Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

The rich are always rich.

  • Florence, 1427. After the economic and demographic crisis of the 14th century, the city revived. Coinciding with the rise of the bourgeoisie and thanks to its patronage, Florence was the nest of the Renaissance.
Florentzia XV. mendean. Hiriaren planoa asko aldatu da 600 urtetan; hiriko familia aberatsenen zerrenda, aldiz, ez (arg: Francesco Rosselli)

And in addition to art, the economy also flourished thanks, mainly, to the wool trade. That's what the Albizzi family did, which at the time was in power. But by then the Medici had extended their tentacles, by the hand of the Old Cosimo (1389-1464); a few years later, the Medici family would acquire command of the city and would not liberate it for more than three centuries.

Specifically, that year, in 1427, a census was formed in the city to collect taxes, in which the citizens' property and income were collected in detail. A few years ago, these taxpayers' data were digitized and put online. Taking this opportunity, Italian economists Guglielmo Barone and Sauro Mocetti have compared this data from the 15th century with those from 2011.

Among other things, they analyzed the revenues related to 800 surnames and drew up a list of the five earning names in the current Florence. Later, in the 1427 census, they sought information on the incomes, assets and professions of these five surnames. And the result is clarifying: four of the top five names in the list (the top four) exceeded the average income in 1427, and three of them among the richest, 10%. And what are those last names? In the research they have been designated with the letters A, B, C, D and E, for privacy reasons.

In other words, after 600 years of siege, Napoleon's campaign, Mussolini's dictatorship and two world wars, little has changed in the distribution of goods. But Barone and Mocetti claim that the result of their research cannot be generalized.

In 1986 economists Gary Becker and Nigel Tomes said in his book Human Capital and the Rise and Fall of Families: “Most of the goods collected by the ancestors, for good and for evil, are destroyed in three generations.” In this regard, he stressed that what happened in Florence is "an exception".

But a few years ago, Gregory Clark and Neil Cummins conducted similar research in England (Surnames and Social Mobility in England, 1170–2012), and in eight centuries (28 generations) they showed that most elite families had maintained their status. Clark would add eight countries in another play (The Son Also Rises, 2014): Sweden, United States, India, Taiwan, Japan, Korea, Chile and China. In all of them he concluded that the rich of the past are also rich today.


You are interested in the channel: Desberdintasun soziala
2024-12-13 | Julene Flamarique
In the largest companies in Spain, executive executives pay 118 times the average
Jesús María Herrera, executive director of CIE Automotive, received a remuneration of almost EUR 24 million in 2023. In 2022, she received an extraordinary premium of EUR 20 million and rose six times the annual wage. Iberdrola took a place on the podium and the report reveals... [+]

Restrictions, exclusion and business interests: deadly cocktail for a disaster in Valencia
It would be too naive to think that in Valencia there are empty weather factors behind the dead and the damage caused by the storm. Many have denounced the management of the emergency by the Generalitat and that the business thirst of the multinationals has prevailed. And we can... [+]

Oxfam report
1% richest in the world accumulates more wealth than 95%
Oxfam Intermón’s report warns that major challenges on the planet, such as the climate crisis, and global efforts to address poverty and lasting inequality are under threat. “Power is accumulating in the hands of ultra-rich and mega-enterprises.”

2024-06-27 | Jauzi Ekosoziala
How many are too many and enough?
What are our real needs to live well? What is living well? Answering these questions is fundamental in the society of abuse, even more so in times of climate emergency, ecological crisis and civilizing crisis.

The rich heirs of the Conqueror of Gil

Hastings (England), 1066. The army of the Duke of Normandy I of Gil conquered the troops of King Harold II and conquered the throne. Gil's conqueror I was king until 1087.

In this reign after the Norman conquest, the rebellion organized uprising, effective administration and the... [+]


44% of men believe that equality policies have gone "too far" and that it is they who reject
This is the first monographic survey conducted by the Centre for Sociological Research of Spain (CIS) on “Gender Perceptions and Stereotypes of Equality between Men and Women”, where the majority of women participating in the research (65.5%) claim that this statement is... [+]

If we gave the class without considering the house booster?
Professor José Antonio Herranz has decided to modify the formula of "explaining the subject in school, doing the duties and putting the exam", limiting the entire teaching to the school hours so that some students do not stay behind due to the reality of the house. He tells the... [+]

Free after-school activities, Portuguese key to tackling the imbalance
Children aged 6 to 10 years have free after-school activities in Portugal. Ensuring universal participation in these activities has been beneficial in tackling the socio-economic and consequent academic imbalances of Portuguese pupils and in reducing school failure, among... [+]

Face of the Gap

Rent 338 euros or buy 119,000 euros. This is what a woman between 18 and 44 years old can afford on average to live on her own in the CAPV. In any case, since the housing reserve will not exceed 30 per cent of the income. They are data from the Basque Government, and, as they... [+]


Wimbledon Stain Free Regulation
London, July 1877. Organized by the All England Lawn Tennis and Crocket Club, the world’s oldest tennis championship was held for the first time. Seven years later, in 1884 women were also able to participate. And in the act that has just ended this year, almost a century and... [+]

The cracks caused by the university and the educational system
Thousands of students are about to take the university entrance test. In our unbalanced society, education is always the last point of maturity and hope: symbol of equal opportunities, dream of the social lift. But actually, the education system doesn't go beyond the career that... [+]

The strategy of ultrariums is to guide decisions on the climate problem
Political scientist Edouard Morena analyzes the climate emergency from a class perspective and has just published his book Fin du monde et petits fours: Les ultra-riches face à la crise climatique. The excessive consumption of the ultra-rich is more harmful than that of the... [+]

Technology
Ethics of digital transformation

I have been talking to a colleague of all the aids to reduce the ‘digital divide’: from the private sector, from Europe, from the state, from the government… Among the quotation marks I place the digital divide, as many problems that existed before its implementation are... [+]


Bread 14%, onions 258% and mortgage 3,600 euros more: To whom does the price increase affect the most?
Basic food has grown by 15.4% in the Spanish State in one year and the Consumer Price Index has risen again to 5.9%. This increase in prices has generated concern and the Government of Spain seeks solutions with large producers and sellers. However, so far they have not agreed.

Peru hegoaldetik Limaraino iritsi dira manifestariak, beste konstituzio bat eskatzeko

Ostegun honetarako manifestazio handia espero da Liman Dina Boluarte kargutik kendu, parlamentua desegin eta Perurentzako beste konstituzio bat eskatzeko. Herritar asko autobusez eta kamioiez karabanetan antolatuta iritsi da hegoaldeko eskualdeetatik herrialdeko hiribururaino.


Eguneraketa berriak daude