Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Solitude of the tortured


28 June 2024 - 08:09
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

When we talk publicly about torture, we realize how much society embraces the opinion that the “system” itself puts into effect on this issue. It uses a wide range of ministers and advisers, judges and experts, all with the help of the organic media, of course. And it has to be said: you achieve your goal. In Spanish democracy there is no torture, no torture. That's the result. The reason is axiomatic and frightening. “In Spain and the Basque Country there are no torture because they cannot be proved.”

Despite seeing many amazing things in this strange democracy, both in Madrid and in Pamplona and Vitoria-Gasteiz we still have a lot to do.

Even at the time of Francoism, torture and murder could not be demonstrated. So no, but now yes, some “forever” Democrats, not all, have just begun to regret, but many others have not. Looking back, reproaching that they threaten democracy.

We are not the only ones who live in such situations. The political race of “winners” is universal and its ideological initiation has such results. Gas chambers, sterilizations, etc., also in concentration camps of Hitler's time. There was no way to test it. A “neutral” commission in Germany, led by a Swede, conducted an investigation. He found nothing. Therefore, Goebbels could not conceal that those allegations were slanderous to harm the Third Reich.

But in 1945, the Soviet Army discovered those realities that apparently did not exist and could not be proved. And of course, then they did exist.

As we were recently informed, the statements that the police have obtained "by itself" are to be annulled. OK, suppose you're going to do your word, but you don't make any mention of the isolation of detainees.

Something similar will happen in a few years' time, here in Euskal Herria. We will then know today what is impossible, why in our small country we are so many of ETA, and in Spain, on the contrary, none of the LAGs.

Felipe González's PSOE did not know how to distance itself from the members of the GAL, and now instead of moving away from the covert violence, pp uses the political resources it generates. You know, you're used to cheating.

Is it a simple question, perhaps Mr Goebbels, like Hitler and Franco, knew nothing? The same has happened with F. Gonzalez and all the other presidents, nobody knows anything.

Decades later, we sat in front of television, and we all saw the Holocaust. Impossible to prove. What the investigation had not witnessed. Slander was invented to harm the third Reich.

In the Spanish State, as the Soviet army has not yet entered, we will have to follow other ways of ending the plague that so well protects the system. But in the meantime, Spanish democracy is going to keep theirs, torture, feeding the hidden damn guardian of the system. These are some of the consequences of the breakdown of Franco.

I think we all know that when we reform what we have we do so with the intention of maintaining it. That is why in Spanish democracy, such as the Franco regime, the law that prevents torture from proving torture, is the one that has been given with all the blessings of “democratic” political parties. In my opinion, even if there were no torture, by itself, and no more, a wreck and cruel elimination of human rights. In democratic or fascist states, it doesn't matter.

It is not the citizen – who is asked to vote from time to time – who has to close the doors to torture and who has to try to ensure that there is no torture. It is a task of the State. Prisons and torture are the “thermometer” of democracy. As the nature of the law shows the form of the legislator, the true nature of the State is manifested in it.

However, if democracy is based on human rights and dialogue, the laws place the prisoner, tortured, outside dialogue and human rights. Therefore, outside democracy, outside the state.

So what's not a person is not a person. A State that could “dehumanize” the person is not the State of Humanity. What democracy, therefore, or what state, that the prisoners, tortured, and who join their sufferings, must defend against the attack on terrorism? Why defend ourselves, a democracy that does not defend us?

In prison, it is the solidarity of strangers that slowly heals broken bones and flattened meats. But, on the other hand, it is this cynicism that always appears transparent, just and “peaceful”, which causes an impotence cry on the cold nights of the prisoner. A bitter source of rage and despair. He who destroys the soul. And finally, violence as a generator. Yes, sir, inspiring violence.

Life in jail is long. The tortured, in the end, will come to hate those who, rather than himself, in his own powerlessness, should help, but those who despise him. “The Democrats of Always” and the democracy of the Democrats of Always.

Democracy of political parties and conventions. Electoral and parliamentary democracy. Democrats who have been corrupting democracy for so many years with total impunity at the height of power.

At the expense of yesterday’s torture, which today, by shouting, has managed to appear in images of martyrs. Those who are asked for evidence of their torture, after having been charged by them.

Although what I have said so far is undeniable, some say that we can be faced with something else. As we were recently informed, the statements that the police have obtained "by itself" are to be annulled. Okay, suppose you're going to do your word, but you haven't made any reference to the isolation of the detainees. They therefore maintain the mandatory protection of torture of different kinds; the isolation of detainees.

I believe that in the twenty-first century, in order to maintain its system, the state it needs of the torturers should not have a place within Europe.

 

Why the solitude of the detainees?

Josu Iraeta, writer

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Irakurleen gutunak
Need for renewable energy planning in the Basque Country

Conservative mentalities are afraid of the term planning, linking with progressive and even communist political currents, as the new authoritarianisms do today (Milei, Meono, Orban, Aznar, among others). However, the idea of planning is still in good health, at least formally... [+]


Meaka-Irimo is still alive!
A long time ago, a wind strike announced that a company was going to build a wind power plant on Mt. Irimo. Most people didn't believe it. Even less so are those who know the orography and the rocky character of Mt. Irimo. "But do you know what damage they would do by going down... [+]

2024-07-11 | Patxi Juaristi
The XIX Congress of Basque Studies Congress, behind closed doors

The issue of cohesion is today the first responsibility of many governments, public institutions and non-governmental organisations. Indeed, societies with low inequalities more easily generate conditions for economic, social and cultural development, better governance... [+]


In the UPV/EHU, Euskaldunization also needs tension

Although significant progress has been made in recent decades in some areas and areas of the Euskaldunization process, in public administrations the Basque Country faces serious obstacles and threats. In addition to the offensive against the Basque people that is taking place in... [+]


The PSN War

The Navarra Federation of Municipalities and Councils was born with the objective of "protecting and promoting their shared interests and local autonomy". A Communication Officer will soon be selected who will have to master Spanish and Basque.

For the PSN-PSOE rejects it... [+]


Education

End of course. The professor in his solitude. It prints the rhythm of the reflection that noise does in the traction of the train: Has the work done this year been worthwhile? Exhausted, thoughtful, remember his friend's words: “Txo, the teachers have no right to complain to... [+]


Bilbao BBK Live absorbs me the 'life'!

Summer comes and with it the popular festivals of towns, neighborhoods and cities. Festivities have always been the refuge of social and political demands, neighborhood relations and popular euphoria. They take our streets and for a few days they are an example of... [+]


37 questions to the new counselor living on the other side of the public education limit
Who orders us ...?

The Basque Government has just been set up and the Minister for Education will be Begoña Pedrosa. Being a vice-counselor in the previous legislature and being one of the founders of the new Education Law passed last December, we are allowed to ask some... [+]


2024-07-03 | Joan Mari Beloki
They lead us to war.

The last elections have sent us a clear message. We Europeans do not want wars. Ukraine has to end and the politicians have to take steps in this direction as soon as possible. In France and Germany, the far-right has been loosely imposed and the reason is in the war in Ukraine:... [+]


Is everything tied and well tied?

The Spanish state would become the dystopian stage of Tejerazo, in 1981. There, the political leaders confined to Congress were "invited" to approve a tacit agreement in which the status quo linked to the monarchic system, the bipartisan political system (establishment of closed... [+]


The sun burns the house
Tourists have filled apartments and hotels with exorbitant prices. And you in your parents' home, desperate, while big companies and speculators put rental to the test.

Head by neck

The new government formation has left many unanswered questions, but it is clear that once again we will have to be firm in betting on the Basque Public School. We were told that, although the same party will govern, we would have new faces, but that has not been entirely true... [+]


20 June Joint Initiative for Palestinian Children and Adolescents in Schools

We are parents of Euskal Herria, daughters and sons; they are called Maddi, Izei, Dani, Alaitz, Aida or BEÑAT, but they may be Hatem Salem, Awad Muhammad 14 years old, Zakaria Magdy 6 years old or Nour Ahmed 7 years old. They were all killed by Israel in Gaza.

We can't imagine... [+]


2024-06-28 | Rober Gutiérrez
People in the center

After the post-election negotiation phase, PNV and PSE-EE have laid the groundwork for a government agreement between the two to “advance welfare, progress, self-government and transformation of the global Euskadi”. An 11-page document details the commitments and activities... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude