Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"When constitutional reform is not possible, the consequence is an authoritarian system"

  • Parliament, Constitutional, separation of powers (Parliament, Constitutional Court, separation of powers), is the last book by the professor of administrative law of the UPV/EHU, Iñaki Lasagabaster. It has been published by the Basque Institute of Public Administration. He also added a small note to the title: Making an essential reference to Catalonia.

15 January 2021 - 13:01
Argazkia: Iñigo Azkona

The book analyzes in a theoretical and practical way the separation of powers, especially the relationship between Parliament and the judiciary, and more specifically, Parliament and the relationship of constitutional courts. How were the relations between these organizations articulated? What has been done and what has not? Basically, Lasagabaster argues that the Basque Parliament should be inviolable before the Constitutional Court and, in general, with exceptions, so would parliamentarians.

In his view, this does not happen and more and more, in the Spanish State the Constitutional Court has more and more power to participate and send in the day-to-day of parliament and, if necessary, to punish non-compliance with its mandates. It analyses in particular the case of the last few years in Catalonia, which has culminated in the imprisonment of its parliamentarians, members of the government and leaders of civil society.

The professor has dealt in detail with the case of successive prohibitions issued by the Constitutional Court to the Bureau of the Catalan Parliament and concluded that: “There you see clearly how the administration of judges is given in a democracy, it would be difficult to find a more appropriate example. It is the judges who decide what is debatable in Parliament. The Constitutional Court has a monopoly on rejecting unconstitutional laws, but its action is far from that theory.”

 

 

The political impetus of the judges in Spain has spread a great deal in recent years, it is not just a question that a Basque professor says. Although the final conclusions are not the same, some passages in the book have led me to a conference that was pronounced by journalist Enric Juliana after the referendum in Catalonia in Pamplona. Juliana said that in the case of Catalonia not only has the Government of Rajoy responded, but that the legal structure has entered fully, and not, as it is often said, by the impetus of the Government, but on its own initiative: “Judges play in the spirit that today lives in Madrid. Justice is a world in itself, a part of the depths of the State, and a new doctrine is now being consolidated. In the end, a paradox is going to happen, that politics is going to be done by the Constitutional Court and not by Parliament, which it really has to do. It was curious, the Parliament of Spain has done little in the whole matter.”

As for the inviolability of parliaments, Lasagabaster says that the Constitutional Court does not act in the same way with the main political forces of the State or, for example, with nationalists. The book analyzes the Catalan question and the Atutxa cases of the Basque Parliament in 2005, but also the discrepancies of the Constitutional with the parliaments of Asturias or Extremadura.

The book details that the constitutional courts do not behave in this way with parliaments in the rights of a profound democratic tradition in Europe and sets the example of the United Kingdom: In the face of a similar problem in Scotland and Catalonia, a referendum is ended in Scotland and those who have asked for a referendum are imprisoned in Catalonia.

The conclusion of the book is hard: The democratic health of the Spanish State is very poor. In his view, "the constitutional system should not prevent any parliamentary debate, there is no rule that would allow it, and if there were any, the political system would not have a democratic character (…)". When constitutional reform or ritual law reform is not possible, the conclusion is an authoritarian system in which the democratic principle has a secondary meaning. We live in that moment.”


You are interested in the channel: Politika
Just as we experienced the flourishing of the Basque Country with the help of the artists, so that this time, taking advantage of their impulses, we continue to make our way together giving the necessary support to the Basque political prisoners, exiles and deportees

The... [+]


A man arrested by the Civil Guard in Amurrio for laughing on social media at the expense of two dead agents
"Dead police, the best fertilizer for the garden," the detainee wrote on social media, and his profile has more than four million followers, the Civil Guard said.

2025-02-14 | Gedar
In Munich, a union demonstration is captured and at least 21 people are injured by a man
Using a vehicle, Ver.diren takes the protesters who were at a protest in front of them. A few days ago, a white supremacist murdered 11 people in Sweden.

2025-02-14 | Euskal Irratiak
David Gramond
“Gizartea beldurrarazteko baliatu zuten tortura, militantziari uko egiteko”

Otsailaren 13a Torturaren Kontrako eguna izanki, Euskal Herriko Torturaren Sareak gutun publiko bat igorri du. Poliziek torturatu euskal jendeen lekukotasunak bildu, eta aitortza egiteko xedea du sare berri horrek Euskal Herri osoan. Torturatuak izan diren 5.000 pertsonei... [+]


Environmentalists recall that there are alternatives to drilling in Aralar in the face of threats of expropriation for AAV
The alternative that would connect Navarre with Ezkio-Mar would involve the drilling of a 22 kilometre tunnel inside Aralar, with a cost of 1.3 billion euros. However, the municipalities of the many towns where this link would pass, as well as the neighbors, have obstructed the... [+]

The Spanish Congress approves the PP initiative to delay the closure of nuclear power plants
The Junts and the ERC abstained in the vote and the non-legal proposal presented by the people was put forward with the votes of the PP, Vox and the UPN. The closure between 2027 and 2035 would mean an increase in the useful life of the seven nuclear power plants of the Spanish... [+]

"We are concerned about the technological determinism of the Minister of Education: yes or yes must be introduced in an uncritical way"
The use of technologies is being discussed in the Education Committee of the Basque Parliament, for which several experts and agents are making their contribution in the committee. We spoke with the team responsible for Cabecera Levada, who has requested a general regulation to... [+]

Europe pledges to invest €200 billion in artificial intelligence
On February 10 and 11, a hundred heads of state met in Paris, together with representatives of the Artificial Intelligence sector, for the fourth summit on AI. Although there have been concerns and questions about this technology that is developing at high speed, it was not a... [+]

2025-02-12 | Jone Gartzia
The Table of Health born in Hankamotz arrives limp to the final phase
The Basque Health Pact Board, set up by the Basque Government, will be just over five months old, and the end of the debate process they wanted completed by March is moving away from meeting to meeting. The established methodology, the list of institutions called to the table,... [+]

The police will prepare the bus drivers for the attacks
Azahara Domínguez, deputy of the Department of Mobility, Tourism and Planning of Gipuzkoa, announced it after meeting with the head of the Basque Government, Jabier Zabaleta. Among other things, they will be provided with resources to combat sexual assaults in order to have the... [+]

The Spanish Government approves the project for the construction of a new neighborhood in the plots of the barracks of Loyola
Once the Ministry of Energy Transition has accepted the claims of the City Council of San Sebastián, they will be able to build 1,750 homes there. The City Council has established the line of protection for the construction of the new neighborhood twenty meters from the Urumea... [+]

The alleged left doing (and proud of) migrant raids in the UK: 4,000 detainees in six months
The ruling Labour Party has shown images of arrests and deportations, proudly claiming it has made a “record” this January.

'Give them here, give them Basque' will be the slogan used by the Government of Navarre in its campaign to promote Basque
Especially families with children. Because we want the best for our children, giving them Basque would broaden their horizons for the future. "It is an invitation to choose for multilingualism, because giving Basque is a union," said Ana Ollo, Basque counselor.

Lawyer sentenced to six years in prison for helping a prisoner in exchange for drugs
The Public Prosecutor’s Office of Gipuzkoa wants to sentence the head of patrols of the Citizen Protection of Donostia-San Sebastian to six years in prison. The gunman offered benefits in the court process in exchange for cocaine to a man arrested on charges of drug... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude