Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Urkullu’s proposal is coldly picked up in Spain without closing doors

  • Lehendakari Urkullu proposes a constitutional convention to deepen the debate on self-government in the Spanish state and to make a genuine recognition of the plurinational state.

01 September 2023 - 09:00
Last updated: 2023-09-02 11:52
Ibarretxe eta Santzez gobernu buruak bilera batean.

The proposal, which he presented this Thursday in the letter published in El País, basically consists of a constitutional convention on territoriality to take further steps in self-government, interpreting the Spanish Constitution more broadly, without the need to reform it. The objective would be to recognize the plurinational character of the Spanish State and to achieve a new pact that would make bilaterality a reality.

The Lehendakari considers that it is time to overcome the provisions of the Spanish Constitution in 1978. It recognizes that it was then that an effort was made to recognize the national characteristics of the State, but through LOAPA and other centralizing laws it says that the plurinational state was finally abandoned and a process of recentralization was imposed, which resulted in the extension of the formula of “coffee for all”, with the path opened to the Historical Territories until the formation of the State of the autonomies.

Urkullu says in his opinion article that until the 18th century the Spanish State was plurinational and that this situation should be recovered. As he has done on other occasions, he has set as an example of bilaterality the economic concert that comes from then and considers that this model should be extended to the political sphere.

It proposes two steps to achieve this new pact with the State. First, to establish a pre-agreement on self-government in which the basic principles for the new coexistence are determined, such as compliance with the provisions of the statutes, recognition of plurinationality, bilaterality, the system of guarantees or the capacity to decide. Secondly, within one year the Constitutional Convention itself would be convened, a space to discuss the previously established and propose a new pact. However, nothing is specified in the composition of this area.

Ready to listen, no more

It is post-election time in Spain and the PP and the PSOE try to form a government. But not only will they, not even with their closest allies, but the Basque and Catalan nationalists will be key to government decisions.

In this context, the Urkullu proposal has arrived, which nobody has closed the doors violently, but which has been coldly collected. From the Government of Spain, the PSOE and the PP have spoken several voices on the subject, showing different positions. The government has taken the proposal well: it is fine to speak, we are prepared to do so; the proposal is respectful, but that is not our way. More or less. The PSOE spokesman has been more demanding: yes, one could speak, but the border is the Spanish Constitution, which today perfectly defines what the territorial model of the state is.

Similar positions have also existed from the PP lines: they respectfully reflect the proposal, but the current Spanish Constitution is the only reference and limitation. And from some autonomies governed by them, like the presidents of the governments of Andalusia and Galicia, have also spoken in this sense: it is good to speak, but if we speak, it will be “café para todos”, that is, to equate the competences of the other autonomies with those of the historical autonomies, and in no case for the latter to have more rights. They have not used those words, but behind their message is that.

The Catalan Government has also shown a very clear attitude: they welcome the proposal with respect, but its foundations are self-determination and amnesty, and will continue to work on these paths. In this regard, it has been stressed from different points, such as the Gara newspaper, that the lehendakari Urkullu now uses the “power of decision” and not the “right to decide”.

As Urkullu explains in the letter, from Euskal Herria nothing can be imposed on the State, but not on the State or on the nations, and therefore, among the principles one should take into account the “decision-making capacity” agreed by pact. It doesn't delve into it, but between two subjects you would decide what you want. Besides being a curious way of deciding, it has not gone unnoticed that he leaves the “faculty”, namely: “questioned decision-making capacity”.


You are interested in the channel: Politika
Citizens of the Uribe Coast claim the need for a public day center
It is the only region in Bizkaia that does not have a public day centre. The meeting will take place on April 27 at 12:00 in the Town Hall Square in Sopelana (Bizkaia).

The Spanish government withdraws its purchase of Israeli bullets
The President of the Spanish Government, Pedro Sánchez, has ordered the cancellation of the bullet purchase made by the Spanish Ministry of the Interior with the Israeli company IMI Systems. The decision eases the risk of rupture in the government coalition between the PSOE and... [+]

The Spanish government has spent 1,041 million euros on arms purchases from Israel in the last year and a half
Since October 2023, the Spanish State has signed 40 arms purchase contracts with Israel and its companies, half of them in the last half year. A contract between the PSOE and Sumar, which are part of the Spanish Government, has caused controversy, especially within the latter,... [+]

2025-04-24 | Gedar
Protection against male violence: In the Southern Basque Country, 31% of reported cases did not include measures
At the national level, both the protection measures implemented and the applications submitted have decreased.

2025-04-23 | Jon Torner Zabala
Another policeman infiltrated by the environmental movement in Madrid is detected
The revelators La Directa and El Salto have reported twelve policemen who have infiltrated different collectives of the Spanish state since 2002. The most recent case that has been made public is the case of the Spanish police who used the false name of Nieves López. El Salto... [+]

The Spanish government has taken another step in militarization: Allocate 10,471 million euros more to Defensa
The expenditure that the Spanish Government will allocate to Defensa by the end of the year will represent 2% of the Gross Domestic Product: EUR 33,123 million. Sánchez points out that this decision is aimed at "guaranteeing the security of Spain" and "modernizing" the army's... [+]

The Provincial Council of Bizkaia opposes the Argalario wind farm for the "critical" damage it would cause to the environment
The Natural Heritage Service has submitted a report against the Iparaixe II project, which aims to install five windmills on this mountain in Barakaldo. The Barakaldo City Council rejected the project a year and a half ago thanks to the pressure of the No–Barakaldo Wind Farm... [+]

Ernai expresses his intention to undertake "a new national impulse" at the Youth Meeting held in Berriozar
Ernai said he had gathered more than 3,000 people at the meeting between Thursday and Sunday. The main political event of the conference took place on Saturday evening, with the intervention of the spokesman of the youth organization, Amaiur Egurrola. The meeting point ended in... [+]

The Basque Country as a nation is proclaimed by many actors on Patriotic Day
A number of political parties and actors have raised their voices on this year’s Patriot Day. As in recent years, the streets of Bilbao and Pamplona have been occupied by EAJ and EH Bila, respectively. Bagira, the Patriotic Movement of the Northern Basque Country, calls for... [+]

2025-04-16 | Euskal Irratiak
Mikel Epaltza
“Nire etxea utzi nuen ETAk nazioarteko begiraleen esku armak utz zitzan”

Atxik Berrituz giristino taldeak Kristauak Euskal Herriko bake prozesuan liburua argitaratu du Maiatz argitaletxearekin. Giristinoek euskal bake prozesuan zer nolako engaiamendua ukan duten irakur daiteke, lekukotasunen bidez.


The Government wants to increase the police force and 8,000 police officers by 2030
Bigen Zupiria opens the second negotiating table with the Basque Government after agreeing in March with ERNE, ESAN and SIPE to increase the annual salary to the Basque Country by at least 4,200 euros. In this plan to increase the number of agents, the Security Minister said... [+]

Agurain City Council rejects project to install 50,000 photovoltaic panels
The motion tabled by the Chairman was adopted in plenary. To the company that promotes the project, the City Council has asked Cañaveras Solar to ensure that the project does not take up agricultural land classified as of high strategic value and that it establishes a distance... [+]

2025-04-16 | Sustatu
It's been two months and we're the same: IP blocks when there is football against dozens of Basque websites
A few days ago, Puntueu announced that it would monitor the damage caused to the Basque domains by the blockade of La Liga. There have been matches this weekend, in fact, and the monitoring data is there, it's disastrous.

2025-04-16 | Karmelo Landa
The Patriotic Opportunity

It’s not Christmas Day, it’s Christmas Day that we Basques need. Once a year there are repeated calls from potential patriotic parties and groups, on these dates, the homeland of the Basque Country is the Basque Country/Euskal Herria around the proclamation. It's a matter of a... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude