Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Spanish justice will decide whether IRPH is abusive

  • The European Court has argued that cases of IRPH abuse should be tried by the Spanish courts. Cases should be examined individually to determine whether purchasers were able to understand mortgage clauses.

03 March 2020 - 11:49
IRPHaren aurkako protesta. Argazkia: eldiario.es.

The Mortgage Lending Reference Index (IRPH) is as legal an index as the Eurybor, but with strong growth in relation to it. Those affected, in addition to their mortgage price, paid between 200 and 300 euros more per month. Between EUR 18,000 and EUR 21,000 in the entire mortgage.

The complainants have accused the banks of lack of transparency, alleging that the terms of these mortgages were not explained and that they therefore bought them. The judgment of the European Court (ECJ) has opened the door to this argument, claiming that the argument of lack of transparency is possible. However, it has not issued a favourable judgment, but has left in the hands of the Spanish Justice the decision to investigate each case and to make it the one that begs if it has been an abuse.

In the Spanish State there are more than 1.3 million people affected by the case of IRPH. The individualized analysis of each case can lead to the collapse of justice. Many have defined the European judgment as ambiguous, although they have warned that the loan clauses should be sufficiently understandable to all, they have not stolen whether the loans were understandable or not.

Finally, if the Spanish courts conclude that in some cases these are abuses, the European Court has proposed that the index be replaced by another legal index, even if it involves cancelling the mortgage.

For the banks, an increase in the stock market has been detected after the judgment. The handing over to the Spanish Justice of the abuses can have positive consequences for the banks, as the Supreme Court had already given the banks the reason.


You are interested in the channel: Hipoteken zerga
2022-10-11 | ARGIA
Kutxabank sells to a fund putre mortgage debts from several Basque households
Kutxabank has sold 2,500 "toxic" debts to the Irish slut fund Zima Finances and trade has harmed several Basque families; the vulture fund can file lawsuits and initiate eviction proceedings. The Stop Deshaucios platform has identified seven cases in Gipuzkoa and Araba, and the... [+]

2020-10-22 | ARGIA
TSJC believes that mortgages with IRPH are not abusive
The Supreme has acknowledged that some clients were not properly informed of the index, but that the indication itself is legal. By this resolution, banks will not be able to be condemned for abuse and, at the very most, they will be accused of lack of transparency.

2018-11-07 | ARGIA
Hipoteken zerga bankuei ordainaraziko dien dekretua iragarri du Espainiako Gobernuak

Espainiako Auzitegi Gorenak bigarren itzulian erabaki ondoren herritarrek ordaindu behar dutela hipoteken zerga, ezohiko prentsaurrekoa eman du Pedro Sánchez Espainiako presidenteak: dekretua aterako du Gobernuak, hipoteken zerga bankuek ordaindu dezaten. Sánchezek... [+]


2018-11-07 | ARGIA
Hipoteken zergak herritarrek pagatu beharko dituzte: zer eragin du erabakiak Hego Euskal Herrian?

Espainiako Auzitegi Gorenak epai polemikoa eman du hipoteken zergen inguruan: hasieran zera hori bankuek ordaindu behar zutela ebatzi ondoren, atzera egin du eta astearte honetan erabaki du herritarrek ordaindu beharko dutela. Nola eragingo du neurriak Hego Euskal Herrian?


Eguneraketa berriak daude