Automatically translated from Basque, translation may contain errors. More information here. Elhuyarren itzultzaile automatikoaren logoa

CNN video releasing the Syrian prisoner: allegations of fraud

  • The video shows how journalist Clarissa Ward, the international leader of CNN, enters a secret Syrian jail and records the moment a prisoner is released.
CNNren bideotik jasotako irudia.

20 December 2024 - 07:00
Zarata mediatikoz beteriko garai nahasiotan, merkatu logiketatik urrun eta irakurleengandik gertu dagoen kazetaritza beharrezkoa dela uste baduzu, ARGIA bultzatzera animatu nahi zaitugu. Geroz eta gehiago gara, jarrai dezagun txikitik eragiten.

The images show how Clarissa Ward and his recording equipment move through the prison aisles and suddenly come across a cell that was still closed. They came in and saw that there was somebody under a blanket. After touching the armed guards with his rifle, the prisoner rises frightened and shouts: "I'm civil, I'm civil," and asks visitors not to hurt.

According to CNN, the prisoner is Adel Gharbal, a citizen of the city of Homs who had been in the cell for three months without seeing sunlight. A Syrian rebel traveling with the band was on guard in jail and was released by order of the judge, according to the chain. Ward, who had just been released, gave him water and drove it out.

CNN investigates your video

Ward hung on the social network X those and other scenes he described. He explained that those moments lived in prison were “the most extraordinary moments of his 20-year journalism career.”

Praise for the video and the journalist soon began, but allegations of scam spread quickly across the network. Among the latter is the complaint lodged by the Syrian website Verfy Sy, which has published a video on Twitter. The website has investigated the prisoner and first said it is not Adel Gharbal but Salama Mohammad Salama, Syrian Air Force Officer.

According to those who know him, Homs has been responsible for several checkpoints in the city and has become famous for the many cases of detention, torture and corruption. In particular, the 25-year-old detainee ended up in prison as a result of his discrepancies with a leader in one of them. Verify Sy has also checked how his phone number changed after the fall of Damascus and how he canceled his social networks. The website assures that it has recordings of witnesses that corroborate all this, but that it has not published them to protect them.

According to Verify Sy, many of the things that the recordings show are very strange. On the one hand, the fake name; on the other hand, Ward doesn't explain why that prisoner is the only one in jail. Furthermore, they insist that for three months without sun and in this type of jails it is seen quite well, especially in view of the unfortunate state in which the majority of prisoners are found.

The authors of the study have also stressed that it is surprising that he leaves the street and does not harm himself when the prisoner lifts his eyes and does not see a sun in three months. Ward has commented that the events inside the prison occurred as seen in the image, and CNN has announced that it is investigating what happened.

Videos such as Al Jazeera or Middle East Eye, which have captured the information, have also been echoed.

 


You are interested in the channel: Hedabideak
Eskuin muturrarekin lotura duen alemaniar batek egin zuen Manheim hiriko auto harrapaketa, ez etorkin batek

Alemaniako Poliziak asteleheneko gertakariaren arrazoiak "politikoak" zirela baztertu duen arren, 35 urteko Alexander Scheuermann Ring Bund talde neonaziko kide zen. Bi hildako eta hamar zauritu utzi dituen atentatuaren egileak sare sozialetan "gorroto mezuak"... [+]


“Hitzarmen duin bat lortzeko” mobilizazioak iragarri dituzte ‘Diario de Noticias de Álava’ko langileek

Lan baldintzen "prekarietatea" salatzeko kontzentrazioa egin zuten asteartean egunkariaren egoitzaren aurrean. Abenduaren 2tik sindaura greban daude langileak eta mobizlizazioak "areagotzea" erabaki dute orain.
 

 


Amaia Portugal. Entzule pribilegiatuaren berriemaile
“Bruselan kazetariak oso ohituta daude hizkuntza asko entzuten, ez diote euskarari arretarik ematen”

Urtea baino gehiago da Olatz Simonek –EITBko berriemailea Parisen, garaian–, orrialde hauetan bertan ohartarazi zigunetik Bruselak kazetariari lanbideaz erakusten dionaz. Eta halaxe joan gatzaizkio galdezka Amaia Portugali. Bruselan gure irrati publikoak duen... [+]


2025-03-05 | ARGIA
Gaztea Sariak bertan behera geratu dira, langileen eta zuzendaritzaren arteko gatazkagatik

Langileek salatu dute zuzendaritzak ez diela lan baldintzen gaiari heldu nahi izan eta enpresak nahiago izan duela Gaztea Sariak ekitaldia bertan behera utzi, “horrek sortutako albo-kalte ekonomiko eta sozial guztiekin”, arazoari irtenbidea eman baino.


Txema Monterok EAJ birsortzea proposatu du, ‘Deia’-k zentsuratutako artikulu batean

Joan den asteartean La Vanguardia-n argitaratutako artikuluan egin zuen proposamena Txema Montero abokatu bizkaitarrak. 30 urtez Deia egunkariko kolaboratzailea izan da eta lehenik hara bidali zuen bere artikulua, baina egunkariak ez zion argitaratu.


Kapitalismoaren aurkako artikuluak debekatu ditu Bezosek ‘The Washington Post’-en

Hemendik aurrera egunkarian soilik "norbanakoen askatasuna eta merkatu librea" sustatzen dituzten iritziak jasoko direla adierazi du enpresaburuak. Iritzi artikuluen zuzendariak hedabidea utzi duela ere argitaratu du. 


Txapa Irratia bere 40. urteurreneko ospakizunetan murgilduta dabil

Egitarau mardula prestatu dute Bergarako irrati libreko kideek: musika, literatura eta tailerrak. Besteren artean, martxoaren 29an Txapa Eguna egingo dute.


Diario de Noticias de Álava egunkariko langileen salaketa
“Adimen artifiziala horrela erabiltzea kazetaritzari eta irakurleari iruzur egitea da”

Diario de Noticias de Álava (DNA) egunkariko langileak sinadura greban daude, eta aspaldi ari dira beren lan baldintza “miserableak” eta horiek kazetaritzaren kalitatean duen eragina salatzen. 2013tik soldatak izoztuta dituzte, eta ordutik erosahalmenaren %30... [+]


2025-02-19 | CTXT | Rafael Poch
Kontrainformazioak haizea alde du

Palestinan genozidioa, Europan gerra eta potentzia nuklearren artean tentsioa. Ez daukagu berri on askorik emateko, baina bada bat, hondamendi orokorretik eratorria, aipatzea merezi duena: aldeko baldintzak sortzen ari dira kontrainformaziorako, informazio independenterako,... [+]


2025-02-19 | Irutxuloko Hitza
The Twentieth Anniversary Event of the Holy Word in Images
The hall of the San Telmo Museum in San Sebastián has been filled with people at the 20th anniversary event of the Irutxulo Word.

A meeting will be held in front of the EITB headquarters in Bilbao to demand the relocation of management positions
"The Basque EITB, starting with the direction!" Under the slogan, the meeting will take place on Tuesday 25 February, convened by the unions ELA, LAB and ESK of the EITB, as well as the initiative Modify the Script.

2025-02-07 | Aiaraldea
The Municipal Government of Amurrio has been surrendered the attachments of 1,700 citizens and agents in favor of the restoration of the subsidy of the Media Ayaraldea
Several media workers and partners attended the plenary of the City of Amurrio a week ago to denounce the elimination of the subsidy for the second year. The mayor, Txerra Molinuevo, gave no answer.

Statement of the Basque Committee of the EITB
With this letter, the Basque Committee of the EITB and the EITB bodies that underwrite it wish to express their concern and rejection of the selection processes that have been put in place in recent months for the management positions of the EITB, since the demand for knowledge... [+]

2025-01-30 | Leire Ibar
The Basque Committee of the EITB denounces the rejection of the Basque language requirement in management positions
The Basque Committee of the EITB has expressed its rejection of the selection processes for the management positions carried out in recent months. Three people who do not have a C1 level have been selected for key positions: For the direction of EITB Media, for the direction... [+]

Eguneraketa berriak daude