Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

There are not enough long-range missiles to change the situation in Ukraine in the West

  • (But if Kiev lets Russia attack, it can lead us directly to war.) George Beebe is a former director of CIA analysis in Russia and this article has been posted on the blog of journalist Rafael Poch and on the Brave New Europe website in English.

20 September 2024 - 10:53
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

Russia and the West are quickly stopping without room for manoeuvre to avoid a frontal military shock.

The United States and the United Kingdom are about to accept the use of Western missiles to attack Russia on their territory, according to several reports, and in this regard Vladimir Putin has made his most resounding statements so far. This measure, he said, ‘will change the nature of the conflict’ and will mean that NATO and Russia are ‘at war’. Russia has warned that it will make "the right decisions".

In reply, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer said: "The conflict was initiated by Russia. Ukraine was illegally invaded by Russia. Russia can put an end to this conflict immediately. Ukraine has the right to self-defence.”

The military logic to prove Russia’s determination in this case is unclear. There is little reason to believe that the use of airborne cruise missiles will increase Ukraine’s chances of winning what has become a war of wear, in which the Russians have great advantages over Ukraine from the population and military manufacturing. The Russians are eroding the ability of the Ukrainians to bring well-trained and equipped forces to combat, and cruise missiles launched from the air will not alter it.

Secondly, the Russians are able to adapt to the offensive capabilities of the far-reaching Ukrainians, as has already been done with the HIMARS artillery and the missiles launched from the ATACMS ground. The relocation of supply warehouses, for example, has resulted in greater effectiveness in neutralizing the advanced weaponry of the West by means of electronic warfare countermeasures.

Thirdly, in order for Ukraine to have a real influence on its ability to damage Russian territory, the West should give it large quantities of long-range missiles. In other words, they would now, apparently, need much more than the small number of basic range models being proposed. But the West has limited power to provide those amounts, and its granting would almost inevitably lead to direct reprisals from Russia.

Nor is the political logic behind the authorisation of deep attacks on Russia clear. There is little reason to conclude whether these attacks will bring sufficient pressure to put an end to Putin’s war or bring it to the negotiating table, but there are good reasons to believe that Russia is fighting NATO and not the Ukrainian people to extend its claims. In the history of large-scale bombing campaigns, there are many examples in which public resistance has been encouraged. So far, it has been, thanks to Russia’s attacks on Ukraine, that they have raised positions in favour of Ukrainian nationalism and the exclusion of the Russians.

Another possible unexpected consequence is that the increasing mortality of Western military aid will tighten Russia’s demands on future negotiating tables. The more the West proves that Ukraine is ready to be used to beat Russia, the more the Russians will commit themselves to the extensive demilitarization of Ukraine as a condition for reaching an agreement.

On the other hand, the risks are quite significant compared to the few awards that have been presented. The greatest danger is that Russia feels compelled to “restore deterrence”, to demonstrate to the West that it cannot continually increase the lethality and scope of the weapons it gives to Ukraine, without a direct response from Russia. Putin is going to be under pressure in his own country to take a tough stand and give a clear blow somewhere in the West, thereby preventing the West from further increasing its involvement. Otherwise, if you go down that road, at some point there will be very little chance for Russia to give up a large-scale war with NATO, something that Putin obviously wants to avoid.

What “appropriate measures” can Putin take? Russia is not very likely to react immediately and to embark on a nuclear escalation. Instead, the sabotages currently practised in Europe can be multiplied by warning shots (so far more than major attacks); it can give missiles and satellite intelligence to Hezbollah or Huthei; or, if it feels the need to go further, it can attack the Western satellites, which are essential to correct the Ukrainian attacks.

Any of these actions could cause serious damage to the West and give rise to its response. The response would further enhance the risky cycle of joint climbing, the end of which cannot be predicted.

Only Putin knows where he can put the hard line. But if you look at the dangers of a direct war between the world's major nuclear powers, it's a little bit spearheaded to keep pushing to know where that line might be.

Russia cannot win this war without conditions. It cannot conquer, occupy and govern the entire vast Ukrainian territory. That should form an invading and occupying force that would be much larger than the size of the current Russian army. But Russia can destroy Ukraine, leaving it in a state of dysfunction that cannot be rebuilt and allied with anyone.

It is not in the interests of the West and Ukraine to obstruct an agreement that guarantees the independence of Ukraine and offers opportunities for a promising future.

What Ukraine needs at the moment, desperately, are not far-reaching weapons. What it needs is a viable plan that will give Ukraine a realistic opportunity to rebuild itself and to move forward towards a negotiated end to this war.

(*) George Beeb spent more than two decades as an intelligence analyst, diplomat, and political advisor in the US Government. US, CIA Analytics Director in Russia and Russian Affairs Staff Advisor for Vice-President Cheney.

You are interested in the channel: Ukrainako gerra
2024-11-18 | Jon Torner Zabala
Biden authorises Ukraine to use long-range missiles against Russia
USA, Joe Biden, who has handed over the witness to Donald Trump, who can mark the change of direction of the United States in the war in Ukraine. However, before concluding its mandate, we have read that Ukraine has authorised the use of ATACMS long-range missiles in the Kursk... [+]

2024-11-05 | Mikel Aramendi
ANALYSIS
Do the North Koreans float between the fog in Russia?
When you hear stories like the North Korean soldiers who would act in Russia on the front line of war with Ukraine, it is difficult for the observer to distinguish what can be a reality blurred by the fog of war and what can be one of the classic masks.

2024-10-17 | Julene Flamarique
How many people have died in the war between Russia and Ukraine? What does the one and the other say?
More than a million people have died since the beginning of the war between Russia and Ukraine, research sources are reported to Europe Press. Most of the deaths are soldiers and then civilians of Ukrainian nationality, according to official sources. This summer has been the... [+]

In Ukraine, where war is being lost, the path of negotiation is being strengthened
Ukrainian President Volodimir Zelensky met with British Prime Minister Keir Starme and the new NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte on Wednesday in London. It has subsequently also met with other relevant European Union leaders at European level. The aim is to explain the “new... [+]

2024-10-07 | Joan Mari Beloki
Most Basque MEPs are betting on extending war to Europe

On 19 September the majority of the European Parliament voted in favour of: "That all restrictions on the use of arms systems granted to Ukraine should be lifted immediately on Russian territory," he added. In common terms: "Launch missiles long across Russia." This Parliament is... [+]


The risks of Salami's tactic

For the powers, the salami tactic is attractive. It consists of cutting steaks progressively. With the enlargement of NATO, violations of international law, regime changes and the international proliferation of its military bases, the United States reduced the security and... [+]


2024-09-11 | Joan Mari Beloki
Russia invaded

Kursk is a historic region of Russia. He lived in peace until 6 August, when the Ukrainian army entered the city. About 15,000 men entered. Hundreds of tanks, armoured vehicles, artillery pieces, air defense radars… the most modern weapons that exist today, brought from all... [+]


2024-09-11 | Gedar
Ukraine’s Azov Fascist Battalion Begins Recruiting Tour in Europe
The intention of the fascists is to make the group known, raise funds for war and recruit soldiers for the cause. The stops to be made include Germany, Poland, the Czech Republic, Lithuania, the Netherlands and Belgium.

2024-09-10 | Axier Lopez
In the new course, they call war.
In summer, it is common for many news stories to cover the interruptions of holidays. And actually, if they were covered, almost better. The sound of wars continues to make the old continent dance.

2024-08-29 | Gedar
The military expenditure of the Spanish Government is even higher than budgeted
In 2022, military investment was 20% higher than that approved in the annual budget, and in 2023, 30% higher. The military spending of the European countries at the moment is higher than at the end of the Cold War.

Russia conducts violent attacks in several regions of Ukraine
The war began on February 24, 2022. Since then, Moscow has staged one of the most violent attacks Russia has perpetrated this Monday in Syria. The attack has targeted energy infrastructure, which has led to widespread blackouts and has affected several parked vehicles.

2024-08-07 | Euskal Irratiak
Oihana Goiriena
“Haserre gara, Polonia airos atera baita Pabloren kontrako salaketa frogatu gabe”

Osasun artak biltzen ari da Pablo Gonzalez Moskun une honetan. Joan den astean, Poloniako Radomgo segurtasun handiko espetxetik atera zen kazetaria bi urte eta bost hilabeteko preso egon ondoan. Poloniak leporatzen zion espioitza frogatu gabe libre atera da.


NATO strikes China and Russia at the 75th anniversary summit
At the 75th anniversary summit of its founding, the Atlantic Alliance has hardened the message against China and accused the Asian country of helping Russia in the war in Ukraine. The 32 NATO members have committed themselves to providing more assistance to Kiev and the European... [+]

2024-07-09 | Mikel Aramendi
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban carries out a specific plan
The 'surprise blitz' carried out by the Hungarian Prime Minister, Viktor Orban, in a week after the Turkish presidency of the European Union, requires a serious explanation. Of material size.

2024-07-03 | Joan Mari Beloki
They lead us to war.

The last elections have sent us a clear message. We Europeans do not want wars. Ukraine has to end and the politicians have to take steps in this direction as soon as possible. In France and Germany, the far-right has been loosely imposed and the reason is in the war in Ukraine:... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude