Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

It is the first time the European Court of Human Rights has punished a state in a climate emergency

  • Strasbourg has punished Switzerland with the conviction that the climate policy pursued by this State infringes the right to health of the elderly and of citizens in general. The resolution has been applauded by environmental groups and individuals and, as they say, it will have consequences for the rest of the States, not least because pressure will increase towards daring climate policies.

11 April 2024 - 10:59
Last updated: 12:25

Sixteen votes for and one against. This is how the judges of the European Court of Human Rights, in the case of Switzerland, have been found, which, because of the scant measures taken for the climate emergency, violates article 8 of the Convention on Human Rights, respect for private life and family life. The resolution has been described as historic by ecological groups and individuals, firstly because for the first time the European Court of Human Rights is punishing a state on the climate issue. This means that it establishes a relationship between greenhouse gas emissions and human rights, and shows that the lack of sufficient measures to reduce emissions violates the European Convention on Human Rights.

The complaint was filed by the Swiss association Schweiz, of Klima Seniorinn, in favor of the Climate Protection of Elderly Women, and four elderly women, as a consequence of the damage caused by the climate emergency in their lives and complement. At first they brought the matter to Swiss Justice and, after a long six year journey, they went to the highest state level. Lost to the Federal Court, the case was transferred to Strasbourg and the hearing passed on 29 March this year. "We can be proud, the Hearing has recognised our fundamental right to a healthy climate and to have our country do what it has not done so far," said Anne Mahrer's co-chair.

According to Joana Setzer, expert in the climate emergency, "although the resolution directly affects, in European states its dissemination will be felt worldwide. It will be a fundamental reference for courts around the world, as it will serve to interpret the human rights obligations of states in the field of climate action." His great political and legal weight, which becomes jurisprudence, does not force him to anything, and that is probably the great nuance thrown by ecologists: "The Hearing has warned us that the Swiss State does not do enough, but does not tell him what to do. In this sense, I think it has the value of a declaration, rather than an obligation," says Marta Torre-Schaube, an expert in environmental law.

Two other issues rejected

As part of the climate emergency policies, the Strasbourg Court, on 9 April, issued resolutions on the other two complaints. On the one hand, the complaint lodged by six Portuguese young people against 32 European states, the 27 of the European Union, the United Kingdom, Norway, Switzerland, Russia and Turkey. After the 2017 food fires, they went to court. Strasbourg has decided not to punish the State because the plaintiffs have breached the rule that he issued: first they had to go to all the courts in the country where the complaint was lodged. However, according to the six young people, the climate should not be applied in emergency cases.

On the other hand, it was a day to hear the judgment on Damien Carem’s complaint from the courts of the French people of Grande-Synthe. Grande Synthe is a town located on the northern coast of France and, according to an Old Testament between 2001 and 2009, the climate has become a "vulnerable place" due to the impact of the emergency. In 2018 he asked the Government of France for measures to reduce CO2 emissions, but Elíseo, in understanding that he did not "respond sufficiently" to his request, started a judicial route, considering himself a "victim". In order not to deal with the case, Strasbourg argues that it is no longer a "victim" because there is nothing more than living entirely in the people. In the face of the climate emergency, scientific research indicates that Grande-Synthe will submerge within 30 years.


You are interested in the channel: Larrialdi klimatikoa
The pollution of ski resort festivals reaches its peak
The lack of snow has placed many ski resorts in adverse weather conditions, due to the climate emergency. But the logic of some to make the most of the economic benefits of landscape and nature is still there, and the tendency of recent years is to organize large and expensive... [+]

2024-12-17 | Julene Flamarique
Cyclone Chido is estimated to have caused thousands of deaths on the island of Mayotte
The wind, over 220 km/h, has rocked the island of Mayotte on the French coast of Marseille. The destruction of the essential infrastructure has left much of the island incommunicado, which has made it difficult to count casualties. The French Government has announced that it will... [+]

2024-12-12 | Nicolas Goñi
The failure of the summit on plastic pollution can make it intolerable.
They have just completed the cycle of summits to find a solution to plastic pollution and also failed at the fifth summit of the South Korean city of Busan: They have not managed to reach an agreement, mainly because the large plastic exporters have hindered the negotiations. In... [+]

Sukar Horiak Awards Friday Literary Competition Awards on Livable Futures
Bilboko Zirika! The distribution will take place in the urban area on Friday at 19:00. Texts will be disseminated through fanzine and on social networks.

Tourism generates 8.8% of greenhouse gas emissions and emissions continue to increase
In the last ten years, the increase in CO2 emissions from tourism has been twice as high as that of the economy general.Se is about the results of a study by the scientific journal Nature Communications, published on 10 December.

Non-concepts

The understanding and interpretation of the mathematical language is what is important in the learning process, at least it is what we say to our students. The language of mathematics is universal, and in general, the margin of error for interpretation tends to be small. We... [+]


40 per cent of the world ' s land is arid and 75 per cent of the land has been dried
Following this path, by the end of the century, more than 5 billion people will live in the arid lands. This would lead to many humanitarian, economic and social problems.

Luna de Valencia

Recently, when asked what the climate emergency consisted of, a scientist gave the excellent answer: “Look, the climate emergency is this, you increasingly see on your mobile more videos related to extreme weather events, and when you realize, it’s you who are recording one... [+]


2024-11-20 | Nicolas Goñi
They pay for climate change in South Sudan with permanently submerged land.
Most Sudanese have lived in extreme poverty for at least two centuries and, unfortunately, their independence has not allowed them to improve their situation, which is that of the poorest countries in the world, because of several wars. In this extremely fragile context, climate... [+]

2024-11-20 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Data to the territory

In recent weeks it has not been possible for those of us who work in architecture that the climate phenomenon of Valencia has not been translated into our work discourse. Because we need to think about and design the path of water in decks, sewers, plazas and building parks. We... [+]


COP29 in Azerbaijan
Baku will receive ten times more money than hitherto to to deal with climate change
COP29 started this Monday in Baku (Iparralde), the capital of Azerbaijan, Navarra. In addition to the 197 countries that are part of this forum, thousands of people from the civilian network around the world will attend the meeting to follow the action of Governments. The star... [+]

Temperature increase by 2024 will first exceed 1.5°C
According to the environmental observatory Copernicus, 2024 will hit a record temperature on Earth, and not only that, for the first time it will be 1.5°C higher than the average of the time before the industry.

2024-10-31 | Nicolas Goñi
The migration of trees is one of the solutions for the climate emergency of forests
The forests of the world are in an increasingly serious situation, due to the fires caused by heat waves and droughts caused by climate change, among others. Although the climate has already changed in the middle and northern latitudes, so far the forests have been very little... [+]

Restrictions, exclusion and business interests: deadly cocktail for a disaster in Valencia
It would be too naive to think that in Valencia there are empty weather factors behind the dead and the damage caused by the storm. Many have denounced the management of the emergency by the Generalitat and that the business thirst of the multinationals has prevailed. And we can... [+]

Why has the sky exploded now in Valencia?
A storm has caused a disaster in the west of the Mediterranean, which has left at least 51 dead and dozens missing from the Mediterranean earthquake. The meteorologist Millán Millán warned that the causes of such severe storms should be sought in the destruction of the coast... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude