Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Reactions to the Education Bill: Basque, Segregation and Public Education Service, main objectives of criticism

  • Immediately after the submission of the CAPV Education Bill, the new text has received numerous reactions, including the complaint that the Basque public education service equips both networks (to the detriment of the public network), the lack of a generalised model of linguistic immersion and the insufficiency of anti-segregation measures.
Sindikatuek iaz deituriko mobilizazioetako bat. Argazkia: LAB

26 April 2023 - 12:10
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

“The education bill needs more Basque”

The unions reaffirm the criticism made by the Council of Euskalgintza: the model of widespread immersion has not been taken up (current models A, B and D have not been exceeded either). Interestingly, the PSE has rightly criticised the opposite: the new law can open the way to overcoming current language models, and does not agree with that.

The Council has also missed instruments to properly measure language competence, and has expressed concern that the draft law “does not specify how the multilingual system should be interpreted, how each educational centre should apply, or how the exposure in each language will be. Determining the minimum exposure hours is essential for the new generations to be able to euskaldunize,” he said. She has positively valued the need for students to reach the B2 exit profile in Basque at the end of the compulsory language and the “recognition of knowledge of the Basque culture”.

CCOO says that believing that the Christian School will comply with the principle of secularism is “absurd”. STEILAS says that “it will be difficult for concerted centres to be laity, free or Euskaldunes because the identity of the centre must be respected”

“Equip the public network with the concerted network”

Both the Agreements and the STEILAS, ELA and CCOO trade unions have been particularly critical of the Basque Public Education Service that is now enshrined in the Law (every center of this service will receive 100% public funding): STEILAS and CCOO have denounced that in this service the public network is equated with the concerted network and that “perpetuates the educational system”.

They criticize that the law does not regulate the working conditions of public education, that it does not open up the possibility of increasing educational investment, that the council that will be created to negotiate the rights of public school workers and staff concerted at the same table is not effective and that “real ways” are not opened to publish the concerted centres. “No real action is taken to make the Basque public school the central axis of the education system and competition between schools is encouraged,” says STEILAS.

In the fight against segregation, the three trade unions state that the problem of the inadequacy of the defined and structural measures is not really addressed (emphasising, for example, that no single municipal registration office has been set up).

CCOO says that believing that the Christian School will comply with the principle of secularism is “absurd”. In this regard, STEILAS says that “it will be difficult for the concerted centres to be laity, free or Euskaldunes because the identity of the centre must be respected”.

The LAB syndicate values more positively the need to concretize and develop more measures to put the public school in the center and fight against segregation, but points out that the contributions made by the union itself have been included in the bill: “the requirements to impose on the centers that will receive public funds have been determined, an administrative unit has been created to control that the fees are not charged, it has been included as a lack of doctrine, that the processes of

EH Bildu: "The public service has been well regulated and well defined, with well-defined obligations. Key measures against segregation and for inclusion

“We see fundamental changes”

EH Bildu has welcomed the changes that have taken place from the first draft of the draft bill to the bill adopted by the Governing Council. “We see fundamental changes in the right direction,” said EH program director Bildu, Pello Otxandiano, who stressed that the Basque Public Education Service has been “well regulated and well defined” and that “duties are well expressed”. The new text “sets out key measures against segregation and for inclusion, relating to the vulnerability rate or access of students”, he adds. It considers that “concrete measures to achieve real gratuity” have been taken and that the language model section has been “defined and improved”.

He says that this law is “a historic opportunity” and that they see how to improve: that the bill will jump to the Basque Parliament, “EH Bildu will table amendments, because the goal is to get the best law.” This week he announced a further reading of the bill.

The article entitled “From the first draft of the CAV Education Act has been amended to the bill and has not been amended” explained the details of the new text.


You are interested in the channel: EAEko Hezkuntza Legea
37 questions to the new counselor living on the other side of the public education limit
Who orders us ...?

The Basque Government has just been set up and the Minister for Education will be Begoña Pedrosa. Being a vice-counselor in the previous legislature and being one of the founders of the new Education Law passed last December, we are allowed to ask some... [+]


2024-06-12 | ARGIA
Hik Hasi publishes a book that aims to be a tool to "seize the open opportunities" of the CAV Education Act
Basque Law of Education. The Hik Hasi project presented the book Coordinates for the following day on Wednesday. “We have analyzed the possibilities opened by the new law to achieve a public, inclusive, social and inclusive education system for all, the advances it entails... [+]

New Education Law: chronicle of a lawsuit against the public school

The recently passed Education Act is as bad as it is new. Throughout the processing process there has been a broad social sector against the spirit of this law, and this opposition has been greater in the face of its adoption. We want to make public the assessment and reflection... [+]


EHE members try to chain themselves to the parliamentary portal to denounce the Education Act
The members of Euskaraz have protested before the Gasteiz Parliament for the approval of the “expired” Education Act. At 9:00 in the morning there was a concentration in which two members tried to chain a parliamentary departure.

The PNV-PSE adopts an Education Act against all opposition
The day comes: This Thursday the Education Act was approved in the Basque Parliament, supported only by the PNV and the PSE. In the court of Parliament, Harro and Euskal Herrian Euskaraz have protested about the Basque Public School. Like the last education law passed thirty... [+]

National construction

The new Education Act, which had to be born of consensus, was adopted in anger and disagreement. The lack of agreement is due to the public-private question and linguistic models. A lot of pity.

In this we follow the Spanish model, because in the CAPV we are not able to lay... [+]


When we are forced to call for a binding law

Those of us who write and sign these lines are young people between 20 and 26 years old who have joined us in the context of the generational relay of Euskalgintza. In our case, we have decided to contribute to the struggle of the Basque Country in the Basque Country from... [+]


The Council describes the Education Act as “missed opportunity”
The Council of Euskalgintza has carried out the assessment of the CAPV Education Act, which will be voted on by the Basque Parliament on 21 December. He criticized that the law will be “far from guaranteeing the right of future generations to become aware in Basque”. He adds... [+]

2023-12-14 | ARGIA
Federation of Ikastolas
"The adoption of the bill as it stands will result in the loss of possibility"
"If the bill approved by the Education Commission of the Basque Parliament is approved on November 29, we will miss the opportunity to transform the Basque Educational System," said the President of the Federation of Ikastolas, Nekane Artola, and the Director-General, José Luis... [+]

The Education Act gives birth to failed goals
Without achieving the social and political support it sought, the CAV Education Act has been given the green light this Wednesday in the Education Commission. The law had three challenges: overcoming the dual system of public and concerted centers, making a leap in the... [+]

The problem is the Education Act, not Amendment 5

I thought I would write this article about the amnesty obtained by the Catalans, because that achievement has shown that everything can be negotiated and, above all, that nationalists have passed the historic moment of achieving anything but amnesty. Some negotiating the usual;... [+]


20,348 signatures have been submitted by the Council in favour of the generalised model of Basque education
The signatures have been presented by the Basque Council in the Gasteiz Parliament. Among the signatories are also the Federation of Ikastolas of the Basque Country, the educational agents EHIGE, HEIZE and Hik Hasi, the unions STEILAS, LAB and ELA, and several parents, workers,... [+]

Education system focused on Euskera

If the Education Act has to ensure sufficient knowledge of the official languages (level B2 at the end of the ESO) and once the current models do not guarantee that knowledge, as has been demonstrated by various research – doctoral theses, educational reports… – it is... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude