Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

“You can’t have a health center without the right staff, so it would be better to close the shutter”

  • Sara Ruilope and Uruko Blanco are, respectively, the administrative of Osakidetza and the physician of the mobile ICU. Journalists have reflected on the situation of the Osakidetza Emergency Services with Aiaraldea Irratia.

19 September 2024 - 10:30
Mila herritar baino gehiago mobilizatu ziren iragan abuztuan, ZIU mugikorrean medikurik ez egoteagatik herritar bat zendu izana salatzeko. / Aiaraldea.eus

The case of the citizen who died of a heart attack last August without adequate medical care has once again focused on the shortage of professionals in Osakidetza.

Urko Blanco: The situation is serious, but the situation has long been known. Last year all the municipalities of Aiaraldea received a message warning that during the summer and summer months there will be no doctors in the continuing care areas of the region and in the mobile ICU, so the municipalities would not have an adequate health service. Only the municipalities of Laudio and Ayala replied, the lack of interest of the other municipalities seems to me to be very serious.

When we talk about good health care, what are we talking about? What should emergency service offer by chance?

U.B. : It is very simple, in all categories 100% of professionals should be working in all shifts: Physician, nursing service and cellator in the Continuing Care Points, while in the mobile ICU are the physician, nursing service and technician. That is the care that citizens have to receive and all categories have to work to ensure that emergency services function properly. In addition, the resources are not very large.

This summer, however, has not always been the case.

U.B. : Indeed, emergency services have often been without medical personnel. The nursing service has replaced the lack of a doctor on several occasions, but this is not the appropriate procedure, a nurse cannot do the work of a doctor.

After the summer season, I would like to think that the situation is going to go a little bit further. At Christmas, however, we will find ourselves again in a similar situation.

Since when has the lack of doctors in emergency services become so common?

U.B. : I would say that this is a trend that has increased greatly over the past two years. What was an anomalous situation a few years ago, today it has become completely normal. It is even more unacceptable that such a service should be maintained with the overtime of the professionals, that is nothing more than a patch, but the problem will remain there.

And what has led to this situation?

U.B. What? I am clear that it is the result of poor management, it is the result of poor management by those responsible for OSI Interior and Emergency Services.

The lack of medical staff in Osakidetza is serious, the professionals are leaving and there is no possibility of replacing them. The most serious thing is that this situation was known a long time ago and that no remedy has been put on the table. Furthermore, working conditions are not good and people have to juggle enormous amounts in order to reconcile their professional and personal lives. There’s no planning, you don’t have billboards… That means that at any time you can get your shifts in.

Sara Ruilope: This clashes frontally with professional and family conciliation. Many professionals are without a sign, not knowing how they are going to work next week.

U.B. : Nor is it normal for the 2018 OPE to be resolved in 2024, after six years. Many Osakidetza professionals have spent six years of uncertainty.

sports club : This is another clear example of Osakidetza’s mismanagement. Deficiencies in the management of workers burn professionals. During all the time until the OPE resolution you are an occasional personal, you live in uncertainty. It is incomprehensible that what does not happen in other public administrations should happen here. Where I work, in my category, we're 50 collaborators, just two structural jobs. These are very precarious conditions.

This happens in all categories. In the emergency services, people work with a one-day contract, which is not the right conditions. Osakidetza today seems like a Temporary Work company.

Is the Public Administration responsible for channelling these obvious gaps in emergency services and primary care?

sports club : I have seen no change in recent months. The only thing I value as positive is that the political leaders have recognised for once that the situation is not good. In January everything was going well, but when the elections came, everyone admitted that there was a problem. One thing is to accept that. We'll see where they take us, I'm not very optimistic.

U.B. : I think the administration is not very concerned: in January a person died for lack of doctors and in August another person died for lack of doctors. No action has been taken in these eight months.

sports club : The situation of Laudio and the region is shameful. Two people have died in the last eight months and the situation has not changed at all. There was no need for a second case, but it has happened, and another citizen has died without adequate medical care. You can't have a health center without the right staff, so it's better to close the shutter. We are normalising the situation, and that is unacceptable.

U.B. : I would like to know what the municipalities of Aiaraldea are doing in the face of this situation. This is not just a Laudio problem. The lack of medical personnel in the mobile ICU or in the Continuing Care Point is a problem for the entire region. What measures are you taking to respond to the situation?

Do you think that the response of patients and citizens is being adequate?

U.B. : I believe that citizenship is not moving enough, I do not know if it is due to lack of information or fear. But a single demonstration is not going to change this situation.

sports club : I invite all patients to file complaints and complaints. I am aware that the answers given by Osakidetza are not individualised, but, despite that, I always encourage you to complain. Complaints cannot be reduced to mere statistics, otherwise it seems that everything works well, and that is not true. We have to open up gaps to reverse the situation.

U.B. Take an example. In the 2022 Christmas Eve I took the turn in the Llodio CAP and in the Amurrio CAP there was no doctor. All the patients in Amurrio had to come to Llodio. Many paid for their anger with me. In total, I saw 98 patients in a single 24-hour shift. I encouraged everyone to file a complaint, but only two or three people filled out the complaint sheet.

We have to go out into the street, there is no choice. We need permanent mobilisation to reverse the situation, and we cannot wait for another accident.


You are interested in the channel: Osakidetza
Osakidetza calls for real and structural solutions in Vitoria-Gasteiz, Bilbao and San Sebastian
Thousands of people took to the streets on Saturday to demand "real solutions" from the Basque Government and the Department of Health to solve the structural problems of Osakidetza.

2025-01-30 | Leire Ibar
Call to fill the streets for public health in Bilbao, Vitoria-Gasteiz and San Sebastian on February 1
The Popular Platform for Public Health (OPA) has called for demonstrations on February 1. They call for mobilisation to combat the privatisation of health, to strengthen primary care, to improve conditions for health workers, to combat precariousness and to advocate for both... [+]

2025-01-19 | Urtzi Ugalde
Goodbye, mom

These were my last words when we left, held hand in your deep breathing sleep. Your heart stayed forever without a special, simple, dignified pain. As you want and demand. How we want and respect.

Already a month before the arrival of winter, the last days of the longest night,... [+]


2025-01-16 | Leire Ibar
Former director of Osakidetza Mikel Sánchez quotes with Mutualia
Sánchez, who between 2019 and 2024 was director of Health Planning, Management and Evaluation, started in November as medical director of the company Mutualia. In the summer of 2024 he took the leap to private enterprise, three months after leaving office, with the... [+]

2024-12-27 | Gedar
Osakidetza cuts 110 health centers at Christmas
In the past Christmas, waiting periods of up to twelve hours were recorded, which have been extended to zero hours. Osakidetza applies such restrictions within 180 days a year.

2024-12-12 | Leire Ibar
Judge closes investigation of Osakidetza's opposition leaks without guilt
Judge Blanca Ester Díaz Pulido has completed her investigation into the leaks of Osakidetza's opposition in 2018, after six and a half years of hearings. All defendants have been acquitted in total, a total of 22, even though two of the cases have been provisionally filed.

Claims to Osakidetza grow by 20% over the past year
Complaints and acknowledgements have remained similar, but there is a difference in complaints. For example, compared to the previous month of June this year, claims have increased by almost 30%.

2024-11-15 | Gedar
Outrage at Cruces Hospital in the week of the Joint Commission audit
During this week, the United States audit will be at Cruces Hospital, which grants accreditation to health centers that meet their standards. Osakidetza has spent EUR 106,843 seeming before him.

Report the "collapse" of the sexually transmitted infections center of the Bilbao Fire Station Etxaniz
Alfonso Setiey, president of Anitzak, said that there is a lack of staff and information, that the waiting list is "long" and that there is a "great stigmatization".

Veterans athletes between 25 and 35 years old, most of the Behobia-San Sebastián corridors that end in the emergency room
What usually ends in emergency situations is not because it is not prepared for a 20-kilometer race; on the contrary, most men are accustomed to doing sport, from 25 to 35 years, who want to go to meet. This is what a doctor at the Donostia Hospital has assured us. The day of... [+]

2024-11-05 | ARGIA
They're back without doctors in the Amurrio emergency room.
The Amurrio Outpatient Continuing Care Centre has not attended any doctors last Sunday, Aiaraldea reported. A number of neighbours in the area have initiated a collection of signatures so that the area ' s neighbours can join it. “The practice without a doctor has been... [+]

The Basque Government intends to equate the number of places to study Medicine in Basque in the UPV with Spanish
Asked whether the UPV/EHU needs more places to study Medicine in Euskera, the Basque Government recently responded that this has to be decided by the UPV. Now, however, the Basque Government has reached an agreement with the public university to offer 40 more places in Medicine... [+]

If there is a shortage of Basque doctors, why does the UPV/EHU offer no more medical places in Euskera?
The issue has come to the Basque Parliament and the response of the Basque Government has been poor. Although Osakidetza is in the absence of doctors, the medical places of the UPV/EHU have barely increased. In addition, they offer fewer places to study the career in Basque than... [+]

They start collecting signatures in Aiaraldea to claim “a public and dignified healthcare system”
A collection of signatures will be launched throughout Aiaraldea to demand a "public and dignified" health system. They have made this known in a hearing this morning at the Office of Orduña. It has been attended by neighbours from several villages in Aiaraldea, stressing that... [+]

EH Bildu, PNV and PSE-EE agree to review the Osakidetza job vacancy model
The three parties have agreed on a parliamentary initiative calling for the Osakidetza OPE model to be revised and the consolidation processes to be completed.

Eguneraketa berriak daude