To what extent should they be small farmers?
Much of the current left-wing movement, albeit intuitively, claims small-scale agriculture, without any doubt. However, this claim for smallness has its contradictions: a small farm, by definition, will not be able to produce a lot of food. And is that important? Well, in a sense, yes. The level of complexity a society can have depends on the surpluses it produces. For example, if a single producer can produce as many food as a thousand people, it means that only one in 1,000 people will have to worry about producing food.
The life time of others will be freed to perform other activities that are socially necessary: nurses, musicians, teachers, cleaners, engineers, craftsmen… In this case, the scale for the social division of labor could be provided in 1/1,000. If there are no surpluses in food production, all those involved in society should devote space to food production. It would be a society with a very low level of complexity.
If production were to be organised on the basis of collective interests, how far would we take the size and production capacity of the farms?
The point is that the size of the farm is closely related to the level of surpluses it can generate: the greater it is, the more it can be tecnized and mechanized. This makes it possible to increase the amount of food produced per person. However, this increase in quantitative production does not occur free of charge. As technification increases, the dependence on processes not directly controlled by the producer will increase, losing autonomy and increasing their level of alienation and dependence. Likewise, with the increase of the scale the ecological damage generated by the productive process increases, because the transformation of landscape and ecosystems is also carried out on a larger scale.
Nowadays, in capitalism, the size of exploitation is established by the market: below a level of scale and technification, food production is not profitable and nobody produces it professionally on that scale. But if this is not the case, and if production is organised by collective interests, how far would we take the size and production capacity of the farms? At what point would we solve the existing tension between the factors of scale technification, productivity, environmental, autonomy?
In my opinion, the collectivization of means and the principles of agroecology as guidelines, the expansion of the productive scale should be a field of testing, both in theoretical and practical terms.
Bidali zure iritzi artikuluak iritzia@argia.eus helbide elektronikora
ARGIAk ez du zertan bat etorri artikuluen edukiarekin. Idatzien gehienezko luzera 4.500 karakterekoa da (espazioak barne). Idazkera aldetik gutxieneko zuzentasun bat beharrezkoa da: batetik, ARGIAk ezin du hartu zuzenketa sakona egiteko lanik; bestetik, egitekotan edukia nahi gabe aldatzeko arriskua dago. ARGIAk azaleko zuzenketak edo moldaketak egingo dizkie artikuluei, behar izanez gero.
The achievement of the Euskadi Selection has undoubtedly been a historic achievement. But if you stick to that, for many Basques – I too, because I am Navarro – it will be the darkest and saddest day. After enjoying the joy and warmth of the first few days, let's go back to... [+]
Hearing and language teachers (PDI) and speech therapists are specialist teachers who work in both the public and the concerted school. Among its functions is the direct attention to students with language and communication difficulties, but also the establishment of incremental... [+]
The victims created by the IAP are not only functionalized teachers thanks to the stabilization process brought about by the IAP Law, but much more. Some have been given some media visibility as a result of Steilas's appeal, but most of them are invisible. All the victims of the... [+]
In recent weeks we have been reading "proposals" for the recovery of the railway line Castec-Soria and the maintenance of the Tudela train station in its current location, or for the construction of a new high-speed station outside the urban area with the excuse of the supposed... [+]
Year of War, year of lie!
That is what the phrase says, and that is what reality confirms.
Given the situation of war in the world and in Europe, its constant upturn and the possible consequences that this has had and will have in Euskal Herria, last December several citizens... [+]
The restoration of the natural characteristics of the beach of Waukee began three decades ago and continues without interruption in the staged restoration to counterclockwork.
Samuel (Bizkaia) is an exceptional space, very significant from the natural and social point of view... [+]
After so many years of struggle for it, 34 years, precisely, we are very pleased with the decision taken a few days ago, on 28 December, Innocent Day, in Pamplona, at the assembly organized by the International Federation of Basque Ball. Well, from now on we will have the... [+]
Jar gaitezen 2025erako proposamen politiko gisa, Espainiako Auzitegi Kolonialaren (AN) epai guztiak berrikusten hasteko eta makila bakoitzak bere belari eusteko.
Unionismoarekin lerrokatutako alderdi, sindikatu eta gizarte-erakunde gehienek, eta ez bakarrik horrela... [+]
In February 2023, I read the news in the press and I was depressed because it surprised me and gave me what to think. The store of Jostaldi Kirolak Erdikale Street in Azpeitia will be closed to the public after 48 years of running.
That made me travel in time. I'd been there... [+]
Next Saturday, 11 January, the Sare citizens' network called for a new demonstration in Bilbao in defence of the rights of Basque prisoners. This is a unique opportunity to move forward on the path of coexistence in our people, after decades of violent confrontation and, even... [+]
Road 20 January. U.S. President Donald Trump will be investigated on January 20. Democratic economic elites have repeatedly tried to put an end to Trump’s life. Will they achieve the target by 20 January? Furthermore, they intend to bring the war to a new, tougher phase. To do... [+]
When we woke up, culturally and administratively, the landscape showed a three-speed disaster.
As far as culture is concerned, I had the opportunity – once again – to confirm this last November 14 at the Mint library in Ortzaize. There we met because Eñaut Etxamendi... [+]
Snow hides the earth and the traces of beings looking for pleasure. Under the beauty of snow there is time, years, generations, ephemerides, quotations; but when time goes by there are words that have not been said before or after. Snow reminds us that we could slip and fall. As... [+]
The world has also done so, because it is a symbol, because in history more genocides have already been done and will be done (bad luck, hear, it has touched you to be born there), but Palestine has special characteristics:
- A long time ago, at the end of the 19th century, it... [+]