Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Historians in the kitchen


20 December 2023 - 11:08
Sukaldaritza eszena bat XIV. mendeko "Tacuina sanitatis" liburuan. (Argazkia: Wikimedia Commons)
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

I had trouble deciding this week’s issue. I could write about genocide, Palestine and the banality of evil. But in the special issue of LARRUN I could not add anything better than what has already been said. He could also write about the historiographical debate that has taken place in Navarre about Carlism, but Hedoi Etxarte went ahead in Berria. Faced with the massacres, we should not be drunk, but I will not have a liver to write with this raw material. I have decided at the moment to address more innocent and innocent issues: in this case, sources and historical-scientific methodology.

Sources for historians are essential because they bring us closer to the past. They can be of various kinds. The most common and used are public and private documents (political, economic, legal, letters, censuses…), newspaper publications (newspapers, magazines), personal memories and journals, literary sources and so on. Iconographic and audiovisual sources include the plastic arts (painting, sculpture, posters, propaganda, …), music, cinema, videos of all kinds, cartography or photographs. Archaeology, on the contrary, deals with material sources, analyzing buildings, objects or landscape in its context. Oral sources collected through interviews are also important.

Well, all those historical sources are our components. But of course, we cannot use these sources raw. We can't believe this information at all, that's where the culinary ability of the historian lies. First, we have to define and define what our object of research is and ask questions and hypotheses about it. We then look for and select the most appropriate sources to answer these questions or hypotheses (if possible, conform to what is otherwise). Next, and this is the key, we must critically analyse the credibility of the sources. Can we guarantee that the sources are original and from that time? What is the issuer? What is the recipient? Why does this source arise? We must not forget that the sources are not neutral and objective, but that behind them there can be political and social interests depending on their social and cultural context. Once the data is extracted from the sources, all this information must be contrasted, that is, whether it is compatible or contradictory to what other sources say. Finally, we use and serve the prepared. That is, it must be written according to the data obtained, because history ultimately adopts a narrative form. The text should reflect our ideas and arguments and, according to the information obtained, respond to initial questions and provide an interpretation of historical facts.

In short, choose the sources, rigorously judge their content and context, contrast the data obtained and finally publish them. That is the historical-scientific method, which is our recipe.

 


You are interested in the channel: Historia
Bego Ariznabarreta Orbea No War
"We still have the traumas and symptoms of the war of our elders."
Their parents were murdered, and the children began to evict the loft. Among other things, lots of notebooks and papers, photographs and all kinds of documents. Bego Ariznabarreta Orbea read in blank the astounding memories of his late father's war, and realized the treasure,... [+]

Historical cartography of the Basque Country
The trail of maps in the history of a people
It is known that cartography represents much more than the characteristics of a town or territory. Hand maps have conquered continents and empires have been built throughout history, and cultural and political identities have been defined with squads and cartabons. Peoples... [+]

Find remains of a Roman circus for 5,000 people in Iruña–Veleia
Next to the archaeological site of Alavés, a structure of 280 meters in length and 72 meters in width is hidden beneath the cultivation fields. The company Arkikus has made the finding using special drone mapping techniques, which have been performed by Astilleros. In the... [+]

Bad practices or archeological policy?

The Roman city of Santakriz is an impressive archaeological site located in Eslava, near Sangüesa. Apparently, there was a fortified people of the Iron Age, and then the Romans settled in the same place. Juan Castrillo, himself a priest of Eslava, gave the site for the first... [+]


They give the family the remains of Republican Deputy Manuel Azcona, killed in 1936
Maria Jesús Fuerte, Nieta de Azcona, was in charge of collecting the mortal remains at an event held this Saturday in the Deputation. It is recalled that between 1936 and 1945 376 people were executed, of whom 299 were executed without trial.

They design a Roncalese suit for mayors to participate in the Three Cows Tax
This Saturday is celebrated the tradition of over 600 years around the Stone of San Martin and this year Roncalese costumes have been prepared for mayors, which until now were only available to men.

Wax: between life and death

Paris 1845. The Labortan economist and politician Frédéric Bastiat (1801-1850) wrote the satire Pétition des fabricants de chandelles (The Request of the Sailing). Fiercely opposed to protectionism, he ironistically stated that the sailing boats asked for protection against... [+]


Claiming the dignity of witches

For a matter of work, I had to reread this wonderful book. A short book that brings together feminist theory, genealogy and history, and that will surely have a lot of criticism looking on the net and, surprise! I found one, which Irati Majuelo wrote in Berria.El book published... [+]


Germán Rodríguez's tombstone is dressed in red carnations
In Pamplona/Iruña, Germán Rodríguez and Joseba Barandiaran have been honoured and congratulated for their work in favour of the workers’ movement. They have also shown their solidarity with Palestine, in the annual meeting of the sanfermines in Pamplona/Iruña.

Cemetery of young children in Auxerre

This winter the archaeologists of the INRAP (National Institute of Preventive Archaeological Research) have found a special necropolis in the historic centre of Auxerre (French State), a Roman cemetery for newborn babies or stillbirths. - Oh, good! The necropolis used between... [+]


Ninth and last

Born 7 May 1824. Ludwig Van Beethoven (1770-1827) 9. Premiere of the Symphony. It was the last symphony that the German composer wrote, but as for intention, you can say it was the first. Beethoven wrote Symphony No. 1 in 1799 and 1800, years before he was born in his head No. 9... [+]


Let the fire warm us up and not burn

The Christian religion ended the knowledge, wisdom and self-management of witches, imposing thought and, therefore, a certain life. They were tortured, raped and killed. With the intention of moving these religious convictions to every corner of Europe, many citizens engaged in... [+]


Exhibition in Ablitas of one of the most important Roman mosaics found in the Basque Country
The great Roman mosaic discovered in 2017 at the site of El Villar has been restored and exhibited in the house of culture of Ablitas. The 4th century villa or farm occupies an area of 40,000 square meters and is believed to be in its entirety, although only a small section has... [+]

Aurresku, bertsos and musical performances in tribute to Germán Rodríguez
Another year, Monday 8 July will be remembered with the monolith dedicated to Germán Rodríguez. It will be at 13:00 hours: the aurresku, first, the bertsos of Mikel Lasarte and then the performances of La Furia and Fermin Balentzia. At dusk, the Peñas, silently and with the... [+]

Is Euskal Herria a colony?
A few months ago there was an intense debate on social media. Two warring sides: Is Euskal Herria a colony? In my humble opinion, the heart of the controversy was found in the definition of the words colonialism and imperialism, which were used very differently. I have decided... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude