Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

The Observatory claims that guaranteeing Euskera is a matter of "social justice" in relation to the Barakaldo ruling

  • The Observatory on Linguistic Rights denounces that access to public services in Basque is a basic collective right and considers it serious that the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has prevented the City of Barakaldo from requesting Euskera in public services. On the other hand, the Basque association Sasiburu de Barakaldo has asked for answers to the city council, since "the right to live in Basque in the locality is repeatedly violated".

05 January 2023 - 10:21
Last updated: 12:45
EAEko Auzitegi Nagusiak galarazi egin du Barakaldon zerbitzu publikoetan hizkuntza-klausulak ezartzea. /Argazkia: Uztarria

From Euskalgintza, the judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country against the guarantee of Euskera services in private companies has been strongly condemned. The last attack on Euskera has been carried out in the services subcontracted by the City of Barakaldo, since the High Court of Justice has ruled that minimum levels of Euskera cannot be required in private positions in charge of the management of cultural projects.

In the public competitions that the City Council took out in 2021, one of the requirements was that the Euskera level be B2 and C1 for administrative and maintenance personnel and C1 for technical personnel. Meanwhile, CCOO used the competition arguing that the conditions did not fit Barakaldo's linguistic reality. These weeks the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has given the trade union the right.

The Council considers that the judgment has not complied with the law

The Council of Euskalgintza qualifies the sentence as “very serious”. He also recalled that it is not the first case that justice gives “a setback” to the Basque country, and that the underlying problem is the judicialization of linguistic policy, the increasingly reduced and distorted reading of linguistic rights in courts. In this sense, he recalled the case of the local police of Irun or the difficulty of not demanding the Basque in Laudio.

The Council argues that the current legislation allows for the establishment of language clauses in contracts to guarantee the services of public administrations in Basque. For this reason, the President of the Council, Idurre Eskisabel, has sent a letter to the Mayor of Barakaldo requesting the appeal because he considers that the law is favourable: “The court has issued a very weak judgment, because it has not taken into account the decrees currently in force”.

The Council of Euskalgintza has asked the City of Barakaldo to appeal the judgment of the High Court of Justice, since the current decree allows the Basque Country to demand the Basque Country.

"Euskera is a collective right"

The Observatory that works against violations of linguistic rights has followed the same line and has pointed out that, in addition to being legal to require conditions to guarantee Basque to private companies, it is “social justice” to guarantee a collective right.

Regarding the consideration of the socio-linguistic situation, he criticized that “injustices are used to perpetuate” in the courts: “Precisely, to reinforce the gaps and needs that should be taken into account”.

The Basque Association Sasiburu of Barakaldo has also denounced the ruling and pointed out that in the locality the citizens' right to live in Euskera is denied "over and over again": "When we resort to municipal public services, we are often forced to speak in Spanish". They have perceived that they are "much more" Euskaldunes than a few years ago: 30 years ago they did not reach 5,000, and now there are 26,251 Basques and almost 20,000 Basques. The association questions the High Court of Justice’s reading of Barakaldo’s socio-linguistic situation.

Public administration measures

Likewise, ELA opposes the sentence and adds to the claim of the right to live in Basque the work in Basque. Recalls the measures agreed by LAB, ELA and the Council in 2022 to use the 15-year deadline for public administration.


You are interested in the channel: Euskara lan munduan
People's Agreement on Euskaldunising the World of Work
Euskaldunization of the world of work, one of the main challenges of the process of normalization of the Basque Country, is the shared diagnosis between the Basque Country and the Basque agents. All the investment made for decades in the Euskaldunization of the new generations... [+]

A municipal agent of Eibar exempts from Basque knowledge a court of Donostia
The Municipal Guard has been working since 1992 in a position with an Euskera profile and in a competition that requires a stabilization process the Basque was still a requirement. This obligation has been appealed by the Municipal Police Officer, and the Judge is right.

227 places by Basque profiles in Bizkaia
The Administrative Dispute Tribunal of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country suspended two processes for the stabilization of the staff of the Provincial Council of Bizkaia. Judgments are not firm.  

2024-02-21 | Rober Gutiérrez
Languages at work

Languages Lan has just organised the first international conference on linguistic management in Bilbao. Much has been said in the Congress about language policy, management and tools. And emotions. And from emotions, how many cooperatives, companies and organizations in our... [+]


2023-12-11 | Rober Gutiérrez
What to ask for a job?

Few spend their whole lives at the same work. What was common at the time of our parents, today, is absolutely unusual. It seems that millennial generation youth will not spend five years in the same job and the time will be much shorter between Z and Alpha generations.

I too,... [+]


The directors of the two departments of the City of Donostia will not need to know Basque.
Exceptional procedures have been initiated to appoint two directors, so they should not certify the Basque level. The LAB union denounces the situation and explains that “the efforts” made in the last three decades to euskaldunify municipal employees will be thwarted.

2023-08-29 | Rober Gutiérrez
Magnitude of small achievements

In June, at the last meeting of the Euskaragileak Works Committee, I was informed that the Elay Group presented the consolidated accounts and the management report for the financial year 2022, together with the independent audit report, in the State Trade Register. As regards... [+]


The test for the Berritzegune post can be carried out in Spanish, as the Government has modified the call
Professors who attend the call to work in the Berritzegunes of the CAV for the next school year will see a change in the oral defense patterns of their work: in the previous call, where he said “defense will be in Basque”, now says that “defense will be preferably in... [+]

Patients at the centre against discrimination
According to the Nationmetro, 56% of the population considers that the possibility of receiving care in Euskera should be a right and 32.5% believe that it is not.

"Knowing that we want a Basque doctor, they make us calm in Spanish"
Joseba Otano, a member of the Basque Administration, has spoken about the violations of linguistic rights in the health sector.

2023-03-02 | Rober Gutiérrez
Supply and demand

It is often difficult to find a service or product in Basque. Not everything can be achieved in Basque. We must look for suppliers that offer us products and/or services in Basque, both in the private and professional spheres.

Consumer legislation in the regulations of the... [+]


New sentence in Basque
The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country considers the application of Euskera in opposition to 34 public carers illegal
The San Sebastian court ruled last year that the request for Euskera in competitions to cover 34 places of caregiver at the Uliazpi Foundation of the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa was lawful and non-discriminatory. This resolution has now been revoked by the High Court of... [+]

Why has the government not appealed against a ruling that does not require minimum Basque standards for municipal officials?
Judge Ana María Martínez decided in September that municipal agents do not have to certify the level B2 of Euskera; she has now ratified the ruling and has given a period of two months to recognize those who were left out of the Arkaute workbench by the linguistic profile in... [+]

2023-01-25 | ARGIA
Arkaute must collect applicants who do not have the Basque level B2
The Administrative Tribunal of Vitoria-Gasteiz has approved the appeal of the UGT union and has ratified the judgment: municipal agents will not have to certify a minimum level of Euskera. The Hearing grants the Arkaute Police Academy two months to recognize those who were left... [+]

2023-01-03 | ARGIA
The City of Barakaldo will not appeal the judgment of the Basque requirements of the subcontractors
The Council of Euskalgintza requests that an appeal be made on the ground that the judgment goes against municipal legislation.

Eguneraketa berriak daude