Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

"The best thing for women is to say no to mammograms."

  • Peter C. Gøtzsche is a Danish medical researcher and leader of the prestigious Nordic Cochrane Center driven by the Rigshhospitalet clinic in Copenhagen. Her most famous book has recently been published in Spanish (Drugs that kill and organized crime) but before, under her direction, Cochrane had published in the scientific journal The Lancet Is screening for breast cancer with justifiable mammography? (Is breast cancer screening justified?) with the report. He was interviewed by journalist Kim Witczak after his speech at the Selling Sickness congress held in Washington in the summer of 2013.

23 October 2014
Peter C. Gøtzsche Danimarkako ikerlari medikua.
Peter C. Gøtzsche Danimarkako ikerlari medikua.Nordic Cochrane Center

Will you summarize what you say about mammographic checkups?

You have to stop them. That's what they say life saves has never been proven. The overall mortality rate is the same, the same cancer mortality. What they get is that many healthy women get cancer without any need. Poor people are responsible for an overdiagnosis of 50%, so a woman who rejects these mammograms reduces the risk of cancer by 1/3. [Not doing those checkups] is the best thing wives can do.

We have been investigating the matter for fourteen years. In Denmark, we have had a proper observatory, as the authorities decided that 20% of wives would carry out checks. The remaining 80% have not been generalized screening of this type of women for seventeen years. Therefore, in Denmark, there has been a control group [that does not take treatment] in the world to compare it with those who take it.

In recent years, it has been found that breast cancer mortality has decreased everywhere and that it has decreased even more among young women than never checked by mammography. Therefore, the situation has not improved in the check-ups, but there have been better treatments.

What led him to investigate this kind of check-up?

When the Danish Parliament debated the implementation of this screening for all women in 1999, a 15-year study was presented in Sweden showing that both the women who performed the mammography and the women who did not did it had the same results. That's why the Danish Medical Association asked politicians: How can they apply this general care if their benefit is not clearly proven? The authorities commissioned the Nordic Cochran Center to review all the studies carried out so far, as the new measure could cause more harm than good.

What answers those who disagree with the results of their research?

It's pretty straightforward, because our data is very grounded. For example, when the head of the breast checkups in Norway realized the results, he left his profession. Some colleagues denounced that he was wrong as a scientist, because they were angry because the woman discovered that the activity was useless. The idea of these mammograms is to decrease cancers, and if this doesn't happen, they don't work. It's as simple as that. I do not see room for discussion with our results.

Take mammograms from countries that have established 15 years apart and compare, for example, the Netherlands and Belgium, Norway and Sweden… and you will realize that breast cancer mortality has gone on a similar schedule when it goes down. It has nothing to do with the spread of mammograms, since mainly more effective treatments have been created. They're very compelling data.

In your opinion… what should a person do on this issue?

The best thing a woman can do is say no to mammograms. We know for sure that this does not benefit you. When you see that some women are going to die of breast cancer, you have to see that many others fall into overdiagnosis, and this increases the risks of heart attacks or lung cancer, for example. After all, we see no benefit from mass mammograms. In a way, these checkups are the ones that cause cancer. They produce diseased cancers, sometimes detecting harmless cancers. On the other hand, we see that cancers fade on their own, without any treatment.

He has published a new book. Can you tell us something about him?

It's the medicine doctors give. It concerns medicines and organised crime, doctors sold and the law enforcement authorities, who do not fulfil their duty. They don't protect us from dangerous drugs. Therefore, our medicines are not safe. I'm not original in what I'm going to say, but it's been shown that heart attacks and drugs administered by doctors after cancer are the third leading cause of death, as in the United States in Western Europe. This demonstrates the corruption in the health sector and the lack of control by the authorities that have caused this almost as deadly epidemic as tobacco. What the pharmaceutical industry does is similar to what organised crime does.

Nicole Delepine: "Tabu batez ari gara"

Nicole Delepine mediku pediatra eta onkologoa da. Bere azken liburua da Cancer, un fleau qui rapporte (Minbizia, dirua ematen duen izurritea). Erretretan sartu artean Garches klinika onkologikoaren zuzendari aritu da, sistema publikoan. Ondoko zatia berak ezarri berri du bere blogean, ohar honekin: “Liburuan idatzi nituen hitzok ez ditu inork gezurtatu; salatzen dute “arrosa koloreko urria” (Octobre rose) bezalako kanpainen manipulazioak, behin eta berriro errepikatzen dira kanpainok inolako lotsarik gabe, krisi aroan eta finantza publikoak ito larrian daudela. Borroka politiko ‘feminista’ omen dena, baina babestu nahi omen diren emakumeen kalterako doana. Baina bi mila milioi euro… horiek ezin dira galtzen utzi hain erraz”.

Heriotza tasak jatsi eta tratamendu goiztiarrago batez kalteak gutxitzea ideia ederra da. Zoritxarrez, kantzerren txekeoen onurek basamortuko espejismoen antza dute: hurbiltzen ari zarela uste duzunean berriro urrun ageri zaizu. Azken ikerketek erakusten dute kantzerraren galbaheketen onurak gehiago zor zaizkiela terapien aurrerapenei; hori esatea, ordea, benetako tabu bat da eta zientziazko eztabaida baten argudio objektiboak kutsatzen dituzte desinformazio kanpaina gogorrek, irizpide politikoek (“emakumeen borrokaren lorpena da”, “berdintasunezko osasungitzaren politika berriena da”…) baina baita ere finantzieroek, zeren eta gehiago baitira [Frantziako] gizarteak urtero gastatzen dituen 1.500 milioi euroen pagotxak bizimodua konpontzen dien jendeak (txekeoen burokrazia, subentzioetatik bizi diren gaixoen elkarteak, erradiologoak, zirujauak, anato-patologoak…) kantzerrak berak hiltzen dituenak baino.

Ezin onartuzkoa da erakunde independente batek ez kontrolatzea urtero galbaheketa kanpainok: emaitzak bularreko minbizien hilkortasunean, emaitzak hilkortasun orokorrean, diagnostiko faltsuen tasak, gehiegizko tratamenduenak, hauen alboko kalteenak… Finantza publikoak Kontuen Auzitegiak gainbegiratzen ditu. Finantzen ikuspegitik haiek bezain garestiak diren eta populazioarentzako hain zamatsuak izanik, zergatik ez da berdin egiten osasun publikoko proiektuekin? Bitartekorik onenak eduki behar ditugu, horretarako funtzio publikoaren kontabilitate arau berak bete araziz eta ez finantzatuz herritarrei benetako onurak ekartzen dizkieten proiektuak baizik.


Newest
2025-01-08 | Leire Ibar
Gaztetxe Hori Bai of Larrabetzu turns 60, the oldest in Euskal Herria
The Gaztetxe Hori Bai of Larrabetzu was founded in 1965, in the midst of the Francoist era. Since then it has not closed its doors and by 2025 it has turned 60. Under the slogan “60 years untied”, the members of the gaztetxe have begun the anniversary.

In Atarrabia, they decide to take their children out of the classes of a teacher: "She has terrified children."
The parents of Atargi College of Villava have denounced that when this teacher touches them, fear, nightmares, anxiety, crying… are generalized in children from 6 to 9 years old. Faced with the problem of the years, they decide to plant themselves in their classes. ARGIA spoke... [+]

2025-01-08 | Julene Flamarique
The first dead worker of the year, in the construction works of the Alavés-Baskonia headquarters
The operator, who worked for the company Excavaciones Mendiola, subcontracted by the company Construcciones Urrutia, has been transferred to the hospital. It was the first day of the worker in the sector.

2025-01-07 | Julene Flamarique
Esquiroz BSH workers return to work with the threat of closure on top, waiting for Friday's meeting
The multinational has already announced on 16 December the closure of the production plant in Navarra. The management of Esquiroz has asked the workers to deal with production "normally", but the unions have described it as "impossible". The Ministry of Labour has convened a meeting... [+]

As young people’s wages grow by 10%, prices have risen by 31% since 2010
In Álava, Bizkaia and Gipuzkoa, the monthly average of young employees aged between 18 and 34 years old has for the first time exceeded the EUR 1,500 barrier. Compared to 2010, however, there has only been an increase of EUR 142.

2025-01-07 | Leire Ibar
Sare will hold the national demonstration in Bilbao on 11 January under the slogan 'Definitely'
They have announced that they will demand the final end of the solution process and back home, and that they want the Basque prisoners to be at home. In order to receive financial assistance, they have launched the Bizumkada Nacional initiative.

2025-01-07 | ARGIA
Robert Hirigoien, one of the creators of Herri Urrats dies
Euskaltzaindia scholar Robert Hirigoien (Larresoro, Lapurdi, 1944) died on January 4 of the same year. The last goodbye will be given to you on Thursday, in your home town, at 10:00. He was one of the founders of the Herri Urrats festival and the Ote Lore association, which... [+]

2025-01-07 | Leire Ibar
The General Assembly of Baztan expresses its solidarity with the seven accused of paralyzing the work of Aroztegi
The General Assembly of Baztan has adopted a motion in solidarity with the Aroztegi defendants and calls for acquittal. At the meeting held on 2 January, the motion received 25 votes in favour, two against and three abstentions.

They propose to the far-right to form government in Austria, even though a barrier could be imposed on it.
The elections were held in September and the FPÖ was loosely imposed by obtaining almost 30% of the votes. There was the possibility of putting a wall on the right, but the Christian Democrats and the Social Democrats have not agreed.

Smell of growing mouths
The demonstrations of the peasants throughout the French State have resumed. Despite the demands of the various trade unions, the first one that has been heard and that has been invited to the mainstream media has been the "dominant" FNSEA. What do you have to sell? A multitude of... [+]

2025-01-07 | Jon Torner Zabala
Inaugurated the bus service in Ipar Euskal Herria with the aim of improving mobility
New bus lines have been launched since 6 January in Zuberoa, Baja Navarra and Lapurdi. The frequency of services has also been improved through collaboration between the Mobility Union of the Commonwealth of Iparralde and the company RATP. On the other hand, Alaveses under 12... [+]

2025-01-07 | Leire Ibar
Calls for mobilizations to denounce Barakaldo's machist murder
The 84-year-old woman was murdered by her son on 3 January at her home in Bilbao. Several sources have indicated that the man died as a result of his neck injuries. On Tuesday afternoon, concentrations will be held in Barakaldo and in the four capitals of Euskal Herria.

2025-01-07 | Gedar
Other racist aggression in Biarritz
The assault was committed by an uber pilot, who was brutally insulted by a young client. Baiona and Arrigorriaga have also been the localities most affected by racist attacks in recent years.

2025-01-07 | Mikel Aramendi
ANALYSIS
The long shadow of the naval industry in the South Korean crisis
I wondered if the South Korean crisis was indigenous or imported when it got inflamed a month ago. Since the matter has calmed down and been offended, it is necessary to continue to seek a response that is not clear. Because, although geographically it is a distant issue, it can... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude