Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

The mental health problem isn't yours, it's ours.


05 April 2023 - 10:51

“Houston, we have a problem!”

Well, to say that we have a single problem, as things are, can be a temerity, but this time I want to focus on an issue that concerns us and affects us internally, mental health.

Historically, suffering has had a profound meaning and meaning. It was a sign that told us that something worked wrong, put us in front of the environment, looking for the structural origin of our discomfort, and that evolution of the causes of suffering could become the starting point that activated us to fight collectively.

Neoliberalism has revolutionized it. Since 1980 there has been a new interpretation of suffering, totally depoliticizing our discomfort and making it a trade opportunity for the benefit of economic objectives:

– Suffering has been related to individual origins: what needs to be changed is not the system, it is you.

– Individual well-being has been linked to consumerism.

Attitudes and feelings that seek to question or modify the status quo have been medicalized.

– Suffering has become a business opportunity.

The ideology of mental health for the economy has not only transformed activity in this field, but also the psychological attitude of a whole generation. At least that's what British professor at James Davies University says: "Sedated. How modern capitalism managed the mental health crisis” (2022, Captain Swing).

Can't make sense of the work you do? You have to learn how to develop positive thinking; tori self-help books. Are you unemployed and unable to find a job? You have to change that inadequate mental attitude, work the positive psychology, you can! What do kids spend a bad time in school? The younger you are diagnosed and start taking the corresponding psychopharmaceuticals, the better…

Can't make sense of the work you do? You must learn to develop positive thinking; books of self-help tori

Davies makes an interesting comparison between the debt trend and the consumption of psychopharmaceuticals since 1980. They both grow and rise, but neither do they improve our lives, they say they are a way of hiding the structural problems that our society has.

“The use of psychotropic drugs has become widespread, not because they are the safest, most beneficial and most effective, but because public services do not have the necessary funding. This direction has been imposed by neoliberalism. The approach of very powerful pharmaceutical and psychiatric interests has prevailed; the use of psychopharmaceuticals and the cognitive behavioral approach have placed the problem among our ears”.

Psychotherapy didn't have to be that way. I didn't have to depoliticize and medicalize people's suffering. In fact, in good hands, psychotherapy could be useful for sociopolitical awareness and criticism. But the health of the economy has taken precedence over people's health.

If we do not respond to our basic needs (physical and economic security, affective linkage, personal fulfilment, meaningful work. equal treatment and respect) we will have little welfare. Consumerism is not only not useful in solving this discomfort, it is also harmful because it distances us from what would truly enrich our lives.

The medicalized approach dissolves the collective experience, removing our discomfort of social and shared origin and applying it to dysfunctions that are situated in the individual self

When a group understands and becomes aware of the causes of its problems, social and political action is made possible. The medicalized approach, however, dissolves the collective experience, extracting our discomfort of social and shared origin, applying it to dysfunctions that are situated in the individual self. Political tribes become diagnostic tribes because we begin to identify with a group related to a particular mental illness. Our suffering is deactivated politically. The emphasis is placed on the individual self, rather than on social reform, and individualistic therapies accentuate it.

In Davies’ words, “most mental illnesses have psychosocial origins. This does not mean that we can reduce all causes of mental illness to inequality or any other particular social factor. You can't say that our biology doesn't influence our social and psychological lives. It means that social determinants must be central to the interpretation and management of our mental suffering. That is why we must put the world and everything that happens in it at the centre of our work. This requires mentally healthy social policies. We must ensure that all our interventions incorporate a sociological perspective. As Michael Marmota, one of the most illustrious public health professors in the UK, says, "We need to build a society based on the principles of social justice that reduces income and wealth inequalities, and that builds a welfare economy at the heart of the government's strategy, replacing blind economic interests with well-being and health."

James Davies highlights in his book the words of Lithuanian psychiatrist Dainius P?ras (UN special rapporteur on the right to physical and mental health from 2014 to 2020). In fact, when psychologists are asked what's going on, 90 percent say the problem is a lack of resources. Dainius P?ras, however, states that the main problem is not the lack of resources, but the correct reorientation of expenditure to address the social causes of discomfort and to implement effective psychological and social interventions.

Policies that address the social roots of suffering, a fairer tax system, more unionization of workers, better social benefits, more community protection and reduction of inequalities and social exclusion

According to Fr., the austerity policies implemented since 2008 have accentuated the factors that worsen mental health: social fragmentation, inequalities and social isolation. If governments do not oppose these social determinants of suffering, biomedical and individualistic treatments increase, poor mental health outcomes will worsen.

The UN rapporteur has his recipe for improving things: policies that will address the social roots of suffering, a fairer tax system, more unionization of workers, better social benefits, more community protection and reduction of inequalities and social exclusion. “We must focus on relationships, not on the brain: bringing people together, demedicating discomfort and addressing problematic social and environmental causes.”

Reading the book shows that the problem of mental health is a win-win-win strategy for capital: not only do the conditions that cause discomfort (individualism, consumerism, depoliticization) occur, but they are enriched with medicalized remedies and the collective response with insanity. In the end it is true that the only problem we have is capitalism with all its surnames.

Unai Oñederra

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Irakurleen gutunak
Statement of the Basque Committee of the EITB
With this letter, the Basque Committee of the EITB and the EITB bodies that underwrite it wish to express their concern and rejection of the selection processes that have been put in place in recent months for the management positions of the EITB, since the demand for knowledge... [+]

From the Caldereros: A blackface in San Sebastian?

I don't want my daughter disguising herself as a Gypsy in the caldereros. I don’t want Gypsy children at my daughter’s school to dress up as Gypsies in caldereros. Because being a gypsy is not a disguise. Because being a gypsy is not a party that takes place once a year, with... [+]


The challenge of shortening the working day even more than 37.5 hours per week

The year 2025 will lead to a general policy of establishing shorter working weeks, bringing low costs for new hires for companies and an effective direction of change in labour relations.

With the aim of complying with the Spanish government agreement, the reform to shorten the... [+]


2025-01-29 | Aramaixo Bizirik
Assessment of the environmental report against the “Itsaraz” wind power plant
On January 16, the Ministry of Energy Transition of the Administration of Madrid published the environmental impact statement about the “Itsaraz” project that we were looking forward to and worried about. The resolution expresses a decision that is as firm as it is clear... [+]

2025-01-27 | Aritz Arrieta
The Basque host country?

To be honest, I don't know why I'm writing this. In today’s hostile environment, opinions of this kind are not well received. Perhaps LUZ will not publish this because it does not correspond to the opinions they have published so far (but if they have finally decided to publish... [+]


Don’t let the sound of money silence the buzz of bombs

On January 15, the techno-business lobby called Cedarios presented its 6th report, Euskadi and the European Union, the shared destiny of prosperity and competitiveness. This neoliberal Think Tank, made up of eminent experts drawn from the world of finance, presented a magical... [+]


The Basque Country Welcome Village

We Basques move our feet behind the witness of Korrika to proclaim that we want to survive as a Basque people in favor of our language, with the aim of the Basque Country we desire.

The tipi-tapa is the first step taken by a migrant person who leaves his homeland in Africa,... [+]


Strikes of glutamate

And for another year, the unions have organized prefabricated strikes for us. And we, individually, will decide whether or not to join the strike, without the need for any assembly at the school.

The strike model that I was taught is no longer in vogue, it seems. In my... [+]


50 years of potash strike

Today, January 21, is a day to remember and reflect on an interesting ephemeris of our recent history. It is 50 years since the lockdown of 47 workers from Potase in Navarre. This lockdown, which lasted fifteen days, caused a general strike in Navarre, the Department of the... [+]


Conversion of the military industry, ethical necessity

A couple of weeks ago, a number of data from Norway was published. In this country of Northern Europe electric cars have predominated, being the Tesla brand the most sold, with 90% of recyclable energy consumed there. On the contrary, Norwegian public enterprises have no problem... [+]


2025-01-19 | Urtzi Ugalde
Goodbye, mom

These were my last words when we left, held hand in your deep breathing sleep. Your heart stayed forever without a special, simple, dignified pain. As you want and demand. How we want and respect.

Already a month before the arrival of winter, the last days of the longest night,... [+]


2025-01-17 | Oihane Artetxe
Vulnerable children: institutional violence in our context

Today, the voices of women and children remain within a culture that delegitimizes their voices, silencing their experiences, within a system aimed at minimizing or ignoring their basic rights and needs. A media example of this problem is the case of Juana Rivas, but her story... [+]


No to the ban on political militancy!

On Tuesday, the sentence was released against five young people from Lapurdi, convicted of belonging to Segi. Fifteen months in prison for reversal to two young people, with a fine of EUR 500 each; 140 hours of forced labour and EUR 500 fine to two other young people; and,... [+]


“More with less”

The other day, as I was walking through the famous television series The Wire, there came a scene that reminded me of despair. There, the management of the newspaper The Baltimore Sun brought together the workers and alerted them to the changes that are coming, i.e. redundancies... [+]


Smartphone: our fetish king

The consumerist culture we live in sends every user to an unreasonable enjoyment. As Slavoj Zize says, Enjoy your fetish, it has become the rude mandate of hypermodernity. Current enjoyment is carried out through existing technological devices to occupy the place of fetish. But... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude