Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"What has been done is that a few privileged women have moved from one place to another."

  • Nancy Fraser is an American politician and feminist. In her opinion, only a part of women has managed to get power. They compete with men and imitate men's attitudes. The structure remains: economic production and social reproduction have not been combined.
“Menpean hartzeko modu oso modernoak ere badira, egituren bidez, aitaren edo senarraren debekuen bitartez baino”.
“Menpean hartzeko modu oso modernoak ere badira, egituren bidez, aitaren edo senarraren debekuen bitartez baino”. Maxresdefaut
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

Nancy Fraser is interviewed by Mariana Vilnitzky in the journal Economic Alternatives (September 2014) and the next is the translation of a part. The original can only be obtained on paper.

P. Historian Thompson mentioned women who were already complaining about double work (at home and abroad) before the Industrial Revolution.

That has been the case throughout history. In a period of emergency men fought and in some cases got the so-called “family wage”. It served to support the whole family. Women didn't have to go to work to make money. The working class wanted that and fought for it. But it has been an exception.

Anyway, there does not seem to be a favorable attitude towards women…

Of course not. It was a form of male domination and female subordination. Workers in England, the United States, France and other countries received great support. But it was an exception. Women have always had a double job. They work and work to contribute to the family budget.

Is there any place in the world where women have been able to be liberated from this dependence?

I do not think it has been achieved. The types of inequality may vary from country to region. In South Asia, in some countries, women are also forced to go out into the streets, it's a very old way of understanding patriarchy, although things are changing. There are also very modern forms of subjugation, more through structures than through the prohibitions of the father or husband. In the United States, we have a modern form of submission, double work, more and more frequently three or four jobs because of the economic situation. Many women in precarious conditions have more than one job. Many do ten hours in McDonalds, another ten hours in Wallmarte, in so many other stores. They're part-time and part-time jobs.

Is there light at the end of the tunnel?

Hope is in the capacity of social struggle. It will not occur automatically. Change is in our hands. Feminism has eras, live and slower times. Today, radical feminism is standing still, and instead we have liberal feminism. I think that feminism creates problems, it's inadequate.

Why?

Very privileged professional women, high educational level, highly qualified, who occupy the highest positions in the corporate and military world are empowering, in other words, “the glass ceiling is breaking”. Reach the top, compete with men, in the way of men.

Type of “masculinized” power…

We say that they become “socially masculine.” This kind of feminism has strength in the United States, England, in many parts of the world. They're like Christine Lagarde, who runs the International Monetary Fund. But if the IMF leaves out a part of the world with structural and political adjustments, and if women do, that is not progress.

There does not seem to be much room for policies that will focus on reproduction, in a world that is fully organised for production.

Unfortunately, women in power work the same way as men. The company, lawyer or medicine. And you don't have time to bleach, wash the dishes, prepare the meals, clean the bathtubs, change the packages… Somebody else will do all that work.

Another woman?

In most cases, immigrant women, brunettes, from poor, rural countries. It is common for this woman to have a very low wage to take care that she has left her children or someone poorer than her. These women, whom I referred to at the beginning, are successful on them. The history of production is eternal, it is built upon reproduction. What has been done is that a few privileged women have moved from one place to another. But the structure has not changed.

How can you change the structure if everything around us is organized differently? How to say: “I’m going to four because at five I have to pick up the child at school” and don’t stay behind, if nobody does the same (and of course their father doesn’t)?

The example you have given is the vision of a person who lives and must fight in the structure that we now have. What if there was a political movement that said that “this working structure is not fair and needs to be changed”? We would refer more to the redesign of the structure of associations and movements than to the individual struggle.

Do you know any examples?

Some. It's not perfect, but there were some attempts. The Communist countries tried to do something different. It was not necessarily good, but some progress was made with regard to capitalist countries. In Latin America there are cooperative movements of social economy and solidarity. Cooperative models are being organised for the distribution of works that integrate social reproduction into economic production. People are trying.


You are interested in the channel: Feminismoa
2024-11-29 | Irutxuloko Hitza
Several women report a well-known music technician from Donostia-San Sebastián for sexual harassment
Yesterday the reports against music technician Iñaki Castro began to be disseminated in the account '@docena_euskalherria', and the testimonies of more than a dozen women have already been collected.

Hysterical materialism
I want with you

In recent years, I have made little progress. I have said it many times, I know, but just in case. Today I attended a bertsos session. “I wish you a lot.” Yes, that is why I have warned that I leave little, I assume that you are attending many cultural events, and that you... [+]


2024-11-26 | ARGIA
Message to men on the day against male violence: "If you're not the solution, you're a problem."
A thousand people have supported the demonstrations and concentrations called for on the occasion of the International Day against Male Violence. The Feminist Movement has targeted men, the media and institutions.

2024-11-22 | Antxeta Irratia
“Feministon aurkako oldarraldia” gelditzeko indarrak batu dituzte Lizuniagan

Udan izandako indarkeria kasuen gorakada batetik, eta hainbat gizonezkok mugimendu feministak antolaturiko ekitaldiak boikotatu dituztela bestetik, Bortziriak, Xareta, Azkain, Bertizarana, Malerreka eta Baztango mugimendu feministek, erakunde publikoen konpromiso irmoa exijitu... [+]


2024-11-21 | Julene Flamarique
Feminists and emerging artists by hand: Sister festivals Feministaldia and Dives
On 20 November the festival will start at the bar Le Bukowski in Donostia-San Sebastián, with the collaboration of Eitb.com. More than 40 artists, activists, thinkers and collectives will participate. The final will be in the ZAS space of Vitoria-Gasteiz.

Elene Lopetegi, member of Bilgune Feminist
“It is necessary to think of the maximum utopias in order to draw the paths to reach them”
Recently, the Basque Country Women’s Feminist Encounters* Abertzales de Euskal Herria were held on November 16 in Laudio. Under the motto Feminist Transition in all dimensions, 500 feminists met. They dreamed throughout the day to draw the path to utopias and fill the members... [+]

"Instead of patenting menopause, we have to live as part of a stage."
Physio Juncal Alzugaray Zurimendi, a specialist in sexology and pelvic floor, has given some keys to better understand climacteric and menopause.

The Navarre Parliament reaffirms its confidence in the Lantxotegi association in the process of integrating immigrants
The workers of this social entity have appeared before the Commission on Housing, Youth and Migration Policies of the Basque Government to explain their work. The rapporteurs have asked the foral Government for more public mental health and decent housing resources, as well as... [+]

2024-11-13 | Julene Flamarique
Prisoners in Iran's Kurdish feminist Pakhshan Azizi call for justice
He was arrested at his house on 4 August 2023 by agents of the Tehran Ministry of Intelligence. After his disappearance, he was tortured both physically and psychologically in Evín prison, where he was arrested by the Mossos d'Esquadra. He is now sentenced to death and his... [+]

Body sounds
"The road has been cut and we are in a vacuum"
Leire Manzanares Etxeberria (Donostia-San Sebastián, 2005) is passionate about swimming, skating and reading. It has a developmental disorder and is located in the Task Learning Classroom (ZIG). She's been looking for information with her parents to explore the possibilities of... [+]

Report the "collapse" of the sexually transmitted infections center of the Bilbao Fire Station Etxaniz
Alfonso Setiey, president of Anitzak, said that there is a lack of staff and information, that the waiting list is "long" and that there is a "great stigmatization".

2024-11-05 | Estitxu Eizagirre
Garbiñe Larrea, author of the book "Cosmetics with medicinal plants":
"Industrial cosmetics are hacking our hormonal system and I wanted to provide resources"
Garbiñe Larrea has presented the cosmetic book with medicinal plants to be published on 7 November in Donostia-San Sebastián. The book provides complete information and information on how to perform the necessary products ourselves to clean and care for the skin, hair and... [+]

2024-11-05 | Euskal Irratiak
Debrien Figurak, feminismoaren eta transfeminismoaren inguruko egun arrakastatsua Oztibarren

Baionan Loverdose eta Atharratzen Bekat’uros egin den bezala, Oztibarren (Nafarroa Beherea) Debrien Figurak feminismoaren eta transfeminismoaren inguruan antolatutako egunak arrakasta izan du.


2024-11-04 | Leire Artola Arin
ANALYSIS
What have we gained from Errejón?

Since 24 October, Iñigo Errejón has been named head of the line of all the media in the Spanish State, and his name has been used to date, right and left. It has achieved a very rare media noise, and it seems that the echo is going to take a long time. Now we all have... [+]


Brushes for merging Euskera and Sex-Gender Dissidents
‘Xoka. Ehgam Navarra organised the ‘Jites dissidents’ conference. Three sessions will be held in Laba de Pamplona: 5, 13 and 19 November.

Eguneraketa berriak daude