Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Courts reject a municipal agent having to know Basque in Erandio

  • Administrative Dispute of Bilbao 1. The Court disregards the preceptivity of the linguistic profile assigned to a post of Municipal Police Agent in Erandio, level B2. The judgment mentions the arguments used against the linguistic profile of the Uliazpi Foundation.

02 May 2023 - 13:30
Last updated: 17:05

Numerous judgments have been delivered in recent months against the language profiling schemes established by the administrations in the calls for employment and recruitment. In the last known case, a Municipal Police officer working at Erandio attempted, by means of an appeal, to dismiss the compulsory level B2 level in the post he had been occupying. The city council failed to approve the request. After going to the Court of Justice, you are now right.

Iñigo Urrutia, professor and lawyer at the UPV/EHU expert on issues related to linguistic profiles, announced Berria that the resolution "is another sign of aggression".

The Judgment mentions the arguments of the judgment of the High Court of Justice of the Basque Country of March against linguistic profiles for the exercise of the Uliazpi Foundation. Urrutia points out that the jurisprudence of the last judgment goes along these lines. He argues that, although it is a "different" case, it is not a public job offer but a "judgment against an amendment" in the RPT.

Urrutia believes that the characteristics of linguistic profiles should be met "objectively". In this case, the sentence says that since the municipal police that covers the post is not Euskaldun, "the city council cannot make an adaptation to it". The lawyer therefore stresses that he has opposed municipal autonomy.

The sentence mentions the age of the municipal police from the age of 45. Urrutia explains that above this age they are not obliged to prove the profile, but considers that "age should not limit the linguistic profile of the position".


You are interested in the channel: Euskaldunen aurkako erasoak
2024-10-30 | Sustatu
Do we have the right to be treated in Euskera?
One of the last offensives of the rulings against the Basque Country has been that which has called into question a Gipuzkoan public entity, Kabia, with a ruling contrary to the established linguistic profiles. The ruling considers that the requirements in Euskera established... [+]

2024-10-28 | Leire Ibar
Regarding the last sentence of the TSJPV, they denounce that "the only language for public employment is Spanish"
ELA, LAB and Kontseilua have concentrated on protesting against the ruling handed down by a Administrative Litigation Court to the body headed by Kabia. They denounce that there is a risk that the effort to guarantee the level of Euskera will become "zero".

Decathlon from San Sebastian says that the labelling also in Euskera is "imposition"
A consumer has made a complaint to the Observatory about the lack of advertising in Basque of the large Decathlon trade in Donostia. The Point of Sale response is significant: Community law does not contain any imposition on the placement of the billboard in Euskera. In other... [+]

A court in Donostia-San Sebastian describes as "disproportionate" the requests of Euskera from some nursing homes of the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa
Gonzalo Pérez Sanz, judge of Donostia-San Sebastián, suspends the job offer approved in 2022 to stabilize 54 places in the nursing homes of the organism Kabia. The judge considers that the linguistic profile imposed by the institution of the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa is... [+]

Another Euskarafoba judgment: Against the cleaning of hostels in Gipuzkoa
The Donostia-San Sebastian Court has issued a judgment on the process of cleaning staff jobs in the shelters of the Provincial Council of Gipuzkoa, which considers the implementation of the linguistic profile for all jobs to be “disproportionate and discriminatory”. CCOO has... [+]

Euskaldunes marginalized by the Basque Country

In some territories of the Basque Country, the Basque Country is official, in others official or denied according to the meridian and, on the contrary, if we go north, tolerated (unofficial).

In recent times, some courts have ruled that public officials do not have to have... [+]


2024-09-26 | ARGIA
Reporters protest again about the use of Basque by the coach of the Real Sociedad
Real Sociedad football team coach Imanol Alguacil had to listen to complaints from several journalists in Basque responding to the media at the press conference prior to the Europa League match. A week ago a similar situation occurred in Valladolid to that experienced in... [+]

2024-09-25 | ARGIA
Aiaraldea Medios de Comunicación calls on the Basque Government to reach an agreement in the conflict with the City of Amurrio
The City of Amurrio unilaterally discounted the subsidy to the only media in Basque in the region, and hundreds of residents and entities asked him to re-establish the subsidy. Aiaraldea This media has tried to meet with the City Hall, but the City Hall has refused to meet, so... [+]

Want to study in Basque at the UPV/EHU and have to do it in Spanish
In the fourth course of Philosophy, at the UPV/EHU, students have to choose a subject in Spanish, as there are not enough subjects in Basque. Spanish students do not have this problem, and it is curious, because there are more students in Basque than in Spanish. Similar cases... [+]

2024-09-19 | ARGIA
The Council and Bagera call for a concentration in Donostia to “manifest disagreement” over violations of language rights
The final judgment is dated 18 September: The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has rejected the call for places of the Municipal Police of Donostia-San Sebastián. The Basque Council of the Basque Country and the Association of the Basque Country Bagera of... [+]

2024-09-17 | ARGIA
In the midst of the judicial "offensive" against the Euskaldunes, annulling once again the request of Euskera
The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country has rejected the call for two positions of agent of the Municipal Police of Donostia-San Sebastián requesting a linguistic profile B2 in Basque. Faced with this new ruling that "violates the rights of Euskaldunes", several agents... [+]

2024-09-11 | ARGIA
The Baiona court condemns Gorka Torre for acts in favour of the Basque Country
The judge denied him the declaration in Basque and decided not to participate in the trial held against him. Faced with dozens of Euskaltzales who have come to the room to show their support, Tor has called for disobedience. In total, he has been sentenced to pay EUR 3,268 for... [+]

2024-09-06 | ARGIA
The Council calls for all Local Police officers to know Basque in response to the TSJPV ruling
In 2021, a unified work bag was created for CAV Local Police Auxiliaries. The High Court of Justice of the Basque Country (TSJPV) has dismissed the required linguistic profile, level B2, in Basque. He has argued that the linguistic profile is "disproportionate" and that the Basque... [+]

2024-07-24 | Adrian Zelaia
Health workers against the Basque Country, health workers against patients

The demands of Basque Country in Osakidetza are abusive. No doubt. We are putting and mobilizing health professionals in this line. Without being against the Basque Country, with little intention to learn and much less to use.

The new reference platform is “United by a Real... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude