It is clear that we are experiencing a profound eco-social crisis. It seems clear that the energy transition is inevitable. However, it does not seem so clear that the axis of the energy transition must be ecological regeneration and adapting our economy to the biosphere. Nor is it clear that the green transition being imposed serves to challenge the power of major energy corporations. We need only look at how states, the European Green Pact and the Next Generation funds are attracting all kinds of companies, multinationals, investment funds -- that only see a business opportunity in electrification.
Forestalia is one of the hands that balance the cradle of the renewable business, with serious social and environmental implications, and now also in Navarra it aims to make high-tension macrolines. Company representing the opportunistic and speculative nature of energy exploitation.
The forestalist lacks anything. Company values include responsibility, sustainability, rural development and decarbonisation. But the reality is very different. It is a company of origin of the Jorge Group, one of the largest exports of meat and pork from the State. It is a company that has hired people from different parties in the Diputación General de Aragón, in the Generalitat or in the Government of Spain. José Manuel Soria, former minister of the PP and Julio Tejedo, former secretary of the Presidency of the PSOE of Aragon, are his last major fichajes. It is a company which absorbs thousands of MW in ministerial auctions classified by the press as pelotazos; which has been condemned by dozens of projects in towns and regions of Aragon; and which has participated in speculative operations to buy and sell projects.
Forestalia intends to transport and sell to major industrial centres, Bilbao, Vitoria, Barcelona, Tarragona, Valencia, the electricity generated in their projects or in projects of other companies, with disproportionate lines
Now Forestalita wants to project two high-tension macrolines in Navarra. For the time being, the Ministry of Ecological Transition and Demographic Challenge (MITERD) has received a positive environmental impact statement. The first, 270 km long, would drive electricity from the Cinco Villas de Zaragoza, through Carcastillo, Centro, Cuenca de Pamplona and Sakana, to Gatika (Bizkaia) and Vitoria (Álava). This line also has a third branch from Olite to the Castejón substation. The second projected macroline, over 200 kilometres, emerged in the region of Tauste in Zaragoza and would affect the Ribera de Navarra, La Rioja, Álava and Burgos. At the same time, Forestalia plans to transfer its surplus from Aragon to Catalonia and Valencia via more high-voltage lines.
This is an initiative that has no energy logic. With these projects, Forestalia is presenting itself as electric evacuation lines that are authentic transportation lines, in contravention of Law 24/2013, of the Electric Sector. In that law, Red Eléctrica de España, S.A. is assigned as the sole carrier of that activity. Another obstacle to the necessary socialisation and democratic planning of the energy sector. It prevents progress towards a diversified and decentralised model, while contravening the principle of sustainability of the approximation of production and consumption points. It is absolutely irrational that the existing infrastructures in Zaragoza reach their point of connection for evacuation in places as far away as Burgos, Bizkaia, Álava, La Rioja or Navarra.
This project also has no environmental logic. One of the two lines designed by Forestalia coincides in large part with another line of REE that runs between Muruarte and Mar (Gipuzkoa). Both lines would run parallel at 92 kilometres at a distance of approximately 200 metres. Thus, the environmental and territorial effects of this type of infrastructure (tree removal, barrier effect, electromagnetic fields, avifauna) would double due to the coexistence of both lines. We understand that the Ministry has not taken into account the cumulative impacts of both projects.
Finally, we can see a new chapter on the use of energy to fill private pockets. As surplus stratospheric electricity is expected to be generated, with difficulties in leaving the current network, Forestalia intends to transport and sell to the large industrial centres (Bilbao, Vitoria, Barcelona, Tarragona, Valencia) the electricity generated with disproportionate lines, in its projects or in projects of other companies. In this case we would not be talking about the response to the ecological crisis or environmental sensitivity. It would only be a response to ensure the economic viability of a business project that generates many doubts and debts.
Renewable forestry is another hand balancing cradle. But it's not the only one, because there's a lot more. And all of them are left. In the name of a supposed "energy transition", private companies are being allowed to function as they please and generate a new economic bubble. This disaster cannot be accepted or demanded by greater profits, such as the alleged fight against climate change. They only seek to satisfy their thirst for business by eliminating the sovereignty, biodiversity, territory and natural resources of the planet. Once again, it is essential to reiterate and demand. For all these projects, a moratorium is needed to rationalize, organize and plan democratically under appropriate conditions.
Mikel Saralegi Otsakar and Jule Goñi Montero, members of the Subai Erakuntza Foundation.
Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora
ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.
Bagira prozesuaren emaitza, Herri bidea bide-orria izan zen. Bide-orri honetan, abertzaleen helburua herriari boterea itzultzea dela aipatzen da, eta boterea itzultzeko, herriari burujabetza maila maximoa emanen dioten instituzioak herriari eskaintzea adierazten da. Zehazten da... [+]
The Municipal Police of Donostia-San Sebastián has not yet solved the lack of staff in its staff. During the summer the workforce has been strengthened by the hiring of dozens of local police officers to meet the different needs and services that emerge during the summer in a... [+]
The demands of Basque Country in Osakidetza are abusive. No doubt. We are putting and mobilizing health professionals in this line. Without being against the Basque Country, with little intention to learn and much less to use.
The new reference platform is “United by a Real... [+]
Despite the fact that two centuries have passed, the problem of La Plutónica cannot be allowed to fade in the well of oblivion. In addition to 200 years ago to learn about the history of La Plutónica, we must go back to the other side of the ocean, Montevideo.
The brothers... [+]
The crew is one of the hallmarks of the Basques. Every Basque has a crew or, at least, that is what is expected of a Basque born. It is no less, because we could say that the Group is the social unit of the Basque Country, the atom or basic component of our society. In this... [+]
Two days later, the advertising wave announcing the Ironman of Vitoria said: “Anything is possible.” I had an appointment with a friend at Plaza Nueva in Vitoria-Gasteiz and, along the way, I saw other posters, advertising stands and tents. Some in English (“Finish... [+]
Noise causes serious health problems and quality of life. Gernika-Lumo, despite its apparent beauty and hospitality, has serious noise problems.
By way of introduction, the above fact will be shown. At the height of the street Iparragirre de Gernika was the company of the... [+]
I can't contain the fire that hugs me inside, and I can only write these stupid words so I don't get mastered by despair.
I hate hypocrisy, I hate whites. The problem is that whiteness is everywhere, that we are all white.
It is well known that all the institutions take... [+]
Apparently, the fire originated on 13 July in Errenteria's home originated in the battery of an electric scooter. On this occasion, and fortunately, there was only material damage. However, don’t think this accident is an unusual thing, lately, firefighters are busy with this... [+]
Summer is coming, the main expression of the tourist destination, and again the problems arising from the overexploitation of the city as a tourist destination are especially visible, such as noise or the massification of the streets. However, we are more concerned about the... [+]
In 1977 the Basque Country Kopa of Lekeitio was launched, a time of transition. At the time of the Republic, in 1931, the first Basque Wedding left the Batzoki. In 1964, the Euskadi Wedding Championship was also held in Lekeitio, in tribute to Resurrection Maria Azkue.
I think... [+]
A few years ago I spent a weekend in Pamplona. It was October 12.
I was surprised to see dozens of Latin Americans celebrating ephemerides, with concerts, txosnas and everything. Had I celebrated the conquest of my ancestors? ! I thought that the cultural assimilation of the... [+]
Conservative mentalities are afraid of the term planning, linking with progressive and even communist political currents, as the new authoritarianisms do today (Milei, Meono, Orban, Aznar, among others). However, the idea of planning is still in good health, at least formally... [+]
The issue of cohesion is today the first responsibility of many governments, public institutions and non-governmental organisations. Indeed, societies with low inequalities more easily generate conditions for economic, social and cultural development, better governance... [+]