Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Glasses to watch closely

Argazkia: joseteo2, CC BY 2.0.

04 December 2023 - 07:14

It all depends on the glass that we look behind. That is, our subjectivity is the key to explaining the world. From this phrase comes the figure of purple glasses invented by feminism, that to value the history of women and the presence of women in society it is necessary to wear purple glasses.

When I was studying history, our university had a great left-wing reputation. In a very consistent way, they offered, among others, some subjects that had the title of Women in the Old World, Archaeology of Women. But in those subjects, I only detected the surface of the problem. I would like to say that in the Roman era and in the world, in addition to men, there are also women, but I do not think it is very revolutionary, nor difficult to demonstrate.

The real change happened when I started researching on my own. Because I realized that many heavy weights circulating in historiography did wrong the work that corresponded to them, by inertia, by the shape of the molds and, above all, by the use of obsolete glasses miopes. I understood that it was not just about securing the presence of women, but about lying some things that had been told so far in a way. What was wrong? Well, it has not been said, for example, that in the riots prior to the French Revolution women were in the first ranks, or that the main promoters and managers of the Romanesque churches were women, or that the image of bertsolari and women coincided with each other, or that they laid the foundations of the construction of the Basque Country ...

The molds of the modern state (and with it cultural hegemonies) are used to make history

I later saw the same thing happening with minority cultures or stateless nations. It is not difficult to demonstrate that the molds of the modern state (and with it cultural hegemonies) are usually used to make history. One small example: my doctoral thesis was on the Romanization of the Pyrenees. So, surprisingly, I realized that most of the research was focused on the study of the Pyrenees in the Roman era, taking care of the current state borders! In other words, researchers (in the French or Spanish classic) only looked at what was within the framework of the contemporary borders of their state, as if there was no cross-border. Well, look, that's wrong with history, and the conclusions that come out are wrong.

The last surprise I had was with one of my favorite historians, Carlo Ginzburg. His most famous work, Il formaggio e i verni (Cheese and worms), tells the story of the miller Menocchio. It's an incredibly nice story, the most famous example of microhistory. The study is based on the documents of the Inquisition of the trial against Menocchio, more specifically the statements or statements contained in those documents. When it comes to research, words are key. And a big surprise when I realized the author never mentions that Menocchio made those statements in a language that wasn't theirs.

Although the region in which the trial was conducted today is the territory of the Italian State, Menocchio was not Italian, but Friulite. And, of course, the Italian state did not exist. Friuli was at that time the territory affected by the Republic of Venice. Apparently, Menocchio used the Venetian Tuscan language to answer the questions of the inquisitors, because he wanted to show that his questioned ideas did not belong to an “undetermined peasant who lived in Friulian”. For the trial, Menocchio left his usual language, the Friuli, and tried to speak, for convenience, in the language of political power. That is, there is a history of linguistic hegemony there, but Ginzburg does not perform socio-linguistic analysis in the book and is not interested in talking about linguistic dependence. So, in my opinion, research goes crazy and some important things for Menocchio's portrait are hidden.

It seems that with Carlo Ginzburg's glasses you didn't see those things, or maybe it's mine that's poorly focused? I will leave that in your hands. In this regard, I do what the author says at the beginning of the book How the Irish Saved Civilization:

"Throughout this history we will find several hosts, all of them basic and with something to say, and perhaps some think their story is the only one that exists. We will be human and listen to them without contempt. We will also try to see things from your point of view. But from time to time we will be blurring lions (i.e. losers), in which case each reader will have to know how to manage themselves."


You are interested in the channel: Estaturik gabeko nazioak
U.S. Withdraws Visa from 300 Students Mobilized for Palestine
The new U.S. president signed a decree on January 30 authorizing the expulsion of foreign students participating in pro-Palestinian demonstrations. Student visa cancellations have been repeated since then.

2025-04-10 | Cira Crespo
by Carli Pup
"Our villages are like the others and we don't want to be in a museum"
Carli Pup (Udine -friuleraz Udin-, 1973) is one of the most important cultural activists of Friuli [friuleraz, Friûl]. He has become a writer of his minority language, a linguist and a historian of his people. He is currently president of the cooperative Informazione Friulana,... [+]

Microsoft dismisses two employees for denouncing the multinational’s relations with Israel
The two workers cut off Microsoft’s 50th anniversary event on Friday and accused the company’s leaders of their role in the Gaza genocide. The multinational sells artificial intelligence weapons to the Israeli army.

Germany to expel four Palestinians
A Pole, two Irish and one American are ordered to leave Germany on April 21. If this does not happen, the Berlin Migration Office clarifies that they will be expelled. A complaint has been filed in order to stop the expulsion procedure.

Another Israeli massacre came to light: He killed fifteen health workers in Rafah and then threw them into a mass grave.
The Palestinian Red Crescent Emergency Service has confirmed that an autopsy of the bodies shows that Israeli soldiers opened fire on medical personnel. One of the health workers before his death recorded with his mobile the moment when the soldiers attacked them, and in the... [+]

"Rebellion grows in Argentina, a whole people is pushing"
Laura Taffetani works at the Argentine Lawyers Guild (Buenos Aires, Argentina, 1963). He has worked with numerous Mapuches who have suffered government repression in recent years and has been part of the anti-imperialist meetings organized by the organization Liberation in the... [+]

Hungary shows its support for Netanyahu and ceases to be a member of the International Criminal Court
The decision was announced by Hungarian Prime Minister Gergely Gulyas on the same day that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whose arrest warrant has been issued by the Hague Court, arrived in the country.Israel Katz, Israel’s defense minister, has said the Israeli... [+]

2025-04-03 | Gedar
Israel Premier Tech expels Zionist team from a cycling race in Estella
On the initiative of the platform Solidarity with Palestine, some 70 people linked to cycling have asked for the Zionist team not to participate in the tournament, and they have succeeded.

“Neutrotzat aurkezten dena, egiaz, ideologia nagusiaren konplizea da”

Gozamen aparta bezain deskribatzeko zaila dakar, norbaiten hitzak irakurri edo entzun ostean, zera pentsatzeak: “Horixe zen neu aurreko hartan azaltzen saiatu nintzena!”. Idazlea eta itzultzailea da María Reimóndez, eta galegoz aritzen da, hizkuntza... [+]


2025-04-02 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Military urbanism

Egypt ' s urban planning plan for the Gaza Strip has recently been expanded. A drawing shows the streets, buildings and imagery of the future on a reality that still smells of shrapnel and explosives. The urban planning proposal, used as another bomb shot. Individual house... [+]


A Spanish police officer infiltrated the political and social movements of Lleida for two years
The police infiltration has been investigated and published by the Directa media. In September 2019 he approached the Ateneu Cooperatiu de Lleida for the first time, under the name of Joan Llobet García, and left his militancy in November 2021, arguing that he had found a job... [+]

Borrokak balio du: Israel Premier Tech, ez aurten, ez inoiz

Aurten "Israel Premier Tech" txirrindularitza talde israeldarra ez da Lizarraldeko Miguel Indurain Sari Nagusia lasterketara etorriko. Berri ona da hori Palestinaren askapenaren alde gaudenontzat eta munstro sionistarekin harreman oro etetea nahi dugunontzat, izan... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude