I was left with the advice of a Basque official: in case of infection with the virus, please let him stay sick in his room and, if possible, in the room with his own bathroom. The home settings of the most comfortable and superior layers of the middle class are not bad. What would the Nicaraguan waitress who looks after her elders and shares a room with three other women?
Without school, on the other hand, Basque families are not equal in technological equipment and cultural support for the home. It has to be seriously analyzed, because online education goes on for a long time and it can increase educational inequalities among children who were already large. It is an old issue in the sociology of education: by blurring school and its equivalent effect, the child will be more visibly modeled with the educational, cultural and economic capital of the family, increasing the impact of handicaps and inequalities of origin. In addition, children easily suck the anguish and fear of the family, and it is evident that these feelings accumulate in the face of what comes in precarious bodies and families.
In other words, the virus is class based, such as gender (and the nation, Spain more centralized). Tragedies are never built in an abstract and symmetrical way in the social space, misfortune never triggers the same consequences on the ground floor and in the attic of society.
But we've also discovered new lessons. Governments can, if they wish, encourage strong public intervention by socialising the resources that are in private hands. They have also been prepared to nationalise strategic companies. Well, we've learned that the will was the key, and who says we can't go any further, putting finances, food, the pharmaceutical industry or energy for the benefit of the social majority. The postliberal sense, and perhaps the anti-capitalist sense, has gained momentum: there is no natural law to enclose these spaces in the neoliberal logic of private benefit. Even more so in the state of emergency, but not just in the state of emergency. However, Naomi Klein showed us that shock situations can be used to rule out challenging temptations and strengthen the elite project (post-liberal gymnastics also at the beginning of the 2008 crisis).
The coronavirus clarifies the other big problem: you can stop injecting so much carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, but you have to reduce production and transport. Today's ecology and economy are incomplete.
But I am convinced that there is another lesson in the lessons. It will be clarified which animal is behind the coronavirus, if any, by the destruction of ecological habitats by the human being, or what specific aspect of its development is the last cause. But, in the meantime, I'm convinced that this experience that we're experiencing can be taken as a sample, to prove in flesh and bone what collapse, deglobalization or disordered contraction, fear in the streets and the army is. What is more, assuming that the economic and financial world that was about to explode by the virus is going to burst, and that the effects of deglobalisation and contraction are going to take root.
In 1940, Walter Benjamin prophetically advanced, from Marxism, that perhaps the revolution was not to climb the train of progress, development and modernization, as Marx had suggested, but to pull the emergency brake of that train. The machine operator is an automattic. The train runs, cannot stop or change direction. Absorbed by speed, it has no other destination than to leave the rails. It seems that it's being the coronavirus, not the anti-productivist Marxism, the hand brake of capitalism. Therefore, the contraction is not voluntary, it is not planned, it is not a reasonable self-limitation. It has not been organised fairly, so it has not given the citizens the least security.
The situation is truly complicated: the stagnation of capitalism will disperse suffering in tons, but its healthy activity, guided by the logic of constant exponential growth, unites us to an ecocist and suicidal path that generates even more suffering. In an economic territory burned after the virus, the recovery of the system cannot be an option. The emancipating project requires the contraction of human systems, but orderly (guaranteeing the material growth of various human groups, economic sectors and countries). Democratic and peaceful contraction for human systems to fit into a limited biosphere. And that these systems are articulated around justice in all its meanings: social justice, gender justice, international justice, with the unborn and other living beings.
At the moment, ecosocialism is not, but we have a detonating pathogen of the system, with the capacity to provoke a huge economic and social disaster, and with dark consequences from the point of view of class, gender and nation. It is understandable that Ada Colau’s claim, the pain of the hardest hit to stimulate growth and soften its friction by demanding public intervention. But it's disappointing to see that on the left there's that (auto)destructive script left. The dry script, as well as destructive, will become a permanent and deeper contraction, inevitably, with energy growth and material scarcity. We will be in a permanent emergency situation, will we use this small chapter of collapse as a warning?
This historical era has long been calling for a new cognitive framework: the normality of growth is over, and it is about whether the new normality will bring an emancipating alternative or even more savage capitalism. The challenge is to turn the intuition of the great Benjamin into a binding imaginary for this century, a successful strategy and a feasible program. Let's be the containment for strategic reflection. In addition to stopping, to start the change of direction.
Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora
ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.
At Christmas they leave a new book on the bedside table. About the philosophy and joy of the house, recently written by Emanuele Coccia. Coccia, an Italian philosopher, has become popular in making known our connections with plants on the road to the construction of a healthy... [+]
I've done a quick analysis of the technology forecasts for 2025. Like every year, when you talk about what technology is going to bring to the media in 2025, the discourse is very similar. Many of us who write about technology have the anxiety of knowing more than it's going to... [+]
When we woke up, culturally and administratively, the landscape showed a three-speed disaster.
As far as culture is concerned, I had the opportunity – once again – to confirm this last November 14 at the Mint library in Ortzaize. There we met because Eñaut Etxamendi... [+]
Snow hides the earth and the traces of beings looking for pleasure. Under the beauty of snow there is time, years, generations, ephemerides, quotations; but when time goes by there are words that have not been said before or after. Snow reminds us that we could slip and fall. As... [+]
The world has also done so, because it is a symbol, because in history more genocides have already been done and will be done (bad luck, hear, it has touched you to be born there), but Palestine has special characteristics:
They appeared, as usual, through the hut, parked in the center of the passage, in herbs and encharcations so as not to dirty the mills, and went through the road, tracing, to the porch, with a large dish in the hand. As usual, the bûche was ready. In French bûche it can be a... [+]
As the fall ends, the crows appear on Basque Day, in the Basque era or in the Durango Fair. Aware of the results of socio-linguistic surveys on the use of Euskera, the "politically corrective" exercise has no longer drawn anyone's attention. Without Ttattarri, with cool and smiling... [+]
There are those who, being a brilliant brain, with definitions of "little detail," are experts in transforming and transforming the same thing, in other words. It was yours and it has been a project in eternum that has been repeated for decades. This was one of the main reasons to... [+]
On 26 December, during an air strike, the Israeli Army killed five Palestinian journalists trying to reach the city. They killed 130 Palestinian journalists. This news has reminded me of a couple of things, the first, the persecution of true journalists in any part of the world,... [+]
In recent months I have had to work in a number of institutes and, at some point, I have had to talk to the students about the possibilities offered by the labour market. The typology of the students is varied and in the same city varies a lot from one neighborhood to another,... [+]
The girl who appears in the center of photography, which can hardly be considered historical, is writing a list of adjectives: I, you, he, we, you, they. Looking down, I couldn't see what his gaze looked like.
Insensitive to the work of the photographer, you, slowly and... [+]
When you work with older people or people with physical and neural diversity, you realize that the idea of competition in our society limits us a lot as a species. That is, our system puts you in value by doing things specifically, and what it doesn't do is incapable of the... [+]
I wanted to write for the Christmas lights and claim to become an annual tradition in this time of street lighting, a welcoming, joyful and joyful public space from the point of view of the class. But, of course, also warm public spaces where some young people can be warming up... [+]