Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Judicial blow to Navarra Sumari for eliminating bilingualism on the social networks of the City of Pamplona

  • The Administrative Tribunal of Navarra gave the right to the appeal presented by EH Bildu after the implementation by Navarra Sum of profiles in Spanish and Basque in the social networks of the City of Pamplona. He has described the distinction between Castilian and Euskera as "contrary to law".
Artikulu hau CC BY-SA 3.0 lizentziari esker ekarri dugu.

30 July 2020 - 09:06

The Administrative Tribunal of Navarra gave the right to the appeal presented by the municipal group of EH Bildu after the implementation of profiles in Spanish and Basque in the social networks of the City of Pamplona. Thus, it has suspended the decision to separate both languages and change the institutional profile of Pamplona, which went from being the only bilingual support to two different media, one in Spanish and the other in Basque, as it considered it "contrary to the law".

The municipal government team argued that the measure was in accordance with the current law, and the court notes that the municipality has "the obligation to use Spanish and Euskera on an equal footing when addressing citizenship and, especially, in the corporate image".

In its resolution it refers to the ordinance prior to the Basque Country – in force when bilingualism was eliminated on social networks – but also to the one in force – adopted on 14 April by Navarre Suma and the PSN – so it is likely that this is not the last blow the coalition receives for linguistic issues.

In fact, in analysing the appeal of EH Bildu, he mentioned a judgment of the Superior Court of Justice of Navarra which concluded in 2002 the debate on the interpretations of the bilingual term in a judgment on the Sanfermines cartel: "In the corporate image of the City Hall, bilingualism is not achieved with two differentiated programs in Spanish and Basque, but with a single bilingual program."

Single support

In its opinion, the Administrative Court has established that “there is no legal or regulatory mandate to prevent a mixed-area administration from offering a bilingual corporate image, and has recalled that the previous article 12 of the Basque ordinance stated that: “The bilingual term necessarily means that the contents are offered in a single medium or unit.”

The Minister of Education has ruled out that the decision to separate the two languages into the networks is included in the exception that the ordinance itself gathers (that the content has a volume that prevents it) because "there was no technical reason that would make it impossible, it was feasible, because it was doing so until then".

Regarding social networks, the judicial resolution indicates that it is a web "of municipal ownership, blogs, networks, apps and the like" and in the case of the websites, the possibility of choosing the language you want to browse from the home page will be offered.

It cannot be ruled out, taking into account the criteria that have been established in this matter, that the arguments can be repeated in other similar remedies that have been presented in the legislature in relation to other decisions of Navarre Suma.


You are interested in the channel: Euskara Nafarroan
A study concludes that the majority of the inhabitants of Navarre, 63%, are in favor or very favorable to the promotion of the Basque language
The majority of the inhabitants of Navarre (63%) are "supporters or very supporters of the promotion of the Basque language" and only 17% oppose it, according to a study carried out by Xabier Erice and Carlos Vilches in the framework of the agreement between Basque Language... [+]

Euskararen aldeko sareak ehuntzeko Erriberan Euskaraz ekimena sortu dute Nafarroa hegoaldean

Prentsaurrekoan, maiatzaren 17an ospatuko duten Erriberako Euskararen Egunaren inguruko argibideak eman dituzte. Ume, gazte zein helduentzat zuzendua izango da. Ekimena, Erriberan egiten diren ekimenetan indarrak biltzeko eta euskararen normalizazioaren alde saretzeko... [+]


Oier Sanjurjo
“D eredua bultzatzen eta ikastolen nortasuna zabaltzen ahaleginduko naiz”

Nafarroako Ikastolen Elkarteak lehendakari berria du. Oier Sanjurjok hartu dio lekukoa Elena Zabaleta Andresenari.  Beste zazpi kide izanen ditu alboan Sanjurjok.


Euskararen gurditik denok tira egin behar dugu, baita hezkuntzan ere

Ez dira gutxi azken boladan euskara bere onenean ez dagoela eta bere transmisioa bermatuta ez dagoela ohartarazten ari diren ahotsak. Bestetik, inork ez du ukatzen hezkuntzak ezinbesteko betebeharra duenik euskara eta euskal kulturaren biziraupenerako. Erronka estrategikoa... [+]


Garikoitz Torregrosa
“Eredu mistoak ez du elkarbizitza sustatzen eta azkenean haur eskola horietan gaztelera nagusitzen da”

Iruñeko haur eskoletako zuzendariek, EH Bildu, Geroa Bai, Zurekin Nafarroa eta PSNren arteko akordioa kritikatu dute. “Murgiltze ereduaren alde egin dugu beti, baina inoiz ez da gure iritzia kontutan hartzen” salatu du Euskalerria Irratian, Garikoitz Torregrosa... [+]


Haur eskoletan euskarazko ehun plaza gehiago eskainiko ditu Iruñeko Udalak hurrengo ikasturtean

Euskarazko eskaintza handitzeko akordioa erdietsi dute EH Bilduk, PSNk, Geroa Baik eta Zurekin Nafarroak


Famili'on egonaldi ibiltaria aurkeztu dute lehendabizikoz Baionan

Plazara, AEK, Uda Leku, Dindaia eta Ebete antolakundeak Baionan elkartu dira Famili'on egonaldi ibiltariaren lehen edizioa aurkezteko. Hizkuntza mailaren arabera eskaintza bat edo beste egongo da eta haur zein gurasoentzat izango da udaberrian.


Lizarrako kultur teknikari izateko nahitaezkoa da euskara Administrazio Auzitegiaren arabera

Administrazio Epaitegiak arrazoia eman dio EH Bilduk Lizarrako plantilla organikoaren hizkutnz profilen aurka jarritako helegiteari.


“The Basque immersion is under attack with the dissemination of the PAI model”
The union STEILAS has filed an appeal against the court order to increase the hours of English and reduce the hours of Basque. “They’re putting the submersion in a serious hole,” they say.

The UPN of Estella interrupts the program of bertsolarismo of the schools
The complaint has been made by the association Gara, which works to promote the Basque language in Estella: "The capacity for creation is enhanced and critical thinking is cultivated, all from a playful perspective, based on enjoyment."

'Give them here, give them Basque' will be the slogan used by the Government of Navarre in its campaign to promote Basque
Especially families with children. Because we want the best for our children, giving them Basque would broaden their horizons for the future. "It is an invitation to choose for multilingualism, because giving Basque is a union," said Ana Ollo, Basque counselor.

The Sorionekua movement calls for the fulfillment of the bridges of Navarre by May 10 in favor of the Basque language
Building "bridges of the future", they emphasize that "in these turbulent times" the pro-Basque voices must be heard aloud from now on: "It's time to give him the treatment, the place, that belongs to the Basque language."

The premises of the Pamplona Lava Association and the Windsor Bar will be unified
In this way, they will give stability and solidity to the project that has taken the Basque language and culture to the heart of the city.

The City of Pamplona presents the bases of the plan for the promotion of the Basque Country
The City wants to get the approval of the political majority before the end of the year

2024-12-13 | ARGIA
Euskarabidea will have a budget of €13.4 million in 2025, 9.7% more than last year
The parties are negotiating these days in the Parliament of Navarra the closure of next year’s budgets and have agreed that the entity responsible for the normalisation of the Basque country will have 1.3 million more than last year.

Eguneraketa berriak daude