Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

They denounce that the characters in the film about Elkano are "plagiarism" of the 'Vía del Dorado'

  • Through Twitter, the main characters of Elkano's film are a copy of the movie El Camino de El dorado set in the conquest of Mexico. The film on Elkano in the Basque Country continues to receive harsh criticism in the Philippines.

08 November 2019 - 08:15
Ezkerrean "El Doradorako Bidea" filmako protagonistak, eta eskuinean "Elkano, lehen mundu bira"-koak.
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

The Road to El dorado is a 2000 film by the prestigious producer Dreamworks. Set in the bloody conquest of Mexican lands today, the work revolves around the history of two “Spanish adventurers” who head to the police on the boat of Hernán Cortés that will conquer and plunder Mexico.

Indigenous leaders who solve 'well' with conquerors from Spain

The film is full of racist clichés and historical-geographical errors. Hernán Cortés hides or shows from a very high point the barbarities provoked in the conquest of Mexico, and although he wants to sell a “peaceful encounter between two worlds”, he tries in a paternalistic way his relationship with the indigenous people. For example, presenting indigenous people, good and bad according to the dichotomy and all as daring to beautify the adventures of white men European protagonists, especially women.

The film about Elkano, released in 2019, is also about another armed expedition related to the Spanish Empire. Repeat the same Eurocentric view of the film on El Dorado. Through Twitter they have also shown how the main characters have been copied.

 

Tulio and Elkano, protagonists of the same mold

Although Mexico and the Philippines are thousands of kilometres away, their inhabitants have been represented in almost the same way. An evil indigenous, with a glimpse of anger and a long nose; a good indigenous who develops with the conquerors, smiling and fat; an indigenous woman who falls in love with her protagonist, with the stereotyped body of the woman of the twenty-first century; and the most curious, they too, Tulio and Elkano, seem clones.

Brave and indolent women for children

Although the changes in the male characters they have copied are very small, the development of the indigenous woman who falls in love with her European white protagonist is very significant.

The Pasaitarra director Ángel Alonso has brought the stereotyped body of women to impossible proportions. In addition to the usual “minimalist” clothing, the large ankles of the lips and the almost anorexic thinness, the neck is now as long as the face and the waist and the width of the back have been physically impossible by the producers Debulitoon and Barton Films.

Indigenous women who fall in love with white men protagonists have not changed anything in 20 years, even if the cartoonists are from Dreamworks or the Basque Country.

Considering these premises, it is more serious that the two films are created and designed for the children's audience.

 

 

 

 


You are interested in the channel: Elkanoren mundu bira
In Vitoria the "Basque Country Decolonial" will be proclaimed on the anniversary of the Elcano world tour
Wednesday will be mobilized for the second consecutive year to denounce the "historical dominion of the global and white north".

No Limits or how to repeat conventional narratives about the first world tour
On 6 September, the 5th Centenary of the arrival of the ship Victoria to Sanlucar de Barrameda was celebrated, with the memory that three years after its departure, five centuries before, the first world round was formed. As is usual in this type of commemoration, in these years... [+]

2022-09-06 | ARGIA
"We want to work for a decolonial Basque Country"
On 6 September it was declared a holiday by the Basque Government in the Basque Autonomous Community to celebrate the tour that Juan Sebastián Elcano has given to the world. The Vitorian popular initiative has focused on Plaza General Loma. He pointed out that "with this... [+]

2022-09-05 | Axier Lopez
Landings in Getaria and the Philippines to pay tribute to
On Tuesday, the popular theatre El desembarco de Elcano will be represented in Getaria. Coinciding with the festivity established by the Basque Government and with the 500th anniversary of the arrival of Elcano to Sanlúcar de Barrameda, in Cádiz. However, this is not the only... [+]

2022-09-05 | Sonia González
Elcano and us (and who are we?)

Two friends offered a small rap performance in the plaza and musutruk, after a simple popular meal. With a song, we were reminded that a neighbor, a young man, recently passed away. Money had to be raised to return the body to its hometown. Oh, that mother of mine! Your child's... [+]


2022-08-29 | ARGIA
'Our heroes. First presentation of the book 'A Story of Elkano and the Colonialists of the Basque Country' on Thursday in Getaria
Axier López, a journalist of ARGIA, has analyzed in his book Ot. heroiak, the presence of characters related to colonialism and slavery in the streets of Euskal Herria, moving the international debate on these symbols around the importance of Euskal Herria. The book is... [+]

2022-07-23 | Nekane Txapartegi
Who we are and what we want to be ...

Unconscious day-to-day exercise has become a topic during your stay in the Basque Country. I haven't been there for many days and I've been squeezing my breath several times... I'm an observer trying to find and rediscover my people. If I didn’t want to see things before or if... [+]


The Government grants a direct grant of EUR 15,000 to the Elkano Foundation for the organisation of a congress
The Basque Government, at its Government meeting on 5 July, agreed to grant the Elkano Foundation a grant of EUR 15,000 through the Department of Culture and Linguistic Policy.

2022-07-14 | Peru Iparragirre
Axier Lopez
"Speeches to our navel have prevailed here when the debate on decolonality is boiling"
Our hero has written the book López on the occasion of the fifth centenary of the Elkano World Tour and will be published by ARGIA in September. He has analyzed the presence of characters related to colonialism and slavery in the streets of Euskal Herria, considering the need... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude