko Hitza
The Basque Culinary Center will open its new GOe headquarters in San Sebastian in October
The works of the Gastronomy Open Ecosystem (GOe) have already entered the final stage, explains Joxe Mari Aizega, director of the Basque Culinary Center (BCC), during his institutional visit to San Sebastian on Monday.

2025-04-15 | Bertsozale.eus
Kattin Madariaga Apaolaza wins the Navarre Inter-School Championship 2025
The 39th edition of the Navarra Inter-School Championship has been played in Irurtzun. Six young bertsolaris took part in the tournament, of which Kattin Madariaga of Arantza wore the hat. The runner-up was Kattalin Lizarraga. Both will represent Navarre in the Basque Country.

Two years since the war broke out
Sudan’s paramilitaries kill 350 people in refugee camps over weekend
The UN says that since the beginning of the conflict, at least 13 million Sudanese have been forced to leave their homes, and half of the population suffers from food shortages. The Rapid Support Force (RSF) has attacked the Darfur region over the weekend, killing at least 350... [+]

With the approval of the motion of censure, the UPN loses the mayor's office of Noain-Elorcibar
The independent team of NSAID Noain-Elorcibar, Valle Gara and Cambio Elorcibar will be in charge of the city council, and the latter’s Luis Maya will take command.On March 31, it was announced that the motion would be presented because of the "drift" and "lack of transparency" in... [+]

2025-04-15 | Mikel Aramendi
THE ANALYSIS
With millions of lawyers or swimmers, reindustrializing the United States?
The joke of a million swimmers is from the time of Mao’s 1953 video, which someone has put back into circulation in connection with the tariff dispute. I mean, from the year Xi Jinping was born, who now seems to be joining him.

Rally to condemn the rape reported at the Xingar Fair in Bayonne
A man was arrested on Saturday on charges of raping a woman on Thursday night. The man remains in custody until the case is resolved. Itaia made a mobilization on Monday at 6:30 p.m. at the Casa del Pueblo in Bayonne, emphasizing its responsibility.

The memory of those deported by the Nazis in a wallet
The wallet of the Gamerean Jean Iribarne,who died in 1945 in the Nazi concentration camp of Neuengamm, has been recovered and handed over to his relatives. In the Northern Basque Country, at least 350 citizens were deported for their participation in the resistance, and almost... [+]

Elena Barrena, referent of professors and historians dies
His doctoral thesis on the creation of Gipuzkoa was a pioneer in understanding the evolution of the historical territories. Professor at the University of Deusto, his way of working and teaching has been an example for many historians.

Once again, ten years after the closure of the Old House of Gernika
The Egurre Youth Assembly has stated that it will launch a project that responds to the "interests and needs of young workers" in Gernika. The building, which was closed ten years ago, has been denounced as saying that the city council has three legislatures saying it will install... [+]

Mario Vargas Llosa, Nobel Laureate and writer
He died at the age of 89 in Lima, and his death was reported by the children of the Peruvian writer. He was one of the most famous authors of Spanish literature and played an important role in the flourishing of literature in Latin America in the 1960s and 1970s. He went from... [+]

2025-04-14 | ARGIA
Gabriel Elli's "Communist Character", 50th Anniversary of his Death Kari
Organized by the Socialist Council of the Basque Country (EHKS), a full-day event was held on Sunday at the Campos Eliseos Theatre in Bilbao. Several speeches have completed the programme, culminating in the premiere of the play Segunda un futuro Aresti (Before the future).

Eguneraketa berriak daude