Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

School sport vs club debate in full swing

  • The Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa will now appeal the ruling that a child who wants to work in a sports club does not have to do school sports. On the one hand, the freedom to choose the sport that the child wants, on the other hand, the model that favors educational and integrative objectives, has revived the debate.

29 January 2025 - 07:29

In Gipuzkoa, a child can enroll in a sports club, but is required to do School Sports from 6 to 12 years old (from 6 to 8 years old Educational Games, from 9 to 12 years old Multikirola). Currently, 17,545 children participate in the Multikirola program, of which 36% only do Multikirola and 64% are also registered in a club, according to data published by Diario Vasco

Why only the club?

The ruling that suspended the obligation has cheered many parents. They argue that they should be free to choose the sport they want and that the child does not have to do other sports that he does not like. What is more, in addition to doing the sport you like in a club, the need to attend School Sport takes a lot of time for the child, so it is understandable that several parents consider the obligation excessive. Performance is also sometimes key: they often focus on improving and progressing in the sport that the child (family) has chosen, specializing in what he likes and/or is skillful and competent. With the elite sport in mind, moreover, the model that imitates or approaches it, based on competition, is not seen as bad by many, and more or less many clubs move around this model.

Why School Sports?

According to the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa, which is going to appeal, it is clear that: If the School Sport is rejected and only a club-based sport remains among the lords and children, “an elitist and exclusionary system, structured around the talented and focused on results and achievement, would be built. It would be divided between good and bad.” In fact, those who cannot participate in a club – for example, because of their socio-economic situation – are excluded from the model.

At the beginning and with children, instead of being limited to a single sport, in the case of boys, directly to football, one of the objectives of School Sport is to try everything related to physical activity and work on competences and skills in a comprehensive way, also because, according to several experts, early specialization is not beneficial in the long term. The characteristics and values of School Sport were summarized by Luis Mari Zulaika, professor of Physical Education, during the round table held by LUZ: “the diversity of sports; the de-emphasis of the result –there is no classification in the lower levels–; the groups do not do it by level –instead of putting the best in one group and the mediocre in the other, forming natural and mixed groups with the roommates–; the prioritization of the educational objectives; the responsibility of the management is the schools and not the clubs or sports associations whose objective is the result and performance; the participation of all, with rules that the difference between the less and the more played is small”.

One model and the other: the tree vs the pyramid

We can talk about tastes, freedom, wasting time... but basically, what is often behind is two ways of understanding sport that often collide. As Zulaika explained in the above-mentioned round table: “Before, the model of the pyramid was followed, organized to create high-level athletes in the future, for which the best were chosen, they focused on them and the others were lost along the way. In the 21st century, if the goal is to promote an active lifestyle among all citizens, this model does not serve us. Twenty years ago a general law was proposed for the UAE –then each historical territory made its own interpretation–, closer to the model that would be for all citizens, to promote an active and healthy lifestyle. The model of the tree was chosen for this: at first the child will try everything to develop basic motor skills in integrity and generality, and tomorrow the branches will begin to emerge, some will be destined to the upper level and performance, but all others will be prepared and have the culture internalized to maintain an active lifestyle in their free time. What happened? What happened? That the pro-performance collectives have enormous strength, that they are an extraordinary factual power, and that those who should make decisions succumb to this pressure. In the case of Gipuzkoa, for example, for many years we have had a very well developed tree model but we are going backwards due to the strength of the pyramid model.”


You are interested in the channel: Kirola
One of those arrested in connection with the attack on the realist Ion Aranburu in Soria is sent to prison
Ion Aranburu was in a coma and was admitted to the ICU for several weeks due to the attack.

analisia |
Save the Children, saldu bonbak (II)

Historia errepikatzen dela idatzi zuen Marxek, “lehenik tragedia gisa, gero fartsa moduan”. Armagintzaren eta militarismoaren inguruan errepikapen hutsa ez, espiralean goraka doan buklea ari gara bizitzen, fartsatik asko duena, eta tragedian amaitzeko gero eta aukera... [+]


2025-03-28 | Sustatu
La Ligaren blokeoak euskal domeinuei eragiten dien kaltea monitorizatuko du Puntueus-ek

Azken aldian, asteburuetan, Internet ez dabil ondo. Hasieran, zaila zen webguneei ezarritako blokeoen zergatia ulertzea; orain, badakigu Espainiako La Ligak agindu zituela, futbola modu ilegalean emititzea saihesteko. La Ligaren blokeoak euskal domeinuei eragiten dien... [+]


Gorputz hotsak
“Desgaitasunaren eta eskiaren mundua deskubrimendu bat izan da”

Orain arte desgaituak ez diren pertsonekin lehiatu da Uharteko Ipar Eski Taldeko Eneko Leyun eskiatzailea (Iruñea, 1998). 2024-2025 denboraldian, lehenengo aldiz parte hartu du Adimen Urritasuna duten Pertsonentzako Iraupeneko Eskiko Espainiako Txapelketan. Urrezko... [+]


Euskal Pilotan euskal selekzioa aitortzearen alde kokatu da Espainiako Kirol Kontseilu Nagusiko lehendakaria

Euskal Pilotako Nazioarteko Federazioaren eta Espainiako Federazioaren arteko gatazkak bere horretan jarraitzen duen bitartean, Jose Manuel Rodriguez Uribesek euskal selekzioaren aldeko adierazpenak egin ditu. Desadostasunak direla eta, Nazioarteko Pilota Federazioaren eta... [+]


2025-03-20 | Gedar
“Ertzainek aita jipoitu zuten nire alboan, 65 urte ditu eta elbarria da”

Ertzaintzak martxoaren 13an Bilbon zauritutako bi pertsonaren testigantza jaso ditugu. Athleticen partidaren ostean larriki zauritu zituzten aita-semeak, borra-kolpeka, eta atxilo eraman zuten haietako bat. Furgonetatik ikusi zuen ertzainek nola egin zuten tiro jendearen kontra,... [+]


Guraso elkarteek antolaturiko eskolaz kanpoko jarduerak ordaindu ezin dituzten ikasleak

Eskolaz kanpoko jardueren eskaintza zabala egiten duten ikastetxeen aldean, beste askok ez du horretarako aukerarik; eta eskola bereko ikasleen artean ere, denek ezin dute ekintzetan parte hartu, baliabide ekonomikoek baldintzatuta. Esku hartzeko dei egin diete instituzioei:... [+]


2025-03-15 | Jabi Elorza Antia
Txapela buruan

Iazko udan ere Alacant aldera hurbildu ginen eguraldi hobea aurkitu nahian eta, urtero bezala, egun batez, Benidorm erraldoian sartu ginen hango giroan murgildu, zerbait hartu eta seme-alabekin izozki edo gofre bat dastatzeko asmoz.

Hiri bitxia da, denetarik aurki dezakezu... [+]


2025-02-28 | Gedar
Adin txikiko neska bati eraso dio Sarako kirol entrenatzaile batek

 15 urteko emakume bati egin dio eraso Izarra klubean jarduten zuen pilota entrenatzaile batek.


Two football teams stand in front of racist insults in Bizkaia and the matches are suspended
The youth football match of Gaztelueta C -Berango C was cancelled on Saturday. During the game, a young man from Gaztelueta C called his opponent "the damned dirty black". Even in the Otxarkoaga-Fuenterrós match at the highest regional level, one of the footballers had to suffer... [+]

2025-02-06 | Gedar
Buses set to travel to Vitoria-Gasteiz on Friday to protest against Maccabi
The Israeli state basketball team will play in Vitoria-Gasteiz on Friday and Solidarity with Palestine has called for its mobilisation.

Iñigo Cabacas Herri Harmaila
“Jazarpena azken urte eta erdian areagotu da”

Iñigo Cabacas Herri Harmaila taldea eta Athleticen arteko harremana nahaspilatuta dago azkenaldian. Iñigo Cabacas Herri Harmailako Iñigorekin hitz egiteko aukera izan dugu astelehenean.


2025-01-29 | Leire Ibar
Solidarity with Palestine gathers nearly 200 signatures to prevent Maccabi’s departure from Vitoria
The pro-Palestinian movement has presented a manifesto demanding the cessation of the competition between the Israeli basketball team and Baskonia. 40 basketball clubs from the Basque Country, teams and amateur teams from Baskonia, 91 personalities from the world of sport and... [+]

2025-01-15 | Jon Torner Zabala
Basque Selection
On the road to officialdom, an open reindeer?
The International Federation of Basque Ball has taken the step of achieving the official status of the Basque Country Selekzioa, accepting that the Federation of the Basque Country is a full member. “It’s a historic achievement,” the Basque Country said on 28 December, but... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude