Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

“Department stores are affected by what consumers have said on social media”

  • A consumer has made a complaint to the Observatory about the lack of advertising in Basque of the large Decathlon trade in Donostia. The Point of Sale response is significant: Community law does not contain any imposition on the placement of the billboard in Euskera. In other words, the legal obligation is called imposition. We interviewed the director of the Agurne Gaubeka Observatory to inform us about the consumer law.

25 October 2024 - 10:42
Last updated: 2024-10-31 12:57

The Observatory has denounced the response of the large commercial establishment Decathlon, located in the Gipuzkoan capital. They have explained that they have qualified as imposing their legal obligation to shoot in Euskera.

We feel serious about the contempt they give to customers, to say that it is an imposition to disseminate in Basque the information you send to your client. That's why we spread this issue.

In the Catalan countries, they enjoy greater legal protection and greater social pressure. We are also trying to do so, but we need more legal support.

It is not just a question of Decathlon, we have more and more multinationals in our towns and cities, and some action needs to be taken on them. We are talking about total liberalisation of languages, and that is where we must also demand action.

What are the consequences of a trade that does not respect the language requirements laid down by law?

The new consumer and user law dates from 2023, the previous one from 2003. We, when the new law was passed, denounced that there was no innovative step in guaranteeing the rights of Euskaldun citizenship. What is more, it has setbacks in relation to the original 2003 law. Taking into account the law of 2023, in the CAPV there are some kind of legal obligations, at least in relation to the rotulation of large commercial centres, but these are also not properly complied with. One example is Decathlon. They are often not met, and when they are not met there are no consequences. In other words, the 2023 law from the outset refused to take proper advantage of the normative nature of the law and to impose its obligations. Consequently, it is about the promotion of the rights of citizens, and not about the legal obligation. The law itself is taken away from the normative value, and that is a contradiction. Companies, in other matters, which violate the law and do not infringe language rights. For example, they don't have a fine. That is why we are calling for greater legal support.

Some large businesses join the Basque Country. How is it possible that such infringements of language rights will then take place?

I have just quoted the characteristics of the 2023 law. The basis of the law is the will and encouragement of the Basque Country, not coercion. We take these two bases with tweezers to refer to big business. Euskaraldia may be an incentive to take action, but with regard to these large companies we believe that legal support can be more effective. Strengthening support and establishing specific obligations, because the lawyers of these companies have responded many times that they have no legal obligation (for example, in Navarre) and that there are few enforcement mechanisms in the CAPV.

Jonmikel Intsausti

What strength do customers have in the face of violations?

It is true that we receive answers like Decathlon's, and sometimes they don't even respond to us. However, customers have the power. In Decathlon, in Oiartzun, there were self-tanning machines and they were able to choose Euskera, but they were eliminated. A protest was made and he recovered from the election of the Basque. A new Alcampo trade was installed and all the exterior labeling was in Spanish. The clients filed complaints and the incidence was higher. They are affected by what citizens and consumers have said on social media.

The attitude of these macro-enterprises towards small peoples and towards language is often clear, derogatory. In order to change these attitudes, we have to work from the bottom up and make consumers aware: where we consume, how, what recognition they make of our rights ...

You say that Catalan consumers have more legal protection.

One example is the websites of big brands. They offer the possibility to choose Catalan, but they do not have the Basque, and as in the Catalan countries, they also have positions in the Basque Country. They have greater legal protection and stricter obligations, and it can also be due to social pressure.

In the interior of Euskal Herria there is also such discrimination, although companies are not so large. They have different linguistic policies in the CAV, Navarra and Iparralde, answer: “The Navarre law does not oblige me.” They are very “legalistic”.

Jonmikel Intsausti

You are interested in the channel: Euskaldunen aurkako erasoak
“Interference of the judiciary” denounced in San Sebastián in relation to the issue of the Basque language requirements of local police
In January of last year, the judges annulled two local police posts with a B2 requirement, considering that applying for Basque could be "discriminatory", and in the previous week, the Superior Court of the Basque Country has decided not to consider the appeal filed by the City... [+]

Aggression against the linguistic requirements of the local police in Donostia, Astigarraga and Usurbil
The City Council of Donostia-San Sebastián appealed in September 2024 because in January of the same year the judges annulled the B2 language requirement of both municipal police officers. The Supreme Court of the Basque Country will not even refer the appeal to the court... [+]

San Sebastián residents sentenced for speaking Basque have been fined
The Basque Government has lifted fines for the Basque people who were punished for speaking Basque to the border. These citizens are Manex Ralla and Amaia Abendaño, who have confirmed to this media that they have been deprived of fines.

2025-01-30 | Aiaraldea
Amurrio City Council refuses to include the Ayaraldea Media subsidy in the municipal budgets of 2025
The budgets of the Amurrio City Council for 2025 will be discussed and voted in this Thursday’s Plenary Session and, once again, the Municipal Government has refused to reinstate the agreement and subsidy of the Ayaraldea Media.

The hiring dossier for the drafting of the HAPO of San Sebastián has excessive language requirements, according to the college of architects
Due to the appeal of the College of Architects, the City Council of San Sebastián rejects the hiring file.

Bizkaiko Foru Aldundiko langileen eta euskararen alde elkarretaratzea egin dute Bilbon

Euskalgintzaren Kontseiluak eta Bizkaiko Foru Aldundiko langileak elkarretaratzea egin dute langileen egonkortzearen eta euskalduntzearen alde.


Painted in the courts and offices of CCOO and UGT to denounce the aggression against the Basque Country
After painting the Baiona and Donostia-San Sebastian courts, a painting was carried out on Thursday evening at the Eibar Court. The authors have written "stop the onslaught" and launched a green painting on the building, which has been demolished. In December, several offices of... [+]

2024-12-27 | ARGIA
The LAB trade union has denounced the appointment of URL0 director to "a person who does not know Euskera"
"A person who is not Euskaldun – Nagore de los Rios – has been elected by the EITB General Directorate Eitb.eus and as the director of the Social Media section and, consequently, a person who does not know Euskera has been designated as the director of a media that has among... [+]

Event commemorating the Basques of Irun: 35 associations tell the city council "enough"
The patience of the Basques of Irun has been overwhelmed; they are angry and on this occasion they are not going to "shut up". The fact that the act of lighting the Christmas lights was carried out in full in Spanish has led 35 associations of the city to denounce the linguistic... [+]

2024-10-30 | Sustatu
Do we have the right to be treated in Euskera?
One of the last offensives of the rulings against the Basque Country has been that which has called into question a Gipuzkoan public entity, Kabia, with a ruling contrary to the established linguistic profiles. The ruling considers that the requirements in Euskera established... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude