Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"Current housing management favours individualism"

  • In order to analyze the impact of globalization on the internal organization of housing, at the beginning of the year a brief article was published in the specialized magazine Urruni, composed by Andoni Duque (Bilbao, 1984) and Irantzu Ibáñez (Basauri, 1987), which make up the study of Architecture Halo of Bilbao. The title, The indoctrination of globalization in the domestic space, and one of the conclusions is that the distribution of housing is a reflection of capitalism.
“Badaude etxe mota desberdinak, baina merkatuak mugatzen du horri buruzko hausnarketa, ez du aukerarik ematen
“Badaude etxe mota desberdinak, baina merkatuak mugatzen du horri buruzko hausnarketa, ez du aukerarik ematen". (Argazkia: Hodei Torres)

What encouraged them to do this study?
For our work, the internal organization of housing is a very close issue for us. We had a bias that they're all pretty similar. We thought the market is very standardized. From there, we did a ludic analysis. Through the web pages, the housing offers from different countries were consulted, always with the first example found in each one of them. And we set criteria for the study to be balanced: two-bedroom homes, without terraces and located in urban areas. We wanted to see if that limitation of the opportunities we perceive in our environment is around the world. Or to organize the interior of the housing in which each country still has its own form.

The conclusion has been the first, that is, the existence of a restriction of opportunity.
Yes, in line with what we think, indeed. However, we have seen some differences. For example, areas related to personal hygiene continue to maintain their local character. It is a rather private issue, little present in audiovisual products.

According to your study, what are the dwellings of the world today?According to
the rationalist model: there is a division between night and day, between the public and the private. They are day centers, public, kitchen and lounge, increasingly united, but the kitchen is still closed in many countries. Next to the living room, but closed, by the theme of hygiene mentioned above (because the kitchen is “dirty”). And in the living room, the TV sofa has become the binomial. The kitchen and the living room are organized around it.

There is no housing without television, therefore...
No, and in addition, the center where television is located is the center of the house. For example, in the old houses built in Euskal Herria, 60 years ago - or many times you see the kitchen, and above all the dining room linked to the kitchen was the center of the house. Life was organized around this. This option no longer appears in the offers and the binomial TV couch is the protagonist.

Photo: Hodei Torres

The conclusion they have drawn is that this division is a reflection of capitalist culture. Why? Architecture
is a good indicator of the political, social, economic and technological reality we live in. In short, it is a cultural product. Product of today's society. Therefore, it shows many values and principles of society. In addition, the authors of most housing offered are aligned with economic power and regulatory powers.

And what value is driven?
On the one hand, individualism. This is very evident depending on the type of room offered. There is always a master bedroom, double, for the heads of the family (and the heads of the family should be as a couple). On the contrary, the second bedroom, or the third, has a much smaller surface, fully enhancing individualism, being considered as a unit of independent use. It has a bed to sleep, a study table and a wardrobe. That's where you can spend the day without having to relate to others in the house. Now, in addition, on many occasions, you can also have TV inside. Therefore, one characteristic is individualism and another is hierarchy. The fact that a bedroom has a closet means that the owner of that bedroom is the owner of the objects found inside it. This determines something. In a way, private property is praised: everyone has their own.

What alternatives are there?
As we have said, a deconstruction process would be necessary. But there are examples in history and in the world. An alternative may be that the rooms are just for sleeping, not much larger than the size of the bed, and that they are outside a space of learning or work shared by the members of the house. Or a closet. You can create new spaces with new names, rearranging all the uses of the house. Play spaces, etc.

You speak of a paradox that, despite being a reflection of capitalism, supply is contrary to the rules of the free market. Because it gives no margin of
choice n.La reason is that, in our opinion, housing is a product that the market sells only once. And because it's a necessary product, people have to buy what's offered. We have it very internalized, but it's not hard to realize that there are other models. We know the different types of houses, but in the end the market limits reflection. It doesn't give you the opportunity, and you just have to decide where the house is, how many square meters it has, whether it has two or three bedrooms and whether you're going to be in a kitchen and a living room. Almost nothing else.

The same opportunities on all continents
“We have analyzed housing offers on all continents. And, as Zaida Muxí says in his book Architecture of a Global City, there are three groups: EE.UU Europe, etc. The United States exports models, American kitchens that we see in movies, etc. It has also come here, but as we in Europe have the deepest traditions, we take some things and others do not. On the contrary, in Africa, Asia, South America -- these models are a reflection of Western culture, so they're often considered good and copied. Consequently, local identity is lost or eliminated.”

 


You are interested in the channel: Arkitektura
2025-01-22 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Lurraldea eta arkitektura
Erosoa

Eroso gaude ingurunea gure egoera fisiko/emozionalera egokitzen denean. Besteak ni kontuan hartu nauenean, izan gizaki bat, objektu bat, espazio bat. Erosotasunaren klabea produktu eta espazio diseinuan beharrizan handi gisa sartu da, erosotzat jotzen dena erosgarria delako... [+]


Ander Zangitu. Beyond the buildings
"It's become a trend, but there are no compelling reasons to merge the kitchen and the living room."
Last year I met for the first time with Ander Zangitu at the School of Word who organize in the Dinamoa creation space of Azpeitia. We reflect above all on silence. Since then he has more carefully observed his forms from the world of his trade, from architecture. Although we... [+]

2025-01-08 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
On the planet of the house

At Christmas they leave a new book on the bedside table. About the philosophy and joy of the house, recently written by Emanuele Coccia. Coccia, an Italian philosopher, has become popular in making known our connections with plants on the road to the construction of a healthy... [+]


They propose the construction of a hotel spa in the monumental complex of Quejana
The Catalan architect Estela Roca Rom has been the winner of the ideas competition organized by the Provincial Council of Álava. The foral institution will begin to look for public-private channels to finance the project.

2024-12-04 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Sir

A prestigious architect comes from London to a small Galician town. It is David Chipperfield, a building with offices in Berlin, Milan and Shanghai, and has a large team of buildings. An elegant, refined architecture, made by a Sir. The story begins in the village of Corrubedo... [+]


Monument to the Fallen of Pamplona
Relatives of the gunmen ask not to use the name of Marvels Lamberto
The Association of Relatives of Shot Men of Navarra has strongly criticized the agreement reached by EH Bildu, Geroa Bai and PSN on the Memorial to the Fallen in Pamplona. He says that there are better places to do "pedagogy" and that the interpretation center will be made a... [+]

2024-11-20 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Data to the territory

In recent weeks it has not been possible for those of us who work in architecture that the climate phenomenon of Valencia has not been translated into our work discourse. Because we need to think about and design the path of water in decks, sewers, plazas and building parks. We... [+]


Ancora denounces to the Ertzaintza the "clandestine works" of the Fine Arts Building of San Sebastian
The Ancora Association has submitted a complaint to the Ertzaintza for the "clandestine works" being carried out in the Fine Arts Building. In fact, on September 30, Ancorá recorded a letter in the City Hall in which he denounced that the protected envelope of the Fine Arts... [+]

In schools, we have an architecture that prioritizes control rather than surveillance.
Although the transformations of the courtyards of the centers are increasing, the old buildings and the rigid infrastructures are still the ones that dominate the education (both in interior and exterior spaces), to learn, move and relate to taste, far from the spaces, designs,... [+]

Eneko Tuduri Zubilhgh,Doctor of Art History
"It is a systematic destruction of the heritage of San Sebastian"
Eneko Tuduri Zubilwaukee (Centro, 1990) works in teaching and historical research. Doctor in History of Art, wrote a thesis inspired by the mural paintings of some ancient churches in Navarra. For a while he has been a member of the Ancora Association and has been very attentive... [+]

2024-09-25 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Class list

The first of September, releases, novelties and releases: new case and notebook, first meeting with the members of the group for the courses and/or activities to which it is appointed, a wide range of activities in the advertising pages where you can complete the course agenda,... [+]


2024-09-23 | Garazi Zabaleta
The need to renaturalize cities in the face of heat
Although most of Euskal Herria is located in a temperate zone, not only in the south of Álava and Navarra, but also throughout the territory, the strong streaks of summer heat. And apparently, with climate change, the situation is going to get worse, or are you already doing... [+]

2024-09-11 | Ula Iruretagoiena
Territory and architecture
Europe

I have few friends with a European feeling, I do not know whether Europeity becomes an identity. But when we travel to Europe, a friendship may emerge, because the main areas of territoriality that are taking place in Europe and in Europe are shared, where it is decided to... [+]


Eguneraketa berriak daude