Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

Denis Diderot, father of Wikipedia

  • On 5 October it is 300 years since the birth of Denis Diderot. Although he highlighted in several areas, the tributes that will be made throughout the year remind us especially that he was the father of the Encyclopédie. But Diderot did more than create that encyclopedia of paper; he dreamed of the resources that would be generated two and a half centuries later, with the Internet, with Google, with Wikipedia.
Entziklopediaren sortzailea ez ezik, nobelagile, filosofo, editore, antzerkigile eta arte kritikaria ere izan zen Denis Diderot.M.L. Van Loo

“Man will not be free as long as the guts of the last priest do not choke the last king,” said Denis Diderot (Langres, 1713-Paris, 1784), a novelist, philosopher, editor, playwright and French art critic. One of the main protagonists of the Enlightenment Century passed away five years before the explosion of the French Revolution that would physically threaten kings and priests, but while he lived he tried, through knowledge, to squeeze the neck of the absolutist monarchy and the Catholic church, to free man. Thus, in Diderot's rich curriculum stands out the Enlightenment's top work, Encyclopédie, whose objective was to gather as much knowledge as possible and make it available to society.

In 1747, André Le Breton commissioned Diderot and Jean Le Rond D’Alembert to edit the artwork. Diderot ran the project for 25 years. The collection involved 160 experts from different fields: Voltaire, Montesquieu, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Adam Smith… and Diderot himself wrote several entries on economics, mechanics, politics, philosophy or religion, among others.

In 1751, the writer prepared a long text of about 80 pages to explain the concept. But this text was not a mere description of a collection of 17 volumes, 18,000 pages and 44,632 items (among other things, because until 1772 Diderot did not know what the result would be). More than it was, he explained what it should be: “A job that gathers everything related to the curiosity, jobs, needs and pleasures of human beings.”

The encyclopedias that followed this project led by Diderot and D’Alembert sought more and more accuracy, gathered more and more entries, but went away from Diderot’s vision. The encyclopedia dreamed of by Diderot had to be “clear, understandable and affordable.” But the encyclopedias that were published were prepared by members of the intellectual elite, holders of “absolute truth”, to understand these texts a cultural level was needed within the reach of few citizens, and they were also expensive products. These were works carried out by a few for a few and, therefore, defended by the enlightened, rather than to promote the intellectual emancipation of citizens, used the heavy volumes to strengthen the wall between elites and citizens. In the 20th century the price of encyclopedias became much cheaper, which led to the democratization of the product, but not so much the content; Britannica, Larousse, Encarta or Espasa became an element of hypocrisy and decoration.

Diderot's conception is much closer to Wikipedia (and, in general, the Internet) than to the series of books with golden and hard letters. However, to date, paper encyclopedias remain a repository of truth and precision and we question the reliability and usefulness of Wikipedia (and many content on the Internet), at least in theory (because we criticize Wikipedia a lot, but we use a lot more).

Wikipedia is much more comprehensive than paper encyclopedias. British, for example, set the limit of 100,000 articles, while Wikipedia has 3,321,000 English entries (15 million entries in 250 languages). This doesn't mean it collects all the human knowledge, but it's 33 times closer to that goal than the prestige paper encyclopedia. In addition, classical encyclopedias focused on academic fields of knowledge and the Internet offers more possibilities to introduce what has to do with “needs and pleasures”.

In his article, Diderot constantly mentions the “unfinished” nature of the work. He notes that the evolution of science or art influences the usefulness of the encyclopedia and advises the “descendants” (those who continue their constant work in the formation of the encyclopedia) to fill the gaps that occur. That is, he was aware from the beginning of the need to constantly update the information. “Although it achieves the highest degree of accuracy possible, it is clear, by its very nature, that the encyclopedia will not achieve perfection.” Therefore, the concept of “encyclopedic precision” commonly used to fight Wikipedia was not coined by Diderot, but by the supposedly incomplete encyclopedias later.

Although we admit that encyclopedias cannot be entirely accurate by definition, we tend to think that Wikipedia has much more failures and less reliability, as anyone can write on them. As Diderot attempted to bring together all human knowledge, he stated that the encyclopedia could not be the work of one person for more than 250 years, but had to be built by people from all academies. Later, he also sought the authors beyond the academies: “We will also need the help of many people of all kinds, people of great value who, because of their social level, have the doors of closed academies.”

In addition, Encyclopédie’s editor-in-chief did not want political power to be involved in the project: “If the Government participates in such a work, the work will not be carried out.” In his opinion, the government would use its influence to defend its interests and was not interested in authority by the legal society that the encyclopedists sought. “The encyclopedia cannot be sent from above.”

If Denis Diderot were born again two and a half centuries later, he would find alive the species he sought (kings and priests) in the extermination. But an imperfect collection of human knowledge, made by citizenship for citizenship, which is changing, updating and continuously expanding, would see that it is feasible thanks to new technologies. And maybe I'll call it the free encyclopedia.


Newest
Netanyahuri babesa erakutsi eta Nazioarteko Zigor Auzitegiko kide izateari utziko dio Hungariak

Gergely Gulyas Hungariako Presidentetza ministroak eman du erabakiaren berri, Hagako auzitegiak atxilotze agindua ezarrita dion Benjamin Netanyahu Israelgo lehen ministroa herrialdera heldu den egun berean. Israelgo armadak Gazako eremu gehiago hartzeko asmoa duela... [+]


Hezkuntza saila eta sindikatuak ostiralean bilduko dira, eta akordio bat lortzeko nahia adierazi du Jaurlaritzak

Araba, Bizkaia eta Gipuzkoako hezkuntza publikoko irakasleek urtarrilean abiaturiko greba zikloaren bigarren kolpea amaitu eta biharamunean deitu du bilera Eusko Jaurlaritzako Hezkuntza Sailak. Begoña Pedrosa sailburuak adierazi du "akordio bat lortzeko nahia"... [+]


‘Guggenheim Urdaibai Stop’ek Urdaibaiko proiektuaz hitz egiteko bilera eskatu dio museoko zuzendari berriari

Bilboko Guggenheimeko museoaren kanpoaldean bildu dira plataformako kideak, bertan zuelako bere lehen agerraldi publikoa Bilboko Guggenheim Museoko zuzendari berri Miren Arzallusek. Landuko dituen ildoez hitz egiteko "goizegi" dela adierazi du Arzallusek, nahiz eta... [+]


2025-04-03 | ARGIA
Behatokiak hizkuntza eskubideen urraketak betikotzeko arriskuaz ohartarazi du 2024ko txostenean

Behatokiak Hizkuntza Eskubideen Egoera 2024 txostena aurkeztu du. Herritarrek helarazitako gertakarien bilduma aztertuta, ondorioztatu dute 2024an egoerak ez duela hobera egin, eta gainera, kexak jaso dituzten hainbat entitateren eskutik urraketak iraunarazteko jarrera sumatu... [+]


Gasteizen, eskaleak soberan daude

Duela aste batzuk, Diputazio kalean, Gasteizko erdigunean, bi gizonek etxerik gabeko pertsona bat bota zuten lo egiten zuen lokalaren kanpoaldeko eskailera-buru txikitik. Bota ez ezik, berehala metalezko baranda bat ere jarri zuten lonjaren aurrean. Lokala luzaroan hutsik egon... [+]


Trumpek %10 eta %50 arteko muga-zergak ezarriko dizkie mundu osoko herrialdeei: “Amerika berriz aberats egingo dugu”

Mundu osoarentzat %10eko muga-zerga globala inposatuko du Donald Trumpen administrazioak, eta hainbat herrialderen inportazioak are gehiago zergapetuko ditu, tartean Txinakoak (%34) eta EBkoak (%20). Baina Hegoalde Globaleko herrialdeak izango dira kaltetuenak: Lesoto (%50),... [+]


2025-04-03 | El Salto
Prosecutor Demands Death Penalty for Luigi Mangione for Murder of Health Insurance Company Chief
U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi has told the media that he will seek the death penalty for Luigi Mangione for shooting and killing Brian Thompson, CEO of private insurance company UnitedHealthcare. Bondi says the attack was an “act of political violence” and a... [+]

2025-04-03 | Gedar
Israel Premier Tech expels Zionist team from a cycling race in Estella
On the initiative of the platform Solidarity with Palestine, some 70 people linked to cycling have asked for the Zionist team not to participate in the tournament, and they have succeeded.

One of those arrested in connection with the attack on the realist Ion Aranburu in Soria is sent to prison
Ion Aranburu was in a coma and was admitted to the ICU for several weeks due to the attack.

Linear The longest sign A

Linear A is a Minoan script used 4,800-4,500 years ago. Recently, in the famous Knossos Palace in Crete, a special ivory object has been discovered, which was probably used as a ceremonial scepter. The object has two inscriptions; one on the handle is shorter and, like most of... [+]


Gizonak frontera, emakumeak zubira

Londres, 1944. Dorothy izeneko emakume bati argazkiak atera zizkioten Waterloo zubian soldatze lanak egiten ari zela. Dorothyri buruz izena beste daturik ez daukagu, baina duela hamar urte arte hori ere ez genekien. Argazki sorta 2015ean topatu zuen Christine Wall... [+]


Ruins of Resa in Andosilla
In the wake of the old border of the Ebro
In the town of Andosilla, in the Ribera de Navarra, archaeologists and groups of citizen volunteers from Aranzadi are carrying out an archaeological excavation that is giving many surprises. In the site of Resa, they have found, among other things, clues to better understand the... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude