Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Gaza: where is the left?


07 March 2024 - 11:07
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

I will spare you too many explanations and details, the esteemed reader who looked at this text. The issue is very simple. I'll talk about you, about me, about all of us. I am going to refer to the amazing travellers of this boat that is still floating without direction and ever more escorted. Also on the Left that we know, the Left that we consider to be the repository of the values that we should bring to a new, fairer and more egalitarian world.

Put the political acronym you want, because basically, I think we're all almost inanimate, half dead. I do not care about the institution of the left, understood in the broad sense, in which it votes or supports, or in which militancy. For me, the era of exclusions, sectarisms, tribes and clans, superfluous barricades among the closest, and many other unsustainable divisions that we know well in this country has ended.

I'm going to do concrete things. Does the left really want to change the world? This could be asked by someone, for example an impartial observer who would observe what is happening around us from a space capsule. You may want to change it. Almost certainly yes, I would say yes, but if so, I would add that it conceals very well. And I would increasingly give you the previous answer.

And I'm going to tell you why I think the Left (of this country and other continents) doesn't seem to want to change the world. The reason is very simple. Strangulating, almost malignant. The left is trapped in the deception that the capitalist system has spread to it with its many tentacles. As it has happened to us all (to you, to me), to a large majority of the citizens, not only on the right, but also on the left, the left lives together with a consumer society that is doing everything. The values, the people, the nature and the society that threatens one's own life. In addition, the left remains fully separated in all latitudes.

The left is trapped in the deception that the capitalist system has spread to it with its many tentacles. As it has happened to us all (to you, to me), the Left lives together with a consumer society that is killing everything

Yes, the system poured several hooks into the pond of life to wake us up, and we, the little fish of all species and classes, swallowed one of them, the big fish of the system, the owner of the farmer, while one by one eats all the small, especially the most vulnerable.

And I ask you, how are we going to change the devil if we are not able to stop the world if the genocide that the Israeli Government has been doing in Gaza for more than four months against the Palestinian population?

It is a genocide that we are seeing every day on television, which is taking place before world governments (except South Africa and a few others) and before the laziness, tibiality and inactivity of a large part of the population. Faced with an audience divided between those who struggle to survive in this chaotic world and those who do not care about anything that directly affects them. And we are also witnesses, the lefties, the children of different political families, while we are in all kinds of debates.

All of this and many other factors mean that the unwillingness to unify that we are seeing among all sectors of civil society that are considered to be left-wing is confronted by an inclusive and massive movement that gives a firm response to this destruction of the Palestinian people.

I know that some may say that the left or the left have another thirty-seven thousand eight hundred and forty-six more important issues to channel their strength, all legitimate, of course. But is that excuse? Is not what is happening in Gaza and the West Bank so serious as to give the impetus, support and strength it deserves above all the world? What else do we need every day to drop the bombs on themselves? Are we going to allow the State of Israel to wipe out all the Palestinians?

Acceptance of such a genocide will mean that the world will pay too much in the future, as it would mean accepting that such massacres can be left without sanctions. If we accept such a holocaust, the hope for change will also die. The answer did not go beyond a concentration or manifestation of rejection (can it only clear our conscience?) or we have limited the response to the boycott messages of companies with Israeli capital among us, and all of this has been shown by no means to stop this massacre. Because in Gaza and in the West Bank not only is the survival of many Palestinians at stake (also, of course), but in Gaza we are playing the future of mankind, related to today’s most disparate left, because it is increasingly afraid to regard it as radical or terrorist for firmly defending human rights. We have reached that level of shame.

Yeah, I know, it's always. Have fun. Each in its own way, the other, the other, as if something were different. We're seeing it all the time. Farmers are interested in the purchase price of tomatoes. To farmers, to the meat of their animals. Government staff and health and education systems, increased CPI and other job improvements. Take out of precariousness and low pay many workers from private companies... and enjoy a good holiday to all. Yes, everything is fair, but also compatible with looking to the East, to that small territory of Palestine and its inhabitants, which is disappearing among the constant daily bombs, when they do not kill disease or hunger.

The left has a great challenge ahead. In fact, I would say that this issue is your test of fire, as you are opening a corridor to the rise of ultra-fast forces, which are already growing all over the world. And I think there's not much time left to turn that trend around.

However, and for those who believe that little has been done so far, I would like to highlight the work carried out by the Gernika-Palestine People's Initiative and the platform "Yala, Navarre with Palestine", together with what they will push forward in the coming weeks, which in the short term will considerably increase the scope of the response to this genocide, which has focused on the objective of being as transversal and unitary as possible.

Difficult and decisive moments are above all moments to change the script of what is done by inertia. I therefore only have to suggest two actions, one smaller and one larger, to help everything that has been done so far, and I believe that this does not correspond to the terrible attack on the Palestinian people.

The first is to combine concentrations in big cities and in the most populous countries with other formulas that give greater visibility to this tragedy that penetrates the heart and mind. In other words, in addition to concentrating on the Arriaga or the City Council of Bilbao or other countries of the Basque Country, we must consider testing other alternatives that have not been used so far.

I think of the following: two days a week (for example, Tuesday and Friday), one hour, from 7 p.m., the inhabitants of this town come down with a chair in front of the portal of our house or on the sidewalk of our street, along with the Palestinian flag with a clear motto ("Not a war, it is genocide"), and ten minutes' walk and silence to condemn the massacre. Next, a space of ten minutes to show our neighbours and neighbours that we cannot stand still in the face of this cruel attack on the Palestinian people.

This dispersion may lead to many other people who do not pass through the Arriaga Theater and the Bilbao City Hall also see that this complaint reaches their neighborhood, even with fewer people, because the objective of this measure is to expand the radius of view of the complaint. I know that this costs more than concentrating on a single group, but only the things that are worthwhile demonstrate their maximum effectiveness. Or isn't it hard to change the world? Do we want to change it?

The best thing for a better organisation would, of course, be for the institutions themselves that work in solidarity with the Palestinian people to shape the proposal, or others, and I am convinced that these proposals will be created and that we must involve parties, trade unions, civil society, neighbourhood groups, environmental movements, etc. more forcefully.

And finally, the main challenge would be to lift this country as soon as possible and to paralyse its activity by calling for a general strike. Although there are no "objective conditions" for this, I see no better cause for the left to regain its self-esteem, to rebelieve what it does and to begin to reinvent itself to believe that it is shy or desperate. So, are we going to go down the street with a chair or are we going to do something that comes out of that irritating dynamic? "Don't sit. Move. It's genocide."

Txema García, writer and journalist

Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora

ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.


You are interested in the channel: Irakurleen gutunak
Building the Basque Country of tomorrow

In recent decades I have worked in the Basque field, both in the Euskaldunization of adults in AEK, and in the defence of linguistic rights in the Observatory, or in favour of the normalization of the Basque country in the Council of Euskalgintza. Everywhere I have heard... [+]


2024-11-11 | Patxi Azparren
Basque constituent process

As we know, the Institutional Independence of Hego Euskal Herria has begun a certain roadmap. Signing a new pact with the Spanish State. This path uses some main variables or premises. Thus: The PSOE is a leftist party, the Spanish State is recyclable and it is up to the... [+]


The year of the popular platform Meaka-Irimo
Sometimes we need a threat to know the importance of what is at risk. And the magnitude of that threat depends on the strength that we feel within us to respond to a possible aggression. As soon as you realize, you see yourself working hard to protect those who are at risk of... [+]

2024-11-11 | Gorka Torre
“Justizia euskaraz eta euskaraz justizia”
Baionako epaileei bigarren gutuna

Agorrilaren 27an igorri nizuen gutunean, irailaren 10eko auzian euskaraz deklaratzeko asmoa nuela adierazi nizuen. Auzi honen hastapenean, epaile nagusiari euskaraz zekienez galdegin nion. Gutxiespenarekin ezetz erantzun zidan. Orduan, nere gutuna eskuratu zuenez frantsesez... [+]


2024-11-08 | Egurra Ta Kandela
Strategic lines of the Basque Government
If the reading of the Renewable Energy Sector Territorial Plan (PTS EBB) for farmers and livestock farmers was disappointing – and it was – it was not that it was much happier to read the report of responses to 4,217 allegants in this regard in July 2023. It was published on... [+]

Is there critical awareness in today's society?

Wikipedia.org considers that Gish gallop (Gish's gallop) or the machine gun of fallacies "is a technique of controversy that attacks the opponent with as many arguments as possible, without taking into account the accuracy or solidity of those arguments" and would have as side... [+]


2024-10-31 | Joan Mari Beloki
Rusophobia before and now (I)

The origin of the term lies at the beginning of the nineteenth century. At that time, the imperialist pretensions of the British Liberals clashed with the Russians, which spread in Asia and hindered the desire for colonization of England. To protect its interests, England used... [+]


Funeral
Juanje, only until later
Attorney Juanje Soria died on Thursday, 26 October, in Pamplona/Iruña. Former members of the Permanent Social Forum recall Soria in this letter.

Solidarity with the colleague who will have to go to court on 29 October
On Tuesday, a penalty case will be filed under the Moorings Act against a member of the EH Bildu network. He suffered the persecution of the Ertzaintza for touring the mountains that want to be devastated and for defending territory, land, care and defence. Once again, they use... [+]

Monologues

I started to mentally write my article while I was in the car. I usually have the best ideas in the car while driving alone. I'm going to Bilbao, to the Arriaga theater. The Artedrama company is today staging the Miñan play. It's Friday, October 25.

Approaching the atrium of the... [+]


2024-10-28 | Iñaki Landazabal
Sovereignty and political parties

The society in which we live is absolutely based on subordination. Over the centuries, our lives have been shaped according to it, and little by little the power of decision, freedom and sovereignty have been reduced. Sometimes they've taken us away with force, sometimes we've... [+]


2024-10-25 | Josu Jimenez Maia
The medical voice

What blew me a lot is the way some doctors talk to the patient. They talk to us about pain as if we were children. As I have had two kidney transplants, I know what I mean: among other things, I have had a tube inside my penis. Because of the anesthesia, I didn't feel how I got... [+]


2024-10-25 | Filipe Lascaray
Lords, land and citizens

The two main voters in Kanbo (the mayor and the prime minister) are the rabid ones. Three citizens have been beaten with a plainta, for protesting in favour of the eviction of the neighbor Marienea.Es the second time that, at 06:00 in the morning, they take us out of bed (with... [+]


2024-10-24 | Joseba Alvarez
Let's change the glasses

“The time has come for courageous, comprehensive and noble proposals (…) for Euskal Herria to re-enter the world’s revolts,” said friend Hartu López Arana in her opinion article “For an effective aggression” published in ARGIA magazine in July 2018. Six years have... [+]


2024-10-24 | Rafa Arriola
Good morning, Spain…

We are seeing more and more spelling errors in the writings of social networks, not only of young people, but also of the media. Some have become so common that they hardly hurt their eyes.

In this way, we can read in Spanish many things like: "You lose a dog," "It'll be that or k... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude