Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"90% of the world's languages are not in schools"

  • American linguist Suzanne Romaine claims that all children learn in their own language. He has denounced that millions of boys and girls are schooled in a language they do not understand, so the doors of school are closed. Without education, there is little chance of life progressing. A conference was held on 15 December at the European Forum on Linguistic Diversity in Donostia-San Sebastián. The two-day forum took place between Donostia 2016 and UNESCO Etxea. After the talk, we interviewed the linguist.
Argazkia: Andoni Canellada / Argazki Press
Argazkia: Andoni Canellada / Argazki Press
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

You said that there is no development without linguistic diversity.

That is not exactly the case. There is no real development without the development of languages.

And what is real development?

Development that empowers. People are not passive recipients of aid coming from outside, people are involved in their development, citizens can argue with those who help them. Let me give you an example: most international development agencies and non-governmental organisations do not learn local languages. They try to meet people, but they only communicate with international language speakers. If we talk about African countries, most of the time they partner with men. If you don't speak your language, how will you join poor women, women with five children who want microcredit in India or in Africa? How can that woman communicate what she wants? That is what I meant by reference to real development. People can discuss their situation with strangers in their mother tongue, not through translation.

Do you really believe that NGOs take minority languages into account?

I believe that some have good intentions, but they do not understand the situation in the languages of the world. The example is the earthquake in Haiti. It's officially spoken in French, but 90 percent of people don't speak French. Those who suffer most in such disasters are always the poorest of the poor, those who live in rural areas. So what do you do talking to them in French? In Africa, it's like doing it in English or French. If you're going to go to citizenship, you need to speak in your language. Translators Without Borders are doing incredible work. Some non-governmental organisations are working very well, others not so well.

At the conference, you've shown a photograph. In a t-shirt worn by a young man, he speaks English about the subject of AIDS. If you don't do it in English, isn't it surprising that you have information in English?

“Most international development agencies and non-governmental organizations do not learn local languages”

Many languages of citizenship are not read. You have to do radio shows, puppets or theaters at school to transmit information, you have to be an inventor in the forms of communication. You can put a great written symbol, but it makes no sense to the citizens.

A study by Doctors Without Borders points out that communication was the biggest problem in the Ebola crisis. They say that the crisis would have ended sooner if people had realized communication problems. The problem is tremendous if the institutions do not realise this obstacle.

The same is true of the refugee crisis in Europe. Most of them come from poor communities and many speak minority languages. How will he explain to them what their rights are? Here's the example of the Calais rainforest. Some of the refugees who have taken refuge in the area have relatives in the United Kingdom. According to international law, some of them would have the right to access the area, but there was no one to explain to them such a possibility. More of those who would have left could travel to the United Kingdom.

So I mentioned to you the development that before it empowers, if you had come to the sites and asked what language you speak, if you had been told in your language what your rights are, the result would have been different. It's not easy, that's also true. That is why I say that language is the key to development.

Why is education so important in relation to minority languages?

Education is a key to everything, isn't it? How will you learn in school if your language is not taught?

At home…

Sometimes even their parents don't understand the language their children use in school. How will the child learn to read? If you don't learn how to read, how will you learn something else? Many boys and girls try to learn to read, but when they see that they can't, they leave school.

There are studies that say that boys and girls stay longer in school if they learn their mother tongue. It makes all sense. How are you going to learn if you don't understand the language of school?

90% of the world's languages are not in schools. It's a terrible number.

I've studied 30 years at Oxford University, and I've had a lot of students who speak minority languages. However, most were English and have studied English at school. My mother tongue is English and the classes were in English. I believed that everywhere the same thing happened, that people studied in their language at school. The students were surprised when I told them what's going on in the world. What would you learn if I had to speak in Basque at school? I wouldn't understand it. Hundreds of millions of people speak these languages at home, on the street, but not at school. Not applicable.

"I'm talking particularly about indigenous people. They speak most of the world's languages, they are among the poorest in the world."

Is there a good example in Africa?

Ethiopia. They have moved from teaching in a single language (Arabic) to using minority languages. In addition to local languages, they use Arabic and English. Unfortunately, most schools in Africa are trying to introduce English as soon as possible. It's not good. They think that children need an international language, and they think it's better to start teaching as soon as possible. So you will never learn, you have to have your base in the mother tongue first. They will then add other languages.

You made a direct link between poverty and minority languages.

Of course. I am talking about the poor because it is the poor who speak the majority of minority languages. I am referring in particular to the indigenous people. They speak most of the world's languages, they are among the poorest in the world. Either they do not have a state, or they live in a state that does not tolerate them, or they are banned directly from the language, or they are exploited by the natural resources of their territory.

Yes, there is a direct relationship. I do not mean that speaking minority languages creates poverty. There's a relationship. If people don't have a chance to learn, if they don't go to school, what are they going to do? It's a cycle and it repeats itself. They have no chance of getting out of poverty.

I insist, it is not a question of speaking minority languages bringing poverty, because that argument is used by some. Those who argue in this way say, for example, that English and French must be taught in order not to be poor.


You are interested in the channel: Hezkuntza
International Congress to Discuss Transformative Syndicalism and Work in Leioa
More than 40 rapporteurs will participate this Thursday and Friday in the Leioa Campus of the UPV/EHU at the First International Labour and Trade Union Congress of the 21st Century. The guest will talk about the challenges and strategies of the world of work and the... [+]

"Education has to be quiet and indifferent."
In the round table for the presentation of the book Superpowers, the Contertulios have claimed "to leave the exhausting speed of daily life and take time to dream of the school project". They have calmly devoted themselves to transformation, to impotence, to illusion, to the... [+]

2024-11-27 | ARGIA
Joxerramon Bengoetxea, rector of the UPV/EHU, with 64% of the votes
Bengoetxea's candidacy won the UPV/EHU Rectorate elections with 63.6% of the votes. The other group, Eva Ferreira, obtained 36.3% of the votes. Turnout has been 21.9 per cent and has increased over previous elections

2024-11-26 | Leire Ibar
Three professors of the Conservatory of Music of Navarra are denounced for machista violence
The facts have been denounced by several students from the UPV/EHU. One of the teachers has been accused of harassing and harassing students through social networks and sexual proposals. The second is due to inadequate attitudes in the classroom and sexist comments. As for the... [+]

2024-11-26 | EHU Palestina
At the UPV/EHU in favour of the study committee and the cessation of any relationship with the Israeli genocide and apartheid

The UPV/EHU Palestine was born with the aim of breaking with all Israeli companies and institutions that are carrying out and working with genocide in Palestine. Israel’s impunity comes from its political, military, economic, scientific and academic relations in Europe and the... [+]


The students of ESO present the reading competition for the promotion of literature
After its success in the schools of Slovenia, the editorial Alberdania has brought to the educational centers of Euskal Herria the Joko Ona Denontzat reading contest: The students of the ESO will read “high quality books” by groups and selecting avatar will overcome the... [+]

Book 'Superpowers'
Wednesday will talk about school projects in Larraul
The appointment is at Larraul School on November 27, at 17:30. In addition to Koldo Rabadam, the author of the book 'Superpowers', we will count on Nora Salbotx, who has written the foreword, and several colleagues: Ainhoa Azpirotz (coordinator of Hik Hasi), Irati Manzisidor... [+]

2024-11-25 | Jon Torner Zabala
Elections UPV/EHU
Bengoetxea asks to investigate the "irregular practices" of Ferreira's candidacy
This Tuesday, 26 May, the elections to the Rectorado of the UPV/EHU are held. The campaign is being confused, and proof of this is that the team of Joxerramon Bengoetxea has called for "the investigation of actions supposedly performed by people of Eva Ferreira's candidacy or its... [+]

Fog

Many times, after looking at the brumas from my house, it has occurred to me not to catch umbrellas, even though I know I will just soak up. Why will it be? Maybe you don't want to catch the umbrella? Maybe in the hope that I don't get wet? Nevertheless, the conclusion has always... [+]


Koldo Rabadan Izagirre. Author of the book 'Superpowers'
"Luckily, children don't have adults inside of them, because if they don't, they'd be down to reality."
Even in the saddest days, when the doors of the school of Larraul (Gipuzkoa) are opened, the mood revolves. Close to the children of the Haurreskola, a few meters away is the corner of the library. We've found a little girl in front of the computer, with headphones on, writing... [+]

Maddi Agirre Epelde. Bertsolari Mathematician Cantauthor
"It would be my dream to sing with Xenpelar."
Maddi, 19, holds a degree in mathematics at the Faculty of Science and Technology at UPV/EHU in Leioa, has musical studies and is also a very expert bertsolari. And it has warms to be better than a good bertsolari, as we've seen in the different squares. “Are the new ones going... [+]

Epistemic injustice in schools?

In Sociology of Education there is a classical question: Why does the education system exist in a society? The answers to the question are numerous and change according to the time. But among them, it should be noted that the main objective of the school is the creation of... [+]


"Many things happen in school dining hours, it's not just a place to eat."
For two hours or two and a half hours the dining area is home to a group of children and young people. In this space to eat, play and live together, we will talk about the intervention limits of the head of the dining room, the criteria followed, the role of the monitors and... [+]

2024-11-19 | Leire Ibar
The Council of Ministers of Foreign Affairs, Security and Defence Policy and the Council of Ministers of Foreign Affairs, Security and Defence Policy
On 20 November, International Day of Childhood, the citizens' initiative in the field of education proposes to place a Palestinian flag with black crespon and two pairs of shoes on the entrances to schools. Between 30 November and 31 January, messages of support for Palestinian... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude