Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"The vegetarian diet benefits humans and other animals, also the planet."

  • Journalist Edurne Elizondo and member of anti-specialist group Nor talked to nutritionist Lucia Martínez about some of the keys surrounding vegetarian diets in recent years.
Artikulu hau egilearen baimenari esker ekarri dugu.

18 January 2019 - 09:40

“Being vegan doesn’t mean being stupid.” That's the key to stories from news stories that are trying to question animal-free diets in the environment. This is what the dietitian and nutritionist Lucía Martínez has highlighted in her speech at the head of the study. He runs the blog dimequecomes.com and is also the author of several books and articles (Vegetarians with Science and Vegetarian Shaped, among others). We interviewed him and, to begin with, he said that veganism makes it better than anything else to be a healthy entrepreneur. Ask them not to forget to take vitamin B12.

"No problem being vegetarian?"

There is no problem. We can be vegetarian, and that's not an opinion. Eleven organizations have positioned themselves in favour of vegetarian diets. These diets are supported by research carried out by dozens of organizations. It is important to make it clear that they should take vitamin B12 who are vegetarians or eat eggs and dairy products. People with special needs or a particular disease should be advised otherwise, but in general, vitamin B12 intake is sufficient.

- Are vegetarian diets healthy?

They can be. They can be healthy or harmful to our health. If we take no more than potatoes and Coca Cola, our diet will be bad. But that's what happens in any diet. Also in traditional diets. That's why we have the second type of diabetes and cardiovascular diseases that we have today, among others. We must make it clear that the vegetarian or vegan label does not have to say that it is a healthy thing; our diet will be healthy depending on the planning we make and the choices we make.

- Are the diets to be enhanced vegetarian?

I am clear that it will always be better to wager on a way of feeding that does not hurt anyone, neither you nor anyone. The vegetarian diet benefits humans and other animals, favors the planet and helps to take steps towards a more ethical world and greater social justice. I think no one can say that it is not good to get all of that.

-A vegetarian or a vegan is not necessarily good, not bad, right? But it's that idea that many propagate.

Yes, we have those two extremes. On the one hand, vegans who propagate the idea of an immortal vegan; and on the other, those who hate vegans, who propagate the idea of a vegan who must move without force and traces. The problem arises when these kinds of ideas are driven by a health professional. The professional who joins this idea of a weak and sick vegan demonstrates, on the one hand, that its formation is null and that the one who says does not share, much less, what we know today. If such a professional is found, it would be best to look for another.

Lucía Martínez

"What do we know today about what we didn't know?"

We must bear in mind that we are talking about people who live in the so-called first world and have access to food. Today we know that vegetarians have no more anemia than those who are not; we know that they don't lack more protein. However, we know that among vegetarians there is more vitamin B12, so we advise taking it. Until recently, it was thought that vegetarians who drank eggs and dairy products did not need this vitamin, but studies conducted since 2013 have shown that yes, and that they should also take vitamin B12.

- Do humans who eat animals take vitamin B12 that has been given to these other animals?

In most cases, yes. The feed that is eaten by animals cultivated by industry contains vitamin B12. In the case of birds, add the same vitamin B12 to feed. Cobalt is given to cows. It's about these animals creating their own B12 in their digestive system, but to do so they need a substrate like cobalt. The fish caught outside the nurseries are the ones that have vitamin B12 on their own. In the farms, they eat feed and add vitamin B12 to the feed.

-You have claimed the critical consumer. Is this difficult to achieve?

It's hard to be a critical consumer, because the industry has a lot of money and power. And he uses that money and power to sell his product and the benefits of his product. The industry pays the research it wants to disseminate messages in favour of its products. One study recently revealed that a child receives 25 food related ads per day via different routes. Fighting that is difficult, because we do not have the means. I can't put an ad on TV, but Nestle House does. They do very good marketing campaigns, because they hire the best for it. They have money to do it. That is why it is very difficult to get critical consumers who are able to draw their own conclusions.

- The nutritionist doesn't have a chance to collaborate on it?

Here nutritionists are not integrated into the health system, but in other European countries. There is no nutritionist in primary care and little in hospitals. So the citizen who wants to go to the nutritionist has to pay for it. Studies have also come a short way; they have been created less than 20 years ago. In South America, for example, the figure of the nutritionist has come a much longer path and has the respect of other health professionals. This is not the case here. There the training is better and they work much more in hospitals. They're integrated into the health system.

- Without the advice of professionals, is it easier to spread myths about vegetarian diets?

In the case of children, it is where the discussion is most aroused. If children are vegetarians, parents say they impose their diet. Do the rest make a referendum to decide what to give to children? It's clear that a child is imposed by his or her parents, because he or she doesn't have the ability to decide for himself or herself. Are there vegan parents who feed their children badly? Yes, there are. And there are also fathers and mothers who are not vegan and who feed their sons and daughters badly, in favor of the traditional diet. The point is that in this second case no one has raised any discussion.

- Why do the news about vegans seek to question the movement?

The treatment of this news is not appropriate. And we have to make it clear that in these cases the child doesn't get sick because he's vegan, but because his parents are stupid. But this also happens in the case of parents who have a traditional diet. These don't come out in the media; if they came out, we'd be talking about them all day. It is common for parents who have a traditional diet and feed their children badly. That's why it's not news.

- What would you say to clear up the doubts?

I think the only thing that is needed to clear up doubts is that you want to listen without prejudice. If we refer to health professionals, it is enough for the person to want to be trained to avoid doubts. In the case of citizenship, I believe that the main problem is the prejudice that burdens our decisions. There's information, and it's clear, it's about wanting to listen. No prejudice.

Do you think things have started to change?

I think so. There is still a lot of bad news about veganism, but now the issue is in the mainstream media and, in many cases, treated in the right way. I believe that it is also important to change things in the health system, among health professionals, and I believe that we are also taking steps in this area. The training of these professionals is essential to adequately attend to vegetarians.

This interview was posted by anti-specist group Nor and we brought it with the Creative Commons license.


You are interested in the channel: Elikadura
2025-02-18 | Mikel Aramendi
THE ANALYSIS
When Economic Fluctuations Come to the Banquet: The Rice Crisis
If U.S. tariffs weren’t heady enough, a rather naive piece of news from last week has sent waves of tremors to the food tables of a large part of the world: The Japanese government has ordered the marketing of 210 thousand tons of strategic rice stocks to counter the... [+]

2025-02-17 | Garazi Zabaleta
Location of Xüxenka
Collective point of sale managed by small farmers nearby in Maule
The Maule Euskalduna Guesthouse has been working for years with the products of the small producers of houses in Zubero, and when they bought a building in front of the hostel in the capital, he proposed to the same growers: why not open the point of sale of nearby producers in... [+]

2025-02-10 | Garazi Zabaleta
Location of Herrizoma
The Vitoria-Gasteiz food network transformation tool
In the post-pandemic context, a group in Vitoria-Gasteiz began to move to work on food, which is supposed to be a fundamental right. “Other issues were already being dealt with in the field of militancy, such as housing, but with food as a focus there were no such groups, we... [+]

2025-02-03 | Garazi Zabaleta
The Bio-K
Chukruta and kimchi of the Basque Country
Satxa Zeberio, promoter of the Bio-K project, moved to Errezil and planted apple trees several years ago. “It was time to do something with apples, and then we started producing apple juice and cider,” he explains. In 2015, the Bio-K project was officially created and, in... [+]

2025-01-29 | Kelo Arribas
Food sovereignty and resistance to genocide
The struggle of the peasants in Palestine
Today, there is a ceasefire in Gaza, and we do not know how long it will last, while massacres, annexations, colonization and all kinds of human rights violations continue in the rest of the occupied territories. The following are not isolated cases, but a few isolated examples... [+]

Watering in winter
In February, when we are in the middle of winter, the priority is to have a well-watered body. Just like the walnut is doing: it uses the roots as a reservoir in winter, it needs short and thick roots to collect water and nutrients from the soil.

2025-01-08 | Garazi Zabaleta
Aina Socies Fiol
"In each island of the Balearic Islands there are many varieties of plants that do not exist in the others"
Many of them will join the Balearic Islands only with Oporleku, but on the island of Mallorca they have a living movement around agroecology and consumption: The Associació de Varietats Locals de Mallorca (association of local seed varieties) is an example of this. In early... [+]

January, the dream of the walnut
I painted with purple color the first month of the year, with the color of creativity, imagination, knowledge and spirituality.

2024-12-26 | Estitxu Eizagirre
Representatives of Vía Campesina have witnessed the violence suffered by the Palestinian peasants
A delegation from Via Campesina visited Palestine from 8 to 18 December, invited by the Union of Palestinian Working Committees (UAWC), of which it is a member. On this journey, they wanted to show their solidarity with the Palestinian people "amid the genocide taking place in... [+]

At Christmas, consume local and seasonal and, by the way, boycott Israeli products
Hunger is one of the main weapons used by Israel for the genocide of the Palestinians. On the one hand, the ban on food entering Gaza and, on the other, the abolition of Palestinian food sovereignty.

2024-12-23 | Garazi Zabaleta
Ekin Dulantzi
Agri-food test area in Dulantzi
We have more and more agricultural test points, that is to say, training spaces in agriculture and livestock before we start your project. The Zunbeltz space of Navarre and the Trebatu de Gipuzkoa and Ipar Euskal Herria are some of the examples that have been launched. Since... [+]

2024-12-11 | Eli Pagola
First high seas nursery in the Basque Country
Fishing for the future in a cage
The first fish farm in the Basque Country has just emerged at sea in Getaria (Gipuzkoa). Two cages of 50 meters in diameter and 40 in depth have been installed, and if they adapt well to sea conditions, this summer is expected to grow 50 bluefin tuna, also known as bluefin tuna,... [+]

2024-12-09 | Garazi Zabaleta
Bread of Errasti
Bread created with the knowledge of the above and macrobiotics
The Errastiko Ogia project, powered by Xabi Abasolo Etxabe and Naiara Uriarte Remedios, is located in the Beroña district of Arrasate. Everyone came to the bakery world on their own, but in the ecological model and in the production of mother dough they have very well combined... [+]

Tunagate: Do you want some mercury with the salad?
The population is excited by the amount of mercury found in tuna cans. According to a study carried out in Europe by Bloom, Carrefour, Intermarché, Mercadona, Aldi... all supermarkets market contaminated tuna. Industrial fishing has quickly underestimated these data. And that... [+]

Dismissing the fall to embrace the winter
December has the brown color of the leaves: from the leaves that have remained on the ground, under the naked walnut. The walnut is over its cycle. It will rest: strengthening the stems, feeding itself, aims to nourish. Looking inwards, it's time to form the bowels, after the... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude