Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Two workers show that the Strasbourg incinerator misses measurements

  • Two qualified technicians from the Strasbourg incinerator (Alsace) explained in the Rue89-Strasbourg newspaper how the owners of incineration plants take advantage of the extensive capacity that the law grants them to self-control and falsify the toxic emissions of the incinerator. This fraud avoids the fines that the administration must impose (small, certain) and also the investments necessary to better manage pollutant emissions in its incineration plants.

27 November 2019 - 13:06
Estrasburgoko erraustegiak neurketak faltsutzen dituela erakutsi dute bi langilek

"In two years I have seen at least ten times how the company was scamming the pollution data," said Christophe (name invented to protect the worker's identity) to Guillaume Kremppi, of the electronic newspaper Rue89 Strasbourg. He collected the testimonies of two former technicians in the chronicle "of how two Altsatian incinerators have been able to disguise their polluting emissions".

The system is very simple and called self-control: incinerators themselves control their contamination and decide what data and how to send it to the environmental authorities of the department (known as DREAL in France). One of the systems they have for this self-control is combustion analysis. "The problem," Cristoph said, is that the authors of these computer systems deliver the codes to their customers." As a result, if pollution exceeds a certain level, it is easy to remove or change the results informally. "When the incineration furnace is set in motion, or waste that did not have to reach the furnace arrives, such as PVC windows, when burned, hydrochloric acid and ash can rise at full speed. And then, we manipulate the data that allows it to be included in the norms, making "part 10."

The journalist has also addressed the authors of the software, who have told him that they keep a copy of the client’s unmanipulable data and that it is in the hands of the authorities if they want to compare them with those which the company has subsequently taught the administration. The information technology company has said that the DREAL authorities have never asked them for the real data they have in their possession.

Data from the continued control of the other incinerator in Altsacia, the city of colmar, have been sent through DREAL showing what the journalist had to publish. The journalist has analyzed these documents and graphs with a technician and soon realized that they are organized in such a way that they cannot reach conclusions, on the one hand the daily averages, and on the other a rain of data and curves. The journalist has asked for more precise and complete information from the director of the incinerator in Colmar, who has not responded to the request for a hearing.

At the incinerator in Strasbourg in 2014 it was demonstrated that some excesses of pollution had been illegally disguised, even then the workers of the company informed, risking their jobs: "It is observed that the data for the whole day, collected with the operating furnaces, were not recorded in the last computer system, as they exceeded the permitted contamination levels". One of the workers interviewed by Rue89 Strasbourg has made it clear that the main objective of this falsification of data was not to avoid fines, as the fines are not so high, while for the company it was more important not to make costly improvements in the incinerator to reduce pollution: "Electrofilters and smoke cleaning systems have long deteriorated, today they remain the same, as I have been told by colleagues who are continuing this work. They had to invest in it in order to be able to enter the norms normally." In the case, it was shown that the company Senerval, which carries the management of the incinerator, gave the employees... an accurate guide to falsify data when contamination was too big!

This same year the Strasbourg incinerator has repeatedly exceeded dioxin emissions, in particular on 21 August and 19 September. M3Co 0.17 dioxin nanograms were poured at 0.10 ng per m3 level. But that was average, because one of the two ovens provided 0.23 ng per m3. Those responsible for DREAL (calmly, yes) appeared at the incinerator on 4 November... Tamala: when the inspector appeared, the two furnaces were casually shut down.


You are interested in the channel: Errausketa
2023-09-08 | ARGIA
They organize the human chain against incineration on the day of the Concha races
The Anti-Incineration Movement denounces that waste management in Gipuzkoa continues to worsen. It is explained that the San Sebastian incinerator has increased pollution and reduced selective collection, and that the new projects planned in the country will go further in this... [+]

2023-08-04 | Ilargi Manzanares
GHK recognises 42 days of untreated waste incineration
They indicate that they have done so “provisionally” for “maintenance”. It is also said that all “environmental demands” have been met and that no rules have been broken.

2023-05-28 | Zero Zabor
Dear Iñaki Usabiaga
Many of those involved in the mobilizations against the Zubieta incinerator in Gipuzkoa met Iñaki, the oldest activist with 80 years of history. In the photo you can see the work done in the mountains to the incinerator in 2018 with a young militant.

2023-04-24 | Zero Zabor
Authorities recommend not to eat eggs from chickens in the Parisian capital because they are contaminated with dioxins, furans and PCBs
The Health Authority of the region of Pil-de-France, the capital of Paris and the entire metropolis of the area, has recommended that citizens not consume eggs from small hens of their houses: a study commissioned by the public authorities confirms what the ToxiWatch foundation... [+]

2023-02-27 | Zero Zabor
Faced with the uncontrolled expansion of toxic PFAS, the European Commission is initiating its regulation
A study promoted by major European media reveals that PFAS is distributed in thousands of black spots across the continent. PFAS (per- and polyfluorinated compounds, ‘Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances’), which you have not heard of, are particularly polluting and have... [+]

2022-09-08 | Zero Zabor
On Sunday they will protest at the beach of La Concha against the incinerators of Zubieta and Bergara
The Anti-Incineration Movement has called on Gipuzkoan citizens to mobilise against the incineration of waste on 11 September in Donostia at the same time as the regattas are held. The EAM militants have been demonstrating for years their protest against the incinerator built in... [+]

2022-06-20 | ARGIA
Mass mobilisation against the Larramendi incinerator in Bergara
The Larramendiko Arnasa group has called for a demonstration against the incinerator that the company Valogreen wants to build in Bergara on Sunday noon. They denounce the Government ' s attitude.

2022-04-26 | Zero Zabor
The incinerator Zabalgarbi earns 17 million in subsidies, despite not really valuing the waste
The Ekopol Association, which investigates the characteristics of ecological sustainability, social and environmental crises and climate change in the Basque Country, has analysed the result of the activity carried out by the Zabalgarbi incinerator in Bizkaia in 2020. The most... [+]

2022-04-20 | Zero Zabor
The Prosecutor's Office denounces the incinerator of Barcelona for infringing environmental regulations
In 2018, the citizens of the Airenet platform complained to the courts that the incinerator of Sant Adriá de Besòs, which burns the metropolitan waste of Barcelona and its metropolitan area, repeatedly violates the law. In the framework of its investigation, the public... [+]

2022-01-31 | Zero Zabor
Kutsadura toxiko handia detektatu du ikerketa batek Espainia, Txekia eta Lituaniako hiru erraustegiren inguruan

Zero Waste Europe-k (ZWE) Espainia, Txekia eta Lituaniako hiru erraustegiri buruz argitaratu duen ikerketa berri batek egiaztatu du instalazio horien inguruetan kutsadura maila handia dagoela, eta hori arriskutsua litzateke ingurumenerako eta gertu bizi diren pertsonen... [+]


2021-12-23 | ARGIA
Jaurlaritzak Zumarragan erraustegi bat eraiki nahi duela salatu du ELAk

Zumarragan 2023 amaierarako eraiki nahi duten plastikoak tratatzeko plantan pirolisia erabiliko da olioa lortzeko (takoil), eta olio hori plastiko berria eta erregaiak egiteko erabiliko da. "Hondakin solidoak errez erregaia sortzen du, eta Europar Batasunaren beraren... [+]


Bergarako erraustegi proiektuaren erruz, 200 langileko kooperatiba bat herritik joan dela salatu du Udalak

Bergarako Udalaren webgunean irakur daiteke albistea izenburu honekin: 200 langileko kooperatiba batek Bergaratik joatea erabaki du Valogreene-k bertan ezarri nahi duelako hondakinen planta. "Paper-industriaren hondakinen tratamendurako planta Bergaran ezarri aurretik,... [+]


2021-11-24 | Leire Artola Arin
The Bergara Incinerator Project Round Table Raises Public Concern
The representative of Ecologists in Action accused Greene of “lying” and “hiding data” from the public, and warned of the harm of dealing with waste with pyrolysis. The project managers, however, have explained the "benefits" of the plant and have ensured that pyrolysis is... [+]

2021-11-04 | Zero Zabor
Concentration in Bergara against the incinerator
The Ekologistak Martxan movement called for a concentration in Bergara on 4 November, in protest at the construction of a plant to gasify waste from paper mills. This environmental group has been the first to denounce the true nature of the waste plant they want to build in the... [+]

New Bergara plant
You say pyrolysis, I say incinerator
The Alicantina company Greene Waste to Energy S.L., promoted by the Euskadi Paper Cluster, has announced the construction of a waste treatment plant for paper plants in Bergara.

Eguneraketa berriak daude