Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

- Is your madness favorable to life? Then there is no problem, the risk is to lose the social connection"

  • Lucía Gricman, psychologist and Argentinian, holds in the therapeutic center of Buenos Aires very fruitful meetings with people with mental illness. We've talked about insanity, medicalization and psychoanalysis.
“Jatorrizko komunitateen genozidioaren gainean eraikitako gizartea da argentinarra, arazo identitario handia dugu eta horregatik gure buruari galderak egiteko beharra dugu”.
“Jatorrizko komunitateen genozidioaren gainean eraikitako gizartea da argentinarra, arazo identitario handia dugu eta horregatik gure buruari galderak egiteko beharra dugu”.

What exactly are you doing in your home?

We performed an intensive therapeutic stay with patients who have previously been admitted to a psychiatric center, a kind of transition to social integration. When a person is at risk for himself or others, he enters a center and when it disappears he is willing to come to our center. In addition to rehabilitation (to help organize life), we conduct workshops to promote creativity and expression (through puppets, radio…), as from creativity you can recover the link with society.

Is creativity the key?

Insanity can lead you to lose the social bond, and being tied to society does not mean being economically productive, but wanting to relate to other people; that special thing that happens in the mind (which leads some to illness), creativity is the way to bring what is so yours to a collective level, to make your contribution to others. I remember a person with Paranoid delusions created a comic book about those delusions; he did something about that madness that isolated him from society, to share it with others.

Some say that madness does not exist...

I think of a phrase by Truman Capote: “You don’t have to be crazy to live here, but it makes things easier.” I usually talk to patients. To start with, we take away a despicable connotation from the crazy word, it's not a bad thing, we can all go crazy in concrete situations. But the relativism of the statement “we are all crazy” is silly, because your madness can lead you, for example, to compromise yourself and others. What are we all crazy about? If you want to believe it that way, but when does your insanity depart from life? That is the question; as Nietzsche said, the balance is life: Is your madness favorable to life? Then there is no problem, but if it moves away from life (from socialization) we have to intervene. That is our criterion.

Is that healing?

That is, your madness lets you live. What we have to do is keep the person as close as possible to their community. And I don't mean being always happy, because curing is not suffering, but having the means to take it and face it.

Are we increasingly tending to pathologize everything?

Yes, especially in childhood, and it is very serious, because childhood is psychiatric and medicalised. The trend comes from the United States, a gigantic drug company, and we end up medicating children's most basic behaviors. Having a child alive is a symptom of good health, but it is medicalized to be at rest. The centers are assumed, because the social problems that young people have are eaten in schools and the usual process is to bring the ‘difficult’ child to the psychological cabinet, hence to the psychiatrist and return to the classroom from the psychiatrist. It doesn't happen to us that we have to rethink the school.

“Instead of rethinking school, it’s easier to pathologize and meditate the student. We transform social problems into individual ones and leave out what doesn’t fit”

It's easier to pathologize to the student and keep the status quo as it is. We transform social problems into individual ones and leave out what doesn't fit, with madness the same thing happens. Do you know what a patient told us in the assembly? They're more sensitive, more sensitive to this system that wants us sad and messy, and that's why they're in that situation.

Organizing patient assemblies is your responsibility.

At first they didn't understand that I said I was one more, that everyone had a voice and space in the assembly. We rethink ourselves as political subjects, as citizens, and we talk about news and news, what the media wants to sell to us… Because thinking about what happens in society is also therapeutic: participating in a human collective cures us, it makes us want to live again. We talk a lot about minorities, for example, groups that are considered different from the majority, including our own. A recently very delirious patient tells us that he feels the need to help; in the assembly people first said that he should be cured, and in the end we came to the conclusion that helping others can be therapeutic. I can be alone and sad, but if I can do well to another, I will feel better.

Or when we talked about the massacre that took place in the Orlando nightclub, we saw that the media always have the same behavior, blaming a madman, individually, instead of thinking that behind there is a more serious social problem. But we talked about the ease of access to arms in the United States, and to me it was a huge achievement of the stigma that it's dangerous for patients to disassociate insanity.

“Belonging or not being a party is the collective pathology we live in, the risk of exclusion. In the end we are all out, because they want to be normal and nobody gets that fiction.”

We also discuss what it means to be sick and to be sick. I told them that I was recently told that I had asthma and that, by medical means, all the doctors insisted that I was asthmatic. What about that label, and what do I do about it? It has served us to think of labels, which do not have to constantly present themselves to people as crazy, as if they were wrong and all others good, as if it were not part of life that in some moments were good and in others bad.

Is today's society crazy?

A professor of mine told me that one of the most serious things in today's society is normality. There's a strong boundary between being normal and not being, that's the great fiction that's generated by today's society. Belonging or not is the collective pathology that we live in, because we have a very bad risk of staying out and because everything is psychopathological so much that it is very easy to stay out. In the end, we're all out, because we want to be normal, and nobody gets that fiction. When I've been left out, what should I do, try again to be normal, or learn to play from my difference?

Argentina is the territory of psychoanalysis.

Some people think that psychoanalysis is about staying quiet and listening to people, and it's not. Psychoanalysis is an ethical and political attitude to listen to the world, and it is an anti-capitalist practice, because it allows you to rethink, live and reflect on whether the decisions you make are related to what you want.

Is psychoanalysis the best way to deal with problems?

When I have talked to criminals who have ended up in a psychiatric hospital, I often see in them a social problem that has left out of the world beyond the mental illness, which has also influenced the path they have taken. We should therefore also respond to the problem from a social point of view, in each case. In Argentina, for example, the social imbalance is very large and we cannot listen to someone and morally judge by their actions, whether that person has never found a social haven or whether he has been educated in violence. Among the marginalized young Argentinians, the base of pasta [similar to cocaine] has spread widely and with what has fallen into the claws of the drug you do not have much time to think, you have to act. These are problems that go beyond psychoanalysis or any other individual therapy.

In each case, the psychoanalytical, psychological, psychiatric, social perspective can be combined...

There are many ways to deal with problems, there are psychologist psychoanalyst, psychotherapist psychiatrist, cognitive-behavioral therapies… If a quick solution works, great… Psychoanalysis invites you to ask yourself a little more, but if you don’t have questions, go ahead with your life! The point is that in Argentina we have a great need to ask ourselves. My theory is that we are a society built on the genocide of the communities of origin, the children of Europeans, and that we have a big identity problem that leads us to wonder where we come from, what we do, what we are…


You are interested in the channel: Osasuna
2024-12-30 | ARGIA
Almost a quarter of the population of Álava, Bizkaia and Gipuzkoa has health insurance
23.9 per cent of the CAV population were covered by health insurance in 2023, according to Eustat data. Compared to data for 2021, there has been an increase of 4.1%. Most of the consultations were in traumatology, ophthalmology, gynecology and dermatology. 61.3% of the... [+]

2024-12-27 | Gedar
Osakidetza cuts 110 health centers at Christmas
In the past Christmas, waiting periods of up to twelve hours were recorded, which have been extended to zero hours. Osakidetza applies such restrictions within 180 days a year.

2024-12-12 | Leire Ibar
Judge closes investigation of Osakidetza's opposition leaks without guilt
Judge Blanca Ester Díaz Pulido has completed her investigation into the leaks of Osakidetza's opposition in 2018, after six and a half years of hearings. All defendants have been acquitted in total, a total of 22, even though two of the cases have been provisionally filed.

2024-12-11 | ARGIA
The Government of Navarra advocates changing the law so that the health system does not fail
The Health Advisor of Navarra has defended the need to amend the Health Law and turn it into a public enterprise entity such as Osasunbidea, otherwise "the system will not fail". Trade unions do not agree with this formula.

2024-12-05 | Julene Flamarique
Every year 30-40 new cases of AIDS are detected in Navarra
The Director General of Health of Navarre has underlined the importance of making these diagnoses earlier so that there is no less contagion in the Foral Community. The Department of Health has focused on “people with the greatest difficulties in accessing the health system”... [+]

Tunagate: Do you want some mercury with the salad?
The population is excited by the amount of mercury found in tuna cans. According to a study carried out in Europe by Bloom, Carrefour, Intermarché, Mercadona, Aldi... all supermarkets market contaminated tuna. Industrial fishing has quickly underestimated these data. And that... [+]

Feeling of guilt in perinatal death
The daughter of AMETS Etxeberria, Aduna, died in the seventh month of pregnancy as a result of a long illness. In these cases, the feeling of guilt is the weight many women carry on their backs, which also makes grief difficult. Etxeberria says that the treatment you receive... [+]

2024-11-28 | Leire Ibar
Consumption of anxiolytics and antidepressant medicines increases considerably among young people
The mental health of the young people of Hego Euskal Herria is in a "worrying" situation, according to a report prepared by the digital portal Gurea Geroa. According to the survey, half of the young people suffer from emotional distress and nearly six in ten people have had... [+]

"Petronor uses the word transformation, but we only see job destruction"
Petronor workers have enjoyed a day of free struggle this Thursday. Convened by the Works Council, they have held a strike and have concentrated on the BEC of Barakaldo, where the company held its annual meeting. They have denounced that, despite receiving public money, the only... [+]

2024-11-27 | Estitxu Eizagirre
Cosmetics with medicinal plants
How to wash and care without contaminating the body and the Earth?
Skin is not a superficial issue, but a limit to the outside and the protection of ourselves. However, if we use industrial cosmetics, our body introduces chemical toxins into the skin and when it moves through the hole in the shower, we contaminate the water and the Earth every... [+]

Claims to Osakidetza grow by 20% over the past year
Complaints and acknowledgements have remained similar, but there is a difference in complaints. For example, compared to the previous month of June this year, claims have increased by almost 30%.

"Instead of patenting menopause, we have to live as part of a stage."
Physio Juncal Alzugaray Zurimendi, a specialist in sexology and pelvic floor, has given some keys to better understand climacteric and menopause.

Eguneraketa berriak daude