Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Censorship on Facebook: 15,000 precarious workers in their secret profession

  • Under the title "Fascism and Machista Persecution are Accepted Here", media journalists Eldiario.es Juan Luis Sánchez and David Sarabia have made a report on censorship on Facebook. For the giant multinational, there is talk of 15,000 workers from all over the world, who are forbidden to tell who they are working for. They are subcontracted through other companies. Because of the hardness of the content they have to review and because of the system of mutual denunciation among workers, many have reported that they suffer post-traumatic stress.

The callers have denounced the ideological censorship and the precarious situation of workers in the Basque Country. This report is a rough portrait of the situation of those behind the screen. “We have instructions to erase Hitler’s content, but for example Franco’s, no,” two workers say that they want to remain anonymous. Facebook has already published its censorship offices in Lisbon (Portugal), Barcelona (Catalan Countries) or Warsaw (Poland). Another Wired report shows working conditions at a headquarters in the city of Manila (Philippines).

They charge 700 euros a month and are subcontracted through international companies such as Accenture. They are strictly forbidden to say that they work for Facebook and always refer to it as a “client” in writing.

Each of these "moderators" is shown on the screen the content that Facebook users have marked as incorrect. 30 seconds to decide: To delete “Delete” content or to post “Ignore”. A total of 500 cases should be treated daily. How do you decide what to remove? The criteria are the strictest on the part of Facebook.

Insults to women, go ahead

30% of emails have to break Facebook's rules to remove an account from someone, they've explained. However, they have recognized that it is dedicated to profiling rather than to the elimination of specific publications. “Let’s be realistic: if we removed the profiles of all the people who are engaged in making kids, who are going up porn, or who are selling marijuana, to name a few, we would have to erase a lot of profiles. And Facebook doesn’t want to run out of user.” They have reported that bullying messages are rare, so they do not reach their hands and, therefore, messages are posted against women.

The two employees of the company have denounced that on Facebook there is a "brutal" machist violence. “Many men, many young boys, are constantly insulting women through Facebook. Some do so many times that they even take into account the tricks for overcoming censorship. On many Facebook pages there is tremendous male persecution, women are told of everything, and nobody does anything.”

They say the same thing about fascism. “If a person makes comments to extol Hitler, they are erased. If a Spaniard extols Franco, it is published,” they say. “Fascism is accepted on Facebook. You can make a page full of Mussoliniz and Franco, and nothing happens, it's allowed." The Francisco Franco Foundation, for example, has its public page in this social network.

Capture of the page of the Francisco Franco Foundation.

According to the testimonies of these two workers, a criticism of Zionism or of Israeli policies in Palestine can be identified as anti-Semitism, albeit without nuances. "An Israeli soldier who is hitting a child cannot be called a murderer. This comment has to be removed.”

Another pearl of the report: “We have seen children from Arab countries saying in videos uploaded to Facebook that they are going to commit suicide, no matter how; when a child from the United States or from Europe does the same, the authorities are called,” they say.

He has also referred to their censorship of nominees as a “terrorist group”. The regulations prohibit paying tribute to them, but there are countries that have several organizations designated as terrorists and for other countries those organizations are not terrorists. They say the only list that matters is that of the United States. There has also been talk of surreal situations, such as the picture of people who do not know who they are, especially of men with Middle Eastern beards. They've also been looking on the net or measuring the size of the beard to decide whether or not to erase.

The decisions that each worker must make in 30 seconds are known to the managers who are above them in the organizational chart and in 98% of the decisions must agree to assess that the work is well done and that something is appreciated in the precarious remuneration. The two interviewees say that most of the workers are young people of very little time.

The unfortunate situation of workers

“We have seen the children dead, the soldiers who have beaten civilians to death, with the brains spread on the ground,” they say in explaining their work. They say that the work is very hard and that many times they can't sleep because of the images they've seen. They say that post-traumatic stress is widespread among workers and that at the workplace they have a psychologist, although it is not mandatory to collect it with the latter.

Workers get bonuses if they watch the videos to the end. “If you’re not strong enough to watch the video to the end and you’ve made the decision before, your quality will influence,” which means less premium on the end of the month salary. “If someone sets fire on a video, we mark it for children under 18. But if in the video the person is burned to death, it has to be removed. So, someone has to see to the end.”

If a worker pulls a cell phone or bottle of water out of his pocket, the superiors will punish him. The eight-hour workday consists of a 30-minute rest, which is responsible for distributing the breaks, the time of the meal or the time needed to extend the legs. The company awards that workers are denounced and those who do have “good disposition” awards.

Rich entrepreneurs, workers in misery

Marc Zuckemberg, founder of Facebook, is one of the richest people in the world. Last year, Facebook earned 15.230 million dollars, 30 percent more than the previous year.


Most read
Using Matomo
#1
Gorka Peñagarikano Goikoetxea  |  Dani Blanco
#2
Gorka Bereziartua
#3
Gorka Peñagarikano Goikoetxea
#5
Gasteizkoak talde antimilitarista
Azoka
You are interested in the channel: Sare sozialak
From making violence visible, to taking responsibility and organizing avenues for reparation
In the last two decades the issue of macho violence has been brought to the forefront by the struggle of the feminist movement, among other things, and what was described as intimate partner violence or a “family problem” has jumped into the public sphere and onto the... [+]

Teknologia
Techbro go home

Aspaldi pertsona oso zatar bat ezagutu nuen, urrun izatea komeni den pertsona horietako bat. Bere genero bereko pertsonengana zuzentzeko, gizonezkoengana, “bro” hitza erabili ohi zuen. Edozein zapaltzeko prest zegoen, bere helburuak lortzeko. Garai hartatik hitz... [+]


Teknologia
Komentokrazia

Sare sozialetan badira zenbait pertsona eragin gaitasun handikoak. Jarraitzaile ugari dute, eta euren iritziak egiatzat hartzen dira. Askok, ordea, egia barik, interes propioa edo klase baten interesak iraunkortzea bilatzen dute. Ameriketan komentokrata deitzen zaie. Alegia,... [+]


2025-03-05 | June Fernández
Meloi saltzailea
toXic

Ortutik itzuli berritan erabaki nuen Twitterretik alde egitea, oraindik Twitter zenean. Auzolan batera joan nintzen, brokoliak eta azaloreak landatzera, eta mindfulness efektua zapuztu zidan algoritmoak, idazle feminista transgorrotatzaile baten txioak jaurtitzearekin... [+]


TikTok, X eta Instagrameko algoritmoek eskuin muturreko edukiak nabarmen hedatzen dituztela frogatu dute

Ikerketa bat egin dute Alemanian, hauteskundeen atarian: kontuak sortu dituzte TikToken, X-n eta Instagramen, eta aztertu egin dute algoritmoak zer nolako edukiak erakusten dituen. Guztietan, algoritmoak eskuinera eta eskuin muturrera jotzen du gehien, TikToken nabarmen.


Zer erosi?

Azken boladan gero eta gehiago entzuten dugu gazte askok etxebizitza erosteko ahalmenik ez dugula. Batzuetan, badirudi ez dagoela beste gairik; egia da gai serioa dela. Niri neuri ere, 31 gertu izan arren, oraindik pixka bat falta zait neurea izango den etxebizitza lortzeko... [+]


2025-02-11 | Sustatu
If the Met has hacked into Libgen, why not?
The Met (the owner of Facebook) has reportedly hacked Libgen’s network library using BitTorrent protocols. They got at least 81.7 terabytes in this way to power their artificial intelligence systems. In order to get the essay and science in the main international halves for... [+]

2025-02-03 | Axier Lopez
Why does Facebook leave Twitter and Facebook?
Algorithms that promote hatred, applications designed to generate addiction, platforms that see advertising recipients instead of people, social networks that treat us like merchandise... It seems that lately the population only receives toxicity from the main social networks,... [+]

Things to do in Martintxo Etxauri: “In the face of toxic networks we have the alternative Mastodon”
Mastodon is a social network and microblogging service. It was founded by the German Eugen Rochko in 2016. It is based on free software. Lately, free individuals and organizations have decided to enter into it. It is made up of independent structures that communicate with each... [+]

2025-01-24 | Sustatu
News from TeknoTrump: According to the oligarchs, the Stargate AA initiative, and the TikTok extension
Donald Trump’s mandate has begun to impose reactionary policies against anything that could be woke or DEI, and also by announcing technological measures. From the first moment, when he took the oath of office, the presence of the heads of the tech giants on the front line was... [+]

'Goazen lagunok': collective transition between toxic and ugly social networks
Under the motto goazen lagunok, taking advantage of the day when Trump will take over the presidency of the United States. Numerous agents are campaigning to leave "toxic" social networks owned by multinationals and drive the collective transition to farce. “We believe in a more... [+]

Technology
Wow...

In 2018, I leveraged social media and most communications from devices to try to control where I focus on life. Every day I go on that task, in the light of the moth, because my curiosity is constantly looking for fresh information to help me understand reality. At that time I... [+]


2025-01-15 | Sustatu
20 January: Day to leave Twitter (and toxic networks)
Internationally, more than one initiative has pointed out that next Monday, 20 January 2025, will be a day to leave Twitter. Donald Trump will be officially the day of the U.S. presidency, and from his hand, the owner of X/Twitter, Elon Musk, will come to the White House to... [+]

2025-01-14 | Leire Ibar
You can freely say that Instagram and Facebook women are “objects”, LGTBIQ people are “mentally ill” and “wrongful” migrants.
Meta leader Mark Zuckerberg has decided to withdraw censorship of issues such as immigration, gender and sexual orientation in the name of freedom of expression and return to roots. The president has assured that he will work together with Trump and that it will be "an... [+]

Instagram account 'Euskal Herria Complaints' collects nearly 500 testimonies of sexual assaults since November
In November 2024, a group of anonymous women launched the Instagram account to collect testimonies about male violence. In the Spanish state they have based themselves on the #Cuentalo project launched by journalist Cristina Fallaras. Women, through anonymous testimonies, have... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude